Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lee Anderson, Ashfield MP insists Jack Monroe has made a fortune on the backs of the poor.

736 replies

newnamethanks · 15/05/2022 16:47

AIBU to hope for a libel trial as entertaining as Vardy v Rooney and an outcome that rivals the Katy Hopkins debacle?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
yesitssea · 15/05/2022 23:10

Blinky21 · 15/05/2022 22:50

The legal representation is pro bono. What he said is clearly defamatory (I have a qualification in media law) so Jack has every right to sue. If you can't tell the difference between the Tories' attitude to the poor and Jacks then you are beyond help

This is the bit I am confused about.

Which bit is libellous? He said she took money from poor people. She does have a tip jar and a PayPal and a Patreon. Some of the people who paid into it are likely poor.

cakeorwine · 15/05/2022 23:10

The course is NOT compulsory

@SavoyCabbage

He clearly misled the House then

Lee Anderson

I thank my hon. Friend for his intervention, as he makes a perfect point. Not only is it a great deterrent, but the longer those people are locked up in prison, the longer they cannot commit these horrible crimes.
As I was saying, the hon. Member for St Helens North made some great comments about food banks. My invitation is to every Opposition Member: come to Ashfield, work with me for a day in my local food bank and see the brilliant scheme we have in place. When people come for a food parcel now, they have to register for a budgeting course and a cooking course. We show them how to cook cheap and nutritious meals on a budget; we can make a meal for about 30p a day, and this is cooking from scratch

I thank the hon. Gentleman for his intervention, as he makes a great point. Indeed, it is exactly my point, so I invite him personally to come to Ashfield to look at how our food bank works. He will see at first hand that there is not this massive use for food banks in this country. We have generation after generation who cannot cook properly—they cannot cook a meal from scratch—and they cannot budget. The challenge is there. I make that offer to anybody. Opposition Members are sitting there with glazed expressions on their faces, looking at me as though I have landed from a different planet. They should come to Ashfield, next week or the week after, and come to a real food bank that is making a real difference to people’s lives.
I will end now, because Opposition Members are not listening; these are a generation of MPs who never listen. The bad news is that this Labour party is out of control and out of touch, but , thankfully, it is out of power. That is me done, Mr Deputy Speaker.

FartyBrainedHippo · 15/05/2022 23:10

Why does she need PayPal handouts for a Pro-bono case? (or is it no win no fee?). She posted a link asking for money again for the case, but deleted it after Laurence Fox sent her a fiver.

Dodgygeezer · 15/05/2022 23:09

@blinky21
If your 'media law qualification' did include a section on defences to libel, which it appears not to have done, I suggest you ask for your money back. Honest opinion anyone?

Villagewaspbyke · 15/05/2022 23:05

Wrongkindofovercoat · 15/05/2022 22:29

why do you think Lee Anderson is “of dubious provenance”? Because he was a coal miner? Because he “bagged himself” a seat in parliament?

A coal miner at a pit with no name ? There can't have been many pits left open during the time he was working at one, so it can only have been one of a few ?

I’ve no idea where he worked@Wrongkindofovercoat I am asking op why she thinks he has “dubious provenance”.

do you have any information on where he worked?

Theluggage15 · 15/05/2022 23:04

What legal representation are you talking about Blinky? The stuff made up in her head? And what he said is only defamatory if it’s untrue. Don’t need a degree in media law to know that. I am looking forward to the court case although obviously it will never happen.

MaryAndHerNet · 15/05/2022 23:02

Icimoi · 15/05/2022 22:58

By the same token, did food bank users say they wanted lessons in budgeting and cookery? The trouble is that in Anderson's view they and their children shouldn't be allowed to eat unless they attend them.

The cooking lessons are offered, not compulsory.

What I'd like to know is, given the propensity for sharing their lif e on SM, where are all the stories and photos of Jack preparing packages for the poor? Where's the tweets featuring her delivering packages? Wheres the hours she's out in to actually help her local trussel trust?

If she spent time doing minimum wage as she does cyber panhandling, she'd be earning plenty in no time.

