Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lee Anderson, Ashfield MP insists Jack Monroe has made a fortune on the backs of the poor.

736 replies

newnamethanks · 15/05/2022 16:47

AIBU to hope for a libel trial as entertaining as Vardy v Rooney and an outcome that rivals the Katy Hopkins debacle?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
donquixotedelamancha · 16/05/2022 06:36

£30,000 - 6000 books. Doesn't seem like much of a profit to me.
Considering they have to get out to a lot of food banks

Her cut would be IRO £7,500.

WeCouldBeSpearows · 16/05/2022 06:10

Real food for poor people isn't necessarily lentils, vegan meals and soft cheeses

I agree with you, but there's not much on your list that we ate back in the day (grew up poor in the 70s), and even less that my children would eat now. While they have enjoyed (and asked for the recipe of) some of Jack's accidentally vegan meals that were in her original cookbook.

And actually, lentils featured heavily in my diet when I was a child (usually lentil soup which was often vegan) and I still use them fairly often.

I'm sure your mother was amazing, and would have had no truck with Jack's recipes. That's fine. Personally I prefer Jack's recipes to what you've listed. I've yet to see one of her recipes with an 'exotic ingredient' that isn't readily available in the supermarket.

the real question is whether someone who wasn't born poor should be the poster face for poverty porn

Why do you have to be born poor to try to help others that are? She only got to that position because people appreciated what she was doing. Not everyone, obviously, but the ones that don't maybe don't need that kind of help. Do you have to be born into a musical family to help others learn to play music? Why does she have to be born poor in order to be considered worthy?

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 16/05/2022 04:04

And I know that if my mum had met Jack Monroe, she would have sat her down with a big mug of undrinkable coffee, laughed at the exotic ingredients, known the price of everything else to the last halfpenny, admired her hair and made her feel loved, happy and special. And maybe her ashtray ("Poor Old Fred He Smoked in Bed) and tomato sauce plastic tomato holder weren't Instagram-friendly, but so what?

I still miss her.

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 16/05/2022 03:54

Shocking that poor families should be allowed to watch TV, isn't it? Perhaps their children should be down the pit, or up the chimney, or maybe not born at all?🙄

Whether there is a libel action against Lee Anderson or not, the real question is whether someone who wasn't born poor should be the poster face for poverty porn. I see nothing wrong with Foodbanks offering classes to help parents budget and learn to cook in different ways to survive the appalling cost of living hike. And I don't care whether Mr Anderson worked above or below ground, I've supported the miners from childhood and I see nothing wrong in what he has said. I do, however, recoil from Monroe describing David Cameron as "misty-eyed" when she referred to the death of his child, whilst she herself has posted photos of her small boy, describing him as wearing too small clothes and looking hungry.

Real food for poor people isn't necessarily lentils, vegan meals and soft cheeses. Which of these meals do you think was our weekly food as children, usually the same meal on the same day?
Sugar Butties.
Fried Tomatoes (in lard) and sausage.
Cheese mixed with milk melted under the grill with sausage.
Pink Meat and Mash.
Jam Butties.
Hotpot.
Middle Neck & Barley.
Roast beef dinner.
Egg and chips.
White bread to bulk out every meal with Stork Margarine, onions and cheap paste.
When times were especially hard, we didn't ask mum what was for tea, as we would be told "food", and she would be embarrassed.

Families sharing meat when one family were paid ahead of their relatives. That's what we had to eat , except the sugar butties...my mum refused to descend to that...jam butties were a weekend treat and we weren't allowed to have the free school meals we were entitled to, because they were reserved for poor families.(I know) The first time I saw a yogurt was at secondary school. I still remember the reaction of other pupils when I returned a library book that had our rent card inside it .

Shit food for poor people? Yes.* But she was a superb baker, got food on tick when things were desperate , grew vegetables, had chickens, as had her own mother, who was a widow. It's called being proud, working class and totally devoted to her children. She owned nothing, gave away anything she could, and laughed at the days to come.

If someone had offered classes to the mothers in our street, I don't know whether they would have attended, or been offended. But they would have had a healthy distrust of anyone who has become famous by writing about their own child's hunger.

Those mothers went hungry, my mum went hungry, and I've done the same....it's not a badge of honour, it's putting your children first, every single time.

