Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To frown on an untidy house

311 replies

allinadaystwerk · 15/05/2022 16:30

My house is not a haven of organised domestic bliss by any means, I have messy corners and cupboards and all that stuff. And some days are much better than others. But I visited someone I've known a while for the 1st time
and was shocked at the state of the house. It was not dirty or smelly. Washing up was done and toilet was clean. But there was clothes everywhere! And clutter and paperwork, letters leaflets and general stuff just not put away, shoes were left in the living room and piles upon piles of laundry. Everywhere I looked there was stuff and an untidy mess. Clearlyvot had been this way for some time. I felt quite sad but also kind of disgruntled. I wanted them to do better but had to have a word with myself and find my way to not being a judgy cow. Thing is, if im honest, a bit of me still feels a bit disgruntled and frustrated.. I'll most likely be asked to the home again as we get on very well and of course a messy home is no reason to ruin a friendship. Question is am I being unreasonable to feel like this? .

OP posts:
ArtVandalay · 15/05/2022 18:52

I guess for most people that live in mess, it's not a problem.

I visited a house last week for work. It was a really big and lovely one but OMG the mess. Every single room was a tip. I would hate to live like that, but I don't have to.

Lasana · 15/05/2022 18:50

Objectively there is nothing wrong with a messy house. Have you thought through why you had such a strong reaction to something that isn't really that terrible? Your friend is either ok with it or struggling, and neither of those possibilities deserve judgement.

BeenToldComputerSaysNo · 15/05/2022 18:49

YABU

Goldenbear · 15/05/2022 18:46

I think YABU but IME i know loads of people that do comment on this and they are all arty bohemian types which I think is odd as you would imagine they would be more casual about tidiness. One friend always apologies for the state of her place but I don't care as I am pleased we are not in my house. I have a tidy house due to an aesthetically obssessive architect husband but I hate hosting!

SpilltheTea · 15/05/2022 18:45

Why do you give a shit? I don't understand people who come on here and judge others for pathetically small things. I doubt your friend cares what you think anyway.

Purplecatshopaholic · 15/05/2022 18:41

You sound nice.

Poppymonty3 · 15/05/2022 18:37

YABU. You said yourself that the house is clean. Some people have busy/exciting lives and don't want to commit all their time to having a show room worthy house.

Bunnycat101 · 15/05/2022 18:36

Your friend will know. I have a relative who isn’t shy about comments about tidyiness. Our house will never be immaculate but it’s at its worst on a Friday night but my word I feel judged even when I’ve stayed up late cleaning and it’s not show-home standard.

MyneighbourisTotoro · 15/05/2022 18:35

liveforsummer · 15/05/2022 18:03

Surely in this case you recognise that as your issue and keep your own house accordingly? Do you judge others on theirs if it's not to your standards yourself, or do you accept people have different priorities? Would you post about another's home?

If you’d seen my earlier reply you’d see that I explained how stressful mess is to me but that I understand it’s my own issues and part of my ASD.

Yes I do judge sometimes, I can be a bit black and white at times and have to remind myself to think more critically and take my own feelings out of the equation which can be really difficult. I also understand everyone lives differently and remind myself we all have different standards.

Normando91 · 15/05/2022 18:34

Why were you disgruntled and frustrated? What an odd way to feel.

I’d think it was none of my damn business, we all have different levels of organisation and it doesn’t sound like the house was necessarily unclean.

Trivester · 15/05/2022 18:33

I admire your friend for opening her home and hospitality when things weren’t as good as they should be.

It’s something I find very difficult to do, and there have been times when I’ve kept people talking on the doorstep and regretted not having the courage to invite them in for coffee.

I’m really grateful when people invite me in - it gives me a little courage that life isn’t perfect for everyone else, and I’m touched that they trust me not to judge.

I know you’re uneasy in your reaction or you wouldn’t have posted.

Banoffe · 15/05/2022 18:29

Of course you are being horrible. It’s not like they are living in a smelly, unclean home. Just not organised to your likeness. How unkind.

Lalliella · 15/05/2022 18:29

I'll speak to my friend about it this evening.

Please don’t do this OP. There’s something very skewed about your judgement I’m afraid. It would be completely inappropriate to bring this up in conversation, it’s impossible to do without sounding really judgy and condescending. It will not go well.

EleonorBronte · 15/05/2022 18:28

you sound bored, or depressed. Sexually unsatisfied - it can manifest in many ways. I would recommend a trip to the gp perhaps to discuss antidepressants.

And just think, when you die, which we all will soon enough, you can't take your domesticated consumerist shite with you. All those years working for what? Ahh, gimme some codeine...

Foolsrule · 15/05/2022 18:27

YANBU. I once went to a friend’s house and was shocked at the absolute state it was in. I think the thing that got me was her DC. They deserved better. I knew her parents and she wasn’t brought up like that. She really was just plain lazy! I couldn’t say or do anything about it, save offering to help clean up, but that would have embarrassed her so I didn’t say a thing. It did make me see her slightly differently though.

Fluffyslippersohyes · 15/05/2022 18:27

I don't think you need to have a conversation. Just meet somewhere neutral or invite her to yours. I am sure she knows it's messy or she's a hoarder. Not always that easy to fix. It can be really complex.

givemetoddlersanyday · 15/05/2022 18:26

OP, why do you feel you need to talk to your friend about it? It might not end well. She might feel criticised and hurt.

My house is very, very messy. A couple of my friends take the piss out of me about it, and I take the piss out of their super-tidiness. I would actually be quite upset if any of my friends were to start a proper conversation about it, however gently.

She may well be perfectly happy with her house exactly the way it is.

motherofchihuahuas · 15/05/2022 18:26

Sone people are just messy. Or prioritise other things or are procrastinate and then the stuff to be done just gets left.

I have ocd in that I can't leave mess I just can't it makes me anxious to think about coming home to a messy house, it's nothing to do with what other people think.

It was clean so like you say have a chat to her if you feel it warrants it and go from there.

Mess and dirt are totally different.

My friend has five kids at home- there is always something to be done.

I have one. So not much mess really on a daily basis but her house is clean. It's lived in.

Nolongerteaching · 15/05/2022 18:25

I think that instead of the focus being on untidy= mental health issues we need to recognise the real mental health issue lies in people who are bothered by other people behaviour when it doesn’t concern them. They are asserting control over something that is not theirs - why don’t we focus on this more? It’s a clear sign of control issues. I often think that the more relaxed are having to compensate for those who think they are in charge/leading the way but are actually just being bullies.

Ijustreallywantacat · 15/05/2022 18:25

I can’t believe you’re actually going to speak to her. Is she distressed by it? Is it actually hindering her life or she just messy? Don’t push your issues on to your friend you think it’s bad enough to risk the friendship.

The only time I’ve ever taken action with a friend was when her mum passed away and her husband divorced her, so her home turned in to an actual biohazard. I rolled up my sleeves and cleaned, but never a word to make her feel like she was being told off. DO NOT tell her that she thinks she can ‘do better’ for gods sake. Muck in.

Binsk · 15/05/2022 18:25

YABU. I'm not getting at you for having the thought in the first place OP, I just want you to do better.

whynotwhatknot · 15/05/2022 18:24

Youre going to talk to her about it? I hope she throws you out

Crankley · 15/05/2022 18:23

What a scummy little post. I hope she dumps you as a friend because you aren't one.

BellePeppa · 15/05/2022 18:20

allinadaystwerk · 15/05/2022 17:57

For starters I'm not talking about any of YOUR actual houses nor am I wanting to be YOUR friend.. so calm down!
I did not say I was going to end the friendship. The person is amazing. I also never said my house is tidy.. its not!

My grammar... well sorry, to the pedants but sometimes I get it wrong, actually quite often tbh. I'm quite good with their, there and they're though so 🤷

😆 😆 at troll, clearly my ability to word correctly has impacted and triggered some people. Sorry if thats the case.
Perhaps the words uncomfortable and a bit shocked might better explain my feelings. I have neurological issues that effect my brain function and cognitive reasoning myself so I certainly am not looking to trigger anyone.
I just didn't expect such a mess. It was close to hoarding, some areas were floor to ceiling. Also, I said I wanted them to do better... actually, I wanted better for them.

Some of the things being said here are outrageous and you have the audacity to say I'm nasty?!

Thank you to those who offered balanced responses.

Its healthy to question your own judgement and admit when you are wrong. Thats how you change for the better.

In my post, if you can get past the 'bad grammar' 😆

I am trying to examine myself. I realise that my response is not ok but I'm honest enough to admit my discomfort. I also say its not something to break a friendship over. I'll speak to my friend about it this evening.
That's how confident I am that I'm not the spawn of Satan as some of more 'sensitive' of you suggest.

And as for going away and not coming back on here.. its a good job I'm not suicidal anymore! Check your own volition. Why are you so scathing and aggressive?

So anyway thanks to all for the advice, responses and even the visceral attacks. oh and quick reminder, bullying and intimidation is 'frowned upon' as a violation on mumsnet last time I checked!

Perhaps I will return and let you know how the conversation with my friend goes. Its all good learning after all.

Mumsnet is a scary place. I post but I’d never have the guts to make a thread as I’d be hiding behind the sofa as soon I pressed the send button. Not really sure what you can do as saying something could cause all sorts of problems if she’s sensitive. I had another friend (not the one mentioned in my previous post) who was as messy as yours, I mean really really messy. She very nonchalantly told me one day her friend, who is an obsessive clean freak, insisted on tackling her house and was there cleaning it as we spoke, she didn’t mind one bit, seemed glad of the help but of course not everyone would be happy about it. (It didn’t stay tidy and reverted back 😬🤷‍♀️).

SemperIdem · 15/05/2022 18:19

You sound like my mother.

Swipe left for the next trending thread