Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To understand not wanting to be involved

431 replies

CandyApplePie · 15/05/2022 10:22

In this situation.....Probably get flamed for this but anyway

I am on another site where a woman has had a baby from a one night stand (this is what he has referred to her as) they met once and she fell pregnant and kept the baby, he doesn't want to be involved and expressed that to her from the beginning. She kept the baby and is now pursuing him for child maintenance. The man is angry and telling her she was just a one night stand and to go away and that he wants nothing to do with the baby, he is saying he used a condom (she says they didn't) so it's not his baby, they are going to be doing a dna test but he is insisting the child is nothing to do with him. All the comments are along the lines of "how can he just walk away" "how can he want nothing to do with the child" "babies are a blessing" "having a child is the most amazing experience" but aibu to understand why someone wouldn't want to be tied to a stranger for the rest of their lives? Maintenance is a separate issue but I can understand why a man wouldn't want to be involved in raising the child, he is insisting he did use a condom she says they didn't so no one really knows the truth their apart from the two of them.

OP posts:
CandyApplePie · 15/05/2022 15:10

Mamai90 · 15/05/2022 15:03

I had an abortion and I'm still not over it, I wasn't coerced, I was young, at uni and it was a ons with a friend. I never even told him I was pregnant.

I still think about it regularly and it was almost 20 years ago. To say I regret it wouldn't be the right choice of words because I wouldn't have what I have now. But, if I knew then what I know now or how much it would have affected me I probably wouldn't have gone through with it.

You're acting like there's no emotional attachment and its easy to just have an abortion, it might be like that for you but it's not like that for everyone.

And you have sympathy for some morally babkrupt man because a women has 'choices'.

I have never had an abortion but equally I wouldn’t have unprotected sex with a stranger

OP posts:
Eightiesfan · 15/05/2022 15:06

BobLep0nge · 15/05/2022 13:32

Especially what is upheld as a woman's right to have a child no matter the cost

You'd prefer it if a woman didn't have a right to continue a pregnancy if she wants?Confused

No one is saying this, but if a woman chooses to have a baby with a stranger which is absolutely her choice, she cannot expect to play happy families with him. This man made his intentions clear, so why should he be forced into parenting her child?

BattenburgDonkey · 15/05/2022 15:06

AntBully · 15/05/2022 14:03

NC for this.

My husband has a child who is 9. He used a condom that was presumed to have failed, it was a friends with benefits type thing.
He made it very clear he did not want a child (was in the middle of a mental health crisis which is still ongoing now).
The woman decided she was going to keep the baby.
4 years later (in front of me and others) she very drunkenly admitted she had put holes in the condom as she was desperate for a baby with him and loves his family so much she wanted a permanent connection.

My husband pays maintenance. He sees his child, however this has been forced upon him due to the family dynamics, the relationship is awful between them.
I can't fathom why you would want to bring a child into that.
So yes I completely agree with the OP

Did he go to the police? The woman can go to prison for doing that, there was actually a case in the news about it last week. It’s the same as ‘stealthing’ in the eyes of the law

Mamai90 · 15/05/2022 15:03

CandyApplePie · 15/05/2022 13:02

If it was the other way round and I fell pregnant from a ons I wouldn’t keep it because I won’t want to be tied to a stranger so why is it different for a man?

I had an abortion and I'm still not over it, I wasn't coerced, I was young, at uni and it was a ons with a friend. I never even told him I was pregnant.

I still think about it regularly and it was almost 20 years ago. To say I regret it wouldn't be the right choice of words because I wouldn't have what I have now. But, if I knew then what I know now or how much it would have affected me I probably wouldn't have gone through with it.

You're acting like there's no emotional attachment and its easy to just have an abortion, it might be like that for you but it's not like that for everyone.

And you have sympathy for some morally babkrupt man because a women has 'choices'.

Eightiesfan · 15/05/2022 15:01

2bazookas · 15/05/2022 14:23

he is insisting he did use a condom she says they didn't so no one really knows the truth their apart from the two of them.

It doesn't matter if they used a condom, no condom or a faulty condom, or whether he wants to raise a child or not.

IF DNA proves the child is his, the law says he should support it financially for 18 years.

None of it has anything to do with you.

This isn’t what the OP is asking, this isn’t about financial support it’s about whether the man should have contact with the baby that the woman in question has chosen to keep even though he was clear he didn’t want anything to do with her or the baby.

LoveSpringDaffs · 15/05/2022 14:59

Pumperthepumper · 15/05/2022 14:03

What if the woman makes the decision to carry the baby but also decides she doesn’t want to raise it? Still absolutely fine to walk away?

