Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lee Anderson, Ashfield MP insists Jack Monroe has made a fortune on the backs of the poor.

736 replies

newnamethanks · 15/05/2022 16:47

AIBU to hope for a libel trial as entertaining as Vardy v Rooney and an outcome that rivals the Katy Hopkins debacle?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
NeverDropYourMooncup · 16/05/2022 22:19

Wrongkindofovercoat · 16/05/2022 22:01

He's worked at Sutton, Wellbeck, Manton and Creswell pits, there's plenty of reference to these on his own Facebook and website im not sure why people are making out he's secretive about where he worked

Thank you for that @C8H10N4O2 As I said it wasn't that I thought he was making it up, it was the whole 'oh he was a coal miner so knows poverty' stuff, it was a relatively decent 'for life' job at one point, obviously not MP salary decent but well above NMW or average UK salary.

Not since he went into it - the entire Miners' Strike was about them being shut down.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 16/05/2022 22:01

He's worked at Sutton, Wellbeck, Manton and Creswell pits, there's plenty of reference to these on his own Facebook and website im not sure why people are making out he's secretive about where he worked

Thank you for that @C8H10N4O2 As I said it wasn't that I thought he was making it up, it was the whole 'oh he was a coal miner so knows poverty' stuff, it was a relatively decent 'for life' job at one point, obviously not MP salary decent but well above NMW or average UK salary.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 16/05/2022 20:51

AppleandRhubarbTart · 16/05/2022 19:35

True. Imagine the ridiculousness.

Depends. I've worked (waitressed, let's be honest about it - it was my second job because I was skint) with 'chefs' whose only experience was microwaving things vacuum packed from Brakes or dropping something from the freezer into a deep fat fryer and some who wouldn't dream of touching any ingredient that wasn't the best of the best and therefore had never touched a tin of basics beans, much less considered using them in a recipe. At one place, the one person who could make great meals out of almost nothing was the guy on potwash.

If they're that broke they need a foodbank referral, it's unlikely they can't afford the fuel to cook anything or could live somewhere that doesn't have cooking facilities - so a class would mean they had access to free gas/electricity, leaving the lower cost option of reheating in a microwave or eating cold as well, whereas without the money to feed themselves and put more money on the gas/electricity, they would have been left with raw ingredients and no means to cook them.

MaryAndHerNet · 16/05/2022 20:46

ermagerdabear · 16/05/2022 20:28

Not just 'ordinary' people either. She's taken a pop at some big names too, including David Walliams, Jamie Oliver (AKA THAT MAN) and JK Rowling. All of whom had the good sense to completely ignore her.

Jack will get support if she goes after the right people.

People don't like Laurence Fox or Tory MPs, so she'll get support. There's little risk to her after all, every penny she gets is handed to her by someone poor schmuck that has drunk Monroe's 6p version of Kool-Aid made from puddle water strained through a scarf.

ermagerdabear · 16/05/2022 20:28

Not just 'ordinary' people either. She's taken a pop at some big names too, including David Walliams, Jamie Oliver (AKA THAT MAN) and JK Rowling. All of whom had the good sense to completely ignore her.

FictionalCharacter · 16/05/2022 20:14

@WilmaFlintstone1 I agree with most of that. I followed her for a long time on Twitter, then I saw a lot of inconsistencies in some of the things she says. And it’s unpleasant to see how vicious she can be to ordinary people who do nothing worse than disagree with what she’s said in some minor way.

AppleandRhubarbTart · 16/05/2022 19:35

mmmmmmghturep · 16/05/2022 18:30

@AppleandRhubarbTart In fact if you follow that through to its logical conclusion it is certainly possible that an unemployed CHEF or a chef on limited hours could be forced to do the cookery course to access the food bank.

True. Imagine the ridiculousness.

1전복q · 16/05/2022 19:16

but since he makes such a big deal of it as evidence that he is an expert on poverty then he should expect that claim to be challenged.
Same as jack then really, both making claims to past poverty to make their point the loudest.
I don't think either come out of this particular situation looking good.

C8H10N4O2 · 16/05/2022 18:47

1전복q · 16/05/2022 15:36

He's worked at Sutton, Wellbeck, Manton and Creswell pits, there's plenty of reference to these on his own Facebook and website im not sure why people are making out he's secretive about where he worked, he's list them here. www.leeanderson.org.uk/news/brexit-coronavirus-and-everything-between-ashfield-mp-reflects-eventful-first-year-office
He's a twat in many aspects but the whole he never worked at a pit/why won't he say the pits he worked at posts on here and Twitter are weird when it's an easy Google.

Well I'd imagine the questions are because the only evidence anyone has cited is from his own pages rather than anything third party.

I don't particularly care about his mining experience but since he makes such a big deal of it as evidence that he is an expert on poverty then he should expect that claim to be challenged.

Anyone who starts from a premise that women using foodbanks (and yes this is about women) are simply incompetent and if they just tried harder they could feed people on 30p a day is trading in old fashioned populist tropes and benefits bashing.

C8H10N4O2 · 16/05/2022 18:37

Luculentus · 16/05/2022 15:08

Yet again, it wasn't cruel comments about his son. It was comments about him and the way he was using him for political ends. We will of course never know whether the endgame was privatising the NHS because Cameron fucked up and had to resign, but frankly given that he was very much in government for his own benefit and that of his chums it is highly, highly likely.

I'm actually not sure what we are differing on here. I never said that Cameron's son was used as a ruse to privatise health care (which has substantial areas of privatisation in place already). I said that it was presented repeatedly in the campaign as part of the image of a new fluffy Tory party could be trusted with teh NHS.

Cameron could at any time in those interviews said that his family experience was a private matter or that he didn't want them to be part of campaigning. It was used in campaigning and was often a key element of those soft focus interviews. As I said upthread, I would not have made that tweet but the facts of that campaign would support her point.

The moment they got into power, Cameron and Osborne launched an austerity campaign and the underfunded UC disaster which had horrific impact on the disabled and chronically ill leading not only to poverty in this group but deaths waiting for benefits and suicides whilst navigating the kafkaesque systems.

The pair of them (and Clegg) then fucked off after a disastrous performance and maximised the revenue streams whilst their names were still hot, instead of staying around to try and help with the fall out. Yes a shining example of commitment and integrity to us all.

mmmmmmghturep · 16/05/2022 18:30

@AppleandRhubarbTart In fact if you follow that through to its logical conclusion it is certainly possible that an unemployed CHEF or a chef on limited hours could be forced to do the cookery course to access the food bank.

WilmaFlintstone1 · 16/05/2022 18:30

I can definitely say that not one of the local food banks near me insist on budgeting and cooking lessons. How absolutely patronising to people who have nothing. They don’t get given ready meals by our food banks. They get various food which can be made into meals. We do have a supply of recipes for people who want them though.

Id have no issue with cooking demos if they were voluntary and as an added offer for people who want them. In my experience though it’s down to lack of money not down to lack of budgeting and being unable to cook.

Again the recipes in Jack’s first book were generally good, I used them myself and I still have a copy of that book.

Recipes which can be made cheaply are fabulous but we need to stop talking about the pennies per portion unless we also include petrol/travel costs to get the ingredients, the energy cost in gas or electric, plus the cost of buying the whole pack of pasta/rice/whatever.

it’s never 30p a portion or 11p a portion unless you’ve taken those extra costs into account.

kateandme · 16/05/2022 18:27

SilverBirchWithout · 16/05/2022 17:30

Personally I really hope the court case goes ahead. For far too long Jack Monroe has been enabled by parts of the media to have a lucrative ‘career’ based on very little talent, her shiftiness needs to be exposed in court.

I’m certainly no supporter of MPs like Lee Anderson, however JM is a classic example of the dangers of social media creating a Saint-like figure who becomes untouchable because of her curated and embellished back-story. On some level I feel deeply sorry for her - having created a brand based on her ‘tragic’ life but with no real skill or talent she has to continue making herself relevant by creating further ‘content’ through Twitter arguments and the retelling of her life story, adding additional emotive-laden issues each time.

However any empathy I feel towards her is eroded because she is so horrible to anybody who dares to utter even the slightest question about what she is presenting. I have a family member who is a narcissist and JM displays similar behaviour.

I wish people on this thread would open their eyes to the damage she causes.

Yes yes yes to this brilliant post.
The embellished grown emotive bs with each new post...ugh
And the horrid way her army jumps on top of anyone she points them to.its disgusting.
It's this saint like status.this superstar veil.people react yo her a bit like me a hinch armys.its worrying.

SilverBirchWithout · 16/05/2022 17:30

Personally I really hope the court case goes ahead. For far too long Jack Monroe has been enabled by parts of the media to have a lucrative ‘career’ based on very little talent, her shiftiness needs to be exposed in court.

I’m certainly no supporter of MPs like Lee Anderson, however JM is a classic example of the dangers of social media creating a Saint-like figure who becomes untouchable because of her curated and embellished back-story. On some level I feel deeply sorry for her - having created a brand based on her ‘tragic’ life but with no real skill or talent she has to continue making herself relevant by creating further ‘content’ through Twitter arguments and the retelling of her life story, adding additional emotive-laden issues each time.

However any empathy I feel towards her is eroded because she is so horrible to anybody who dares to utter even the slightest question about what she is presenting. I have a family member who is a narcissist and JM displays similar behaviour.

I wish people on this thread would open their eyes to the damage she causes.

OversBo · 16/05/2022 17:25

Good post @AppleandRhubarbTart

A lot of food bank users simply don’t have enough money. Inflation is at a 30 year high and benefits would need to go up by at least 8% just to match what they were a year ago. I was listening to someone on the radio talking about this, someone from Citizens Advice I think.

AppleandRhubarbTart · 16/05/2022 16:59

Budgeting and cooking courses, being as they aren't on the national curriculum, are a VERY good idea.

