Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Never thought I'd ask this here but... is this racist?

140 replies

MrsMingech · 15/05/2022 20:29

I know these threads are fricking cringe and awful sometimes and I've deliberately not name changed as I don't want to seem like a troll.

My son and I really like a comedian called Nigel Ng who often slates peoples cooking. He has several quips, one of which is "Emotional damage"

I recently overheard my son and his friends saying it when something bad happens, in this comedians accent.

I said to him later that it's probably not the best idea, it doesn't come across well.

On the other hand I have a vague memory of my parents repeating some of the famous lines from 'Ello Ello, so that can't be racist?

I once heard someone say to their kid, if something feels wrong, then it is wrong.

And hearing the kids saying it felt wrong....

It is, isn't it?

OP posts:
CupidStunt22 · 22/05/2022 20:09

BeautifulWar · 22/05/2022 18:56

Mocking another accent is denigrating regardless of the racism angle. I think you're right in that if it makes you feel uncomfortable, it's wrong.

This is the WORST take "if it makes you feel uncomfortable its wrong". Christ no! Lots of things make people uncomfortable, that in no way makes it wrong. The thought of 2 fellas getting married made my grandad very uncomfortable, by your logic gay marriage is therefore wrong.
No. As if the younger generations need any more of these snowflake supportive bullshit ideas!!

Clymene · 22/05/2022 20:08

It's like saying 'heeerre's johnny!' In a voice that emulates the way that Jack Nicholson said in the Shining.

That's probably offensive to insane would be family annihilators Hmm

BerkyWithTheGoodHair · 22/05/2022 20:08

Is Nigel Ng the guy who does the uncle roger skit? Cos if it is, I saw him live and he made some preeeettty close to the bone paedo jokes about Asian women who tend to look younger than they are. Man, were there some tumbleweeds in that room! Blush

Clymene · 22/05/2022 20:05

BeautifulWar · 22/05/2022 18:56

Mocking another accent is denigrating regardless of the racism angle. I think you're right in that if it makes you feel uncomfortable, it's wrong.

They aren't mocking it

Dibbydoos · 22/05/2022 20:03

As a mixed race person, my take on this would be:-

If they are saying a meme, it's OK.
If they are talking to a person of colour using an accent that the person or their race use ergo Chinese accented English to a Chinese person, yes, that's racist.

BerkyWithTheGoodHair · 22/05/2022 20:03

So, basically, no, don't do 'The Voice

@AffIt are you saying that you disagree with anyone emulating a Scottish accent? Cos, as a birth Scot who just happens to have an English sounding voice, I think you're wrong.

yesthatisdrizzle · 22/05/2022 19:53

Smartsub · 22/05/2022 18:46

I don't think the children had racist intent, but I do think they were probably unintentionally racist.

I also think Allo Allo was "of it's time" and isn't on TV now for a reason.

I've been watching repeats of Allo Allo on tv quite recently.

It could be 'It Ain't Half Hot Mum' you're thinking of. I think that one has been pulled.

stopthepain · 22/05/2022 19:48

TruthHertz · 22/05/2022 18:52

I'm not sure. I'm not offended when my cousins put on an English accent and joke about making a cup of tea.

Nigel Ng exaggerates a stereotypical “East Asian” accent. It is racist but it’s different because Ng is Chinese/Malaysian. Mocking a Cockney accent is totally different to white people taking the piss out of East Asians. Then again, we’re kind of used to it.

FWBanswer · 22/05/2022 19:47

Smartsub · 22/05/2022 18:46

I don't think the children had racist intent, but I do think they were probably unintentionally racist.

I also think Allo Allo was "of it's time" and isn't on TV now for a reason.

“Allo Allo” was of its time, but there was
also a particular reason for the ‘comedy’ accents

Not all viewers knew the inspiration for Allo Allo was Secret Army in which there was a conscious decision to use actors natural accents, instead of attempting accents and avoided subtitles etc
You then had the majority in Belgian, German, British characters etc speaking with well spoken BBC English but with appropriate pronunciation (the cafe / restaurant owner was Albert and his name pronounced with the R of Al-bear not the T of Al-bert

Allo Allo was a comedy alternate to Secret Army (and also a parody of other war films/shows) and one of the in jokes for those who knew the inspiration was the language and accents
It does however make more sense in Allo Allo at some times that in Secret Army you may get RAF evaders not understanding the English spoken conversion going on between Belgians, Germans etc but in Allo Allo you get an accent for each nation

Discovereads · 22/05/2022 19:47

It’s not racist. They’re imitating a specific person as they repeat that persons exact words.

If it’s racist to use any accent different from your own, then that will put most actors and actresses out of a job.

Sometimeswinning · 22/05/2022 19:41

Shrek "Donkey" another thing I've heard from the kids. Just watching the German episode on Fawlty Towers. Are all these things racist?