Apples & pears!!

actually more apples & bananas!!

but if she wanted to let the father raise it or adopt it out if he didn't, then that's her choice. Plenty of adoptive parents who would love to adopt a baby.

id find it even harder to understand & she had an extra option the father didn't, but it's her life, no one can make her parent a child either.

balboaconstrictor · 15/05/2022 14:58

Pro-lifers I know aren't against birth control. I'm sure some are, but I don't think it's all that common, these days.

Everyone knows, or should know, that bother control fails from time to time, and not all women are willing to have an abortion if conception occurs unexpectedly. So yes, when you have sex you risk pregnancy. Don't have sex with someone if you can't accept that risk.

I can understand being unhappy at the thought of being linked to a stranger by a child you weren't expecting, but it doesn't make you a good person, imo, to pretend the child doesn't exist. It's selfish and immature.

Pumperthepumper · 15/05/2022 14:58

vivainsomnia · 15/05/2022 14:40

Do I judge the fuck out of men who walk away from their responsibilities? Hell yes
Do you judge women the same? Who have sex and don't protect themselves and go on to have an abortion? Is this being responsible, especially for those who go on to have more than one?

There are many thousands performed in the UK through choice. That mean many pregnancy, unplanned, in the vast majority due to lack of protection, who women move away from by removing the problem.

Why do men who do the same get a bashing but it's ok for women?

The reality is that one has a choice, the other doesn't. Many people of both sexes act irresponsible. That includes women who are actually happy to find out their are pregnant as that's what they hoped for and don't care one bit about how the guy feels about it.

Men can’t have abortions though! So how can you compare the two?

Pumperthepumper · 15/05/2022 14:57

CandyApplePie · 15/05/2022 14:30

That’s awful. Unfortunately people on here will still blame him as he shouldn’t have sex unless he wants a baby obviously 🙄😏

wouldn’t say the same about a woman having an abortion though would they?

A woman having an abortion is her choosing what happens to her body!

A man choosing to have sex knowing it could do something to someone else’s body is exactly the difference - it’s exactly the reason why those two things aren’t comparable. They’re not opposite sides of the same coin!

JammyThing · 15/05/2022 14:45

vivainsomnia · 15/05/2022 14:40

Do I judge the fuck out of men who walk away from their responsibilities? Hell yes
Do you judge women the same? Who have sex and don't protect themselves and go on to have an abortion? Is this being responsible, especially for those who go on to have more than one?

There are many thousands performed in the UK through choice. That mean many pregnancy, unplanned, in the vast majority due to lack of protection, who women move away from by removing the problem.

Why do men who do the same get a bashing but it's ok for women?

The reality is that one has a choice, the other doesn't. Many people of both sexes act irresponsible. That includes women who are actually happy to find out their are pregnant as that's what they hoped for and don't care one bit about how the guy feels about it.

"Why do men get a bashing but it's okay for women?"

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Yeah. Poor men, always being judged so much more harshly than women. Nightmare for them.

vivainsomnia · 15/05/2022 14:40

Do I judge the fuck out of men who walk away from their responsibilities? Hell yes
Do you judge women the same? Who have sex and don't protect themselves and go on to have an abortion? Is this being responsible, especially for those who go on to have more than one?

There are many thousands performed in the UK through choice. That mean many pregnancy, unplanned, in the vast majority due to lack of protection, who women move away from by removing the problem.

Why do men who do the same get a bashing but it's ok for women?

The reality is that one has a choice, the other doesn't. Many people of both sexes act irresponsible. That includes women who are actually happy to find out their are pregnant as that's what they hoped for and don't care one bit about how the guy feels about it.

RealBecca · 15/05/2022 14:38

I think if it is his hen he is fucking selfish not to put a child over his own wants. The child is a real person who deserves real support, whether he agrees the mother should have kept the baby or not there is a real child in this. He needs to focus on what's in his control.

RealBecca · 15/05/2022 14:37

Pointless all round debate. Condoms aren't 100% effective. DNA test will prove ine way or another.

I think he is responsible for a child whether he wants one or not. Abstinence is his only guarantee. Hers is abstinence or abortion. I get it into fair that he cant have an abortion. But that's biology. But if the child is his then he needs to step up.

Mellowyellow222 · 15/05/2022 14:35

@AntBully I hope your husband is in therapy.

it sounds like he is damaging a very young child: if you mean the relationship is awful between your husband and his nine year old child then someone needs to intervene.

I am sorry your husband is having mental health issues - and this woman sounds awful - but there is a child involved here.

is your husbands access supervised? Poor kid.

AntBully · 15/05/2022 14:32

@donchafeellikecrying I didn't know this. She's just the worst and I'm sure their child will find out the truth eventually which is another reason as to why this was awful.

CandyApplePie · 15/05/2022 14:31

Mellowyellow222 · 15/05/2022 14:30

@CandyApplePie you intrigue me.

you are arguing very strongly that men shouldn’t have to be fathers - emotionally and financially.

what are your circumstances? Was your dad in your life?

