Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To understand not wanting to be involved

431 replies

CandyApplePie · 15/05/2022 10:22

In this situation.....Probably get flamed for this but anyway

I am on another site where a woman has had a baby from a one night stand (this is what he has referred to her as) they met once and she fell pregnant and kept the baby, he doesn't want to be involved and expressed that to her from the beginning. She kept the baby and is now pursuing him for child maintenance. The man is angry and telling her she was just a one night stand and to go away and that he wants nothing to do with the baby, he is saying he used a condom (she says they didn't) so it's not his baby, they are going to be doing a dna test but he is insisting the child is nothing to do with him. All the comments are along the lines of "how can he just walk away" "how can he want nothing to do with the child" "babies are a blessing" "having a child is the most amazing experience" but aibu to understand why someone wouldn't want to be tied to a stranger for the rest of their lives? Maintenance is a separate issue but I can understand why a man wouldn't want to be involved in raising the child, he is insisting he did use a condom she says they didn't so no one really knows the truth their apart from the two of them.

OP posts:
LimeSegment · 15/05/2022 14:14

Not sure why you see the worst part as raising a child with "a stranger", surely it's more about the child, not the co parent.

Anyway it's just pointless to say anything to do with pregnancy and birth "isn't fair" to either sex, no it isn't and it never can be. I threw up hundreds of times while pregnant, my DH didn't throw up once. Also I got a 3rd degree tear giving birth, but my DH didn't. How can we make that fair? Should he have to get one too? Fair's fair right?

Missingindevon · 15/05/2022 14:13

cecilthehungryspider · 15/05/2022 13:47

I wonder how many people who are happy with the idea of the father walking away and wanting nothing to do with the child would feel the same if it were the mother walking away and leaving it with the father to raise alone?

I explained by my personal experience why I feel like it's better then being unwanted and of it was my mother I would feel the same.

KookaburraSit · 15/05/2022 14:13

CandyApplePie · 15/05/2022 13:54

Those that think he should raise the child do you think that will benefit the child? Posters who have experienced having absent fathers have said themselves they would rather he disappear than be forced into having contact with a dad they know didn’t want them. Do you think the child would not pick up on this? Seems people want to force him to raise the child as punishment for his mistake rather than because it’s genuinely in the child’s best interest

I think a decent man would take responsibility, be involved and grow to love his child. The man you're describing, however, sounds like a selfish, peevish arsehole, so I agree it's better he not be involved anything more than financially. I'll still judge him for that though and so will others.

Penguinsaregreat · 15/05/2022 14:12

I totally understand this man not wanting contact and you can't force him to parent his child.
Hell, my cousin's husband pissed off after 20 years of marriage, been together 25 years, he refused to pay maintenance and does not see his kids.
I also think this bloke would never admit to not using contraception would he?
Every time a man has sex with a woman he runs the risk of unwanted pregnancy. Condoms are not fail proof. If he didn't want to be in this position then he should have kept his penis away from her. That's the plain and simple truth.

Marty13 · 15/05/2022 14:07

Re contact with dad, I don't think he should be involved in the child's upbringing because :


  • It'd be hard to enforce contact

  • It'd probably not be in the best interest of the child to have contact with an unwilling father

  • He clearly stated from the start he would have no involvement and she chose to continue with this knowledge.


Honestly, you don't say in your OP how she feels re contact but in her place I certainly wouldn't want to have to juggle contact times for 18 years with a near stranger. I say this as a single parent by choice (and no I didn't have a one night stand, I used a sperm bank, specifically because I didn't want some guy to want to be involved further down the line).

JammyThing · 15/05/2022 14:05

LoveSpringDaffs · 15/05/2022 13:55

Do what do you suggest then? Forced contact?? How long for? Hiw woukd it be enforced? His does it benefit the child?

None of those things. If he's not going to step up, he's not going to step up. I get that. Could I (or would I want to) force a man to have contact with his child? No. Do I judge the fuck out of men who walk away from their responsibilities? Hell yes.

I just wish we'd stop giving men a pass for doing shitty things on the basis that they'll do shitty things anyway.

Pumperthepumper · 15/05/2022 14:05

AntBully · 15/05/2022 14:03

NC for this.

My husband has a child who is 9. He used a condom that was presumed to have failed, it was a friends with benefits type thing.
He made it very clear he did not want a child (was in the middle of a mental health crisis which is still ongoing now).
The woman decided she was going to keep the baby.
4 years later (in front of me and others) she very drunkenly admitted she had put holes in the condom as she was desperate for a baby with him and loves his family so much she wanted a permanent connection.

My husband pays maintenance. He sees his child, however this has been forced upon him due to the family dynamics, the relationship is awful between them.
I can't fathom why you would want to bring a child into that.
So yes I completely agree with the OP

And the lesson he should have learned, which is completely groundbreaking:

Don’t fuck someone unless you’re prepared to get them pregnant.

Pumperthepumper · 15/05/2022 14:03

What if the woman makes the decision to carry the baby but also decides she doesn’t want to raise it? Still absolutely fine to walk away?

AntBully · 15/05/2022 14:03

NC for this.

My husband has a child who is 9. He used a condom that was presumed to have failed, it was a friends with benefits type thing.
He made it very clear he did not want a child (was in the middle of a mental health crisis which is still ongoing now).
The woman decided she was going to keep the baby.
4 years later (in front of me and others) she very drunkenly admitted she had put holes in the condom as she was desperate for a baby with him and loves his family so much she wanted a permanent connection.

