Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lee Anderson, Ashfield MP insists Jack Monroe has made a fortune on the backs of the poor.

736 replies

newnamethanks · 15/05/2022 16:47

AIBU to hope for a libel trial as entertaining as Vardy v Rooney and an outcome that rivals the Katy Hopkins debacle?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
C8H10N4O2 · 16/05/2022 11:47

I disagree. I think It was an awful thing to say. She said he was using his “dead son” as a ruse to “privatise the NHS”. It was complete nonsense to suggest anyone (including the tories) had any plans to “privatise the NHS”. I’m no Tory but abusing a bereaved parent in such a vile way based on conspiracy theories is utterly wrong imo

Cameron repeatedly referred to his own experience during the election campaign and after. He repeatedly cited this as evidence that the new improved fluffy Tories understood disability and health care, especially in the soft focus interviews in his Oxfordshire kitchen being parent of the year.

It was very effectively deployed against any interviewer challenging their record on health and disability.

Nobody made him do that, it was a strategy.

Villagewaspbyke · 16/05/2022 11:47

cakeorwine · 16/05/2022 08:01

Lee Anderson, it appears, has far more experience with actual poverty that JM.
JM poverty was a choice. Which means it not poverty

What makes you think her poverty was a choice?

I think what makes me think it could have been a choice is that she has a wealthy family and her ex was allegedly paying maintenance. So her claims that she was switching off the fridge and her son was constantly in danger of going hungry don’t ring true.

I am a single mum and there is no one I wouldn’t ask for help if my dcs were in any danger of going hungry. I would ask my family, my ex, anyone. I have no pride whatsoever that would stand in the way of feeding my child.

Villagewaspbyke · 16/05/2022 11:40

ClaudineClare · 16/05/2022 11:26

Why is there so much hate on here for her?

I don’t think it’s hate. I think that for many posters she seems like a self important middle class person who makes money out of pretending to be poor. Lots of people find that objectionable. That’s how I understand it anyway.

I hope she does sue Lee Anderson soo the truth of her claims can be explored.

Villagewaspbyke · 16/05/2022 11:35

Andromachehadabadday · 16/05/2022 10:00

I have to say, I didn’t entirely disagree with her tweet about David Cameron. I can understand why Sainsburys backed off working with her.

But I don’t think she was entirely wrong either.

I disagree. I think It was an awful thing to say. She said he was using his “dead son” as a ruse to “privatise the NHS”. It was complete nonsense to suggest anyone (including the tories) had any plans to “privatise the NHS”. I’m no Tory but abusing a bereaved parent in such a vile way based on conspiracy theories is utterly wrong imo.

I think we need to get back to a place where we have some standards in public life and discourse (this absolutely should apply to everyone including bojo too of course). That doesn’t involve using the death of a child for political ends.

she also refers to her own child all the time in her work, claiming she was so poor she couldn’t feed him (despite as pp pointed out apparently having a wealthy family and not exclusive custody). If it’s really true he was going hungry in those circumstances, social services should have been involved.

MaryAndHerNet · 16/05/2022 11:33

ClaudineClare · 16/05/2022 11:26

Why is there so much hate on here for her?

Have you read the thread?
It might give you a clue.

Some people see through the shite and put 2&2 together to get 4. Others put 2&2 together and get 4 but they break it into portions so it looks like it's 2..

Clavinova · 16/05/2022 11:32

Anderson says that his Welbeck deputies lamp takes pride of place on his desk at Westminster

brief explanation of the role of a Deputy below ground in a coal mine. He can be compared to a supervisor, he was responsible for an area of the pit underground. He would walk the roadways (tunnels to non mining folk) and crawl along the coal face where men were working. He would be supervising all aspects of health and safety...
...he would almost certainly have started work down the pit as a miner and worked his way up to being a Deputy.

The deputy was also responsible for testing for poisonous and explosive gases. He would carry a "deputies lamp" (a davy lamp) to assist him in this.

ClaudineClare · 16/05/2022 11:26

Why is there so much hate on here for her?

Luculentus · 16/05/2022 11:22

Where did you donate the Sainsburys money before they sacked you for that horrible tweet regarding David Cameron’s dead son?

This is so lazy. As has been pointed out, she didn't tweet about Cameron's dead son, she tweeted about Cameron's exploitation of him.

