Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this was insensitive - Hastings car insurance

37 replies

itsgettingweird · 15/05/2022 11:24

I'm going through a lot right now. My mum is in hospice with cancer on end of life care.

Sadly everyday life also needs to be sorted included my car insurance.

I'm simple with it - know what cover I want, excess etc and go through search company and select cheapest.

Hastings offered me a quote to stay for £8 a year more. I got it elsewhere for £150 less.

Renewed this morning. Unfortunately stopping Hastings renewing wasn't clear on website when I signed in so rung up.

Started with the questions when I said I wanted to renew. What quotes have you had, who with, monthly etc.

I just said I had to go out so,where important and all I wanted to do was cancel renewal.

Woman goes on. Which company - I say it's irrelevant. I don't want to stay with them and have a right to stop my renewal.

She starts on with how there are changes since last year so she can check and it may be cheaper. I said if that's the case they should have offered me a cheaper deal - told her then I needed to go to visit my mum in a hospice and can she just cancel it please.

Then - and this is the bit that's so fucking insensitive - she starts going on about how she can still check etc.

I said I wasn't interested - I'd already paid for it via a different provider and just wanted her to cancel it so I could go.

Then to add insult to injury she starts on about the 14 days cooling off period. She would not just SHUT UP AND CANCEL MY INSURANCE RENEWAL.

I mean - yes - right now I'm emotional. But when someone says they have gone elsewhere and explain why they don't have time or want to answer a load of questions surely you just thank them and let them go?

I won't ever go with them again even if they offer me the best quote next year.

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 15/05/2022 11:43

She cancelled it herself. No passing through.

I hope Hastings do listen to the recording. I hope they do rethink their tough sales pitch and train staff that when someone states a reason for wanting to go that is serious that they have some respect.

I mean seriously - did she actually think when my mum is dying I wanted her to go and call me back soon with a better quote and I go through the hassle of cancelling the one I've paid for.

Sometimes you have to remember your deal with real people with real lives at the other end of the phone.

OP posts:
DentonsFringeArnottsWaistcoat · 15/05/2022 11:41

I move all sorts of insurance around regularly to get the best deals. When faced with this approach I tend to just stop talking, which usually prompts them to say something like Hello? Are you still there? , I will then repeat Please cancel my policy. Non engagement seems to work, I’m never rude about it, just don’t engage.
Sorry about your Mum Flowers

YarnHoarder · 15/05/2022 11:39

I'm so sorry for everything you're going through but I agree with others, this is likely what she's been trained (threatened with consequences) to do and with most calls being recorded she could be at risk of being told off if she doesn't. It's also likely certain things need to happen before she can pass you onto the people who can cancel as she might not actually have the power themselves. I would probably have escalated (asked for manager or put through to cancellation team etc) it at that point as I know I wouldn't be in the right frame of mind to deal with it. I have sympathy for both sides here, is there anyone else who could deal with this on your behalf. I've found if you call, explain you'd like X person to deal with Y issue and hand over the phone most companies are pretty ok with it provided you confirm at the end.

I still remember a company calling about a piece of equipment my granddad was due to get as he was receiving palliative care in my home. This was a week after he died when family had all returned to mine after the funeral. I was very blunt on the phone which was probably unfair to the poor person on the other end who should've been told what had happened by that point.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 15/05/2022 11:39

I don't think YABU but I don't necessarily think she was BU either.

Most customer service staff have a script they have to follow, and they can (and do) get disciplined for not following it.

functionoverform · 15/05/2022 11:37

No, I think you had to get stroppy to get a basic service. I'm fairly resilient but your account of cancelling just brought back a memory of me battling to do the exact same thing.

If more customers get pisses off they might change their shitty policy of dealing with customers who want to cancel.

In the end I interrupted the lady and stated again ( for about the umpteenth time) 'I wish to cancel, I have insurance elsewhere now, your renewal quote was not competitive, can you put me through to a manager who can actually do as I ask....' she then acquiesced and cancelled. I also told her that if it was this difficult to cancel I would not be using Hastings again which was a shame as other than that, they were okay (didn't have any claims ).

Feel for you, it isn't needed! All you need is a cheery thanks and of course, maybe see you as again as a customer....

itsgettingweird · 15/05/2022 11:33

Darkstar4855 · 15/05/2022 11:30

Sadly this is probably what she’s been told she has to do as part of her job. I find just repeating “no thanks, I just want to cancel” over and over again without engaging in any further discussion is the most effective strategy.

I did at first.

Then I said please can she just cancel and explained why.

But she followed the script. And kept going on and on.

I'm sure it wouldn't have taken much this once to use som emotional intelligence and if the call was recorded I'm sure the boss would understand why - in this case - she ended without the sales pitch.

OP posts:
Eloradannin2nd · 15/05/2022 11:31

I moved out of the UK and had to phone to cancel my car insurance. Despite me telling them that my insurance wouldn't be valid as I no longer lived in the UK, I still got the script.

Its very frustrating.

DefiniteTortoise · 15/05/2022 11:31

That's awful and dreadfully tone deaf of her, I'm sorry 😥

Darkstar4855 · 15/05/2022 11:30

Sadly this is probably what she’s been told she has to do as part of her job. I find just repeating “no thanks, I just want to cancel” over and over again without engaging in any further discussion is the most effective strategy.

LottieePopssX · 15/05/2022 11:28

That's really insensitive!
I was with Hastings and they doubled my monthly direct debit to £160 without telling me. When I called to find out what had happened they accused me of lying about how long I'd owned my car. Sent them the documents to prove it (wish they'd asked for them or at least contacted me in some way before just taking the money) and they refused to refund me the over charge and then added it to my account as a credit. Will never go through them again!!

wonderstuff · 15/05/2022 11:27

I had this last year when I renewed, pissed me right off, I don’t want to piss about negotiating, either give a competitive quote for renewal or I’ll go elsewhere.

i imagine she was just doing what she was trained to, but I’d be really annoyed too.

itsgettingweird · 15/05/2022 11:24

Sorry - I promise I did type in paragraphs!

OP posts: