Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Judged for *Only having one child

187 replies

Sameasitwas · 15/05/2022 21:03

Was at the playground yesterday with Dd, almost 4, she was playing with all the kids and I got chatting to a mum with a younger girl and two teenage boys. Chatting away quite happily until she asked if I had anymore children and I said only Dd…her face changed and she looked almost shocked, like a bad smell was under her nose 😬She drifted away after that and went to talk to someone else.
I've never encountered that before, do people really judge people with only one child?
Not that it would have been any of her business, but I had Dd late due to infertility and years of waiting, we would have loved more…but even if we hadn’t, so what?! What’s the issue?

OP posts:
Disneyblueeyes · 16/05/2022 18:59

I think quite a few people have more children even though they don't truly want them, just because they feel sorry for their only.

TeatimeGlitter · 16/05/2022 18:55

yellowsuninthesky · 16/05/2022 16:29

I know I'm going to get flamed for this, but surely with our current climate crisis, and humans being the virus of the Earth, we should be applauding people who opt to only have one child or none at all

I am not going to flame you, I totally agree.

Thanks @yellowsuninthesky !
I love what you had to say on the subject, too. It's so strange to me that people are wilfully ignorant of the impact that we all have on the planet.

howoriginal · 16/05/2022 18:48

We have an only child and this is entirely through choice. Some of our friends have 2 or 3 kids and seem to take to it easily, others have found the jump to 2 kids incredibly hard. We had a pretty easy time of it when our son was a baby, I have no delusions that a second would be as easy! I hate it when people say "only one child?" Or "just the one then?" As if our family is somehow less than for just having one child. We can afford better holidays with just one, it's easy to travel, both my husband and I can have time to ourselves, and we have a great relationship with our son. We are able to give him all our attention. Neither me or my husband are at all close to our siblings, they are actually quite fraught relationships so neither of us see a huge benefit in having a brother or sister. One of our friends has admitted that they regret having a second, their life is pure chaos and incredibly stressful - I don't wish for that life, and while we might find it easy to add another child to our family I'm not willing to risk disrupting our happy set up. Sometimes I see my happy friends with 2 or more kids and feel a bit jealous of their set up and how their kids have each other to play with/keep each other company. But then I look at my incredibly sociable, confident and loving only child and think we've done alright! I judge people who moan about how hard having one child is and then have another one - like, what did you expect? Why choose to do something again that you don't enjoy or find incredibly hard?

RampantIvy · 16/05/2022 18:38

Why do some people judge parents for only having one child?

Jealousy?
Feeling defensive about their own lifestyle choices?

Rosesandbutterflys · 16/05/2022 18:33

Completely agree @yellowsuninthesky

yellowsuninthesky · 16/05/2022 18:33

Mumwantingtogetitright · 16/05/2022 14:03

I assume you don't have an only child yourself? I lost count of the number of stupid judgey comments that people saw fit to pass on this when dd was little.

Indeed, as an only child who had an only child, the lazy stereotypes were very tiresome. And I chose to have one, it would have been more than tiresome if I had been unable to have more than one.

yellowsuninthesky · 16/05/2022 18:30

Why do I think not having any, or not more than one child is a good thing? Because there are plenty of people in the world, we don't need everyone to replace themselves, and the planet is struggling to cope with us all. Every person who decides not to replace themselves is doing a good thing.

And those who have big families then consume more, "need" bigger cars, have to ferry their multiple children around to more activities, their offspring need more houses, etc.

if the population of the planet halved that would not be a bad thing. Yes there would be a few decades where there would be more old people than young, but it would sort itself out, as someone said on another thread.

People moan about immigration and the housing crisis, but they never look at how many children they are having.

AclowncalledAlice · 16/05/2022 18:24

breatheintheamazing · 16/05/2022 15:29

@LuckySantangelo35

I'm being honest here by the way - I'm sure I'll get loads of stick but people ask for opinions and they aren't always popular ones or ones they want to hear

Yes I think it's selfish to deliberately choose to be one and done. I admit I just don't get it. I think if you are prepared to have a child then you should be prepared to have a sibling(s) if circumstances (medical and financial) allow. Reasons I read for people not wanting another child - I want a lie in, I want my figure back, I don't want to do nappies and sleepless nights again, I don't want to make the sacrifices that come with going through the baby years again. I suppose all I hear is "I" , "I". "I" . Children are young for a relatively short period of time in your lifetime so I suppose I wonder why you wouldn't want to go through relatively short term sacrifices for a lifetime of what another child will bring not only for you but your eldest child? My eldest absolutely worships her siblings - it's not just me saying that - her teachers are always reporting on how proud she is to be a big sister and how much her love for her siblings shines through.

