Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Judged for *Only having one child

187 replies

Sameasitwas · 15/05/2022 21:03

Was at the playground yesterday with Dd, almost 4, she was playing with all the kids and I got chatting to a mum with a younger girl and two teenage boys. Chatting away quite happily until she asked if I had anymore children and I said only Dd…her face changed and she looked almost shocked, like a bad smell was under her nose 😬She drifted away after that and went to talk to someone else.
I've never encountered that before, do people really judge people with only one child?
Not that it would have been any of her business, but I had Dd late due to infertility and years of waiting, we would have loved more…but even if we hadn’t, so what?! What’s the issue?

OP posts:
FLOWER1982 · 16/05/2022 16:46

I’m one of 4 and one sibling cut all of us off years ago and I’m not close to my other 2 siblings at all. We are like chalk and cheese. Just because you’re related definitely doesn’t mean you’re going to be best friends.

I sometimes at my friends with one child and think how lucky they are!

Throckmorton · 16/05/2022 16:46

breatheintheamazing · 16/05/2022 15:29

@LuckySantangelo35

I'm being honest here by the way - I'm sure I'll get loads of stick but people ask for opinions and they aren't always popular ones or ones they want to hear

Yes I think it's selfish to deliberately choose to be one and done. I admit I just don't get it. I think if you are prepared to have a child then you should be prepared to have a sibling(s) if circumstances (medical and financial) allow. Reasons I read for people not wanting another child - I want a lie in, I want my figure back, I don't want to do nappies and sleepless nights again, I don't want to make the sacrifices that come with going through the baby years again. I suppose all I hear is "I" , "I". "I" . Children are young for a relatively short period of time in your lifetime so I suppose I wonder why you wouldn't want to go through relatively short term sacrifices for a lifetime of what another child will bring not only for you but your eldest child? My eldest absolutely worships her siblings - it's not just me saying that - her teachers are always reporting on how proud she is to be a big sister and how much her love for her siblings shines through.

But I lost 7 babies trying to give my eldest a sibling. I nearly died twice from multiple ectopics. My opinion is 1000% affected by that. If i could/can have more children tomorrow I would/will

But why do you think children need a sibling? I'm an only and love it. Do you not understand that all children are individuals and that while some might enjoy having siblings, some will hate it.

Rosesandbutterflys · 16/05/2022 16:42

breatheintheamazing · 16/05/2022 15:29

@LuckySantangelo35

I'm being honest here by the way - I'm sure I'll get loads of stick but people ask for opinions and they aren't always popular ones or ones they want to hear

Yes I think it's selfish to deliberately choose to be one and done. I admit I just don't get it. I think if you are prepared to have a child then you should be prepared to have a sibling(s) if circumstances (medical and financial) allow. Reasons I read for people not wanting another child - I want a lie in, I want my figure back, I don't want to do nappies and sleepless nights again, I don't want to make the sacrifices that come with going through the baby years again. I suppose all I hear is "I" , "I". "I" . Children are young for a relatively short period of time in your lifetime so I suppose I wonder why you wouldn't want to go through relatively short term sacrifices for a lifetime of what another child will bring not only for you but your eldest child? My eldest absolutely worships her siblings - it's not just me saying that - her teachers are always reporting on how proud she is to be a big sister and how much her love for her siblings shines through.

But I lost 7 babies trying to give my eldest a sibling. I nearly died twice from multiple ectopics. My opinion is 1000% affected by that. If i could/can have more children tomorrow I would/will

You sound incredibly dull.

Fancy revolving your whole life around children. Do you not have any hobbies/ interests? You seem to be one of these women that thinks all women should become a shadow of their former self once they have children, just a complete martyr as that's the only way to parent.

Heaven forbid we should care about having a nice figure or a life outside of our children!

You also haven't explicitly said why you think it's selfish to only have 1 child? You said your eldest adores their siblings? And? That's still not a reason to have multiple children, especially considering the crisis our planet is in.

