Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Never thought I'd ask this here but... is this racist?

140 replies

MrsMingech · 15/05/2022 20:29

I know these threads are fricking cringe and awful sometimes and I've deliberately not name changed as I don't want to seem like a troll.

My son and I really like a comedian called Nigel Ng who often slates peoples cooking. He has several quips, one of which is "Emotional damage"

I recently overheard my son and his friends saying it when something bad happens, in this comedians accent.

I said to him later that it's probably not the best idea, it doesn't come across well.

On the other hand I have a vague memory of my parents repeating some of the famous lines from 'Ello Ello, so that can't be racist?

I once heard someone say to their kid, if something feels wrong, then it is wrong.

And hearing the kids saying it felt wrong....

It is, isn't it?

OP posts:
Bentoforthehorde · 23/05/2022 07:01

'Emotional damage' is Steven He isn't it? He has collab'd (spelling?) with Nigel (Uncle Rodger) before though. We don't do tiktok but as a family absolutely love their youtube videos. They are regularly watched in the house and we do quote them.

CorsicaDreaming · 23/05/2022 06:25

@Sandinmyknickers
@SummaLuvin

"But essentially the point is it actually doesn't matter whether your kids are being intentionally racist or not, I would be telling them not to mimic it as intent and definitions of racism are irrelevant if something just feels uncomfortable and someone could misinterpret."

But if they are copying something because they admire the original author of it and think it's funny with no intent to deride or be negative about the persons race?

This could easily became racist the other way round - you can only admire and promote things that are by other white Caucasians and must ignore anything by other nationalities for fear of being labelled racist.

Billy Connolly trades on his fabulous larger than life Scottishness and many people attempt to (often badly) copy the accent when repeating his jokes.

It can be admiration not racism.

Thedogshouses · 23/05/2022 06:15

Oh FFS

Tezza1 · 23/05/2022 06:04

@AffIt Does that mean mean that never again will I be able to say "Moneypenny" in my best Sean Connery accent?

Sandinmyknickers · 23/05/2022 05:59

Oh and the type of accent does matter.

There's a bit of stand up from Jimmy Carr on YouTube where he specifically talks about accents and asks people from the audience to tell him where they're from and he does the regional accent (Newcastle, Scotland d etc). One guy responds with 'Chinese ', and judging by carr's reaction, the man is most likely not Chinese and is just trying to get Carr to do it. Carr points out quickly (comedically) how that wouldn't come across well and doesn't do it.

So I don't really think you can use the 'comedians mimic accents all the time', because context of which accent and the person saying it matter.

Sandinmyknickers · 23/05/2022 05:53

SummaLuvin · 22/05/2022 19:31

wrong.

I don't intentionally kick my DH under the table when we are eating dinner, but when it happens I still apologise, because regardless of it being unintentional it still hurt.

Same applies to racial comments, you can hurt someones feelings and be incredibly offensive unintentionally, and your lack of intent doesn't absolve you from wrongdoing.

This.

Also I think its distracting and misleading debating whether or not it's "racist", it only needs to feel uncomfortable for you to think "best not say that". Why does it matter if you can theorise your way out of it officially fitting in that box?

My DP is of Chinese origin and we watch Nigel Ng and others and we laugh at the jokes. I never mimic them back to him (I'm white). I don't think he'd turn round and call me racist, it would just feel really uncomfortable and wrong. In the same way, when discussing something his mum said, I wouldn't say it in her accent as it is unnecessary and would sound like I'm mocking her.

Plus your children might be saying this with people who are not familiar with the tik tok.

But essentially the point is it actually doesn't matter whether your kids are being intentionally racist or not, I would be telling them not to mimic it as intent and definitions of racism are irrelevant if something just feels uncomfortable and someone could misinterpret.

ChanceNorman · 23/05/2022 05:39

Jeez. People really need to lighten up. You don't need to be offended over every little thing.

To the poster who said please don't do 'The Voice' - a Scottish accent - no can do sorry. Every envelope we open with Scottish money we'll probably continue to immitate MM because it's funny. I'll take the word of dh and the dozens of Scots I know in RL over a couple of offended Internet randos.

I'm not English though if that helps.

TheLovleyChebbyMcGee · 23/05/2022 03:02

I'm just here for the English people who think Scottish people like having their accent mocked, newsflash, we do not. It's extremely annoying especially when English people seem to expect us to go along with the hilarious joke

100% this, a relative on my DH side taught their young child to say a phrase in a very bad Scottish accent and they all think its hilarious.

Its really not and I'm glad the child has forgotten it in recent months!

mnnewbie111 · 23/05/2022 01:55

This thread makes me sad

HRTQueen · 23/05/2022 01:15

I think it depends how it’s done

Russell Peters has built a whole career on mimicking accents and observing and making fun of different cultural ways. People are ridiculous at times all cultures have this. He is very funny. He will pick on someone in the crowd ask their name and often then mimic their accent (or accent he expects them to have) and then usually a playful insult based on a stereotype

he is highly popular all over the world but I doubt he would be shown on the BBC

Doona · 23/05/2022 00:58

Of course it's racist. The comedian is making fun of his own culture/family. That doesn't make it okay for everyone else to pile in with their "hilarious" Asian accents wth.

VanillaImpulse · 23/05/2022 00:54

It's just doing an impression of the voice. If you didn't follow it exactly as it sounds it wouldn't make sense. It's like doing Peter Kay's "garlic bread" in a West Country accent. It just wouldn't have the same effect and you'd have no idea why the person was saying it. You need the impression to get that association. Race doesn't come into it.

dropthevipers · 23/05/2022 00:45

These people would faint dead away if they grew up in the seventies-you remember (if you do) Love thy Neighbour, The Black and White Minstrel show-as for "The Melting Pot" or "Curry and Chips", forget it.

PandoraRocks · 23/05/2022 00:39

Allo Allo was a funny and popular comedy. COMEDY, remember that? It was before everything got cancelled and we started living in 1984.

StuckInTheMiddleOfNowhere · 23/05/2022 00:17

No not racist

DarkShade · 23/05/2022 00:09

I'm just here for the English people who think Scottish people like having their accent mocked, newsflash, we do not. It's extremely annoying especially when English people seem to expect us to go along with the hilarious joke.

I don't know about this - I think alerting him to it being insensitive to people who have that accent rather than focusing on whether it's racist is probably the way to go.

goodsturdygirl · 22/05/2022 23:18

Haven't rtft but can people stop comparing mimicking someone black or E/SA Asian to someone Scottish? It is not the same if it's not a minority/racialised group.

jcyclops · 22/05/2022 23:04

Waaaazzzzzzuuuup???
If people think a comedy catchphrase created by non-white people but then repeated by white people is racist, they can kiss my chuddies.

CorneliaMarie · 22/05/2022 22:41

No idea who those comedian are, never heard that phrase, don’t go on TikTok. This thread has been educational.

crawls back under rock.

WiseRobin · 22/05/2022 22:33

DF was Scottish and my maternal Grandmother was also Scottish, we have far more relatives across the border than over here, we grew up mimicking each other and still do today.

Sadly DF and DGM are no longer with us but their legends and their amazing accents live on through us, telling stories about them, in a lighthearted way.

I love doing a good accent, Peaky Blinders, Killing Eve, Trump!, Liverpooool, all lighthearted and in good humour, I struggle with the Geordie accent though, can manage Photocopier and Kawasaki 😃😆. They’re all so much nicer than my own so I’m not mocking or being racist, it’s always been our humour growing up.

CorsicaDreaming · 22/05/2022 21:56

My DS9 is forever saying it and showing me the meme. He thinks it's hilarious.

I'd never considered it racist at all.

Quite annoying. But not racist.

LateAF · 22/05/2022 21:49

“Emotional damage” is Steven He. Nigel Ng does the rice cooking review videos, while all Steven’s vids pretty much centre on the emotional damage that the high expectations of immigrant Asian American parents can cause. As someone with immigrant parents, there are lots of parallels that I can relate to.

Personally, I wouldn’t imitate the accent but I can see why a teenager would do so seeing how popular the meme is.

FlyingMasticatedParticles · 22/05/2022 21:43

I think people can be offended by whatever they want, but that intent is everything. I still quote Goodness Gracious Me, because I thought it was a very funny programme. Is that racist? I don't think so, isn't comedy supposed to be enjoyed? I think things like this are just causing more divide than is necessary.

justgotosleepffs · 22/05/2022 21:39

The original is Stephen He I think. He basically mocks strict Asian parents. My DCs love his channel and often mimic it. My MIL (their GM) is Chinese and the videos capture very well our experience of stereotypical "strict asian parent/grandparent". I don't see why it's okay to put on a French accent but not a Chinese one. Or why it might be okay for my half Chinese DH to copy his mum's Chinese accent but not okay for my 1/4 Chinese (but white-looking) DCs to fo the same.

schnitzels · 22/05/2022 21:34

I went to see Six the Musical recently, and there's a whole song where they all sing in exaggerated German accents. It made me wonder where we are on whether putting on an accent of another nation, in a slightly mocking way, is xenophobic / racist / offensive. It really surprised me as the show as a whole was pretty woke.