Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want MIL to take toddler DD for a whole day?

60 replies

AwfulDilemma · 15/05/2022 14:12

MIL wants to take DD (2 years and four months) on a day trip to an animal petting zoo. Which would be lovely, except that I have major concerns about MIL's ability to look after a toddler.

MIL does help us out occasionally by looking after DD if she is home ill from nursery, and we are so grateful for this, but even in the relatively safe environment of our home, a few things have happened that have made me question MIL's judgement - MIL giving DD a lollipop (choking hazard), MIL letting go of DD's hand on a footpath outside our house (DH saw this from a window and it was only sheer luck DD didn't run on to the road) and letting her jump up and down on a windowsill (DD fell off and badly bruised her elbow, thankfully nothing broken).

Due to other things that have happened, I suspect that MIL may be showing early signs of dementia. She also suffers from anxiety and panic attacks.

Every instinct I have tells me that I shouldn't say yes to this. DH and I can't go as we'll be working. DD normally goes to nursery full-time but there aren't any issues with her skipping a day, so I can't use that as an excuse. I don't want to upset MIL - she's lovely, and quite fragile emotionally, saying no would hurt her. But I have to keep my DD safe.

AIBU in desperately trying to figure out a way to say no? Am I being an overprotective parent? I don't think I am, as I'm confident in handing DD over to nursery, a couple of friends, other relatives . . . it's just that I'm so uneasy about MIL. DH feels the same - he thinks we should say yes, but doesn't want to.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AwfulDilemma · 16/05/2022 15:16

Thanks everyone, it's been really useful to read the responses. I think we'll see how the holiday goes, and make a decision after that.

MIL is 68, so not elderly by any stretch, but she's not very active and struggles to move quickly when needed. DD is a bolter and we use reins, but MIL doesn't like them, so I don't think she'd use them even if we asked (she's quite contrary; this has increased in the last couple of years, she's lovely but very stubborn).

MIL hasn't actually looked after DD for us since early January, when DD had chickenpox, so all the interactions in the last few months have been when we've taken DD to visit her every couple of weeks, or met PILs somewhere for lunch or a day out etc. There's been so many instances where I've thought 'uh oh!' Things like DD wanting a sip of MIL's tea - instead of saying "no, it's too hot, that's gran's tea", MIL actually started to give DD a sip before I intervened, or the time when we were out for a walk and, behind us, MIL helped DD climb over a fence so DD could see some lambs - DH had to climb over and get her back again as she immediately ran further into the field. Pretty sure the farmer would NOT have been happy about that!

So yes, if we're noticing all these things when we're there, I really worry about what could happen if we're not around and MIL has to manage DD on her own. PIL isn't in great health so unfortunately can't really provide back-up.

OP posts:
Dajeeling · 16/05/2022 07:38

My own child nearly died on a lollipop at 2. You are not being over cautious there.

Either family day out or you make it very clear what you expect in a friendly way. 2 is very young. If that goes down like a stink or she is dismissive then she doesn’t go.

Lasana · 16/05/2022 06:51

Trust your instincts. Fine another day to go when you're all free.

cptartapp · 16/05/2022 06:36

Ask them to call her in for a memory assessment under the guise of a 'health check' and go with her if you can.

edgeware · 16/05/2022 06:34

As for dementia - it can take a long time to properly show. If we think back it was easily a decade that the signs were there. So I don’t think you are unreasonable for saying that at all. It is important to pick up early.

edgeware · 16/05/2022 06:31

Your child, your decision. Personally I wouldn’t trust my dad with my children even at home. He is just not sharp enough anymore. If I don’t feel comfortable with it it won’t happen.

girlmom21 · 16/05/2022 06:24

How old is MIL? Because a lot of dementia 'symptoms' are actually the same as menopause symptoms.

AwfulDilemma · 15/05/2022 20:51

Thanks everyone. I'm really doing my best to be reasonable and rational but it's very difficult to put a gut feeling aside. And some of your experiences are making me think I'd be negligent to do so.

As for the potential for dementia, I've done some research in the last few weeks and it looks like all we can do is contact her GP and put our concerns on record, in the hopes that they'll broach an assessment when she's next there. I don't have a lot of faith that this will happen, though; her GP doesn't seem very reliable, from what MIL has described in her dealings with their local surgery.

OP posts:
SirChenjins · 15/05/2022 19:40

If you don’t feel comfortable about it then say no - go with your gut instinct. As a PP suggested you can just say she’s a bit of a handful at the moment.

A day’s emergency childcare in your own home is very different to a day out at a petting zoo. However, if you really think she might have the start of dementia you should probably get an assessment arranged for her so you can decide what level of childcare you’re happy with going forward.

JennyForeigner · 15/05/2022 19:37

Listen to your instincts, they sound entirely reasonable.

Why shouldn't you all go together? What exactly is the importance of a day alone that it justifies having to worry about it in this way?