AgentJohnson · 16/05/2022 16:41

People have asked why DD is an only but my I must give off ‘don’t fuck with me’ vibes because no one has ever challenged my done at one” reply.

BiscuitLover3678 · 16/05/2022 16:38

LuckySantangelo35 · 16/05/2022 16:36

You’re almost enforcing that women should have two children no matter what, you take away that choice and we’re on a slippery slope to some dystopian state.

Exactly! Which is pretty scary especially coming from a woman

Also why two? Is it also bad to have two of the same sex or different sex? Ridiculous

BiscuitLover3678 · 16/05/2022 16:37

This is hilarious. People really are horribly judgemental and for such stupid reasons!

id love a second child but my god, how can people actually believe it’s selfish to only have one? Madness.

Doremisofarsogood · 16/05/2022 16:36

My DD is 8. She does have a half brother but he's 20 and doesn't live with us so she's basically growing up an only child. She's well adjusted and very sociable but people seem to feel sorry for her, saying oh she's an only child...well technically she's not, but we enjoy spending time together as a family and actually get on really well just the 3 of us. I definitely get the whole "oh you don't know what it's like to juggle multiple kids" feeling though. Although actually I juggle 3 jobs and one child, whereas another mum might be juggling 3 kids and one job. But I wouldn't judge them the way they judge me. Everyone's doing their best!

LuckySantangelo35 · 16/05/2022 16:36

You’re almost enforcing that women should have two children no matter what, you take away that choice and we’re on a slippery slope to some dystopian state.

Exactly! Which is pretty scary especially coming from a woman

Chubarubrub · 16/05/2022 16:32

Yes I think it's selfish to deliberately choose to be one and done. I admit I just don't get it. I think if you are prepared to have a child then you should be prepared to have a sibling(s) if circumstances (medical and financial) allow. Reasons I read for people not wanting another child - I want a lie in, I want my figure back, I don't want to do nappies and sleepless nights again, I don't want to make the sacrifices that come with going through the baby years again. I suppose all I hear is "I" , "I". "I" .

and? So what?

Do women not have a choice now? So you’re saying it’s none or 2+? This is ridiculous. You’re also saying that it’s detrimental to a child not to grow up with siblings, also ridiculous. Siblings aren’t the be all and end all.

I’m sorry for what you went through but what you’re saying is not just untrue but hurtful.

It’s also 2022 and somehow I’m getting tired of telling someone (again) on the internet that a woman must have a choice. Whether you agree with that choice or not. A woman always has the choice! It’s not up to anyone else to judge if a woman wants zero, 1 or 5 children.

You’re almost enforcing that women should have two children no matter what, you take away that choice and we’re on a slippery slope to some dystopian state.

Uggh why am I saying this in the 21st century? 😣

LuckySantangelo35 · 16/05/2022 16:31

yellowsuninthesky · 16/05/2022 16:29

I know I'm going to get flamed for this, but surely with our current climate crisis, and humans being the virus of the Earth, we should be applauding people who opt to only have one child or none at all

I am not going to flame you, I totally agree.

@yellowsuninthesky

Do you? Why?

yellowsuninthesky · 16/05/2022 16:29

I know I'm going to get flamed for this, but surely with our current climate crisis, and humans being the virus of the Earth, we should be applauding people who opt to only have one child or none at all

I am not going to flame you, I totally agree.

LuckySantangelo35 · 16/05/2022 16:29

breatheintheamazing · 16/05/2022 15:29

@LuckySantangelo35

I'm being honest here by the way - I'm sure I'll get loads of stick but people ask for opinions and they aren't always popular ones or ones they want to hear

Yes I think it's selfish to deliberately choose to be one and done. I admit I just don't get it. I think if you are prepared to have a child then you should be prepared to have a sibling(s) if circumstances (medical and financial) allow. Reasons I read for people not wanting another child - I want a lie in, I want my figure back, I don't want to do nappies and sleepless nights again, I don't want to make the sacrifices that come with going through the baby years again. I suppose all I hear is "I" , "I". "I" . Children are young for a relatively short period of time in your lifetime so I suppose I wonder why you wouldn't want to go through relatively short term sacrifices for a lifetime of what another child will bring not only for you but your eldest child? My eldest absolutely worships her siblings - it's not just me saying that - her teachers are always reporting on how proud she is to be a big sister and how much her love for her siblings shines through.

