Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lee Anderson, Ashfield MP insists Jack Monroe has made a fortune on the backs of the poor.

736 replies

newnamethanks · 15/05/2022 16:47

AIBU to hope for a libel trial as entertaining as Vardy v Rooney and an outcome that rivals the Katy Hopkins debacle?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Luculentus · 16/05/2022 15:08

Villagewaspbyke · 16/05/2022 11:58

@C8H10N4O2 - David Cameron did not use his deceased son as a “ruse to privatise the NHS”. That is entirely false. I do not think there is anything more to be discussed there. What happened to his son was a tragedy. Also given he was the parent of a disabled child, I think it’s fair enough for him to say he had an understanding of that (if he did).

plenty of legitimate things you could use to criticise David Cameron. Making cruel comments about his son to back up a conspiracy theory is not on though.

Yet again, it wasn't cruel comments about his son. It was comments about him and the way he was using him for political ends. We will of course never know whether the endgame was privatising the NHS because Cameron fucked up and had to resign, but frankly given that he was very much in government for his own benefit and that of his chums it is highly, highly likely.

ermagerdabear · 16/05/2022 15:03

WarnerSisters · 16/05/2022 14:46

Don’t know why @teyallm ’s post was taken down by MN, but it did prove the point about JM in several ways.

It was probably a troll, sent here to discredit the entire thread. I can't believe someone could be that stupid, tbh. It's not beyond the realms of possibility but still...

WarnerSisters · 16/05/2022 14:46

Don’t know why @teyallm ’s post was taken down by MN, but it did prove the point about JM in several ways.

WilmaFlintstone1 · 16/05/2022 14:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Scianel · 16/05/2022 14:12

@teyallm that's tax evasion 😂 Or more likely satire.

ermagerdabear · 16/05/2022 14:03

@teyallm is your post a joke?! You're sending her cash?! GTFO 🤣

teyallm · 16/05/2022 13:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Trainbear · 16/05/2022 13:39

Surely if you write a book you expect to get paid and if your book is focussed at a particular group then the allegation is incontestable?

Then again it's a Tory so behaviour to quote Lord of the Flies-
"Kill the pig, slit it's throat, spill it's blood" is Dr rigeur.

WeCouldBeSpearows · 16/05/2022 13:35

Thank you for your reply. I think your comment that there's not much on my list that your children would eat illustrates my point: we didn't have a choice as children; you ate the meal you were given, there was no plan B. How could there be? There wasn't anything else to eat -we had to eat those meals through the 70s and 80s

I note that you missed out the fact that there's not much that i would have eaten as a child either, despite being brought up in the 70s with not much money.

What you ate was based on what was available where you were and what you're mother was willing and able to cook. Thankfully things have changed since then, diets are more interesting, ingredients are more varied. My children also ate what they were given. They just weren't given the same things that I was in the 70s. That's a good thing.

AmwajAnnie · 16/05/2022 13:02

He worked at the Sutton pit. It's on HIS Facebook and very easy to find. No mystery at all.

C8H10N4O2 · 16/05/2022 12:51

Villagewaspbyke · 16/05/2022 11:58

@C8H10N4O2 - David Cameron did not use his deceased son as a “ruse to privatise the NHS”. That is entirely false. I do not think there is anything more to be discussed there. What happened to his son was a tragedy. Also given he was the parent of a disabled child, I think it’s fair enough for him to say he had an understanding of that (if he did).

plenty of legitimate things you could use to criticise David Cameron. Making cruel comments about his son to back up a conspiracy theory is not on though.

Presumably you missed all those Hello magazine type interviews with him in 2010 when it came up every time the Tories were challenged on health and disability. It was also being cited routinely in canvassing to shut down any suggestion that the Tories had a poor record on health and disaiblity.

In fact that whole campaign in 2010 was based on them no longer being the "nasty party".