Icimoi · 15/05/2022 22:58

WarnerSisters · 15/05/2022 22:49

The money donated was spent on buying copies of her book

HER book

Did the food banks say they wanted it? That it was useful? That their users wanted it? More than, say, using that donated money to get, say, food?

And as a PP has pointed out, she gets royalties on those book sales. She didn’t use her author discount to buy books and donate them herself. She asked for handouts from the public to gain royalties for herself and inflate her sales figures.

Charitable indeed!

By the same token, did food bank users say they wanted lessons in budgeting and cookery? The trouble is that in Anderson's view they and their children shouldn't be allowed to eat unless they attend them.

Smileyaxolotl1 · 15/05/2022 22:57

Blinky21
judging by the evidence of this thread it appears that Monroe likes to take charity money to line her own pockets whereas the Tories don’t help the poor and give them unwelcome advice.
jack doesn’t have a moral high ground here.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 15/05/2022 22:56

Wrongkindofovercoat · 15/05/2022 21:57

So he left college at 19 after doing a course in shipping management ? and then followed his Father down the Pit , 2 years after the miners strike started in 1984, worked there for 10 years and left at 29 in 1996 ?
I struggle with the fact that nobody can come up with the name of the mine he worked at , I know the name of the mine my Grandfather worked at and he has been dead for nearly 40 years.
If he worked down the Pit for 10 years, the name of said mine should be common knowledge surely ? If it isn't, why ? I know he switched sides politically and the Conservatives were, how shall I put it , not previously well thought of in Ex Mining communities for fairly obvious reasons, but if you worked a pit , surely it would be a big part of your story ?

Well, Silverhill closed in the 1990s. Sutton/Brierly closed in 1989. It's not the law that somebody has to work at one pit all their life, whether doing the actual underground stuff or being above ground doing something else like transport (no idea if that's what he did, it's a guess based upon a qualification in shipping management). I think if he'd been making it up, it would have come out long before when he was in the Labour Party.

Rantypanties · 15/05/2022 22:56

@Tilltheend99 stop making this a left vs right thing. It is ridiculous to assume that because I dislike Jack I must be ‘on the right’. She’s trying to make this lawsuit a left vs right/working class vs middle class to deflect from her lies, and yet I don’t know anyone from any background, having to sell their Omega Seamaster watch to pay the rent. She is not working class and that’s not even the worst lie she’s told!!

Blinky21 · 15/05/2022 22:50

The legal representation is pro bono. What he said is clearly defamatory (I have a qualification in media law) so Jack has every right to sue. If you can't tell the difference between the Tories' attitude to the poor and Jacks then you are beyond help

WarnerSisters · 15/05/2022 22:49

donquixotedelamancha · 15/05/2022 22:42

She does nothing but line her own pockets by making loads of noise about poverty, because who could argue with that as a cause? But she actually doesn’t DO anything to help it.

That's not true, she's had fundraisers for food banks. The money donated was spent on buying copies of her book for the food banks- could be more charitable than that?

The money donated was spent on buying copies of her book

HER book

Did the food banks say they wanted it? That it was useful? That their users wanted it? More than, say, using that donated money to get, say, food?

And as a PP has pointed out, she gets royalties on those book sales. She didn’t use her author discount to buy books and donate them herself. She asked for handouts from the public to gain royalties for herself and inflate her sales figures.

Charitable indeed!

Andromachehadabadday · 15/05/2022 22:48

donquixotedelamancha · 15/05/2022 22:42

She does nothing but line her own pockets by making loads of noise about poverty, because who could argue with that as a cause? But she actually doesn’t DO anything to help it.

That's not true, she's had fundraisers for food banks. The money donated was spent on buying copies of her book for the food banks- could be more charitable than that?

She raised money for a food bank, but the food bank spent the money on buying her book. From her?

So she raised money to increase the sales of her book and put money in her own pocket?

Slackadder · 15/05/2022 22:48

Done done good- made a difference. Sorry.

VeryLittleOwl · 15/05/2022 22:46

Clymene · 15/05/2022 21:55

I don't think you can consider filing a whole year late 'accidental'. She has responded to the multiple letters from Companies House or she would have been struck off.