But I lost 7 babies trying to give my eldest a sibling. I nearly died twice from multiple ectopics. My opinion is 1000% affected by that. If i could/can have more children tomorrow I would/will

@breatheintheamazing

Urgh you sound so pious!

“I want a lie in, I want my figure back, I don't want to do nappies and sleepless nights again, I don't want to make the sacrifices that come with going through the baby years again”

Yup, and…? Whats so wrong with that?! I want all that stuff and make no apology for it! I want that stuff more than a second child. I suppose you are some kind of superior being and don’t care about any of that? Well I do… I’m a human, a woman as well as a womb and infant caregiver.

And it’s great that your eldest has that kind of relationship with their siblings but plenty of kids don’t, they tear chunks out of each other and it continues into adulthood.

yellowsuninthesky · 16/05/2022 16:29

Some people are just stupid about only children OP. There are lots of very good reasons to choose to have one child, and of course lots of people can't have more than one.

Maybe reference Emma Barnett's article in this weekend's Times about secondary infertility if you come across this ridiculous attitude again.

yesthatisdrizzle · 16/05/2022 16:29

There are so many people doing the judging these days...

I blame Simon Cowell.😂

Everyone is so used to using their critical skills when sitting in front of the tv that they've started doing it in real life too.

TeatimeGlitter · 16/05/2022 16:27

I'm acutely aware*

TeatimeGlitter · 16/05/2022 16:26

I know I'm going to get flamed for this, but surely with our current climate crisis, and humans being the virus of the Earth, we should be applauding people who opt to only have one child or none at all?

Just saying...

By choosing to have more than one child, we're choosing what is best for us, and best for our families, in the full knowledge that our dying world doesn't need more people, and that our legacy is contributing to wrecking it as a result.

I would like more than one child, but acutely I'm aware that I'm thinking about my own family and not about the planet, which makes me feel guilty, but as humans we are deeply self-absorbed, insular creatures, with only a handful of us who are deeply committed to stopping our planet from ecologically imploding.

KettrickenSmiled · 16/05/2022 16:22

What’s the issue?

The issue is the other mum is a twat.
Truly, OP. You needn't waste another moment thinking about it.

Tdcp · 16/05/2022 16:20

some people don't like the idea of only children, like they're at a complete disadvantage for not having siblings. People have one child for a whole host of reasons. I have one because I can't have more, my friend has one because she doesn't want any more. It's no ones place to judge and if they are judging their opinion isn't worth the ear muscles it takes to listen to it.

Onedaylikethi5 · 16/05/2022 16:20

So, I should give my "only" a sibling and thus give her half my time and attention rather than all of it? Because not doing so is cruel?

Doesn't really make sense does it?

TheNinny · 16/05/2022 16:19

@breatheintheamazing good for you that your youngest worships your oldest, but if you’d bother to read the replies you’ll see this is not the case for everyone. And I hope it remains for your sake, can’t imagine trying so hard for a second for them to go no contact or for the first to get downgraded to an acquaintance in later life.

bookworm14 · 16/05/2022 16:13

The thing is, if you tell people they must have a second child if at all possible, you are often telling them to have a child they don’t want. I haven’t felt the slightest twinge of broodiness since DD was born (and before I had her I was desperate for a baby - had two miscarriages and found it very hard to be around pregnant women or other people’s babies as my need was so great). Should I just suck it up and have a baby anyway? I know you’ll be thinking ‘you won’t regret it when it’s here’, but a cursory search of Mumsnet shows that there are absolutely people who regret having some or all of their children. It’s not a risk I’m willing to take.

