Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lee Anderson, Ashfield MP insists Jack Monroe has made a fortune on the backs of the poor.

736 replies

newnamethanks · 15/05/2022 16:47

AIBU to hope for a libel trial as entertaining as Vardy v Rooney and an outcome that rivals the Katy Hopkins debacle?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
newnamethanks · 04/08/2022 19:33

It certainly is sixoclock and, in the absence of any creative policy in a leadership campaign piling lie upon lie, what else have they got? If you're looking for lying grifters, Tory voters, you could start a lot closer to home.

OP posts:
Isitsixoclockalready · 04/08/2022 17:38

TBF this is a very typical Tory deflection technique.

Isitsixoclockalready · 04/08/2022 17:23

jgw1 · 15/05/2022 17:09

I always like it when the Nasty Party forgets that is meant to be nice and shows its true colours.
And the bonus is that along come some supporters on here to confirm what they are like.

Yep. The Tories have made plenty for themselves and their friends.

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 04/08/2022 17:16

Dauncets · 15/05/2022 17:05

Poor people can't afford solicitors' fees for defamation cases.

This.

Bnxybee · 04/08/2022 16:40

She recently tweeted that she basically can’t lie due to her autism. She’s tweeted this before and I have an issue with that. It’s not true that autistic people don’t lie. It’s a lazy stereotype. Autistic people sometimes do lie, albeit not very well (a lot of the time), but the notion that autistic people never lie should stay in the eighties/nineties. (I have an autistic brother and have supported autistic adults professionally.) I would challenge her directly but she’s shut off her replies.

She seems to think any criticism aimed at her comes from the GC crowds and are thinly veiled transphobic attacks. She’s claimed to be the victim of horrific transphobic death threats but when asked for receipts, couldn’t provide any. She’s initiated pile ons but is very sensitive to any criticism herself.

She’s a wonderful writer and campaigner who has done some real good, but I take her claims with a large pinch of salt!

SplatPancake · 04/08/2022 15:54

“That said, I do have questions. Where were her family and child’s father when he was begging for more bread and jam? Why did they let her do sex work?”

They were all right there, @Bnxybee engaged and helping her. But this is where her timeline can only be charitably described as “unclear”. In various publications she has herself described her poverty as lasting for a only a few months or a couple of years (or 10 years), dependent on food banks for months for formula (although they’re not allowed to give this out, particularly for a 2.5year old), or only a few times. In a podcast with Sophie Ellis Bextor last year she described the actions of her parents as “the wrinkle in her story”. In the podcast she says she accompanied a friend once to a foodbank, saw a friend of her parents from their church volunteering there, and confessed all to her parents immediately before they found out from the friend. Her parents then turned up the same afternoon with bags of food. She claimed she was “too embarrassed to tell them”, preferring to let her child go cold and hungry? (You will doubtless be aware that she herself has provided different versions of this over the years, so 🤷‍♀️ )

Her parents foster children, and do not give the slightest impression that they would let their grandchild suffer in any way. So again 🤷‍♀️It really doesn’t stack up.

Her ex partner, the actual resident parent has been involved since pregnancy, with completely shared custody until she came back to Essex after the split with Allegra, when he became main carer as the boy got a school place in his town, not her’s. She thanks him here amp.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2019/dec/27/jack-monroe-motherhood-thank-you-brave-father

And I believe that her ex’s new partner appeared on a mumsnet thread some years ago decrying the way he’d been depicted in her tales (not sure the thread still exists as her threads have previously been zapped immediately…) and setting the record straight re custody, maintenance etc. She has always been a co-parent, not an “abandoned single mother” as she often paints herself…. His grandparents on his fathers side also seem to be very engaged.

Her timelines change so often and I think are deliberately obfuscated so that it is impossible to work out when it was even possible for her to take on “sex work” (a term which covers everything from chat lines to prostitution and beyond). I’m afraid I don’t believe she ever did this - and there’s no way such engaged parents and partner would stand by and let this happen. If she couldn’t sort out childcare for her fire service job, how could she sort it for a spot of light prostitution? (I don’t mean to be flippant, I know there’s a lot more to say about sex work in general…)

I think like with all her tales there’s perhaps a nugget of truth in parts of this, but it’s been exaggerated and twisted for impact so much that the truth is lost. And I think she really believes whatever version is the most current, thus all these big contradictory statements, using her own tweets and publications, that have caused such a splash over the past couple of days.

