Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Never thought I'd ask this here but... is this racist?

140 replies

MrsMingech · 15/05/2022 20:29

I know these threads are fricking cringe and awful sometimes and I've deliberately not name changed as I don't want to seem like a troll.

My son and I really like a comedian called Nigel Ng who often slates peoples cooking. He has several quips, one of which is "Emotional damage"

I recently overheard my son and his friends saying it when something bad happens, in this comedians accent.

I said to him later that it's probably not the best idea, it doesn't come across well.

On the other hand I have a vague memory of my parents repeating some of the famous lines from 'Ello Ello, so that can't be racist?

I once heard someone say to their kid, if something feels wrong, then it is wrong.

And hearing the kids saying it felt wrong....

It is, isn't it?

OP posts:
Sometimeswinning · 22/05/2022 21:30

SummaLuvin · 22/05/2022 19:31

wrong.

I don't intentionally kick my DH under the table when we are eating dinner, but when it happens I still apologise, because regardless of it being unintentional it still hurt.

Same applies to racial comments, you can hurt someones feelings and be incredibly offensive unintentionally, and your lack of intent doesn't absolve you from wrongdoing.

But when racial words are used in songs/rap its OK? I had a year 4 in a whole lot of trouble the other day because he used a certain word (which should not be said outloud unless you are allowed to apparently!!)He, as it turned out had heard it from a song and repeated it. He was in more trouble for this than when he punched a girl in the face and called her ugly. Being offended is not the end of the world.

JudgeJ · 22/05/2022 21:27

A white person emulating a different race has connotations.

Only a white person? Maybe if you said a person emulating a person of a different race it might sound less pathetic.

Charley50 · 22/05/2022 21:19

I agree with Asim Chaudry, who is feckin' brilliant as Chabuddy G on People just do Nothing. I think he said it anyway. Doesn't mind people doing different accents or it's done in a truly observational way, rather than to be insulting or offensive. My ancestors have what is made into a 'comedy' accent sometimes. I can't get worked up about it.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 22/05/2022 20:59

@Smartsub, ‘Allo ‘Allo has been repeated very recently on TV.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 22/05/2022 20:58

X-posted with adhdforme.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 22/05/2022 20:57

If an Asian or African comedian builds their career around sketches playing off Asian/African stereotypes is it racist for non Asian or Africans to find it funny?

I've wondered before, when non-white British comedians play characters or make jokes using accents that maybe their parents or grandparents might have, but which they themselves most certainly do not, having lived in the UK all (or almost all) of their lives. People like Omid Djalili, Jocelyn Jee Esien, Gina Yashere, Sanjeev Kohli, Steven K Amos etc.

Most obviously, it's not borne of racial hatred of people of their own racial heritage, but as people with 'majority' British accents, for which they will never have been mocked, is it still 100% OK for them to imitate stereotypical non-white accents for comic effect?

LegsOfJelly · 22/05/2022 20:52

My DS has a habit of putting on silly accents. I've spoken to him about this and said some people might think you're taking the mickey/ being disrespectful. I think this falls into that category.

As an aside - speaking of offence being in the eye of the beholder, and since Allo Allo has been discussed here - I had relatives who were Holocaust survivors who found Allo Allo very offensive (not because of the accents, but because they felt the entire topic was not a joking matter).

BordoisAgain · 22/05/2022 20:48

Yeah, allo allo was xenophobic and sexist- as were a lot of shows from that era.

adhdforme · 22/05/2022 20:47

I know exactly who you're talking about and find his videos hilarious. Not seen him on TikTok, but on YouTube for years. I wouldn't think mimicking him and repeating his jokes would be racist at all, as long as the people you're speaking with also are aware of him and know who you're talking about. It's all about context.

It's the same with comedian Russel Peters. He's Indian with a Canadian accent. He mimics his dad during his routine and uses and Indian accent. He wouldn't have been half as popular as he is now without the jokes where he mimics his dad in an accent and I know many many people of all colours who repeat his catch phrase line and jokes. I wouldn't consider it racist at all.

Would you consider an Indian (or any other non-white British) person racist if they repeated a Jack Whitehall joke in a posh British accent?

bridgetreilly · 22/05/2022 20:46

On the other hand I have a vague memory of my parents repeating some of the famous lines from 'Ello Ello, so that can't be racist?

Allo Allo was massively racist.
Using the lines from Allo Allo out of context was almost certainly racist.
Your parents are not exempt from the all-pervasive racism in society.
If something feels racist it probably is.
If something doesn’t feel racist to you, it still might be.
Society isn’t made up of ‘racists’ and ‘non-racists’. We can all do and say racist things.
The difference is whether you learn and do better next time.

BordoisAgain · 22/05/2022 20:45

If an Asian or African comedian builds their career around sketches playing off Asian/African stereotypes is it racist for non Asian or Africans to find it funny?