If, as he claimed in the Commons, they're a condition of getting food then no they're not. That is support that should be available, yes, but it shouldn't be compulsory. It also far too often, and apparently in his case, goes hand in hand with a refusal to accept that it sometimes isn't a question of good management, there simply isn't enough however the cloth is cut. For some food bank users, cooking and budgeting courses will simply be a waste of their time.

We have had a poster say they actually aren't compulsory at that particular food bank, though I don't know whether that's true or not. If it's not compulsory then that would be better, but it would also mean he's either lying or doesn't know much about the food bank he apparently works at. Neither of which would paint him in a great light.

Dauncets · 16/05/2022 16:42

Is the backlash against JM because she's not in poverty anymore?

She was never "in poverty" any more than a middle class student is "in poverty" if their loan runs out before the end of term. She had a temporary cash flow issue 10 years ago because she quit her job. That is not the same as being "in poverty". If she thinks it is, then she is the last person who should be commenting about poverty.

FreddyVoorhees · 16/05/2022 16:27

I wonder if they will actually go through with this libel action because given the amount of media work and other funding sources (e.g. Patreon) they are either going to be shown as earning a decent amount by the standards of those they claim to be helping or they are actually nowhere near as influential as they make themselves out to be.

From what little I know of them, they do seem to play the "I did the poverty thing" card quite a lot. Which frankly suggests they aren't poor anymore. People genuinely on the poverty line tend not to have time to do what they are doing.

I'd expect them to be hoping that the nasty Tory won't actually call their bluff on this one.

As for the Tory MP, just because he's a Tory and even worse, male, doesn't make him automatically wrong. Budgeting and cooking courses, being as they aren't on the national curriculum, are a VERY good idea.

From life and work experience (single parent family/council estate/worked in both benefits and debt) some people are skint because they are truly, genuinely bloody awful with money as the MP in question probably saw quite a bit when at the CAB.

You can increase benefits by however much you want other people to pay for them but some people will not be helped unless they change their spending habits and decision making. Quite a few friends of mine if you gave them a £2,000 cost of living help cheque would have the lot spent in minutes on whatever caught their eye. Net effect? Absolute zero.

SofiaSoFar · 16/05/2022 16:07

1전복q · 16/05/2022 15:36

He's worked at Sutton, Wellbeck, Manton and Creswell pits, there's plenty of reference to these on his own Facebook and website im not sure why people are making out he's secretive about where he worked, he's list them here. www.leeanderson.org.uk/news/brexit-coronavirus-and-everything-between-ashfield-mp-reflects-eventful-first-year-office
He's a twat in many aspects but the whole he never worked at a pit/why won't he say the pits he worked at posts on here and Twitter are weird when it's an easy Google.

Completely agree. I despise the man for various reasons but some in this thread are determined to make out he's lying about his background when he's almost certainly not.

It just smacks of desperation to paint him in an even worse light than he manages himself, as if that somehow negates what an arsehole JM is.

They can both be vile people at the same time.

1전복q · 16/05/2022 15:36

Wrongkindofovercoat · 16/05/2022 15:24

@AmwajAnnie Sutton pit that shut in 1989 when he was 22 ?

He's worked at Sutton, Wellbeck, Manton and Creswell pits, there's plenty of reference to these on his own Facebook and website im not sure why people are making out he's secretive about where he worked, he's list them here. www.leeanderson.org.uk/news/brexit-coronavirus-and-everything-between-ashfield-mp-reflects-eventful-first-year-office
He's a twat in many aspects but the whole he never worked at a pit/why won't he say the pits he worked at posts on here and Twitter are weird when it's an easy Google.

Lee Anderson, Ashfield MP insists Jack Monroe has made a fortune on the backs of the poor.
AppleandRhubarbTart · 16/05/2022 15:34

Luculentus · 16/05/2022 15:08

Yet again, it wasn't cruel comments about his son. It was comments about him and the way he was using him for political ends. We will of course never know whether the endgame was privatising the NHS because Cameron fucked up and had to resign, but frankly given that he was very much in government for his own benefit and that of his chums it is highly, highly likely.

Yep. And the idea that the deliberate underfunding of the NHS for over a decade couldn't possibly have had anything to do with a desire to soften the public up for selling it won't wash either. None of this is to say Jack isn't full of shit about her background, I don't know anything about her, but the way in which her tweet was presented as being awful about a child's death is plain wrong.

Andromachehadabadday · 16/05/2022 15:27

Really want to know what @teyallm post said now!

Wrongkindofovercoat · 16/05/2022 15:24

@AmwajAnnie Sutton pit that shut in 1989 when he was 22 ?

PAFMO · 16/05/2022 15:12

Whelmed · 16/05/2022 11:53

Is the backlash against JM because she's not in poverty anymore? I think she highlights, intentionally and unintentionally how complex poverty is and the issues around it, such as mental health, shame, stigma etc. I don't think she is poor anymore but she seems to be able to create nice recipes for very low cost. They've been useful for me when I've had very little money to spend on groceries.

It's not a backlash for those of us who never believed any of the tripe she force fed us.

Luculentus · 16/05/2022 15:09

Sorry, meant to say that it was comments about him (Cameron) and the way he was using his son for political ends.