Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lee Anderson, Ashfield MP insists Jack Monroe has made a fortune on the backs of the poor.

736 replies

newnamethanks · 15/05/2022 16:47

AIBU to hope for a libel trial as entertaining as Vardy v Rooney and an outcome that rivals the Katy Hopkins debacle?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Andromachehadabadday · 15/05/2022 20:13

TheYearOfSmallThings · 15/05/2022 20:09

No she pretended she was poor. She wasn’t.
She chose to live in the conditions she did. And uses that to pretend she knows what it’s like to be actually poor.

Leaving her job wasn't smart, and choosing to live on her benefits rather than being subsidised by her family is not what everyone would have done. But she lived on the same income other people have to live on. I don't think she is a liar.

She has a large family that helped her, in her own words, raise her child. She had support from the child’s father and parents who are wealthy.

She chose a life on benefits. That’s not poverty. It’s the Common people song. One of the worst things about poverty is the relentlessness and lack of choiceS

She chose to live like she did and could have changed it at any moment. That’s not the same for the people in poverty, she claims to understand and speak for.

Its ridiculous to suggest it’s anywhere near the same

ermagerdabear · 15/05/2022 20:12

Jack Monroe suggests strategies she has found helpful. MPs have subsidised restaurants and bars and a subsistence allowance as well as generous expenses. Monroe isn’t telling people that food poverty is down to their inability to cook or budget

What strategies she suggested? She spent hours (apparently) making a menu for a weeks food from an alleged £20, that wouldn't have fed a hamster and used store cupboard ingredients and stuff that wasn't in the list of food she said she'd bought. Then said that only she could do this sort of this thing, and if anyone else could do it, she'd donate money to a charity. How is that helpful, exactly? Nobody in poverty would make any of her recipes either. If you get a tin of beans from a foodbank, you're going to make beans on toast, not rinse them under the tap and stick them in a pan of her unedifying suggested slop.

skodadoda · 15/05/2022 20:11

I have no idea how wealthy she is - as a previous poster says - she hasn't paid her taxes. But poor she isn't

No one said this, they said she hasn’t filed company reports.

grenlei · 15/05/2022 20:11

Whether or not you agree with Lee Anderson's politics, he's far better placed to comment on poverty and solutions than Jack Monroe who grew up with money and actively chose to be poor, or rather to pretend to be poor, a charade she maintains to some extent to the present day.

And her accounts of her own past poverty have been demonstrated to be full of inconsistencies and mostly fictional.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 15/05/2022 20:09

No she pretended she was poor. She wasn’t.
She chose to live in the conditions she did. And uses that to pretend she knows what it’s like to be actually poor.

Leaving her job wasn't smart, and choosing to live on her benefits rather than being subsidised by her family is not what everyone would have done. But she lived on the same income other people have to live on. I don't think she is a liar.

BornIn78 · 15/05/2022 20:08

*Jack’s
Bloody auto correct.

Andromachehadabadday · 15/05/2022 20:07

If we all turn round three times and whisper "Jack Monroe is a construct", she'll come barging on the thread like she used to in the good old days.

Is this true? I have been on MN about 12 years and must have missed this m.

I find that quite funny 😄

Soontobe60 · 15/05/2022 20:07

notthisTimeMr · 15/05/2022 17:36

Because one person has lived through hardship and is giving helpful advice and the other is privileged and judgemental with no concept of what it’s like to struggle only contempt for those that are

At some point in each of these peoples’ lives they have experienced hardship AND privilege.

Andromachehadabadday · 15/05/2022 20:06

Clymene · 15/05/2022 20:02

Schools need to teach cookery from a young age. And proper cookery and budgeting. We are failing our children because they just aren't taught any household management skills at all. My kids learned how to make scones and not much else. Where were the basic staples?

I am 40, but I remember doing gcse cooking. I made Mac n Cheese for 2 years as it was all based around the Cook/chill process for ready meals. Which we couldn’t recreate in a school fridge anyway.

dd is 17. Her experience wasn’t much different.

I learned to cook from exh as he was a chef. As has dd.

PAFMO · 15/05/2022 20:05

Whenthegoatcomesin · 15/05/2022 17:01

I really want to like her but…. Why does she keep claiming she doesn’t have a lot of money? It can’t be true these days. What is that?

It was never true.

If we all turn round three times and whisper "Jack Monroe is a construct", she'll come barging on the thread like she used to in the good old days.

Lee Anderson v Jack Monroe.

Hmm. Tough call.

But anybody thinking she does anything other than for her own 15 minutes needs to do some research.

BornIn78 · 15/05/2022 20:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

YellowDots · 15/05/2022 20:04

Parents are supposed to teach children things too. Schools can't do everything.

Pumperthepumper · 15/05/2022 20:04

Clymene · 15/05/2022 20:02

Schools need to teach cookery from a young age. And proper cookery and budgeting. We are failing our children because they just aren't taught any household management skills at all. My kids learned how to make scones and not much else. Where were the basic staples?

Yes, the Tories really should put a lot more funding into education.

skodadoda · 15/05/2022 20:03

AllotmentTime · 15/05/2022 17:09

Why can she say it and he can’t…

Because she is drawing on personal experience of poverty to say “it’s shit, here are strategies that may help you”

Whereas he is looking down from a place of spectacular privilege to say “you’re doing it wrong and your poverty is your own fault”.