IsadoraQuagmire · 22/05/2022 19:41

Antarcticant · 22/05/2022 19:04

'allo 'allo is on the Yesterday channel daily at the moment.

Yes, it's always showing on various cable channels, it's hilarious! 😂

KermitlovesKeyLimePie · 22/05/2022 19:35

Listen very carefully, I shall say this only once.

It's not racist.

MisterMeaner · 22/05/2022 19:32

www.irishmirror.ie/showbiz/irish-showbiz/chinese-father-ted-actor-ozzie-24200942

Racism is in the eye of the beholder. What one person finds offensive another won't and there's no final definition of what is and isn't racist.

I would suggest you warn your son that some people might think it's racist. He might need to pick his audience and possibly apologise at some point.

SummaLuvin · 22/05/2022 19:31

Readtheroom · 22/05/2022 19:19

As long as its not done to cause offence i dont think theres a problem

wrong.

I don't intentionally kick my DH under the table when we are eating dinner, but when it happens I still apologise, because regardless of it being unintentional it still hurt.

Same applies to racial comments, you can hurt someones feelings and be incredibly offensive unintentionally, and your lack of intent doesn't absolve you from wrongdoing.

Readtheroom · 22/05/2022 19:19

As long as its not done to cause offence i dont think theres a problem

whynotwhatknot · 22/05/2022 19:17

Nigel ng is malayasian so has an accent

whther its racist or not i dont know we dont go round doing the chinese accent anymore

CupidStunt22 · 22/05/2022 19:05

DogsAndGin · 15/05/2022 20:41

But they’re all the same race - white.

A white person emulating a different race has connotations.

Wow, see now that is actually really racist. You just said that all Dutch people and all Scottish people are white. Super, super racist.

Antarcticant · 22/05/2022 19:04

Smartsub · 22/05/2022 18:46

I don't think the children had racist intent, but I do think they were probably unintentionally racist.

I also think Allo Allo was "of it's time" and isn't on TV now for a reason.

'allo 'allo is on the Yesterday channel daily at the moment.

AffIt · 22/05/2022 19:03

ChanceNorman · 22/05/2022 18:56

I don't think imitating a comedians accent when repeating a well known quip of theirs is racist at all.

We regularly get Scottish money gifted from DH's family. Every time we open an envelope either us or the dc will say 'I think you'll find pal, that's legal tender' in Scottish accent a la Michael Mcintyre.
Slightly different obviously as MM was already imitating Scots - but then again I don't know any Scots offended by this skit either.

If the quip is well known in one accent it kind of falls flat if you repeat it in another imo.

As a Scottish person, PLEASE don't do 'The Voice'.

I am not alone, particularly among people from the Celtic nations, in asking people not to do 'The Voice'.

No, it's not racist per se, because the vast majority of indigenous Scottish/Irish/Welsh people are ethnically Northen European and therefore white, but it is pretty annoying, not even slightly funny, and more than a wee bit offensive, especially when English people do it (I'll just point you in the direction of colonialism here, if you have to ask why).

So, basically, no, don't do 'The Voice'.

CupidStunt22 · 22/05/2022 19:03

once heard someone say to their kid, if something feels wrong, then it is wrong

That doesn't mean YOU get decide whether other people are wrong or not. You're not the arbiter or the centre of the universe.

You know Nigel Ng exaggerates the accent for effect, yes? And encourages others to copy him? They aren't mocking him, they are laughing with him, not at him. It isn't racist to put on other accents, ffs.

SummaLuvin · 22/05/2022 19:01

I don't think putting on a Scottish accent is a good comparison. Scottish people haven't in recent history faced significant racial abuse from English people, and mocking the accent hasn't been a common way of laughing at them (on the other hand many people find the Scottish accent quite lovely). It's like saying that making a joke of Dutch people being tall and East Asian people have slanted eyes is level pegging as they are both physical characteristics. One would be accepted to be fair game, the other not ok.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 22/05/2022 19:01

But they’re all the same race - white.

There are plenty of non-white Scottish, Spanish and Dutch people, who have 'standard' accents for their countries (i.e. you'd know you were speaking to a Scot, Spaniard or Dutch person on the phone, but have no idea what colour skin they had) - I know you absolutely didn't mean to do so, but inadvertently othering people can also be racist.

BeautifulWar · 22/05/2022 18:56

Mocking another accent is denigrating regardless of the racism angle. I think you're right in that if it makes you feel uncomfortable, it's wrong.

ChanceNorman · 22/05/2022 18:56

I don't think imitating a comedians accent when repeating a well known quip of theirs is racist at all.

We regularly get Scottish money gifted from DH's family. Every time we open an envelope either us or the dc will say 'I think you'll find pal, that's legal tender' in Scottish accent a la Michael Mcintyre.
Slightly different obviously as MM was already imitating Scots - but then again I don't know any Scots offended by this skit either.

If the quip is well known in one accent it kind of falls flat if you repeat it in another imo.