Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lee Anderson, Ashfield MP insists Jack Monroe has made a fortune on the backs of the poor.

736 replies

newnamethanks · 15/05/2022 16:47

AIBU to hope for a libel trial as entertaining as Vardy v Rooney and an outcome that rivals the Katy Hopkins debacle?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
SamReiver · 18/05/2022 10:45

C8H10N4O2 · 16/05/2022 18:47

Well I'd imagine the questions are because the only evidence anyone has cited is from his own pages rather than anything third party.

I don't particularly care about his mining experience but since he makes such a big deal of it as evidence that he is an expert on poverty then he should expect that claim to be challenged.

Anyone who starts from a premise that women using foodbanks (and yes this is about women) are simply incompetent and if they just tried harder they could feed people on 30p a day is trading in old fashioned populist tropes and benefits bashing.

If you don’t like how his food bank operates have you decided to run yours differently?

It’d be hypocritical in the extreme for you to complain about his if you’ve not bothered yourself to even try to set one up and run it to show him how it ought to be done.

SamReiver · 18/05/2022 10:29

Mumoblue · 16/05/2022 08:39

@TwinklingFairyLights I understand that my wording might have been confusing there- I'm not claiming that expenses is the reason for poverty. Im saying that if you’re part of the government responsible for poverty and you claim expenses- it’s a bad look to suggest poor people are just shit with money.

He’s not in the government.

ermagerdabear · 18/05/2022 10:26

She's been very cagey on the TWAW thing since then, I think she's either changed her thinking (she certainly never thought that was literally true from her other statements about women) or decided TWAW will piss off her working class market

That's not strictly true, but you wouldn't know it from her feed. She posted something recently about how when she first came to prominence, she was compared a lot to JK Rowling (actual fucking lol) and how it wasn't a compliment and she's non binary AND trans and TWAW and they are who they say they are, and people should believe kids are trans if that's what they say blah, blah, blah. I think she was expecting to be lauded to the high heavens and for the post to go viral but what actually happened was a lot of GC accounts (politely) told her she was talking bollocks. So the post disappeared, because if there's one thing you can't say about Monroe it's that she has the courage of her convictions.

Crikeyalmighty · 18/05/2022 10:24

@Sorrynotsorryyeah Yes I do realise it's not all personal income by a long way, but £222,000 is going some. Even if you had a staff person in your constituency and one at Westminster..most MPs have this combination. Even if we take expenses out the equation he is paid by the state, she isn't. Both utter attention seekers- in different ways. She is annoying , but actually relatively harmless, he though is part of a gvt that are anything but harmless.

SamReiver · 18/05/2022 10:14

cakeorwine · 15/05/2022 23:47

Who exactly did she make sure looked at inflation

The ONS

www.theguardian.com/business/2022/jan/26/cost-of-living-crisis-ons-inflation-jack-monroe

Mike Hardie, the head of inflation statistics at the ONS, said in a blog the published annual inflation rate – currently 5.4% – was an average for all households. “But everyone has their own personal inflation rate. Some people may spend a larger proportion of their income on gas and electricity, or petrol if you commute via car daily.”
The move was welcomed by the food writer and activist Jack Monroe, who has exposed how prices for cheaper food products have soared as availability fell, contributing to rising hunger and poverty.

That’s not a “move”, the ONS has always been completely familiar with the idea that different people have a different personal rate of inflation.

Melissa (let’s stop playing along with her name games) seems to have done little about publishing her own index, as she promised to do, after her normal bit of self-publicism.

SamReiver · 18/05/2022 10:09

ermagerdabear · 15/05/2022 23:31

Glad someone's mentioned the Vimes Boot Index! Can someone point me to towards where she's published it?

The interview I heard with her on this index was appalling. She was completely unable to understand that you can’t base an index on what her own, single, local branch of a supermarket in a very nice part of town is selling.

Her excuse for only looking at her own local shop was that poor people can’t travel very far.

That fact is true; very few can afford to travel to her local shop in a nice part of her town, so how can she possibly think that that can be used as the basis for any sort of index?

SamReiver · 18/05/2022 10:03

Blinky21 · 15/05/2022 22:50

The legal representation is pro bono. What he said is clearly defamatory (I have a qualification in media law) so Jack has every right to sue. If you can't tell the difference between the Tories' attitude to the poor and Jacks then you are beyond help

Can’t be a very good qualification if you don’t understand defamation.

It is only defamatory if it is untrue. It is not current,y known if it’s untrue.

donquixotedelamancha · 18/05/2022 10:00

She also said that trans women are women and that anyone who thought she was not a woman was an idiot, as she has large breasts.

She is a woman. She was mocking those who thought she shouldn't accept a woman's award because she was considering transition and felt NB.

She's been very cagey on the TWAW thing since then, I think she's either changed her thinking (she certainly never thought that was literally true from her other statements about women) or decided TWAW will piss off her working class market.

Is it she or he or they or has Jack completely jumped off that unprofitable bandwagon?

She's a she now and has been for some time.

While I agree that a lot of what she says is suspect her claim to suffer from GD and her recovery from it has the ring of verisimilitude given the evolution of her presentation, the age of onset, the fact she's gay and her unfortunate early history with men.