How people can’t see the difference between those two positions is astonishing to me.

I agree. Jack Monroe suggests strategies she has found helpful. MPs have subsidised restaurants and bars and a subsistence allowance as well as generous expenses. Monroe isn’t telling people that food poverty is down to their inability to cook or budget.

Clymene · 15/05/2022 20:02

Schools need to teach cookery from a young age. And proper cookery and budgeting. We are failing our children because they just aren't taught any household management skills at all. My kids learned how to make scones and not much else. Where were the basic staples?

Pumperthepumper · 15/05/2022 20:01

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 15/05/2022 19:45

He's an ex coal miner.
Once the bastion of the British working class.

A real live genuine working class person.
Graft, real graft.

Who now shafts the poor for a living 😍😍

savoycabbage · 15/05/2022 20:00

The idea of a food bank making a cooking course mandatory in order for someone to access a food parcel offensive and insensitive. Imagine getting to the point where the cupboards are bare, and you have run out of cash. You pluck up the courage to get a food bank referral then you are told you must to do a cooking course to access a food parcel. It must feel humiliating, and a waste of time if you can already cook but have simply run out of money. I don’t imagine that people in crisis who need a food parcel are in the right headspace to take in cookery lessons. Education in cooking needs to happen for the whole population.

The course is NOT compulsory.

www.theguardian.com/society/2022/may/12/an-insult-to-the-whole-community-mps-food-bank-comments-out-of-touch-in-sutton-in-ashfield-say-locals

MaryAndHerNet · 15/05/2022 20:00

Borisblondboufant · 15/05/2022 19:49

Genuinely poor people don’t need a ‘representative’. Especially one from a wealthy middle class family. It devalues everything.
What we need is a shift so that the true voices of people struggling are being put out there. It’s very easy for the media to ring up JM and stick her on the TV. It’s wrong though.

Jacks the kind of poor that is palatable on Morning TV.

Stick a Benefit Street person on This Morning...
stick a black single mum from Jaywick on a cooking show.. lets see their Patreons or PayPal's or KoFis
I guarantee people wouldn't be so quick to donate, they'd be quick to blame them or start mentioning big tellies, sky TV and mobile phones, just like you see on some threads here.

Jack walked out of a decent job in the fire service.
Claims they were too ashamed to tell parents and ask for help, but not so ashamed to broadcast it on a blog and start begging donations. That should tell you everything really.

Andromachehadabadday · 15/05/2022 19:59

TheYearOfSmallThings · 15/05/2022 19:56

I like Jack Monroe, and I don't understand the hatred expressed here. She has never claimed to be some new Messiah, never claimed that all her life decisions have been good - all she has done is write cookbooks which take into account that the user may not have lots of money or exotic ingredients. I don't think she deserves all the vitriol at all.

No she pretended she was poor. She wasn’t.
She chose to live in the conditions she did. And uses that to pretend she knows what it’s like to be actually poor.

She has taken money from people who believe her lies under false pretences and kept it.

Those are the things she did.

1전복q · 15/05/2022 19:59

Jack always reminds me of pulp common people. The claims of poverty and asking for donations off her followers after how many books, columns etc he's not wrong really, I doubt it's the rich and wealthy donating and buying these things considering her targeted audience.

WhiteFire · 15/05/2022 19:57

Can someone actually explain why what he has said is libelous / defamation please? Unless there is a whole more to what he said (Google is not shedding light).

She's not doing this for free so who exactly do people think are paying for the paletron and / or books?

TheYearOfSmallThings · 15/05/2022 19:56

I like Jack Monroe, and I don't understand the hatred expressed here. She has never claimed to be some new Messiah, never claimed that all her life decisions have been good - all she has done is write cookbooks which take into account that the user may not have lots of money or exotic ingredients. I don't think she deserves all the vitriol at all.

OversBo · 15/05/2022 19:54

The idea of a food bank making a cooking course mandatory in order for someone to access a food parcel offensive and insensitive. Imagine getting to the point where the cupboards are bare, and you have run out of cash. You pluck up the courage to get a food bank referral then you are told you must to do a cooking course to access a food parcel. It must feel humiliating, and a waste of time if you can already cook but have simply run out of money. I don’t imagine that people in crisis who need a food parcel are in the right headspace to take in cookery lessons. Education in cooking needs to happen for the whole population.

Borisblondboufant · 15/05/2022 19:49

Genuinely poor people don’t need a ‘representative’. Especially one from a wealthy middle class family. It devalues everything.
What we need is a shift so that the true voices of people struggling are being put out there. It’s very easy for the media to ring up JM and stick her on the TV. It’s wrong though.

Clymene · 15/05/2022 19:49

MurielSpriggs · 15/05/2022 19:44

Sorry to be really capitalist and everything, but what's wrong with making money out of poor people? Or any other people? That means your providing something they want at a price that is good value.

I don't have a problem with that per se. I do have a problem with a wealthy young woman taking donations from people living in poverty because she pretends she's poor.

That's a real reverse Robin Hood tactic.

Swipe left for the next trending thread