Villagewaspbyke · 16/05/2022 11:21

Pollydonia · 16/05/2022 07:53

Jack Monroe has a solicitor who works pro bono

Why does she crowd fund to her PayPal for legal fees then?

Luculentus · 16/05/2022 11:18

BornIn78 · 16/05/2022 10:26

Hi Jack

Can you link us up to the Vimes Boots Index that I believe you said would be completed by end of Feb whilst rattling your tip jar? There’s no sign of it anywhere.

Can you confirm the amount and also where the rest of the profits from your Teemill t-shirts were donated to, and show us the receipts?

Can you confirm the amount of donations made to your personal PayPal that you linked to on Friday when you were asking for funding for your upcoming lawsuit? And can you also confirm that now you’ve got a pro-bono lawyer you’ll refund anyone that wants their money back?

Thanks Jack.

Even with a pro bono lawyer she would need funds as a shield against the risk of a costs order.

AppleandRhubarbTart · 16/05/2022 11:13

I don't know that 'made a fortune' was the wisest term for him to use. He'd have been better off saying made a decent living or something like that, because talking about other people being well paid inevitably opens any MP up to complaints about salary and expenses. Anderson is going to be on a salary that's multiples of the median in his constituency, so it's a particularly bad idea for him in a way that it isn't for a stockbroker belt Tory MP.

ClaudineClare · 16/05/2022 11:12

The RRP of the paperback Tin Can Cook is £6.99 in paperback. Paperback royalties are usually around 7.5%. So around 53p per book.

PAFMO · 16/05/2022 11:10

As she's now aware of the thread, I'm sure she'll be creating a new account (if she hasn't already) and clarifying some of the rather grey areas surrounding her. Or threatening to sue.

It isn't a race to the bottom, but, as a serendipitous metaphor, life isn't binary is it?
Lee Anderson- twat does not equal JM - Saint.
JM - a construct who "forgets" to send her declaration in and asks other people to pay for stuff does not equal Lee Anderson- Saint.

If both were on fire I'd piss in my own face tbh and then save some koalas.

Notagoodnight · 16/05/2022 11:09

We like our heroes to be squeaky clean and deserving and our villains to be wrong always....

Jack Monroe is deeply problematic but actually some of her recipes are decent (with a little tweaking), She has raised the profile of certain issues and I dont remember anyone publicly saying you can cook decent tasting reasonably nutritious meals from the value range.

The Tory MP may be deeply unpleasant but he probably is right in this comment.

We need to get back to the idea that not everyone is perfect and even imperfect people might say something worth hearing

ClaudineClare · 16/05/2022 11:01

donquixotedelamancha · 16/05/2022 06:36

£30,000 - 6000 books. Doesn't seem like much of a profit to me.
Considering they have to get out to a lot of food banks

Her cut would be IRO £7,500.

@donquixotedelamancha how do you work that out?

Is the book self published? If not, she must have a very unusually lucrative publishing contract. Royalties are usually 10% at the very very most and usually much lower than that, if the format is paper back. E book royalties are about 25%.

So if 6,000 hardback books are sold for 30k, the most she would get is approx £3k before tax and her agent taking a cut if she has one.

Also factor in if she had an advance on the book, her royalties would go to pay that back. Only once the advance has been fully repaid by her royalties would she actually recieve them in cold hard cash.

www.societyofauthors.org/Where-We-Stand/buying-choices/How-do-authors-get-paid#:~:text=Traditionally%20the%20royalty%20is%20a,paperback%20they%20would%20receive%2067p.

WarnerSisters · 16/05/2022 10:59

EmilyBolton · 16/05/2022 10:36

.
The difference is that the Tory Mp categorically stated that the people using food banks can neither cook or budget and that you can eat a cooked meal for 30p. His inference was that ALL these people were ignorant and wilfully so.