BordoisAgain · 22/05/2022 20:42

"Emotional Damage" was created by Steven He

misses point

redbigbananafeet · 22/05/2022 20:41

DogsAndGin We actually have black and Asian people in Scotland now. How do you know the OP is white?

autienotnaughty · 22/05/2022 20:36

I personally wouldn't say it because some people would be offended and their feelings are equally as valid as those who are not offended. It's a grey area at best.

SparkleOwl65 · 22/05/2022 20:33

I'm black. It's not racist. Really not.

SummaLuvin · 22/05/2022 20:31

AnElegantChaos · 22/05/2022 20:18

Scottish people haven't in recent history faced significant racial abuse from English people

Lived in London in the 90s, which I would argue is very recent history, and "fucking Jocks" was thrown our way regularly. I'd call it xenophobia rather than racism but f*ing horrible abuse anyway.

As I just clarified, happy to admit I am no expert in Scottish/English tensions and issues, I also appreciate there might be variability regionally. The 90's is 30 years ago now, recent history to me means about 5-10 years.

SummaLuvin · 22/05/2022 20:27

No at all, you will see upthread that I disagree with the use of mocking accents of any kind at all. However, it informs the situation, and things to be particularly cautious over, recent abuse is much closer to the bone. The fact that Chinese people (and any East Asians who were assumed to be Chinese) faced a huge surge of racism less than 2 years ago at the beginning of the Coronavirus outbreak means they might be especially sensitive. Understandably, as many were scared of physical abuse, were yelled at in the street, made to feel very unwelcome, and in the US even targeted in a mass shooting. I'm not making a hierarchy of racism, there is no point in that, but you can see why a Chinese person might be more upset than a Scottish person in an equivalent situation. I will hold up my hands and admit I am not that knowledgeable about Scottish/English relations, but in the last 10 years have Scottish people feared for their lives in England just because they were Scottish? That's what I mean by close to the bone and recent.

Antarcticant · 22/05/2022 20:27

Mummyoflittledragon · 22/05/2022 20:22

Prime have Allo Allo - just checked. But a chargeable series otherwise I may have been tempted. It was funny at the time.

You can watch it for free using Freeview Play.

PutinIsAWarCriminal · 22/05/2022 20:26

I personally have told my dc not to mock or joke about any different colour or religion, and this would include non white accents. It can so easily be taken out of context, it just isn't worth it.

Mummyoflittledragon · 22/05/2022 20:22

Prime have Allo Allo - just checked. But a chargeable series otherwise I may have been tempted. It was funny at the time.

Sleepingsatellite1 · 22/05/2022 20:21

Smartsub · 22/05/2022 18:46

I don't think the children had racist intent, but I do think they were probably unintentionally racist.

I also think Allo Allo was "of it's time" and isn't on TV now for a reason.

It is still repeated.

AnElegantChaos · 22/05/2022 20:18

Scottish people haven't in recent history faced significant racial abuse from English people

Lived in London in the 90s, which I would argue is very recent history, and "fucking Jocks" was thrown our way regularly. I'd call it xenophobia rather than racism but f*ing horrible abuse anyway.

TyrannosaurusRegina · 22/05/2022 20:17

SummaLuvin · 22/05/2022 19:01

I don't think putting on a Scottish accent is a good comparison. Scottish people haven't in recent history faced significant racial abuse from English people, and mocking the accent hasn't been a common way of laughing at them (on the other hand many people find the Scottish accent quite lovely). It's like saying that making a joke of Dutch people being tall and East Asian people have slanted eyes is level pegging as they are both physical characteristics. One would be accepted to be fair game, the other not ok.

So is only recent abuse that counts?

PuppyMonkey · 22/05/2022 20:14

The English police officer in Allo Allo who said “good moaning” and “I was just pissing by the cafe and thought I’d pop in”. I mean THAT was funny.Grin

I think there’s a difference between these kids saying a catchphrase and, say, Jim Davidson doing his Chalkie impression.

TheFoxAndTheStar · 22/05/2022 20:11

ChanceNorman · 22/05/2022 18:56

I don't think imitating a comedians accent when repeating a well known quip of theirs is racist at all.

We regularly get Scottish money gifted from DH's family. Every time we open an envelope either us or the dc will say 'I think you'll find pal, that's legal tender' in Scottish accent a la Michael Mcintyre.
Slightly different obviously as MM was already imitating Scots - but then again I don't know any Scots offended by this skit either.

If the quip is well known in one accent it kind of falls flat if you repeat it in another imo.

As a Scot, no it’s not racist, but it is very offensive. Please don’t do it.

Scottish people haven't in recent history faced significant racial abuse from English people

Really? Not big into history then are you?