Bnxybee · 04/08/2022 11:22

I really supported her campaign to (re)expand value supermarket brands and as someone with an ADHD diagnosis, I do understand the impulse spends, etc.

That said, I do have questions. Where were her family and child’s father when he was begging for more bread and jam? Why did they let her do sex work?

I’m no fan of the tories but if you buy an expensive dog then can’t afford shower gel, that’s not down to government policies. I’ve made daft financial decisions so I do sympathise but I do think there’s elements of denial.

Crikeyalmighty · 04/08/2022 10:48

She's a strange one. I don't quite get why she doesn't get a nice part time job with a charity or something similar but keep the subscription membership and tone down the 'personal poverty' thing- would be a great second income and some of the tips are quite useful if you are struggling. What is missing in all this 'oh I've just been to Venice and now got a puppy' is a kind of authenticity. My son who is single earns around what she gets off subscriptions and probably paying similar rent and whilst it's quite tight for him mainly as he's on his own , he isn't exactly poor- he too has ADHD and can be impulsive. She does have something to offer but is damaging her brand by not being 100% authentic and telling a few porkies along the way

Gingerkittykat · 04/08/2022 08:33

Her company was struck off at the end of July which could explain the financial mess she is in right now.

From what I have heard the 1978 date is just a mistake and she really was born in 1988.

SweetSakura · 04/08/2022 07:39

It may well be a filing error or data entry error at companies House end

nokitchen · 04/08/2022 07:37

The date of birth for companies house is wrong. She's definitely in her thirties

Butchyrestingface · 04/08/2022 07:14

I googled JM on Companies House and it came up with an address for a JM who owned a company called "On a Bootstrap" and occupation was listed as 'writer'.

Is that the same person?

The reason I ask - DoB was listed as March 1978, which would make them 44 yo. But everything listed online about JM puts her/them as 10 years younger. 😕

longwayoff · 04/08/2022 06:42

Tory MP complaints that a wealthy person is exploiting the poor and making money out of it. Who said irony died when BJ stepped into No 10?

Gingerkittykat · 04/08/2022 04:06

ShrillSiren22 · 02/08/2022 20:48

Do any people genuinely in poverty use her recipes? I know books were supposedly given to food banks but I’ve never seen any of them or even any signposts towards them in any of the 3 food banks I’ve helped out at. I have seen her book in kitchens of almost all of my middle class friends houses though.

I don’t think Jack Monroe is a bad person and I don’t think she’s deliberately grifting. I do think she should be much better advised by people around her as her ND clearly stops her viewing her actions as anything other than perfectly normal when most people in her situation would have acted very differently - asking wealthy parents/ supportive baby father for financial help before going down the sex work/ selling lightbulbs route, not spending £1,500 on a designer puppy if so financially insecure you’re thinking about moving to a one bedroom flat and sleeping on the sofa etc.

As someone who is autistic and currently going through the assessment process for ADHD, I wonder how you have come to the conclusion that ND makes her view her actions as normal? JM plays the autism and ADHD cards a lot, her backstory about her autism diagnosis is iffy and contradictory but I do believe she has got ADHD. Buying a dog on impulse and being generally impulsive with money could be caused by ADHD but the dog was planned as she posted pics of visiting the litter a few weeks before she brought the dog home. Anyone who can't put a lightbulb on due to poverty should not be bringing a puppy into their lives, even if it was gifted as she is now implying.

If I was being generous I would say depression is making her catastrophise about poverty and doing stupid things like buying those garden lights instead of spending a few pennies putting on a lightbulb. However, she has form for exaggerating her poverty and then showing screenshots of her bank accounts and grifting for money using extremely emotionally charged language.

I'm on a budget food group and a lot of people seem to love her peach and chickpea curry but I've not seen her other recipes being used or praised.

mum2jakie · 03/08/2022 14:58

Has the other thread from yesterday been pulled? Threats to sue I suppose? Gets a bit tedious...