KeepYaHeadUp · 16/05/2022 03:11

AllotmentTime · 15/05/2022 17:09

Why can she say it and he can’t…

Because she is drawing on personal experience of poverty to say “it’s shit, here are strategies that may help you”

Whereas he is looking down from a place of spectacular privilege to say “you’re doing it wrong and your poverty is your own fault”.

How people can’t see the difference between those two positions is astonishing to me.

This!

severrely · 16/05/2022 02:54

I had a £27 grand a year job. I've not been brought up on benefits and a tracksuit watching Jeremy Kyle. I'm a middle class, well educated young woman who fell a bit by the way side. ~ Jack Monroe

BlushBlushBlush

NewBootsAndRanty · 16/05/2022 01:39

StrawberryLipstickStateOfMind1 · 16/05/2022 01:27

It's cos they have Sky TV.

And a big telly to watch it on.

StrawberryLipstickStateOfMind1 · 16/05/2022 01:27

Zotter · 16/05/2022 00:59

I also think that many people are in dire straits because they either can't or won't budget

Many of those on low incomes are in dire straits because the cost of living is higher than their income. You can’t budget with a minus figure.

It's cos they have Sky TV.

Zotter · 16/05/2022 00:59

I also think that many people are in dire straits because they either can't or won't budget

Many of those on low incomes are in dire straits because the cost of living is higher than their income. You can’t budget with a minus figure.

JemimaTab · 16/05/2022 00:55

And that’s what’s annoying I think. She makes claims that simply aren’t true, and people just believe her. The website is just one example.

JemimaTab · 16/05/2022 00:51

cakeorwine · 15/05/2022 23:30

Exactly. That is the ONE recipe since 2018. In my post, I said there was only one recipe published since 2018 - this is it

YouWhatLove · 16/05/2022 00:25

She’s done some great work with raising awareness of food poverty. She’s also someone who constantly lies. They’re both as bad as each other.

sst1234 · 16/05/2022 00:24

This thread has been enlightening. Always knew that this horrible woman was a self serving publicist. But her antics explained on this thread have well and truly exposed her. Shameful.

MaryAndHerNet · 16/05/2022 00:16

@cakeorwine

Yes there were other funding projects.
Like this one:

www.kickstarter.com/projects/780456006/cooking-on-a-bootstrap-by-jack-monroe/comments

£68k raised from people's.
Please do read the comments and enjoy them. Then Google it a little.

Then google some more.
Unless you're really blind or just.dont want to see it, you'll discover that stuff just doesn't add up in the world of the Hardest grafting , most working class, hero Chef Of The People...

Dauncets · 16/05/2022 00:14

Gawd, that "books to food banks" number is exactly the same as a woman I used to work with who was an "agent" for usborne or scholastic or something. She was always trying to flog the books in the staff room and once a year she held a "sponsored read" which involved people sponsoring her nephew to read a book with all the sponsorship money going to buying books - from her, of course - to "give" to a nearby school. Grift grift grifty McGrift.

me4real · 16/05/2022 00:11

It's litigious and daft for her too claim it's defamation. I think Gwneth Paltrow is conning gullible/vulnerable people with Goop. That's just my opinion, I'm not defaming her or accusing her of a crime or anything.

MaryAndHerNet · 16/05/2022 00:08

cakeorwine · 16/05/2022 00:03

Wrong, there was a crowdfund to buy the books which she then profttied from on each sale

How do you know she profitted?

[[https://www.thebookseller.com/news/monroe-sends-over-6000-copies-new-book-food-banks-after-crowdfunder-1013181[[

£30,000 - 6000 books. Doesn't seem like much of a profit to me.
Considering they have to get out to a lot of food banks

Unless there are other crowdfunders?

You think a publisher would sell 6000 books at a loss?... Really?..

I mean there's doing something good and there's risking bankruptcy.