But I lost 7 babies trying to give my eldest a sibling. I nearly died twice from multiple ectopics. My opinion is 1000% affected by that. If i could/can have more children tomorrow I would/will

I too, had several very late miscarriages and a stillborn before DD came along. Why should I be expected to go through that grief and heartache on the off chance that I might give birth to a 2nd live baby. Nope I quit whilst I was ahead and had no desire for anymore.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 16/05/2022 18:11

breatheintheamazing · 16/05/2022 15:29

@LuckySantangelo35

I'm being honest here by the way - I'm sure I'll get loads of stick but people ask for opinions and they aren't always popular ones or ones they want to hear

Yes I think it's selfish to deliberately choose to be one and done. I admit I just don't get it. I think if you are prepared to have a child then you should be prepared to have a sibling(s) if circumstances (medical and financial) allow. Reasons I read for people not wanting another child - I want a lie in, I want my figure back, I don't want to do nappies and sleepless nights again, I don't want to make the sacrifices that come with going through the baby years again. I suppose all I hear is "I" , "I". "I" . Children are young for a relatively short period of time in your lifetime so I suppose I wonder why you wouldn't want to go through relatively short term sacrifices for a lifetime of what another child will bring not only for you but your eldest child? My eldest absolutely worships her siblings - it's not just me saying that - her teachers are always reporting on how proud she is to be a big sister and how much her love for her siblings shines through.

But I lost 7 babies trying to give my eldest a sibling. I nearly died twice from multiple ectopics. My opinion is 1000% affected by that. If i could/can have more children tomorrow I would/will

Please can you elaborate as to why exactly it is selfish? As a perfectly happy only child I'd love to know what you, a complete stranger, thinks my life is lacking.

HelloBarkness · 16/05/2022 18:05

People say stupid things. I remember chatting with a woman in a shop queue and she was asking about DS who was 4 at the time, and I said he was an only.

Lady - "Oh that's a shame for him!"

DS1 - "I haven't got any brothers in my house because our baby DS2's name DIED. He went to heaven, because he is DEAD."

It was delivered with all the seriousness, doom and drama he could muster and the poor woman was suitably goldfished before she recovered herself.

It depends on the circumstance, I don't mind telling people I've had two miscarriages and lost two babies later on in pregnancy, but I don't always share it. If anyone was to judge me, that's on them.

Paddingtonthebear · 16/05/2022 18:01

Absolutely laughable anyone would pity my happy and confident child. Most days she tells me her school friends can’t stand their siblings 😆

Disneyblueeyes · 16/05/2022 17:54

BobLep0nge · 16/05/2022 16:49

Yes I think it's selfish to deliberately choose to be one and done

But I lost 7 babies trying to give my eldest a sibling. I nearly died twice from multiple ectopics

This isn't meant in a horrible way but don't you think it's selfish to risk your life, risk your child losing his/her mother just because you have some weird ideas about only children?

I'm glad someone had the balls to say this.

ohmicorazon · 16/05/2022 17:36

I grew up with four siblings who were much older, no cousins or family friends my age and my parents were very strict with going out etc. A friend of mine was an only child with plenty of cousins, family friends and friends. Siblings are not the be-all and end-all some people make it out to be. Pay her no mind.

DingDongBellPussysInTheWell · 16/05/2022 17:31

Marvellousmadness · 16/05/2022 07:28

I would judge a parent with only 1 kid. But also parents with more then 3 kids . But id do it behind their backs. Like a normal person.

I feel like I know a You in real life … except they don't hide it as well as you think they do and everyone can tell they're a snotty two faced cow.

eatingapie · 16/05/2022 17:25

lolachic · 16/05/2022 16:49

People are so judgemental. Sure most kids want siblings, in an ideal world but in reality everyone's relationship situation and fertility situation is different so it's not fair to judge.

I’m not sure this is a very supportive comment - you’ve phrased it as if you wouldn’t judge someone for having an only child but then followed it up with a value judgment and then seem to imply that you’re not ‘judging’ rather feeling something like pity for one child families. It’s not that it’s ‘not fair’ to judge, it’s that there is nothing to judge. Why should children have siblings in an ideal world?

feellikeanalien · 16/05/2022 17:22

I've never actually had any comments made to my face about DD being an only (although obviously judging by some of the comments on here there have been many made behind my back). Why are people so judgemental these days? What business is it of anyone else how many children I have?

If anyone ever did say anything I would give them the full gory medical details of why I couldn't have any more, throwing in for good measure that DD should have had a twin who didn't survive.

If that didn't shut them up I would then probably also tell them not to be such judgemental twats and mind their own business, but then I have got to the stage in life where I'm becoming less and less concerned what other people think of me.