ReturnoftheMacbook · 03/08/2022 14:07

The cognitive dissonance is so strong. One minute it’s fuck all landlords the next it’s oh my granda was a landlord I enjoyed working there. I can’t get over the parents, one has an MBE, one was a nurse, is active in the local church and both of whom fostered children, rent out property and are big in the local community neglecting Jack or enabling Jack. It’s not right.

picklemewalnuts · 03/08/2022 08:21

@bellac11 it's a work in progress! Leave the soap sitting in a dish of water for a day. Maybe microwave it for 30 secs.

Mine was too hard for the pump dispenser at first- it took far more water than I anticipated. Don't try and whisk or blend out the lumps, you get bubbles!

I've now found that I can microwave my glass soap dispenser bottle and add more water. It's currently the perfect thickness! I've more sat in the fridge waiting for the next top up. It goes further than letting the bits melt in a mitt.

Pruella · 03/08/2022 04:26

MaryAndHerNet · 02/08/2022 21:37

It's Faux poverty and novelty poverty

The woman at the local Aldi filling her Harvey Nichols bags always springs to my mind. She wasn't there because her was hard up, her could have sold her handbag and fed a poor family for a month.

I don’t think you have to be in poverty to shop at Aldi!

MissTrip82 · 03/08/2022 03:35

I don’t see her as calculating, I feel quite worried for her. She has always seemed very unstable and fragile. I don’t think she’s well at all.

I think some of her articles contain good tips for making grocery money go a bit further; her recipes I haven’t enjoyed on the few occasions I’ve tried them. Ironically I wouldn’t be game to try them if I couldn’t afford to bin the result and have cheese on toast instead.

I remember seeing her articles on how to make your own ready meals and at the time I thought although she was quite right, you could make a nicer version for less money, she really lacked empathy about the effect of chaos, mental illness, unrelenting poverty etc on anyone’s ability to produce a pretend ready meal
lasagne.

MaryAndHerNet · 02/08/2022 21:37

Scianel · 02/08/2022 21:17

I think her recipes are more like a middle-class idea of what the poor should be cooking, than what anyone who is skint is likely to cook in reality.

It's Faux poverty and novelty poverty

The woman at the local Aldi filling her Harvey Nichols bags always springs to my mind. She wasn't there because her was hard up, her could have sold her handbag and fed a poor family for a month.

Scianel · 02/08/2022 21:17

I think her recipes are more like a middle-class idea of what the poor should be cooking, than what anyone who is skint is likely to cook in reality.

BornIn78 · 02/08/2022 21:04

Nobody living in poverty uses her recipes.

Is someone really going to rinse the sauce off a tin of baked beans to bung them in a tinned peach curry or whatever terrible concoction she’s dreamed up, in the hope that their kids are hungry enough to eat it Confused.

Of course not, they going to heat them up and eat them on toast, or even eat them cold straight from the tin.

Have you seen her vegetable peel bake? Envy <not envy

JohnsShirt · 02/08/2022 21:02

Erm, the point is she did get help from her parents/ex, the rest is made up to get money, AKA grift.
Imagine lying about sex work, particularly when you have a child who can read that online. As can his friends....

ShrillSiren22 · 02/08/2022 20:48

Do any people genuinely in poverty use her recipes? I know books were supposedly given to food banks but I’ve never seen any of them or even any signposts towards them in any of the 3 food banks I’ve helped out at. I have seen her book in kitchens of almost all of my middle class friends houses though.

I don’t think Jack Monroe is a bad person and I don’t think she’s deliberately grifting. I do think she should be much better advised by people around her as her ND clearly stops her viewing her actions as anything other than perfectly normal when most people in her situation would have acted very differently - asking wealthy parents/ supportive baby father for financial help before going down the sex work/ selling lightbulbs route, not spending £1,500 on a designer puppy if so financially insecure you’re thinking about moving to a one bedroom flat and sleeping on the sofa etc.

WilmaFlintstone1 · 02/08/2022 20:42

Ah yes, a designer puppy, hair done in Toni & Guy plus a tattoo but poor Jack is skint.

Quick…send cash.

oh wait….around 700 people a month do already. Minimum of £3.50….um….yeah!

Grifter and a liar while people live in poverty. Sit down Jack…..you are NOT and never have been in poverty thanks to your lovely family .