Or do you think Jack herself knocks up the books on a 1996 Bubblejet printer in her spare room whilst she's slow cooking a gammon joint she rescued from a puddle in a slow cooker she found in a Skip?

cakeorwine · 16/05/2022 00:06

Newham Books is also helping to supply the books to the food banks for less than their RRP, while Heinz has donated 10,000 cans.
Monroe said: “Fundraising for these books and tin cans to foodbanks is about giving people hope, dignity, and decent meals in the most dire of situations. To give people choices, and agency, and good food, and resources.
“The response and generosity to this initiative has been overwhelming and I want to thank the hundreds of people who have supported me in delivering this to the people who need it most. Working with The Trussell Trust ensures that these books will make a real difference and we really hope that this activity once again highlights an issue we all need to be paying attention to.”

Everything I have read about her and her actions seem to me to be someone who is trying to help people.

I judge people by their actions.

cakeorwine · 16/05/2022 00:03

Wrong, there was a crowdfund to buy the books which she then profttied from on each sale

How do you know she profitted?

[[https://www.thebookseller.com/news/monroe-sends-over-6000-copies-new-book-food-banks-after-crowdfunder-1013181[[

£30,000 - 6000 books. Doesn't seem like much of a profit to me.
Considering they have to get out to a lot of food banks

Unless there are other crowdfunders?

ermagerdabear · 15/05/2022 23:57

The ONS were already looking to change how they calculated inflation. Nothing to do with Jack, but good of her to take credit. She also wasn't comparing like for like. I believe the price of Smart Price rice hasn't changed, but it happened to be out of stock on the day that she visited her local Asda. I will of course retract my statement when the Vimes Boot Index is published and I'm proven to be wrong but I won't hold my breath on that one.

Clymene · 15/05/2022 23:54

@Joeblack066 -happily. Monroe has made a career out of supposedly helping the poor. But there is zero evidence that anything she does actually benefits the people she purports to help. It's all a middle class back slapping exercise.

MaryAndHerNet · 15/05/2022 23:52

She gave many copies free to foodbanks
Wrong, there was a crowdfund to buy the books which she then profttied from on each sale.

Got Asda to return Smart Price food to their stores
WRONG Asda had a supy chain issue in her local stores there was plenty of smart.proce.produce in other stores.

and spent many many hours doing the Vimes Boots Index as the RPI included champagne and £10 ready meals ffs!
Wrong. She may have pointed it out, but it was already being worked on before she did.

She gives much of her stuff away for free online, and sells books to people who WANT to buy them, enabling her to continue her philanthropy.
Philanthropy would be better shown with her time than her asking for donations to her personal PayPal...

Lee Anderson (who claimed £220k of expenses in a year
220k on expenses.. breaks down to:

Office Costs
£33,144.30
Staff Travel
£174.00
Staffing
£165,215.27

This is money going to pay people that work in his constituency office.. and it's checked and verified before payment.

SweetSakura · 15/05/2022 23:52

I read some of her blogs really early on, when money was tight for me. I remember being really frustrated as she gradually edited out inconvenient truths from her original life story.

The actual story might have shades of grey and poor decisions ... But at least it was genuine.

It's a shame because her campaigning on food poverty is good. But she's alienated a lot of support by being fairly creative with the truth.

Andromachehadabadday · 15/05/2022 23:51

cakeorwine · 15/05/2022 23:47

Who exactly did she make sure looked at inflation

The ONS

www.theguardian.com/business/2022/jan/26/cost-of-living-crisis-ons-inflation-jack-monroe

Mike Hardie, the head of inflation statistics at the ONS, said in a blog the published annual inflation rate – currently 5.4% – was an average for all households. “But everyone has their own personal inflation rate. Some people may spend a larger proportion of their income on gas and electricity, or petrol if you commute via car daily.”
The move was welcomed by the food writer and activist Jack Monroe, who has exposed how prices for cheaper food products have soared as availability fell, contributing to rising hunger and poverty.

As I said before, you might want to read the thread.

StrawberryLipstickStateOfMind1 · 15/05/2022 23:47

ermagerdabear · 15/05/2022 23:44

Hilarious how much she's conned people into believing her bullshit. The Vimes Boot Index doesn't exist, she didn't make Asda return the Smart Price brand to their stores because it never went away and a 'philanthropist' wouldn't con people who were worse off themselves into donating money to their personal PayPal account to pay for a court case that isn't going to come off.

They'd probably pay their taxes as well come to think of it.

Yep, she's truly awful, and that's putting it mildly.