For those who still don’t get it: there are plenty of women who never have the urge even to have one child, so is it so very unlikely that there might be a lot of women who never have the urge to have a second? If someone told you that you absolutely had to have one child more than your ideal number, and if you didn’t your existing kids would be miserable, you’d think they were mad, right? That’s how you sound to us.

puddingandsun · 16/05/2022 16:05

@breatheintheamazing Thanks for that. Now that I know you and people like you think I'm being selfish I'm going to feel bad, miserable, anxious and guilty. No doubt this is going to make you very satisfied and happy with yourself and make the world right again.
My circumstances have not changed so I won't be having another one after your wise words but it was definitely not wasted because of the direct effect your words had on my feelings.
Have the best day, you kind, selfless person!

breatheintheamazing · 16/05/2022 15:29

@LuckySantangelo35

I'm being honest here by the way - I'm sure I'll get loads of stick but people ask for opinions and they aren't always popular ones or ones they want to hear

Yes I think it's selfish to deliberately choose to be one and done. I admit I just don't get it. I think if you are prepared to have a child then you should be prepared to have a sibling(s) if circumstances (medical and financial) allow. Reasons I read for people not wanting another child - I want a lie in, I want my figure back, I don't want to do nappies and sleepless nights again, I don't want to make the sacrifices that come with going through the baby years again. I suppose all I hear is "I" , "I". "I" . Children are young for a relatively short period of time in your lifetime so I suppose I wonder why you wouldn't want to go through relatively short term sacrifices for a lifetime of what another child will bring not only for you but your eldest child? My eldest absolutely worships her siblings - it's not just me saying that - her teachers are always reporting on how proud she is to be a big sister and how much her love for her siblings shines through.

But I lost 7 babies trying to give my eldest a sibling. I nearly died twice from multiple ectopics. My opinion is 1000% affected by that. If i could/can have more children tomorrow I would/will

Mumwantingtogetitright · 16/05/2022 14:21

Katypp · 16/05/2022 14:12

@Mumwantingtogetitright I had 13 years of just having one child before I had another, so I've done my fair share of playgrounds etc with an 'only child'. Honestly, I think people imagine all sorts because they either are not at peace with their decision for whatever reason of they want to draw attention to themselves.
I'm tee-total, have been all my life, and I have never, ever, had anyone pull a face at me or make unpleasant comments about it AND I work in a profession where heavy drinking is the norm. Yet every year, there are posts on here and in the press around New Year from people who have given up drinking for a month and seem t think they are the talk of the country. They aren't. They just want to be.

Your experience doesn't necessarily reflect everyone else's, though. I'm pretty sure that I wasn't projecting or imagining things when people told me outright that dd would be lonely, that she would find it hard to share, that she would be spoilt etc. Not to mention the people who would instruct dd herself to "ask mummy and daddy for a baby brother or sister so that you don't get lonely."

These were not just looks that I misinterpreted - they were brazen comments that couldn't be ignored. Count yourself lucky if you didn't have to deal with them.

And yes, I've been veggie for 35 years, and haven't ever once had the sense that anyone else cared. That doesn't mean that other people's experiences are invalid if they're different from mine though.

Katypp · 16/05/2022 14:12

@Mumwantingtogetitright I had 13 years of just having one child before I had another, so I've done my fair share of playgrounds etc with an 'only child'. Honestly, I think people imagine all sorts because they either are not at peace with their decision for whatever reason of they want to draw attention to themselves.
I'm tee-total, have been all my life, and I have never, ever, had anyone pull a face at me or make unpleasant comments about it AND I work in a profession where heavy drinking is the norm. Yet every year, there are posts on here and in the press around New Year from people who have given up drinking for a month and seem t think they are the talk of the country. They aren't. They just want to be.