Courante · 16/05/2022 17:16

Some people are just the kind of judge anyone over anything that doesn't perfectly align with what they do...

My favourite only child comment was at the play park after school and sitting on a bench with two other mums (we had 1,1, and 3 children). The mother of three comments on the poor behaviour of a younger child (not one of ours) and concludes it is because he is an only child. I pointed out that our children are only children to which she replied ours don't count as they aren't like only children...😁

AclowncalledAlice · 16/05/2022 17:02

Hastingsontheup · 16/05/2022 06:15

My sister is my best friend she is the person who taught me about what friendship is. She is my staunchest supporter and my most honest critic, my first port of call for support, advice and wisdom. I talk to her everyday, so I'd say sharing a room and the remote control was a tiny price to pay for a life long right hand woman.

My elder sister bullied me and wished me dead on more than one occasion. I rarely speak to her or see her and she only lives a 5 minute walk from my house. In fact she's the reason I had just 1 child...no way on Earth would I risk any child of mine feeling as awful as I did growing up.

Paddingtonthebear · 16/05/2022 17:01

We have one child and never had any desire for more.Our child is happy and so are we. I don’t spend my time asking other parents why they “only” had two children. Or three. Or four. No one goes around asking people why their first child wasn’t enough for them do they. It’s rude. I don’t know why people care how many children others have. I’ve always felt it says something about their own choices to be honest

YouHaventDoneAnyWork · 16/05/2022 16:59

I’m embarrassed by some of the comments posters have made.

Openly admitting to ”judging” and accusations of being “selfish” because someone didn’t make the same choices as you, or maybe didn’t have the choice, just highlights some women are just as bad as some men in projecting what women should and shouldn’t do in society.

At times MN is a great forum for supporting other women, but threads like are depressing.

Shame on you “judgers”.

FiveNineFive · 16/05/2022 16:57

I have 8 siblings and don't see any of them because my family is a fractured mess. one of the reasons I have chosen to only have one is because I want to break the intergenerational trauma cycle and I know I only have the energy and brain space to do that while parenting one child. If I am to be a good mother to her she has to be my only.

PoTayToes80 · 16/05/2022 16:50

I think my partner and I are one and done. I have a close relationship with my siblings and it makes me feel sad my baby won’t have that but on the other hand:


  • he won’t know any different and there are no guarantees as to sibling relationships

  • I’m 41 and my periods were kinda tailing off before my pregnancy, if we wanted another we’d have to start trying again pretty damn soon and I’ve barely adjusted to life with 1

  • I think I can be a good mum to 1

  • having some life to myself is important, I can just about get enough of that with 1 so that I don’t lose my sense of myself in the demands of motherhood

  • I found pregnancy really tough and it’s fucked up my health a little, I don’t want to do it again

  • the impact on finances - with 1 we are still reasonably comfortable, 2 would be tight


An emotional desire for my son to have a sibling isn’t enough stacked against all that.

BobLep0nge · 16/05/2022 16:49

Yes I think it's selfish to deliberately choose to be one and done

But I lost 7 babies trying to give my eldest a sibling. I nearly died twice from multiple ectopics

This isn't meant in a horrible way but don't you think it's selfish to risk your life, risk your child losing his/her mother just because you have some weird ideas about only children?

lolachic · 16/05/2022 16:49

People are so judgemental. Sure most kids want siblings, in an ideal world but in reality everyone's relationship situation and fertility situation is different so it's not fair to judge.

FiveNineFive · 16/05/2022 16:46

breatheintheamazing · 16/05/2022 15:29

@LuckySantangelo35

I'm being honest here by the way - I'm sure I'll get loads of stick but people ask for opinions and they aren't always popular ones or ones they want to hear

Yes I think it's selfish to deliberately choose to be one and done. I admit I just don't get it. I think if you are prepared to have a child then you should be prepared to have a sibling(s) if circumstances (medical and financial) allow. Reasons I read for people not wanting another child - I want a lie in, I want my figure back, I don't want to do nappies and sleepless nights again, I don't want to make the sacrifices that come with going through the baby years again. I suppose all I hear is "I" , "I". "I" . Children are young for a relatively short period of time in your lifetime so I suppose I wonder why you wouldn't want to go through relatively short term sacrifices for a lifetime of what another child will bring not only for you but your eldest child? My eldest absolutely worships her siblings - it's not just me saying that - her teachers are always reporting on how proud she is to be a big sister and how much her love for her siblings shines through.

But I lost 7 babies trying to give my eldest a sibling. I nearly died twice from multiple ectopics. My opinion is 1000% affected by that. If i could/can have more children tomorrow I would/will

Resentful parents are terrible parents. Why would you want children to experience that?