Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lee Anderson, Ashfield MP insists Jack Monroe has made a fortune on the backs of the poor.

736 replies

newnamethanks · 15/05/2022 16:47

AIBU to hope for a libel trial as entertaining as Vardy v Rooney and an outcome that rivals the Katy Hopkins debacle?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
SofiaSoFar · 15/05/2022 22:32

@WarnerSisters

Yes! The Tories are shits, and are wrecking the country - but she can simultaneously not be all she seems. We don’t have to pick a side in all arguments. Both sides can be “bad”, to use a simplistic term.

Exactly. It's not an 'either or', FFS.

donquixotedelamancha · 15/05/2022 22:32

People dislike Jack Monroe for the same reason people dislike Jamie Oliver

Not at all. The worst I've heard about Oliver is that he's annoying and preachy.

Reasons people dislike Jack Monroe:

  • She took a lot of money for a book on Kickstarter but then didn't deliver for a very long time after it had been released commercially.
  • She was vegan for about a year while promoting her book on veganism.
  • Some people doubt the veracity of some of her many disabilities and feel some of them are only claimed because they are in the news or someone else has it.
  • It's felt by some that she implies experiencing many years of destitute unemployment whereas, in fact, it was a few months after quitting her fire service job.
  • It's felt by some that she implies she was a poor single mum whereas the Dad has always had some custody and paid maintenance.
  • It's felt be some that she implies she had no resources when unemployed but in fact her wealthy parents routinely helped.

(None of the above is me saying she wasn't poor. Her explanation is that she didn't tell them the extent of her struggles)

  • She has been abusive to a number of other people (e.g. Jamie Oliver for taking a job that 'should have been hers'). Some people feel she incites fans to abuse these people on twitter.
  • She talks very openly about how upsetting she finds it to be criticised online. Some people feel that's hypocritical giver other behaviour.
  • Some people feel that she has no cooking skills or training and that her recipes are cribbed from others. I would point out to those people that her tinned peach curry is like no recipe I've ever seen.
Crikeyalmighty · 15/05/2022 22:31

. Hmm I clearly took this person at far more face value than I should have- sounds too much like a Tommy Robinson/Farage situation for comfort- except not right wing, quite the reverse . I don't disagree with some of her sentiments though.
.
Stand by Lee Anderson being an arse though. I'm from that area originally, I was married to a miner and we were definitely not poor. Not rich, but certainly not poor. He's a misogynistic loudmouth who got lucky!

Wrongkindofovercoat · 15/05/2022 22:29

why do you think Lee Anderson is “of dubious provenance”? Because he was a coal miner? Because he “bagged himself” a seat in parliament?

A coal miner at a pit with no name ? There can't have been many pits left open during the time he was working at one, so it can only have been one of a few ?

WarnerSisters · 15/05/2022 22:23

Yes! The Tories are shits, and are wrecking the country - but she can simultaneously not be all she seems. We don’t have to pick a side in all arguments. Both sides can be “bad”, to use a simplistic term.

If you look at her Twitter replies, there are plenty of people saying, “I haven’t got my latest benefits through yet, but I really believe in you so I’ve put some money into your patreon”. Honestly, it’s grim stuff. Saying “Poverty is bad and the Tories have made it worse” isn’t a green light for her to tell porkie-pies about how she really lived/lives.

Villagewaspbyke · 15/05/2022 22:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

FartyBrainedHippo · 15/05/2022 22:22

I don't get why she's so marvellous because her recipes are 'given away free on the internet'. EVERYONE'S recipes are free on the internet - you just have to Google 'pasta beans recipe' (just an example) and you'll get hundreds. Yes, there will be adverts which earn the author an income. Jack's site has been broken for a very long time, and she doesn't update it now. She's been asking for money to fix it since last year. Before that it was absolutely crammed with adverts and requests for tips.

Villagewaspbyke · 15/05/2022 22:19

dragonatetheparsnips · 15/05/2022 21:14

Wouldnt it be great if all this anger at her was channeled into something which made a difference. Like dealing with the poverty which means that our local food bank is almost empty because of the demand. Let’s get angry that people can’t afford to eat while we subsidise MPs dinners.

But as I said before, it’s much easier to be angry with her. Then you can avoid thinking about the inequality that you - and I - are all benefitting from.

She may well be the worst person in the world for all I know, but if you’re angry with her more than you are angry about the appalling poverty in this country then you are not much better.

Stop pretending she’s the problem

This is a thread on mn about Jack Monroe (see header). That’s why a lot of the responses are about Jack Munroe. its not about inequality or anything else. If you want a thread to focus on that, why don’t you start one.

If Jack Monroe has done some of the things stated on this thread, it’s absolutely right that people are angry. I hope she sues Lee Anderson so we can find out the truth.

Tilltheend99 · 15/05/2022 22:19

And don’t forget the Tories even ditched the triple lock so they don’t even care about pensioners anymore!