SamReiver · 18/05/2022 09:58

Pumperthepumper · 15/05/2022 18:53

The Tories have been in power for what, 12 years? And in that time have consistently voted to make conditions for the poor more and more shit. If I was Lee Anderson I’d be very fucking quiet about what people are doing about poverty in Britain.

They have hugely increased the minimum wage and the tax-free allowance, while removing the entire allowance from higher earners, increasing income tax on higher earners, and stopping them from funding their pensions.

This narrative that they have helped higher earners while harming lower earners is disproven by the facts.

SamReiver · 18/05/2022 09:48

Tigofigo · 15/05/2022 17:16

As far as I remember Jack said in interview she is OK with both they and she.

She also said that trans women are women and that anyone who thought she was not a woman was an idiot, as she has large breasts.

She is at best confused, but in my view just someone who will say whatever she things is best for her at any point in time, consistent or not with what she’s said before.

WeCouldBeSpearows · 18/05/2022 07:07

Buying a tin of beans and immediately throwing away up to a third of the contents is extremely poor food management whatever way you look at it

A 400g tin of haricot beans from Tesco costs 60p, and contains 235g of beans. Do you have any suggestions as to what to do with the 165g of liquid?

A tin of Stockwell baked beans costs 22p. Why is it better to buy a tin of 60p beans and dump the liquid (fairly sure you wouldn't complain about that), than buy a tin of 22p beans in sauce that you don't want/like and do the same?

Soontobe60 · 18/05/2022 06:56

Gwenhwyfar · 17/05/2022 21:42

"But the sauce tastes nice"

Unhealthy things often taste nice.

"adds calories"

British people have an overweight and obesity problem. It's worse in low income people so I don't see 'add calories' as a positive personally for the average person in the target audience.

"most recipes for tomato soup would involve putting salt and sugar in anyway"

not as much though I think, usually 'add sugar to counter the acidity if necessary' and 'season to taste'.

"performative stuff (sugar and salt bad!)"

Well, sugar and salt is bad...

I do understand all the general criticisms of her by the way, but I think washing the sauce off baked beans is actually a good idea. I personally buy the low sugar, low salt ones, but I suppose they're more expensive.

www.bbcgoodfood.com/howto/guide/are-baked-beans-healthy

Buying a tin of beans and immediately throwing away up to a third of the contents is extremely poor food management whatever way you look at it.

from the link above:
If you're buying baked beans, it's worth keeping an eye on the salt and sugar content. On average, half a can of shop-bought baked beans can contain around 9g of sugar (10% of the daily reference intake) and up to 1.3g of salt, which is about 20% of the daily reference intake. According to NHS guidelines, a portion of 80g (cooked weight) beans and pulses, approximately 3 heaped tablespoons, makes up one of your five-a-day. Nutritionally speaking, beans (typically haricot or cannellini) are a good source of plant-based protein and are high in fibre, as well as being low in fat and calories. They also contain minerals such as iron and zinc, and are a good source of B vitamins such as folate. Including beans and pulses in your diet is also associated with a lower cardiovascular risk and may help balance blood sugar levels. Shop-bought baked beans (canned in tomato sauce) are a quick, easy and cost-effective snack or component of a meal, but don’t forget they have added ingredients including salt and sugar. Typically, about a third of the can contents is tomato sauce, which is rich in lycopene – a protective carotenoid that's associated with a lower risk of heart disease

Soontobe60 · 18/05/2022 06:47

Gwenhwyfar · 17/05/2022 21:22

"Tell me how someone who has experienced poverty, understands nutritious cooking, and is a good food writer, would create a recipe where you wash the sauce off baked beans to use the beans in a tomato and bean soup? Absolutely staggering lack of thinking there."

The idea is that the sauce is full of sugar and salt so unhealthy. Washing the sauce off baked beans is cheaper than buying a tin of white beans. I get the logic.

Do you think that when beans are cooked in sauce that they somehow magically manage to not absorb some of the salt and sugar in the sauce? Yes, the sugar / salt content is quite high, but the sauce also contains some essential nutrients that we need so why wash it off? I’ve yet to meet anyone who doesn’t season their food - a stew without any salt would be almost inedible!

www.bbcgoodfood.com/howto/guide/are-baked-beans-healthy

Sorrynotsorryyeah · 17/05/2022 21:57

Yep- I'm not keen on either of them but Anderson is the one taking 300k of state money annually - JM only makes if people are prepared to offer'contributions' or pay for features etc.

he’s a twat but you do realise that that money is to pay the salaries of his staff, right?

Crikeyalmighty · 17/05/2022 21:54

Yep- I'm not keen on either of them but Anderson is the one taking 300k of state money annually - JM only makes if people are prepared to offer'contributions' or pay for features etc.