There have been three compulsory strike-off notices delivered in the four years the company has been in existence. Two were discontinued after the required document (accounts or confirmation statement) was filed. The third and most recent one is showing as suspended rather than discontinued, which very strongly suggests to me that HMRC has requested Companies House holds off striking off while they investigate.

Jack themselves said that they got 'five figures' for the Leftover Larder collaboration with Hellmann's in 2020 and their patreon is over 700 subscribers at a minimum amount of £3.50 a month - about 500 of those were added after Nigella Lawson promoted it and I would guess her followers are generally slightly better off than average and some may have signed up to one of the higher tiers.

Oh, and she lives a couple of streets away from a friend of mine and it is categorically not a cheap area.

Slackadder · 15/05/2022 22:46

They are both as bad as each other. But Monroe, she, they, is so obviously not from the poor background she claims. Perhaps she has done done good. I think she is so patronising in the way that only those middle class people with a safety net can be. She really doesn't understand poverty. She really doesn't understand the day to day relentless life of being poor. She can't.

FartyBrainedHippo · 15/05/2022 22:46

(Sorry, donqui, I am of course agreeing with you).

Innocenta · 15/05/2022 22:46

Tilltheend99 · 15/05/2022 22:18

@Rantypanties can you point to a time she has asked the poor for money? Don’t say her book because if you can’t afford a book you don’t buy it. But you could borrow it for free from a library if you need help making your money go further with low cost meals.

Its just a bit sad that people on the right need to find villains to deflect from the deep deep harm done to working people in this country since 2010. The conservative haven’t even brought down debt, they have increased taxes, inflation is back to 50s post War levels and we are headed for recession.

Voters should stop expecting the same actions to have different outcomes.

@Tilltheend99 Loads of people commenting on this thread who have issues with Jack's behaviour are anything but 'on the right' (personally I'm left of the Labour Party), but it's illogical to think that even those who are on the right can't be correct about a single specific topic. Do you think that Boris being pro Ukraine means leftists have to take Russia's side? No, because it's utterly ridiculous.

The same applies with all issues. I disagree vehemently with the Tory Party on 95% of issues, but they're not automatically wrong.

FartyBrainedHippo · 15/05/2022 22:45

That money would have been better spent buying food. Instead Jack got other people to buy her book, got the royalties, the glory, and a boost up the bestsellers chart. How
Many people using foodbanks are that desperate for a cookbook really?

donquixotedelamancha · 15/05/2022 22:42

She does nothing but line her own pockets by making loads of noise about poverty, because who could argue with that as a cause? But she actually doesn’t DO anything to help it.

That's not true, she's had fundraisers for food banks. The money donated was spent on buying copies of her book for the food banks- could be more charitable than that?

Wrongkindofovercoat · 15/05/2022 22:41

These are all the Nottinghamshire Pits that shut during the time Lee Anderson was supposed to be working down one;
Moor Green
Pye Hill
Babbington
Whitwell
Newstead
Linby
Mansfield
Blidworth
Sutton
Warsop
Shireoaks
Steetley
Gedling
Cotgrave
Sherwood
Silverhill
Rufford
Manton
Ollerton
Bilsthorpe

I suppose he might of worked in one or more of them before they closed down ? There are certainly a lot of names to go at !

Smileyaxolotl1 · 15/05/2022 22:38

Tilltheend99

I appreciate that in your desperation to randomly slag off Conservatives, reading the thread was far too much of a challenge for you but apart from the outdated bollocks spouting from your mouth that all Tory MPs are from privileged backgrounds in this particular case it’s Monroe who is the privileged one and the Tory who is the working class one so perhaps put aside your ignorant and unfounded prejudices and educate yourself?

donquixotedelamancha · 15/05/2022 22:37

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Please can we not link to tattle? it might get the thread pulled.

Icimoi · 15/05/2022 22:33

WarnerSisters · 15/05/2022 19:30

You can see on Companies House accounts haven’t been filed for a long time.

It's a small company. I strongly suspect that little if any of her income goes through it, and it may well be that she has paid all her tax on personal earnings.