Tilltheend99 · 15/05/2022 22:18

@Rantypanties can you point to a time she has asked the poor for money? Don’t say her book because if you can’t afford a book you don’t buy it. But you could borrow it for free from a library if you need help making your money go further with low cost meals.

Its just a bit sad that people on the right need to find villains to deflect from the deep deep harm done to working people in this country since 2010. The conservative haven’t even brought down debt, they have increased taxes, inflation is back to 50s post War levels and we are headed for recession.

Voters should stop expecting the same actions to have different outcomes.

WarnerSisters · 15/05/2022 22:16

dragonatetheparsnips · 15/05/2022 21:14

Wouldnt it be great if all this anger at her was channeled into something which made a difference. Like dealing with the poverty which means that our local food bank is almost empty because of the demand. Let’s get angry that people can’t afford to eat while we subsidise MPs dinners.

But as I said before, it’s much easier to be angry with her. Then you can avoid thinking about the inequality that you - and I - are all benefitting from.

She may well be the worst person in the world for all I know, but if you’re angry with her more than you are angry about the appalling poverty in this country then you are not much better.

Stop pretending she’s the problem

My anger about poverty and inequality is why I’m so bothered by her. I can - and am - pissed off by multiple things. She does nothing but line her own pockets by making loads of noise about poverty, because who could argue with that as a cause? But she actually doesn’t DO anything to help it. She’s too busy “having a chaos”.

We need adults with clarity and direction to fight the inequality, women and men like Marcus Rashford and Naomi Lea (both of whom aren’t perfect, because no one is), not social media addicts who bang a popular drum to keep themselves in designer gear and expensive furniture and holidays. We all like nice stuff, but we don’t buy it then say we’re on the poverty line, and set up a PayPal account for more. And just because she hates the Tories, like I do, doesn’t mean I can turn a blind eye to the exploitation she’s guilty of too.

I can campaign against the Tories in my constituency - how do I stop JM having a platform to take money with untruths from those who might only direct any funds and effort towards her, rather than at a useful local political level?

SofiaSoFar · 15/05/2022 22:16

When Covid lockdown first started and Jamie Oliver had a show on C4 (who he was already contracted to in a long term deal to make multiple shows) about cooking with easily available ingredients, JM was awful towards him.

How can some random, barely known person, think that just because they've self-promoted themselves as an 'expert' in something it means an extremely famous, highly experienced TV presenter chef, already contracted by the TV channel, should be cast aside?

Narcissism at its finest. Yuk.

From limegoss.com

Lee Anderson, Ashfield MP insists Jack Monroe has made a fortune on the backs of the poor.
Villagewaspbyke · 15/05/2022 22:09

newnamethanks · 15/05/2022 21:04

The misogyny and bitter envy on this thread is astonishing. Woman earns money. STONE HER. New Tory of dubious provenance bags himself seat in Parliament, a hefty salary with recent payrise, a comfortable expense account and subsidised food and alcohol suitable to his wants. PRAISE HIM. He's a success with his snout in the public trough. Get over yourselves women, shame on you.

do you think she has money or not though? You seem conflicted here. she does seem to have patreon funds and money from her books, writing and tv. And her father by all accounts is very wealthy. Yet I understand she still claims to be poor.

why do you think Lee Anderson is “of dubious provenance”? Because he was a coal miner? Because he “bagged himself” a seat in parliament?

I don’t think there is anything shameful about being elected to parliament as a job in itself or being a coal miner. I certainly don’t agree with his politics but he was democratically elected and I don’t see there’s anything wrong with that.

Tilltheend99 · 15/05/2022 22:05

Smileyaxolotl1 · 15/05/2022 16:59

Can anyone explain why it is fine and innovative for Monroe to suggest people buy from value ranges and batch cook but disgusting and insensitive when Tories say it.

Yeah: Because Jack Monroe is a semi-normal person who has experienced living in poverty and is dedicated to ending food poverty so that there is no need for food banks. Most Tories come from wealthy families who have historically made their money through exploiting working people and are cuing up to be photographed celebrating the opening of new food banks with a slap up buffet etc My local MP even charged £1 in expenses to the taxpayer for parking on a visit to a food bank.

Look into the history of the French Revolution and the phrase “let them eat cake.” There is only so much people in power and privilege can party (coughs) and patronise people with nothing before the majority of ordinary people fancy a change at the top.

donquixotedelamancha · 15/05/2022 22:02

Well. I'm surprised this thread is still here!

This is only the second Jack Monroe thread I've seen survive over many years, though it's early days.

The key is not to directly call specific statements pies, even if you are being factual, and to avoid being too pejorative about her.

Remember the rules are different when addressing another MNer, so things we can say about The Youtuber Owen Jones would be abuse about her.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 15/05/2022 21:57

So he left college at 19 after doing a course in shipping management ? and then followed his Father down the Pit , 2 years after the miners strike started in 1984, worked there for 10 years and left at 29 in 1996 ?
I struggle with the fact that nobody can come up with the name of the mine he worked at , I know the name of the mine my Grandfather worked at and he has been dead for nearly 40 years.
If he worked down the Pit for 10 years, the name of said mine should be common knowledge surely ? If it isn't, why ? I know he switched sides politically and the Conservatives were, how shall I put it , not previously well thought of in Ex Mining communities for fairly obvious reasons, but if you worked a pit , surely it would be a big part of your story ?