I can’t imagine growing up without a dad - I think dads are incredibly important. In the situation you are advocating a child frowns up knowing they were rejected. Unfortunately it is all too common - men (and some women) do give up their children.

I suppose women can sign over their parental rights and give their child up for adoption. Your argument is men should also be able to do this. But the reason a woman does this is usually in the best interests of the child - in your example the man doesn’t want to have to get to know the child’s mother.

I am fascinated by the life experiences that have led you to this position

I think he should contribute financially if the child is proven to be his. I just don’t think anyone man or woman should be forced to raise a child if they don’t want to.

OP posts:
CandyApplePie · 15/05/2022 14:30

AntBully · 15/05/2022 14:03

NC for this.

My husband has a child who is 9. He used a condom that was presumed to have failed, it was a friends with benefits type thing.
He made it very clear he did not want a child (was in the middle of a mental health crisis which is still ongoing now).
The woman decided she was going to keep the baby.
4 years later (in front of me and others) she very drunkenly admitted she had put holes in the condom as she was desperate for a baby with him and loves his family so much she wanted a permanent connection.

My husband pays maintenance. He sees his child, however this has been forced upon him due to the family dynamics, the relationship is awful between them.
I can't fathom why you would want to bring a child into that.
So yes I completely agree with the OP

That’s awful. Unfortunately people on here will still blame him as he shouldn’t have sex unless he wants a baby obviously 🙄😏

wouldn’t say the same about a woman having an abortion though would they?

OP posts:
Mellowyellow222 · 15/05/2022 14:30

@CandyApplePie you intrigue me.

you are arguing very strongly that men shouldn’t have to be fathers - emotionally and financially.

what are your circumstances? Was your dad in your life?

I can’t imagine growing up without a dad - I think dads are incredibly important. In the situation you are advocating a child frowns up knowing they were rejected. Unfortunately it is all too common - men (and some women) do give up their children.

I suppose women can sign over their parental rights and give their child up for adoption. Your argument is men should also be able to do this. But the reason a woman does this is usually in the best interests of the child - in your example the man doesn’t want to have to get to know the child’s mother.

I am fascinated by the life experiences that have led you to this position

donchafeellikecrying · 15/05/2022 14:25

@AntBully

What that woman did to your husband is now classified as against the law now isn't it?
And rightly so.

2bazookas · 15/05/2022 14:23

he is insisting he did use a condom she says they didn't so no one really knows the truth their apart from the two of them.

It doesn't matter if they used a condom, no condom or a faulty condom, or whether he wants to raise a child or not.

IF DNA proves the child is his, the law says he should support it financially for 18 years.

None of it has anything to do with you.

CandyApplePie · 15/05/2022 14:20

MoonKnight · 15/05/2022 14:00

A child has the right to a relationship with both of their parents. The parents have a responsibility to ensure their child is/feels mentally and physically safe and provided for.
the mother chose to continue with the pregnancy - her responsibility starts there. The father chose to penetrate a woman with his penis knowing there was a chance of pregnancy. His responsibility starts there.

once again, men are being allowed to walk away from their responsibilities with a cheery wave.

Sadly this isn’t true and a child doesn’t have a “right” legally to a relationship with their parents as no court would force a partner to have contact if they didn’t want it as it’s not considered to be in the best interest of the child

OP posts:
springbreak22 · 15/05/2022 14:20

And don't care about the consequences.

Thread on here a few weeks back where the OP 'forgot' to take her pill Hmm

springbreak22 · 15/05/2022 14:19

Agree with you OP

Some women are absolutely desperate for a baby

mintybobs · 15/05/2022 14:18

LimeSegment · 15/05/2022 14:14

Not sure why you see the worst part as raising a child with "a stranger", surely it's more about the child, not the co parent.

Anyway it's just pointless to say anything to do with pregnancy and birth "isn't fair" to either sex, no it isn't and it never can be. I threw up hundreds of times while pregnant, my DH didn't throw up once. Also I got a 3rd degree tear giving birth, but my DH didn't. How can we make that fair? Should he have to get one too? Fair's fair right?

Agree with everything here. Firstly, life isnt biologically fair is it? Its not "fair" that women bleed every month and have cramps, its not fair women die in childbirth or end up with destroyed pelvic floors or stretch marks is it? yet it still happens.

Life isnt fair- instead of him whining about it, he could take responsibility for having sex and part of the risk of that is unplanned pregnancy.

JammyThing · 15/05/2022 14:14

KookaburraSit · 15/05/2022 14:13

I think a decent man would take responsibility, be involved and grow to love his child. The man you're describing, however, sounds like a selfish, peevish arsehole, so I agree it's better he not be involved anything more than financially. I'll still judge him for that though and so will others.

Totally agree.