Jack Monroe started by SHARING ideas for cost effective meals based on her own experiences of being on the breadline. She was spending huge amounts of time figuring out where and how to shop with little money and create interesting meals out of it. She had to. And then she thought others might benefit from what she had to learnt to do. What money she now makes of that grew out of that original intent. If she now makes a good living and doesn’t worry about where the next meal will come form - good for her..because it has been and is useful for other people if they chose to use her suggestions. It’s a bit like Martin Lewis making millions from MSE …he set up a site to offer and suggest to people how to manage their money…he’s saved the public that have used his advice probably billions. If he’s made millions form it so what- it is a win win as far as I’m concerned. (And he, like Jack, do give a lot back in charitable causes)

The MP was not SHARING his lived experience, based on his own circumstances. The 30p suggestion showed how little he understood about economies of scale and balanced varied diets for small families or individuals (I.e. the majority of folks that find themselves in food banks). He was lecturing people based on , I assume, a few hours here and there spent in the food bank and watching mass meals being produced. Quite frankly it stank of mansplaining habits of suddenly finding out something for himself that nobody else could possibly know and therefore he needed to lecture everyone on his new found knowledge by bagging himself up to be an expert now.
. He is also in a position of power to influence legislation and policy around the amount of money people using food banks have actually got to spend, and when you hear such a person state that it’s because the people at foodbanks are basically undeserving because they don’t want to help themselves by cooking healthily or budgeting , we’re one step away from poor houses. He was entitled and arrogant and just plain wrong. As I said on another thread, I can feed myself for 30p for the odd meal by using leftovers and storecupboard stuff. But that’s cos I have the money and space to utilise “economies of scale” by bulk buying, batch cooking, freezing. And I’m not in fuel poverty so can slow cook cheaper cuts of meat when I do have it. You can’t do that in a bed sit or HOMO.

Hard agree that the MP seems utterly vile and pretty clueless about improving things other than RW Tories, and that this government has done incalculable damage to the country and those in poverty.

But 1) can you please post a single bit of evidence she’s done any giving, regular or otherwise, of her own money to charitable causes? And 2) re her “spending hours and hours” researching and inventing cheap recipes: imagine, just imagine, you worked at her publisher, having commissioned her recipe book from her successful blog, and just when her book was about to go to print, you discovered they were almost all barely-tweaked (if changed at all) lifts from other authors who wrote cheap recipes (like Nigel Slater) and you had to hurriedly rewrite them all to avoid a lawsuit. Imagine if that had happened!

Just imagine…
looks to camera

Theluggage15 · 16/05/2022 10:47

Where does she say she makes a good living? she’s still pretending to be poor and rattling her tin.

Clymene · 16/05/2022 10:47

@EmilyBolton - I don't have an issue with JM making money from what she's done. It's the fact that she denies it and pretends she is living on the breadline. Which is exactly Anderson's point and why she says she's going to sue him!

Clavinova · 16/05/2022 10:43

Luculentus
Word is that he was a surface worker, so "down the pit" is stretching it a bit.

According to a Facebook discussion between Lee Anderson and fellow ex-miners/pit workers from the same area (reminiscing) he completed his underground training at Lound Hall Mining Centre and Mansfield Colliery - he then worked at Sutton Colliery followed by Welbeck where he was a 'deputy'. Anderson says that his Welbeck deputies lamp takes pride of place on his desk at Westminster - one of the former pit workers says Anderson was his deputy for a short time. Obviously there are various activities he might have undertaken apart from hacking/drilling at the coal face (although they seem to have done that in training) - including track laying, pipe fitting and haulage systems but there's no doubt that he worked "down the pit".

PAFMO · 16/05/2022 10:43

EmilyBolton · 16/05/2022 10:36

.
The difference is that the Tory Mp categorically stated that the people using food banks can neither cook or budget and that you can eat a cooked meal for 30p. His inference was that ALL these people were ignorant and wilfully so.

Jack Monroe started by SHARING ideas for cost effective meals based on her own experiences of being on the breadline. She was spending huge amounts of time figuring out where and how to shop with little money and create interesting meals out of it. She had to. And then she thought others might benefit from what she had to learnt to do. What money she now makes of that grew out of that original intent. If she now makes a good living and doesn’t worry about where the next meal will come form - good for her..because it has been and is useful for other people if they chose to use her suggestions. It’s a bit like Martin Lewis making millions from MSE …he set up a site to offer and suggest to people how to manage their money…he’s saved the public that have used his advice probably billions. If he’s made millions form it so what- it is a win win as far as I’m concerned. (And he, like Jack, do give a lot back in charitable causes)