C8H10N4O2 · 16/05/2022 12:46

Whelmed · 16/05/2022 11:53

Is the backlash against JM because she's not in poverty anymore? I think she highlights, intentionally and unintentionally how complex poverty is and the issues around it, such as mental health, shame, stigma etc. I don't think she is poor anymore but she seems to be able to create nice recipes for very low cost. They've been useful for me when I've had very little money to spend on groceries.

My local foodbank gives out recipes and tips from her materials which are made free of charge to anyone using them for foodbank/educational use. They are popular because they focus on a make do and mend approach to what you have and what is low cost - people can actually use the information in them.

I don't really care how many times Lee Anderson claims to have been down a pit or not. The simple fact that he thinks women are responsible for family poverty because they are incompetent and that you can feed a family for 30p per head per day shows he knows sod all about the reality of poverty or perhaps he doesn't care and just wants the publicity.

It does however fit a common pattern of WC men made good men who burnish their own image by blaming those who don't "make good" for being failures, unlike their important and successful selves.

donquixotedelamancha · 16/05/2022 12:37

ClaudineClare · 16/05/2022 11:01

@donquixotedelamancha how do you work that out?

Is the book self published? If not, she must have a very unusually lucrative publishing contract. Royalties are usually 10% at the very very most and usually much lower than that, if the format is paper back. E book royalties are about 25%.

So if 6,000 hardback books are sold for 30k, the most she would get is approx £3k before tax and her agent taking a cut if she has one.

Also factor in if she had an advance on the book, her royalties would go to pay that back. Only once the advance has been fully repaid by her royalties would she actually recieve them in cold hard cash.

www.societyofauthors.org/Where-We-Stand/buying-choices/How-do-authors-get-paid#:~:text=Traditionally%20the%20royalty%20is%20a,paperback%20they%20would%20receive%2067p.

I'm happy to accept your figures and spy she probably only made 3k from the food bank donations.

You are right, that makes it OK :-)

Andromachehadabadday · 16/05/2022 12:32

Wether you agree or disagree with her tweet.

Her tweet was about David Cameron. You may feel it was awful towards him.

but the phrase ‘awful tweet about David Cameron’s son’ is incorrect. It’s used to make it sound like she said something really terrible about a deceased child with disabilities.

I am not that keen on her but I think the difference between the 2 is important.

donquixotedelamancha · 16/05/2022 12:29

Is the backlash against JM because she's not in poverty anymore?

See my post upthread for a list of what gets the most criticism, it's more about a perception of regular deceit and a feeling that everything she does has shilling for money and attention somewhere in it

On the 'not in poverty anymore': she was voluntarily unemployed for several months after returning from maternity. Her baby's father paid maintenance and her wealthy parents were supportive. Some people feel that doesn't match her claims of extreme poverty.

There is also her online behaviour.

Manicsfan · 16/05/2022 12:25

Clymene · 15/05/2022 18:33

She is like the woman in the Pulp song Common People @NoSquirrels. She comes from a comfortably middle class background, she gets on very well with her family and co-parents amicably with her son's father. If she ever did live in poverty, it was her choice. She had plenty of people who would ensure thar she and her son would be well fed, clothed and housed.

As a pp said, it's cosplay. And as in the pulp song 'If she called her dad, she could stop it all'.

I would have a lot more respect for her if she'd actually come clean. She still says she's poor.

And why anyone is defending someone who DOESN'T PAY HER TAXES is beyond me.

Or is it only right wing people who we can attack for not paying tax?

Just noticed I made the same reference several pages later-oops! Great minds @Clymene 😀

ClaudineClare · 16/05/2022 12:23

I must have missed them!

WowStarsWow · 16/05/2022 12:19

ClaudineClare · 16/05/2022 12:11

Also given he was the parent of a disabled child, I think it’s fair enough for him to say he had an understanding of that (if he did)

It is sad that despite having an understanding of the challenges of disability, his government and succesive governments still had a policy of making life as difficult as possible for disabled people.