Clymene · 15/05/2022 21:55

I don't think you can consider filing a whole year late 'accidental'. She has responded to the multiple letters from Companies House or she would have been struck off.

HemanOrSheRa · 15/05/2022 21:39

Well. I'm surprised this thread is still here!

NeverDropYourMooncup · 15/05/2022 21:37

CapMarvel · 15/05/2022 18:14

Fairly obviously because the tories are the reason why so many people are - in one of the wealthiest countries in the world, let's not forget - in food poverty.

People dislike Jack Monroe for the same reason people dislike Jamie Oliver, for some reason you shouldn't try to champion causes if you have dared to be successful. Oh no, Jamie is trying to help kids, how dare he grumble grumble.

Doesn't she absolutely despise Jamie Oliver?

donquixotedelamancha · 15/05/2022 21:34

Fwiw I’d love it to get to court.

It won't. You can't sue someone for having an opinion. She has made a fortune and she does claim to speak for the poor.

donquixotedelamancha · 15/05/2022 21:27

You've got some nerve describing Jack Monroe as a woman. Hope you have a lawyer.

She is a woman and 'identifies' as one too. She dropped the non binary thing many years ago after it stopped generating publicity.

Fluval · 15/05/2022 21:23

Clymene · 15/05/2022 21:07

No, I don't accept that it's a 'simple, accidental late filing' @Fluval.

For those who don't know how company accounts work, you file and pay taxes for the year about 9 months after the year has actually ended.

So we're talking about taxes Jack owed for the year ending 31 March 2020. Which she was supposed to have paid in June 2021. And still hasn't.

I really don't know how you can defend this.

If you don’t file your returns on time, it will invariably be noted by HMRC, and you will be subject to a late filing penalty. Nobody is going to dodge a tax obligation by making a late filing, particularly as it will end up costing you more.

Obviously in an ideal world, everybody would remember to pay their taxes on time, but accidental late filings are hardly uncommon.

And it’s a world apart from the crime of tax evasion (or any other of the tabloidy synonyms you wish to use for that).

Rantypanties · 15/05/2022 21:22

Jack Monroe is a nasty piece of work. What has her ‘campaigning’ actually changed over 10 years?

Banging on about being one of the forgotten self employed during lockdown and yet her company (that hasn’t filed accounts and most likely not paid tax) claimed furlough whilst she had her Daily Kitchen Live job, her Hellman’s colab (five figure sum received in her words) as well as Linda McCartney and Del Monte. Pretty sure at that time, whilst living with the head of C4 news, she couldn’t afford a stick of butter so are we to believe that these companies have refused to pay her like they do with all the other chefs? And that she was in a financially abusive relationship?

she’s full of catchy soundbites but follow her for a little while and suddenly things start making less sense. And I’m sorry but who the hell uses make up to make her look like she has a black eye whilst squinting at the camera!?!?! 😂

I really hope she gets taken down a peg or two, and it will stop her from asking for money from people less well off than her.

Villagewaspbyke · 15/05/2022 21:20

newnamethanks · 15/05/2022 21:04

The misogyny and bitter envy on this thread is astonishing. Woman earns money. STONE HER. New Tory of dubious provenance bags himself seat in Parliament, a hefty salary with recent payrise, a comfortable expense account and subsidised food and alcohol suitable to his wants. PRAISE HIM. He's a success with his snout in the public trough. Get over yourselves women, shame on you.

what is actually happening is that a woman who claims to be poor and has made a career out of such claims, threatens to sue someone who says she has made a load of money off the backs of some of the poorest people in society. There seems to be a lot of evidence that what he said is true as pp have posted.

it is not jealousy or misogyny to object to some of the awful behavior alleged above: eg taking money to a personal PayPal for a non existent legal case from desperately poor individuals. I’m not jealous of that at all and I can’t think why anyone would be.

Dancingmoon · 15/05/2022 21:16

newnamethanks · 15/05/2022 21:04

The misogyny and bitter envy on this thread is astonishing. Woman earns money. STONE HER. New Tory of dubious provenance bags himself seat in Parliament, a hefty salary with recent payrise, a comfortable expense account and subsidised food and alcohol suitable to his wants. PRAISE HIM. He's a success with his snout in the public trough. Get over yourselves women, shame on you.

To be honest, I was living in poverty at the same time as Jack became famous - we were homeless after losing our house in the recession, mum didn't pay bills and bailiffs used to come around, and we didn't have food in the place, and went to food banks.

So with all due respect, I wouldn't say I am being misogynistic when I am pointing out that she's a middle-class woman making money out of people's misfortune. It's how the world work, and it marginalises the people who are actually going through the lived experiences. I don't necessarily agree with Anderson on politics either.