The MP was not SHARING his lived experience, based on his own circumstances. The 30p suggestion showed how little he understood about economies of scale and balanced varied diets for small families or individuals (I.e. the majority of folks that find themselves in food banks). He was lecturing people based on , I assume, a few hours here and there spent in the food bank and watching mass meals being produced. Quite frankly it stank of mansplaining habits of suddenly finding out something for himself that nobody else could possibly know and therefore he needed to lecture everyone on his new found knowledge by bagging himself up to be an expert now.
. He is also in a position of power to influence legislation and policy around the amount of money people using food banks have actually got to spend, and when you hear such a person state that it’s because the people at foodbanks are basically undeserving because they don’t want to help themselves by cooking healthily or budgeting , we’re one step away from poor houses. He was entitled and arrogant and just plain wrong. As I said on another thread, I can feed myself for 30p for the odd meal by using leftovers and storecupboard stuff. But that’s cos I have the money and space to utilise “economies of scale” by bulk buying, batch cooking, freezing. And I’m not in fuel poverty so can slow cook cheaper cuts of meat when I do have it. You can’t do that in a bed sit or HOMO.

What charitable causes has Monroe given anything to?

EmilyBolton · 16/05/2022 10:36

Smileyaxolotl1 · 15/05/2022 16:59

Can anyone explain why it is fine and innovative for Monroe to suggest people buy from value ranges and batch cook but disgusting and insensitive when Tories say it.

.
The difference is that the Tory Mp categorically stated that the people using food banks can neither cook or budget and that you can eat a cooked meal for 30p. His inference was that ALL these people were ignorant and wilfully so.

Jack Monroe started by SHARING ideas for cost effective meals based on her own experiences of being on the breadline. She was spending huge amounts of time figuring out where and how to shop with little money and create interesting meals out of it. She had to. And then she thought others might benefit from what she had to learnt to do. What money she now makes of that grew out of that original intent. If she now makes a good living and doesn’t worry about where the next meal will come form - good for her..because it has been and is useful for other people if they chose to use her suggestions. It’s a bit like Martin Lewis making millions from MSE …he set up a site to offer and suggest to people how to manage their money…he’s saved the public that have used his advice probably billions. If he’s made millions form it so what- it is a win win as far as I’m concerned. (And he, like Jack, do give a lot back in charitable causes)

The MP was not SHARING his lived experience, based on his own circumstances. The 30p suggestion showed how little he understood about economies of scale and balanced varied diets for small families or individuals (I.e. the majority of folks that find themselves in food banks). He was lecturing people based on , I assume, a few hours here and there spent in the food bank and watching mass meals being produced. Quite frankly it stank of mansplaining habits of suddenly finding out something for himself that nobody else could possibly know and therefore he needed to lecture everyone on his new found knowledge by bagging himself up to be an expert now.
. He is also in a position of power to influence legislation and policy around the amount of money people using food banks have actually got to spend, and when you hear such a person state that it’s because the people at foodbanks are basically undeserving because they don’t want to help themselves by cooking healthily or budgeting , we’re one step away from poor houses. He was entitled and arrogant and just plain wrong. As I said on another thread, I can feed myself for 30p for the odd meal by using leftovers and storecupboard stuff. But that’s cos I have the money and space to utilise “economies of scale” by bulk buying, batch cooking, freezing. And I’m not in fuel poverty so can slow cook cheaper cuts of meat when I do have it. You can’t do that in a bed sit or HOMO.

AppleandRhubarbTart · 16/05/2022 10:27

Theluggage15 · 16/05/2022 10:24

And how is she an expert? Because she says so and she’s a woman? Ok then.

Is it not possible for neither of them to be an expert?

BornIn78 · 16/05/2022 10:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Hi Jack

Can you link us up to the Vimes Boots Index that I believe you said would be completed by end of Feb whilst rattling your tip jar? There’s no sign of it anywhere.

Can you confirm the amount and also where the rest of the profits from your Teemill t-shirts were donated to, and show us the receipts?

Can you confirm the amount of donations made to your personal PayPal that you linked to on Friday when you were asking for funding for your upcoming lawsuit? And can you also confirm that now you’ve got a pro-bono lawyer you’ll refund anyone that wants their money back?

Thanks Jack.

Theluggage15 · 16/05/2022 10:24

And how is she an expert? Because she says so and she’s a woman? Ok then.

newnamethanks · 16/05/2022 10:17

Hear, hear.

OP posts: