Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Never thought I'd ask this here but... is this racist?

140 replies

MrsMingech · 15/05/2022 20:29

I know these threads are fricking cringe and awful sometimes and I've deliberately not name changed as I don't want to seem like a troll.

My son and I really like a comedian called Nigel Ng who often slates peoples cooking. He has several quips, one of which is "Emotional damage"

I recently overheard my son and his friends saying it when something bad happens, in this comedians accent.

I said to him later that it's probably not the best idea, it doesn't come across well.

On the other hand I have a vague memory of my parents repeating some of the famous lines from 'Ello Ello, so that can't be racist?

I once heard someone say to their kid, if something feels wrong, then it is wrong.

And hearing the kids saying it felt wrong....

It is, isn't it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thedogshouses · 27/05/2022 11:21

Blameit is getting such a hard time, at least she is trying to be modern. I think it's ridiculous and wouldn't even do that.

blameitonthecaffeine · 27/05/2022 10:44

@CupidStunt22 No, I'm not an actor, I'm a dancer. I've just been covering Drama this term because the Drama teacher has long Covid. I usually just teach ballet, tap, jazz and musical theatre so spoken acting doesn't often come into it. How do you know the exercise was flawed, I didn't even describe what it was or what the children were set up to do? Just a small part of how a few children approached it. I was following the scheme of work of a HoD of a very successful Drama dept so I'm pretty sure it will have been fine. I hope I'm not letting her down with how I'm delivering it but it seems to be going pretty well, mostly. I don't know, I always call children actors, dancers, singers, performers etc when we're on the stage. Is that bad? Can't see why. And I know a school isn't the theatre but, when it comes to how to approach attitudes to diversity, I wouldn't have thought it should be that much different. I think children need to at least discuss boundaries of what's appropriate, offensive etc - even if they don't agree with the teacher? Maybe I'm wrong but I'm honestly just trying my best.

Thedogshouses · 27/05/2022 10:15

I think that's a bit harsh. The exercise was OK,just the crackers angst afterwards. I am amazed people think this hard about something so stupid. Who cares.

CupidStunt22 · 27/05/2022 09:55

blameitonthecaffeine · 27/05/2022 08:55

@CupidStunt22 😳really?! I don't want to be doing things wrong but I honestly thought that it is not considered okay in current theatrical practice for actors to portray ethnicities that are not their own? Especially in comedy improv ways.

Ah I see....you're a frustrated actor turned drama teacher!

Children are not actors, school is not the theatre, and if you have such a poor grasp of these intracacies, should you really be trying to teach them to children? Your exercise was completely flawed, you set them up to fail and then called them racist when they did as it appeared you expected.

blameitonthecaffeine · 27/05/2022 08:55

@CupidStunt22 😳really?! I don't want to be doing things wrong but I honestly thought that it is not considered okay in current theatrical practice for actors to portray ethnicities that are not their own? Especially in comedy improv ways.

CupidStunt22 · 27/05/2022 08:40

blameitonthecaffeine · 26/05/2022 17:28

I honestly don't know but I think it is, a bit. Or maybe inappropriate would be a better word than racist.

I've had this issue come up when teaching Drama recently. I'm not a trained Drama teacher (I teach Dance/Musical Theatre but we've been short staffed) so I haven't had specific advice on this issue.
I had two 12 year old girls doing a piece of improv. They were playing Grandma/Grandaughter. The one playing the Grandma used quite a strong Nigerian accent. It wasn't a comedy one, it was very realistic and their play was very funny and effective (the comedy didn't come from the accent but was enhanced by it if that makes sense). I gave them the next instruction which built on their piece and they continued but this time the other girl also used the accent. The first girl is British but from a Nigerian family so her parents and grandparents do have that accent. The second is White British. I spoke to the second girl at the end and said that it was not okay for her to use the accent. She looked confused and said that it fitted with the piece as it developed because they were family members. Which I agreed with, it did. But I said that white actors could not use accents that are from other races and cultures as it can be offensive. She asked me why it was okay to do Italian accents then (which someone else had) and I couldn't really give her an answer. I ended up saying, 'you know what, maybe we shouldn't have done that either. It's a really complicated and sensitive issue.' I don't think she really agreed with me (which is fine) but then I also don't know if I was actually correct anyway. I just know that it felt wrong and awkward to hear a white girl using a Nigerian accent. Whereas it didn't feel wrong to hear the black girl doing it. Or to hear another white girl doing an Italian accent. But maybe all three were wrong. I don't think all three were ok but I know others would.

You clearly shouldn't be teaching anyone.

CupidStunt22 · 27/05/2022 08:39

worriedatthistime · 26/05/2022 21:14

@CupidStunt22 yes a white person born in India can be Indian , like a white person born in south Africa is south African , otherwise your saying any person who's parents are say from Africa if born in Britain can not consider themselves british , its up to the person nor randoms on the internet

Don't be daft. You don't decide what your nationality is, you either qualify or you don't.

A person born in India after 2004 is only Indian national if their parents are Indian nationals (or one is and the other has legal residence permission)

A person born in South Africa after 1995 is only South African if their parents are SA or legal permanent residents. Born before 1995 their mother must be a SA citizen.

Don't make ridiculous assumptions about what other people are saying when you don't have the first idea what you are talking about.

Thedogshouses · 27/05/2022 04:34

blameitonthecaffeine · 26/05/2022 17:28

I honestly don't know but I think it is, a bit. Or maybe inappropriate would be a better word than racist.

I've had this issue come up when teaching Drama recently. I'm not a trained Drama teacher (I teach Dance/Musical Theatre but we've been short staffed) so I haven't had specific advice on this issue.
I had two 12 year old girls doing a piece of improv. They were playing Grandma/Grandaughter. The one playing the Grandma used quite a strong Nigerian accent. It wasn't a comedy one, it was very realistic and their play was very funny and effective (the comedy didn't come from the accent but was enhanced by it if that makes sense). I gave them the next instruction which built on their piece and they continued but this time the other girl also used the accent. The first girl is British but from a Nigerian family so her parents and grandparents do have that accent. The second is White British. I spoke to the second girl at the end and said that it was not okay for her to use the accent. She looked confused and said that it fitted with the piece as it developed because they were family members. Which I agreed with, it did. But I said that white actors could not use accents that are from other races and cultures as it can be offensive. She asked me why it was okay to do Italian accents then (which someone else had) and I couldn't really give her an answer. I ended up saying, 'you know what, maybe we shouldn't have done that either. It's a really complicated and sensitive issue.' I don't think she really agreed with me (which is fine) but then I also don't know if I was actually correct anyway. I just know that it felt wrong and awkward to hear a white girl using a Nigerian accent. Whereas it didn't feel wrong to hear the black girl doing it. Or to hear another white girl doing an Italian accent. But maybe all three were wrong. I don't think all three were ok but I know others would.

Is there a prize for moat ridiculous post ever? Fuck me, its hard work looking that hard for offence that offended nobody. Poor kid must have been bewildered.

worriedatthistime · 26/05/2022 21:22

To all the scottish people moaning about english mocking their accents , what about when its the other way is that ok?
Everything is about context surely , our bf are scottish we take the mick out if each others accents at times , neither one of us is offended.
I would necessarily go up to a stranger in the street who was ordering a coffee and copy his accent , so context is huge

worriedatthistime · 26/05/2022 21:14

@CupidStunt22 yes a white person born in India can be Indian , like a white person born in south Africa is south African , otherwise your saying any person who's parents are say from Africa if born in Britain can not consider themselves british , its up to the person nor randoms on the internet

worriedatthistime · 26/05/2022 21:11

@CharlieSJ yet none of my scottish friends are offended and they happily imitate english accents to
Many comedians imitate geordie accents or scouse , where do we draw the line as shock horror not all geordies are white either

CupidStunt22 · 26/05/2022 20:04

Highschoolkid · 26/05/2022 15:48

So Cupid you are not British. Because someone in your family was once not British, you aren’t British. That’s your logic.

Er...what? How is that even vaguely related to what I said?

I am not British, you are correct. But that's because I am not, in fact, British.

Do you actually think that anyone born in Britain is British, by nationality? That is SO sweet!! You think that in 2022 that a child born to non British parents in Britain is automatically British?

Wow. Do you need some recent history lessons or what?!

worriedatthistime · 26/05/2022 20:00

@blameitonthecaffeine but you do realise there are white people in nigeria who have nigerian accents , accents are not always related to a persons colour

worriedatthistime · 26/05/2022 19:55

Not every thing is racist

blameitonthecaffeine · 26/05/2022 17:28

I honestly don't know but I think it is, a bit. Or maybe inappropriate would be a better word than racist.

I've had this issue come up when teaching Drama recently. I'm not a trained Drama teacher (I teach Dance/Musical Theatre but we've been short staffed) so I haven't had specific advice on this issue.
I had two 12 year old girls doing a piece of improv. They were playing Grandma/Grandaughter. The one playing the Grandma used quite a strong Nigerian accent. It wasn't a comedy one, it was very realistic and their play was very funny and effective (the comedy didn't come from the accent but was enhanced by it if that makes sense). I gave them the next instruction which built on their piece and they continued but this time the other girl also used the accent. The first girl is British but from a Nigerian family so her parents and grandparents do have that accent. The second is White British. I spoke to the second girl at the end and said that it was not okay for her to use the accent. She looked confused and said that it fitted with the piece as it developed because they were family members. Which I agreed with, it did. But I said that white actors could not use accents that are from other races and cultures as it can be offensive. She asked me why it was okay to do Italian accents then (which someone else had) and I couldn't really give her an answer. I ended up saying, 'you know what, maybe we shouldn't have done that either. It's a really complicated and sensitive issue.' I don't think she really agreed with me (which is fine) but then I also don't know if I was actually correct anyway. I just know that it felt wrong and awkward to hear a white girl using a Nigerian accent. Whereas it didn't feel wrong to hear the black girl doing it. Or to hear another white girl doing an Italian accent. But maybe all three were wrong. I don't think all three were ok but I know others would.

Notbeinfunnehbut · 26/05/2022 17:17

My son keeps saying this and he’s on the spectrum it’s so annoying and harder to get him out of

I think it’s terrible really these creators are emulating quite offensive stereotypes and financially gaining from it

TitoMojito · 26/05/2022 17:14

Haven't RTTF but the "emotional damage" meme comes from Steven He, an American-Irish comedian with Chinese parents. He makes YouTube videos about his "Asian dad" (which is just him).

CharlieSJ · 26/05/2022 17:12

ChanceNorman · 23/05/2022 05:39

Jeez. People really need to lighten up. You don't need to be offended over every little thing.

To the poster who said please don't do 'The Voice' - a Scottish accent - no can do sorry. Every envelope we open with Scottish money we'll probably continue to immitate MM because it's funny. I'll take the word of dh and the dozens of Scots I know in RL over a couple of offended Internet randos.

I'm not English though if that helps.

I am Scottish and I find you skit of

"We regularly get Scottish money gifted from DH's family. Every time we open an envelope either us or the dc will say 'I think you'll find pal, that's legal tender' in Scottish accent a la Michael Mcintyre."

offensive and derogatory.

CharlieSJ · 26/05/2022 17:05

TheLovleyChebbyMcGee · 23/05/2022 03:02

I'm just here for the English people who think Scottish people like having their accent mocked, newsflash, we do not. It's extremely annoying especially when English people seem to expect us to go along with the hilarious joke

100% this, a relative on my DH side taught their young child to say a phrase in a very bad Scottish accent and they all think its hilarious.

Its really not and I'm glad the child has forgotten it in recent months!

I am Scottish and I fully agree with both these points.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 26/05/2022 16:47

SummaLuvin · 26/05/2022 16:07

If you're calling it a 'British' accent I highly doubt its on point as there is no such thing. There is not a single British accent, but many. These include Glaswegian, South Wales, Cockney, Scouse, Geordie, Brummy... and loads more all of which vastly differ from one another.

Exactly - if you sound like Dick Van Dyke (you no doubt need to Google him) in the Film Movie Mary Poppins you are not "on point".

MisterMeaner · 26/05/2022 16:39

Funnily enough I was watching Phil Wang on Netflix last night (Philly Philly Wang Wang) and he does a bit at the very end of his show about whether it's racist to do an accent. HIs rules are:


  1. If the accent is good, no problem

  2. If the accent is of any race who have previously had an empire or been on the baddies' side in a war, then it's fair game.


So according to Phil Wang you can do a Chinese accent and it's not racist because of point 2. Highly recommend the show by the way.

On the other hand, what I said earlier still stands - that offence is in the eye of the beholder. Calling things "racist" is an attempt to get them shut down absolutely with no debate. It's like an offence trump-card. Much better for us all to consider whether we are offending others, and try not to do so, in the interests of making life more pleasant.

SummaLuvin · 26/05/2022 16:07

Highschoolkid · 26/05/2022 15:50

I can do impressions of other people’s accents and I’m not racist. I just like the way some people sound. (My British accent is on point. I sound cute :3)

If you're calling it a 'British' accent I highly doubt its on point as there is no such thing. There is not a single British accent, but many. These include Glaswegian, South Wales, Cockney, Scouse, Geordie, Brummy... and loads more all of which vastly differ from one another.

Highschoolkid · 26/05/2022 15:50

I can do impressions of other people’s accents and I’m not racist. I just like the way some people sound. (My British accent is on point. I sound cute :3)

Highschoolkid · 26/05/2022 15:48

So Cupid you are not British. Because someone in your family was once not British, you aren’t British. That’s your logic.

Highschoolkid · 26/05/2022 15:47

No one is making fun of Asians doing the voice. It’s just how he said it and I think accents are cool. It’s funny that he said emotional damage and it just isn’t as funny with the American accent (I think my accent is boring)

Swipe left for the next trending thread