As for Jack, she is no different to Oliver and of lots of others in the cookery world. I like Oliver, but he likes to jump on a bandwagon too and has also made some serious mistakes. His mistakes cost people their jobs. I don't see the same unrelenting hate directed at him.

Have you never seen a Jamie Oliver thread on here 🤣

Flavourflava · 16/05/2022 12:18

Jack's life story aside, and back to the case in hand:

She went swinging for Anderson all week and said a lot *about him. He had a pop back. She can't resist the drama, and encouraged by her very enthusiastic Twitter fan-base, whipped up a lot of excitement and views of the video which would have otherwise remained in it's pitiful right-wing obscurity. She spent a lot of the day excitedly discussing how they'd be buying her a house and/or making her a millionaire.

In the cold light of day, she appears to have regrets.

Bring it on, I say, they're all as bad as each other.

ClaudineClare · 16/05/2022 12:11

Also given he was the parent of a disabled child, I think it’s fair enough for him to say he had an understanding of that (if he did)

It is sad that despite having an understanding of the challenges of disability, his government and succesive governments still had a policy of making life as difficult as possible for disabled people.

As for Jack, she is no different to Oliver and of lots of others in the cookery world. I like Oliver, but he likes to jump on a bandwagon too and has also made some serious mistakes. His mistakes cost people their jobs. I don't see the same unrelenting hate directed at him.

MaryAndHerNet · 16/05/2022 12:10

Borisblondboufant · 16/05/2022 11:55

She still regularly gives the impression she is living in poverty. Which is blatantly not true. That’s the issue here.

There's 2 things I can think here.

1: she's actually in poverty as she claims. In which case the monthly patreon cash, PayPal donations, tip jars, book income, media appearance fees etc have all been wasted.
This proves she's bad with money and is in no position to advise anyone on how to spend theirs.

2: she's not actually so deep in the poverty that she claims. In which cases she's lying about the claims of poverty and in no position to advise anyone on money matters.

Which one is the truth? I don't know.
Logically, pretending to be broke would illicit sympathy from her many 1000s of followers. This could lead to a tiny percentage donating to her out of that sympathy.

Pretend to be poor and broke to a few thousand followers, get sympathy and support from those unwilling or unable to research her, get a small percentage of followers to donate.
Even 1% her followers donating £5 to her PayPal is a shit ton of cash the likes of which most UC and poor people could only dream.

340k followers. 1% of those 3400.
3400 donate £5 in a year.
£17000.

Manicsfan · 16/05/2022 12:07

I've bought Jack's books and followed her recipes.
When reading the books I was always struck and awed by how a working class person could claw herself up from poverty, and how she had the confidence to articulate herself so well.
Sadly I then learned she was appropriating the experiences of the poor. I grew up working class, where lack of money caused huge distress and anxiety as my Mum struggled in two jobs to keep a roof over our head and food on the table. Jack's experiences as she describes them are not authentic.
She is the living embodiment of the Pulp lyric " if you call your Dad he could stop it all".
That's the main reason I've stopped giving her any attention. She's a dishonest attention seeker.

Villagewaspbyke · 16/05/2022 11:58

@C8H10N4O2 - David Cameron did not use his deceased son as a “ruse to privatise the NHS”. That is entirely false. I do not think there is anything more to be discussed there. What happened to his son was a tragedy. Also given he was the parent of a disabled child, I think it’s fair enough for him to say he had an understanding of that (if he did).

plenty of legitimate things you could use to criticise David Cameron. Making cruel comments about his son to back up a conspiracy theory is not on though.

Borisblondboufant · 16/05/2022 11:55

She still regularly gives the impression she is living in poverty. Which is blatantly not true. That’s the issue here.

Whelmed · 16/05/2022 11:53

Is the backlash against JM because she's not in poverty anymore? I think she highlights, intentionally and unintentionally how complex poverty is and the issues around it, such as mental health, shame, stigma etc. I don't think she is poor anymore but she seems to be able to create nice recipes for very low cost. They've been useful for me when I've had very little money to spend on groceries.

Swipe left for the next trending thread