He's an opportunistic yobbo , and his suggestions are patronising to women struggling to manage - he hasn't factored in so many things- I'm fascinated at his 30 p meals -- and if his government- the one he is part of hadn't been so busy causing price mayhem by leaving the EU (see reports today by independents- 80% is caused by Brexit) if they hadn't been leaving private rental housing benefit well below what private rentals actually are in many parts of the country , put rent controls in and if they had actually got a grip on more affordable housing of all types and sizes and stopped selling off social housing - then we wouldn't need to be dictating and mansplaining who can have food from food banks !!!! Because we wouldn't need them.

Gwenhwyfar · 17/05/2022 21:42

"But the sauce tastes nice"

Unhealthy things often taste nice.

"adds calories"

British people have an overweight and obesity problem. It's worse in low income people so I don't see 'add calories' as a positive personally for the average person in the target audience.

"most recipes for tomato soup would involve putting salt and sugar in anyway"

not as much though I think, usually 'add sugar to counter the acidity if necessary' and 'season to taste'.

"performative stuff (sugar and salt bad!)"

Well, sugar and salt is bad...

I do understand all the general criticisms of her by the way, but I think washing the sauce off baked beans is actually a good idea. I personally buy the low sugar, low salt ones, but I suppose they're more expensive.

WarnerSisters · 17/05/2022 21:28

Gwenhwyfar · 17/05/2022 21:22

"Tell me how someone who has experienced poverty, understands nutritious cooking, and is a good food writer, would create a recipe where you wash the sauce off baked beans to use the beans in a tomato and bean soup? Absolutely staggering lack of thinking there."

The idea is that the sauce is full of sugar and salt so unhealthy. Washing the sauce off baked beans is cheaper than buying a tin of white beans. I get the logic.

But the sauce tastes nice, adds calories, and is generally liked by children (unlike tinned-tomato-and-washed-bean soup), not to mention the fact that most recipes for tomato soup would involve putting salt and sugar in anyway.

It’s such performative stuff (sugar and salt bad!) and shows clearly that she doesn’t know poverty or food very well.

WarriorNewAgain · 17/05/2022 21:27

They do add iron to the sauce though. All those Heinz foods have added iron.

Gwenhwyfar · 17/05/2022 21:22

"Tell me how someone who has experienced poverty, understands nutritious cooking, and is a good food writer, would create a recipe where you wash the sauce off baked beans to use the beans in a tomato and bean soup? Absolutely staggering lack of thinking there."

The idea is that the sauce is full of sugar and salt so unhealthy. Washing the sauce off baked beans is cheaper than buying a tin of white beans. I get the logic.

Whenthegoatcomesin · 17/05/2022 20:31

@Tigofigo Based on celebrities with a similar profile, atleast 6 figures. A good six figures.

WilmaFlintstone1 · 17/05/2022 16:28

dragonatetheparsnips · 17/05/2022 10:55

I'd never seen Tattle.life before this thread and that's an unpleasant rabbit hole that I never want to go down again.

What a lot of effort on tearing someone down. Perhaps all these people could go and volunteer at a food bank with all their spare time, or even just go and buy some stuff for it.

I post occasionally on Tattle life.

I volunteer and help with food banks. Unlike Jack.

I also bulk buy stuff when I can see it’s needed….also unlike Jack. This included Easter Eggs for Easter because why shouldn’t a child have a chocolate egg.

Try reading the Wiki…it might open your eyes to the reality of her.

Theluggage15 · 17/05/2022 16:02

She leeches off the poor and poverty. She literally has no shame but there’s always some gullible twits who will big her up. She’s a darling of the Guardian and many of their readers, who funnily enough actually can’t stand a lot of the poor people in the U.K. and sneer at the ‘Jeremy Kyle watchers’ just like Monroe does.

StrawberryLipstickStateOfMind1 · 17/05/2022 15:51

She literally lives off poor people in the main.
People who believe her and are in a similar position and share what little money they have with her and she's been doing this for years.
It's sick.

When she was first in the media I liked her, someone in a similar position to me, I bought her first book and thought the recipes were good, I made quite a few and enjoyed them, but as time has gone on it's clear it's all just a grift.

Andromachehadabadday · 17/05/2022 14:44

I think people forget that she has a financial interest on driving traffic to her website. The good banks are doing her a favour by promoting her website.

She isn’t giving them access to something no one else has. The food banks basically promote her website

Villagewaspbyke · 17/05/2022 14:12

WarnerSisters · 17/05/2022 12:10

Tell me how someone who has experienced poverty, understands nutritious cooking, and is a good food writer, would create a recipe where you wash the sauce off baked beans to use the beans in a tomato and bean soup? Absolutely staggering lack of thinking there.

But I’m sure it’s fine that she takes money off vulnerable, generous people who have experienced or are experiencing poverty and feel bad for her and her kid, while she does absolutely nothing for the money, because “she’s a force for good in the world”.

(Plus, as PPs have said, she doesn’t need a medal for having free recipes online - literally every single recipe online is free, including loads by every major food writer.)

agreed - it seems to me that she has no understanding of real poverty from the evidence above. As a single mum who has lived on benefits, it doesn’t go down well with me to see a wealthy person pretending to be poor.

Also many of the people paying into her patreon and to her personal PayPal presumably want to help those in need. Funds are therefore being diverted from the poorest in society. Hardly a “force for good”.