Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Never thought I'd ask this here but... is this racist?

140 replies

MrsMingech · 15/05/2022 20:29

I know these threads are fricking cringe and awful sometimes and I've deliberately not name changed as I don't want to seem like a troll.

My son and I really like a comedian called Nigel Ng who often slates peoples cooking. He has several quips, one of which is "Emotional damage"

I recently overheard my son and his friends saying it when something bad happens, in this comedians accent.

I said to him later that it's probably not the best idea, it doesn't come across well.

On the other hand I have a vague memory of my parents repeating some of the famous lines from 'Ello Ello, so that can't be racist?

I once heard someone say to their kid, if something feels wrong, then it is wrong.

And hearing the kids saying it felt wrong....

It is, isn't it?

OP posts:
CupidStunt22 · 26/05/2022 14:41

Highschoolkid · 25/05/2022 23:16

Cupid, if you are born in a country, you are a citizen of that country. I was born in America and even though some of my descendants were African American and European, I’m still American. A person of European descent is Indian if they are born in India. You can even be Indian if you have lived there long enough. (My descendants were also Native American but that was besides the point.)

No. That is only true in some countries. It's not true in the UK, for one. Or most of Europe.

Highschoolkid · 25/05/2022 23:17

African* (sorry I instinctively wrote American after)

Highschoolkid · 25/05/2022 23:16

Cupid, if you are born in a country, you are a citizen of that country. I was born in America and even though some of my descendants were African American and European, I’m still American. A person of European descent is Indian if they are born in India. You can even be Indian if you have lived there long enough. (My descendants were also Native American but that was besides the point.)

Highschoolkid · 25/05/2022 23:13

The man who made the joke meant it to be funny. He never on his YouTube told people not to say it. I say it just without the accent most of the time because I can’t really do his accent. I sometimes talk in a British accent or Irish accent (I actually have a bit of an Irish accent despite being born in the USA lol) as a joke. I know that people with accents are not bad, and I’m not making fun of them I just think it is fun to talk differently. The way he said “emotional damage” is funny and was meant to be. (The emphasis on “EEM” is hilarious.)

CupidStunt22 · 25/05/2022 23:00

TruthHertz · 25/05/2022 18:27

Scottish isn't an ethinicity, its a nationality. One can be ethnically anything at all and be Scottish.

Indeed. Like how a white person born in India can be Indian.

No, not really.

TruthHertz · 25/05/2022 18:44

One thing I notice having done office work (project management at a FTSE company) and now being in the construction sector around tradespeople all day, is that professional/office workers talk much more about diversity but actually tend to work in predominantly white managed/owned businesses which usually aren't very diverse.

I often wonder if this is because they assume this is how all work environments are and don't realise that in the non-professional sector it's pretty common to have Eastern European people working alongside white British, black British, Indians, etc, due to the fact you don't need the same level of spoken and written English that you do in an office environment.

It's true that most outspoken racists I've met ("nicking all the jobs" etc) have been fairly uneducated rough types, but by large I think the working class and the trade sectors actually have a much higher ethnic integration and level of diversity than the middle class.

Aubriella · 25/05/2022 18:34

On the other hand I have a vague memory of my parents repeating some of the famous lines from 'Ello Ello, so that can't be racist?

Logic doesn't make sense here. What your son is doing (mimicking the accent) is definitely racist.

TruthHertz · 25/05/2022 18:27

Scottish isn't an ethinicity, its a nationality. One can be ethnically anything at all and be Scottish.

Indeed. Like how a white person born in India can be Indian.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 23/05/2022 18:06

PandoraRocks · 23/05/2022 00:39

Allo Allo was a funny and popular comedy. COMEDY, remember that? It was before everything got cancelled and we started living in 1984.

pOliTiCaL cOrReCtNesS gooooooorrrrrnnnnn mmmmmaaaaaaadddd🙄

JustAnotherPoster00 · 23/05/2022 18:02

JudgeJ · 22/05/2022 21:27

A white person emulating a different race has connotations.

Only a white person? Maybe if you said a person emulating a person of a different race it might sound less pathetic.

Im sure you were busy shouting 'all lives matter' at the time too

amusedbush · 23/05/2022 13:35

CupidStunt22 · 23/05/2022 13:28

Scottish isn't an ethinicity, its a nationality. One can be ethnically anything at all and be scottish 🙄

Sorry, that's what I meant - less of the eye rolling, thanks.

I was typing with hold music playing in my ear so I was distracted. The rest of my point stands.

CupidStunt22 · 23/05/2022 13:28

amusedbush · 23/05/2022 13:18

Just adding to the posts about not imitating a Scottish accent but yes, seriously, don't do it. It's not funny. See You Jimmy hats aren't funny, asking us to say "purple burglar alarm" or "curly wurly" isn't funny, joking about us deep frying anything that isn't nailed down isn't funny. It seems acceptable to make comments like "I can't understand a word they say!" about us using Scots or speaking quickly, as if there aren't broad English accents with regional language deviation Confused

It's not racist because Scottish isn't a race, it's an ethnicity but it's 100% xenophobic. Just a few years ago DH was called "jock" by an English guy while we were on holiday - he'd just overheard us talking quietly and felt compelled to make a shitty comment.

Scottish isn't an ethinicity, its a nationality. One can be ethnically anything at all and be scottish 🙄

amusedbush · 23/05/2022 13:18

Just adding to the posts about not imitating a Scottish accent but yes, seriously, don't do it. It's not funny. See You Jimmy hats aren't funny, asking us to say "purple burglar alarm" or "curly wurly" isn't funny, joking about us deep frying anything that isn't nailed down isn't funny. It seems acceptable to make comments like "I can't understand a word they say!" about us using Scots or speaking quickly, as if there aren't broad English accents with regional language deviation Confused

It's not racist because Scottish isn't a race, it's an ethnicity but it's 100% xenophobic. Just a few years ago DH was called "jock" by an English guy while we were on holiday - he'd just overheard us talking quietly and felt compelled to make a shitty comment.

Coffeetree · 23/05/2022 13:03

In most circles, imitating any accent for comic effect is cringe. Anyone doing that in polite/professional company would be really looked down on.

We had a young work experience woman in our office (English) who tried to amuse us by imitating one of our clients' accent. God, the poor thing, the whole office went quiet and everyone looked away. Cringetastic. But looking at some of the comments here, you can see she was probably brought up by "but it's a joke" people.

You'd be doing your kids a real disservice if you didn't mention that.

andtheycalledthewindmoriah · 23/05/2022 12:51

I think this is a matter of opinion and perspective.

I think the real question is whose opinion and whose perspective is it that matters, to you?

And I think once we know this detail the answer of 'whether this is racist' will become clear and unequivocal.

Thedogshouses · 23/05/2022 12:21

Are the vast majority of British middle class teenagers racist? Because it seems that most speak in a Jamaican patras and use gang words. I don't think it's racist just depressing

Regularsizedrudy · 23/05/2022 11:56

MrsMingech · 15/05/2022 20:43

I've only heard it from Nigel Ng, so he stole it from someone else?

Nigel Ng has never said it (as far as I know) but both comedians are doing the character of an Asian dad/uncle

CupidStunt22 · 23/05/2022 11:51

Regina70 · 23/05/2022 11:21

A joke is always funny in the eye of the joker. I think it is positive to raise the concern with your son, that it could hurt someone's feeling so to be mindful of it.

What joke? What do you think this conversation is about?

faw2009 · 23/05/2022 11:43

I'm Asian, and although I've watched some Nigel Ng, was unaware of this Emotional Damage meme. If someone had gone around saying that around me in a mock accent, I think I'd be offended! So your son could be causing distress to others even if that wasn't his intention.

Regina70 · 23/05/2022 11:21

A joke is always funny in the eye of the joker. I think it is positive to raise the concern with your son, that it could hurt someone's feeling so to be mindful of it.

TheFoxAndTheStar · 23/05/2022 10:09

stopthepain · 23/05/2022 09:18

As a British born Chinese woman, this thread makes me incredibly uncomfortable. White people stating that mocking a Cockney/Scottish etc accent is the same as mocking a stereotypical generalised “East Asian” accent? I grew up with people mocking this fake over the top accent, pulling their eyes, asking if I ate dog etc. Saying “I like haggis” in a Scottish accent isn’t the same.

If you don’t think it is racist to take the piss out of East Asians then you are the reason why your “dear” children are continuing the racism. They learn from their parents.

Fyi Nigel Ng and Stephen He’s real life accents are nothing like their personas that you see on Tik Tok.

I might have missed it, but I didn’t see anyone saying it was the same.

I did however say it’s not OK. When I was seven years old I was beaten so badly that I was in the hospital for 3 days, because I was Scottish. That is not OK either.

Notmytiep · 23/05/2022 10:09

I don't think its racist in that context but I wouldn't go around mocking anyone's accent. Its distasteful and crass IMO.

CupidStunt22 · 23/05/2022 09:55

If you don’t think it is racist to take the piss out of East Asians then you are the reason why your “dear” children are continuing the racism. They learn from their parents

But nobody is talking about taking the piss, are they? Completely different thing.

Weird how people are trying to make an innocuous thing about children emulating someone they admire (which is literally the opposite of taking the piss out of them) super racist, while ignoring the properly obvious racism of adults posting on this thread. What's that all about?

stopthepain · 23/05/2022 09:18

As a British born Chinese woman, this thread makes me incredibly uncomfortable. White people stating that mocking a Cockney/Scottish etc accent is the same as mocking a stereotypical generalised “East Asian” accent? I grew up with people mocking this fake over the top accent, pulling their eyes, asking if I ate dog etc. Saying “I like haggis” in a Scottish accent isn’t the same.

If you don’t think it is racist to take the piss out of East Asians then you are the reason why your “dear” children are continuing the racism. They learn from their parents.

Fyi Nigel Ng and Stephen He’s real life accents are nothing like their personas that you see on Tik Tok.

VanillaImpulse · 23/05/2022 09:02

CorsicaDreaming · 23/05/2022 06:25

@Sandinmyknickers
@SummaLuvin

"But essentially the point is it actually doesn't matter whether your kids are being intentionally racist or not, I would be telling them not to mimic it as intent and definitions of racism are irrelevant if something just feels uncomfortable and someone could misinterpret."

But if they are copying something because they admire the original author of it and think it's funny with no intent to deride or be negative about the persons race?

This could easily became racist the other way round - you can only admire and promote things that are by other white Caucasians and must ignore anything by other nationalities for fear of being labelled racist.

Billy Connolly trades on his fabulous larger than life Scottishness and many people attempt to (often badly) copy the accent when repeating his jokes.

It can be admiration not racism.

Yep agreed!