My husband pays maintenance. He sees his child, however this has been forced upon him due to the family dynamics, the relationship is awful between them.
I can't fathom why you would want to bring a child into that.
So yes I completely agree with the OP

whynotwhatknot · 15/05/2022 14:01

I agree op he shouldnt have to be involved iif he doesnt want to - al this but hes got a child how can he not want to is crap-he might nt feel ready or in another relastionship already

he will have to pay maintenance yes but it is the mothers deicsion to carry on soshe has to live with explaining that toher child

Pumperthepumper · 15/05/2022 14:01

CandyApplePie · 15/05/2022 13:57

I never said that. Clearly a man in a relationship would also bond feel the baby kick, attend scans, chose clothes etc this man hasn’t seen her since by the sounds of it, very different.

Still though, he’s made a baby. He’s responsible for the creation of a new human.

Marty13 · 15/05/2022 14:00

I think he doesn't have to be involved but should pay. But in your OP it doesn't sound like she wants him actively involved, she just wants CMS - so I'm not sure what your thread is about really.

As many have said he knew contraception is not 100% and if you don't want to take risks you need to double up. I don't think anyone, man or woman, gets to "just assume" the other is on the pill or had a vasectomy or whatever.

Obviously she has her share of responsibility but her life will also be a LOT more impacted than his. A child will cost her MUCH more than whatever amount he pays, be it in terms of time, of availability for work, of emotional involvement, etc. His life won't change except for the amount he gives her, which usually isn't a lot on CMS calculators.

And yes she gets more choices after the child is conceived, but :


  • An abortion can be traumatic and not something everyone feels able to do. It can also sometimes lead to health complications.

  • As stated above she will be far more impacted than him so it's fair she gets more say in what happens.

  • Someone mentioned adoption. But adoption is a trauma for the child, whose interests should always come first, so it should only happen if neither parent can or want to take care of the child. If the mother had wanted to give up the child and the dad didn't, then SS probably would have given the child to dad (and mom would have had to pay CMS). So it's not just a matter of "Oh, she could have had him adopted and washed her hands of the baby". Not to mention giving up a baby you've carried for 9 months isn't so easy as some seem to think.

MoonKnight · 15/05/2022 14:00

CandyApplePie · 15/05/2022 13:54

Those that think he should raise the child do you think that will benefit the child? Posters who have experienced having absent fathers have said themselves they would rather he disappear than be forced into having contact with a dad they know didn’t want them. Do you think the child would not pick up on this? Seems people want to force him to raise the child as punishment for his mistake rather than because it’s genuinely in the child’s best interest

A child has the right to a relationship with both of their parents. The parents have a responsibility to ensure their child is/feels mentally and physically safe and provided for.
the mother chose to continue with the pregnancy - her responsibility starts there. The father chose to penetrate a woman with his penis knowing there was a chance of pregnancy. His responsibility starts there.

once again, men are being allowed to walk away from their responsibilities with a cheery wave.

CandyApplePie · 15/05/2022 13:57

Pumperthepumper · 15/05/2022 13:55

Men are incapable of bonding with a baby in utero?

I never said that. Clearly a man in a relationship would also bond feel the baby kick, attend scans, chose clothes etc this man hasn’t seen her since by the sounds of it, very different.

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 15/05/2022 13:56

Oh sorry, I misread that.

LoveSpringDaffs · 15/05/2022 13:55

JammyThing · 15/05/2022 13:45

This thread is so depressing. This is how men get away with taking fuck all responsibility for things. I'm so sick of it.

Do what do you suggest then? Forced contact?? How long for? Hiw woukd it be enforced? His does it benefit the child?

Pumperthepumper · 15/05/2022 13:55

CandyApplePie · 15/05/2022 13:52

How is it offensive? A woman grows the baby and bonds with the baby throughout pregnancy, if she was with the man he would also share the experience but sounds like he hasn’t see her at all since the ONS so of course there is no bond yet established? That’s a fact

Men are incapable of bonding with a baby in utero?

Eightiesfan · 15/05/2022 13:55

mintybobs · 15/05/2022 13:08

Morning after pill has horrific side effects and not all women can take hormonal birth control due to medical reasons.

Oh please, I assume the woman is not an idiot, so if taking an oral contraceptive or the morning after pill gives her ‘horrible side effects’ and she is engaging with risky one night stands, she could either have an implant or an IUD. Either way it was just as much her responsibility to make sure her ONS used a condom to protect her sexual health.

CandyApplePie · 15/05/2022 13:54

Those that think he should raise the child do you think that will benefit the child? Posters who have experienced having absent fathers have said themselves they would rather he disappear than be forced into having contact with a dad they know didn’t want them. Do you think the child would not pick up on this? Seems people want to force him to raise the child as punishment for his mistake rather than because it’s genuinely in the child’s best interest

OP posts:
SpoonOnTheMoon · 15/05/2022 13:52

AnneLovesGilbert · 15/05/2022 11:04

What game did he play?

Condom roulette

CandyApplePie · 15/05/2022 13:52

Pumperthepumper · 15/05/2022 13:48

It’s also pretty offensive, it’s essentially ‘men love their children less, therefore why should they be arsed?’

How is it offensive? A woman grows the baby and bonds with the baby throughout pregnancy, if she was with the man he would also share the experience but sounds like he hasn’t see her at all since the ONS so of course there is no bond yet established? That’s a fact

OP posts:
SpoonOnTheMoon · 15/05/2022 13:51

Condom roulette

dworky · 15/05/2022 13:51

Men are always claiming children can't be theirs even when the child happens to be the spitting image of them.

He's hoping rather than facing reality.

MoonKnight · 15/05/2022 13:48

Having even protected sex is like Russian roulette. There is no 100% protection against pregnancy other than abstinence. Even sterilisation can fail.
every time you have sex you risk a pregnancy.

The males choice is at the point of penetration. it’s not like they have none.

Pumperthepumper · 15/05/2022 13:48

It’s also pretty offensive, it’s essentially ‘men love their children less, therefore why should they be arsed?’