Bunnycat101 · 15/05/2022 19:32

I think there is a different set of challenges looking after a toddler in a public and busy place compared to home. My in-laws are perfectly happy and able to take my 5yo out to places but my 3yo is quite a handful and may still be a bit too much until she’s a touch older. She’s a bolter and is unpredictable and I still need to be able to give her a lot of attention when out.

dumdumduuuummmmm · 15/05/2022 19:21

girlmom21 · 15/05/2022 14:57

She's fine to look after DD when it benefits you, though?

What are you basing your assumption on?

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 15/05/2022 19:05

I had big concerns, having witnessed a relative's very poor driving (eg more than once pulling out into traffic without looking ) about letting my youngest get in a car with them.
Declining the invitation caused great offense even though I gave a reasonable excuse.
Later I mentioned to another family member that this person seemed to have a new car quite frequently, were they leasing? and was told it was because the person had car accidents. It was a family "secret" apparently.
I'm so glad now that I acted on my suspicions at the time and said no as it became apparent shortly after that the person in question was very far from being capable of driving.
If you have doubts and you've mentioned several instances, please act on them! Imagine how you'd all feel if you didn't and something awful happened or was narrowly avoided.

VelociraptortheClown · 15/05/2022 18:13

YANBU. Maybe when your daughter is a few years older she can take her out, but definitely not at such a young age if she is not able to safeguard her from serious risks.

Geranium1984 · 15/05/2022 18:03

I would worry about this. My MIL was round this afternoon and we all went for a walk in the park. She was holding my boys (20mo) hand walking up our road and he ran off ahead of her. He got quite far quite quickly (is a quiet street so no immediate danger and his dad ran after him). But if that had been a busy road and she was on her own then she never would have caught him. I think she would also struggle to lift him especially if he wasn't wanting to do something. I would also worry about strapping them into the car seat properly, managing the carpark, buggy and toddler in and out of the car.
Sounds like the upcoming holiday will be a really good opportunity to see what they are like together if you can distance yourself a bit.

MissChanandlerBong80 · 15/05/2022 17:37

For what it’s worth, I don’t think you’re being overprotective or PFB. But it actually doesn’t matter what I or any other poster thinks about that. The point is that you and your DH know your MIL and you both agree that you aren’t comfortable with it. Don’t let randomers on the internet undermine your instincts. You need to find a way to say no.

I also knew what you meant about emergency childcare. My parents looked after my son a few times on an emergency basis and it was only because they looked after him that I realised they weren’t up to the job. And they didn’t look after him any more - emergency or otherwise - once I realised that. It’s not that they were good enough to do emergency childcare and not the fun stuff. It’s that when they did emergency childcare it became clear they weren’t up to caring for a toddler. Which is fine because I find it tiring and I’m in my 30s.

cptartapp · 15/05/2022 17:29

Listen to your gut.
My nephews in separate instances ended up with black eyes, badly cut legs and two broken wrists under the care of PIL.

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 15/05/2022 17:22

I can’t imagine my 2 year old wanting to spend the whole day at a petting zoo, can they go for the afternoon , have lunch at home, a nap then out for a couple of hours “?

mycatisannoying · 15/05/2022 16:54

Her best friend's birthday is on the same day, and nursery are doing a birthday party and cake for the children.
Sometimes a little white lie can't hurt.

7869hf89ywf · 15/05/2022 16:43

I am not sure that anything you've mentioned is a sign of dementia. My gp hands out lollies to two year olds and I know lots of parents who let two year olds run down major London roads after nursery - the windowsill depends a bit on whether this was ground floor or first floor and whether they were next to them.

This isn't about the day out, if you think MIL has dementia she wouldn't be safe to look after your child full stop. Not saying you are wrong about her state of health, I just don't think anything you've said about her indicates this.

LetitiaLeghorn · 15/05/2022 16:23

Definitely don't let your MIL take your DD to somewhere nice. Just use her as an emergency carer. Surely she will be grateful with just that.

Hollywolly1 · 15/05/2022 16:17

If you feel its not safe for your daughter to go on a day out with your mil you must decline the offer regardless of feelings being hurt as your daughter is so so young so think if your daughter

ElenaSt · 15/05/2022 16:00

Reins would prevent the losing grip of holding hands.

girlmom21 · 15/05/2022 15:51

Of course it doesn't go without saying that she's not still currently childcare when you say MIL does help us out occasionally by looking after DD if she is home ill from nursery, and we are so grateful for this, but even in the relatively safe environment of our home, a few things have happened that have made me question MIL's judgement then go on to list loads of things she's done wrong. They wouldn't all happen on one or two occasions.

On this point there are definitely still associated risks, albeit fewer than actually taking her away for the day I disagree. It's easy to get complacent in familiar surroundings. I personally find parenting much easier when I'm out and about because I can solely focus on the activity and the children rather than worrying about cooking the dinner and changing a nappy and tidying up and putting the washing in the tumble dryer etc etc etc

Goldijobsandthe3bears · 15/05/2022 15:47

It’s not PFB to not want a toddler to have a lolly either.