Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Shut down rude colleague

183 replies

PluralForBell · 15/05/2022 07:36

There is someone at work who constantly comes to me to tell me something negative about my work or about me as a person. She is a lot older than me and extremely domineering and confident, she rules the roost.

The thing she says sometimes have a tiny teeny bit of truth to them but she uses any perceived weaknesses to weaponise it to undermine my confidence and doubt myself.

She is not in my team so can't speak to LM.

I am focusing on my job and am quite good at it based on feedback. I think this woman doesn't like me or feels threatened IDK.

How can I breezily shut her flow of negative comments up while remaining polite and professional?

It's not even so much what she says she just comes to make underhand remarks then leaves again, like spreading her daily poison.

Annoyingly, this stresses me and makes me doubt myself.

How do I remain confident with this co worker but make her daily approaches stop?

OP posts:
Happylittlethoughts · 15/05/2022 14:10

If she won't write an email. Record her on your phone

PluralForBell · 15/05/2022 14:09

If OP takes her out to dinner, this will genuinely disarm her and cause her embarrassment. Besides she already quipped about OP spending all her wages on eating out; this is the perfect opening to take her along as well.
I can see how this could work but genuinely would be way too nervous to do this.

Could you repeat that please?” In a slightly neutral tone and get her to repeat what she says. She won’t. She will be embarrassed I think.
This will be my Plan A to see how things work out. I'll also consider writing things down in front but have to make sure that it doesn't show my nervousness or come across as provocative as I feel kind of cornered by her.

Ask to have a private word with her. Set out the things she does and tell her they (not her) make you uncomfortable /belittled. Say you want to understand what's going on, could she explain. If she can't, tell her you aren't going to let it go, you are going to arrange a meeting with a superior so whatever is going on can be sorted. All the other stuff, you're playing along her, it never works. Passive aggression needs to be pulled out from under it's rock. Go to the root of it. Yes, it's terrifying, but no where near as bad as putting up with this corrosive shit. For all you know, you/her superior knows she has form and might be pleased to be able to do something.
This is definitely Plan B. I'm quite bad at playing games due to a lack of confidence (ironically!) so explaining things as I feel they are seems constructive to me and also sheds light on the passive aggressive attitude.

Op, I had this with a colleague. I am completely non confrontational, hate awkwardness etc. But one day, very similar to your comment I ended up retorting ‘well yeah, because I’m cool as fuck’. I have no idea what came over me. I would never normally say anything like this but it just spewed out. long story short, the comments stopped after that. She still hates me, but secretly now!
I love this and am pleased for you that your colleague stopped bothering you.

I feel well armed for tomorrow thanks to all the support on this thread, it feels like you lot got my back😍Thank you!

OP posts:
DaisyQuakeJohnson · 15/05/2022 14:04

Have a few stock phrases ready eg
'Gosh, that's an interesting view.'
'Hmm, ' call to another colleague, 'x says this, what do you think?'
'Haha, you're such a card. I love your daily comments to me. I can't wait to hear what you say next!'
'I'm confused, is that your professional feedback or did someone ask you to mentor me even though I'm in a different team?'

Johnnysgirl · 15/05/2022 14:00

Just ask her what it has to do with her, op? Retorts like "thank you for your feedback" just give people the impression that they're perfectly within their rights to comment, surely? Confused
Stand up for yourself properly, don't hide behind weasel words.

Juniper68 · 15/05/2022 14:00

Take her out to dinner 😳
Nope

MaudieandMe · 15/05/2022 13:57

Marmalade201928 · 15/05/2022 12:20

You don't need to make enemies with her. She's threatened by you, and is your senior. Do the right thing. Invite her out to dinner and get to know her and if not friends at least understand each other better. I see no long-term gain for you to start a war of attrition against her in the work place.

Don’t do this OP. It’s not remotely helpful advice.
It’s not your job to work out why she’s a bully to you or to try to cure her of doing it.

Note down the things she says and report her to HR is the correct way to handle these sorts of situations.

When I was much younger, I had a similar scenario but there was no HR back then and I had a stand up sweary row with her in front of several staff as she’d pushed my buttons one time too many.

It resolved the issue instantly as she wasn’t used to anyone standing up to her and she treated me like Royalty afterwards.

However, I wouldn’t recommend this approach unless everything else has failed, as it’s totally unprofessional.

Juniper68 · 15/05/2022 13:54

Good luck for tomorrow. Hopefully you find strength from mumsnet. Tell us how you get on.

Planterina22 · 15/05/2022 13:51

Taking a bully out to dinner is a bit like victim blaming, as in oh if you’re just a bit nicer she wouldn’t single you out. It’s not about op, it’s about this woman’s insecurities.

BellePeppa · 15/05/2022 13:48

Marmalade201928 · 15/05/2022 12:20

You don't need to make enemies with her. She's threatened by you, and is your senior. Do the right thing. Invite her out to dinner and get to know her and if not friends at least understand each other better. I see no long-term gain for you to start a war of attrition against her in the work place.

The last thing I’d want to do is have dinner with my bully, don’t think I’d have much of an appetite.

WibblyWobblyJane · 15/05/2022 13:43

Given her influence and your anxiety about pushing back, I would just
choose one each time:


  • agree heartily

  • laugh along

  • play dumb


You have a big head? “Oh I didn’t know I had big hair today! That’s awesome! I love when I get big hair!”

Embrace it, and her and just don’t ever let her see it’s getting to you. She wants a fight. It will drive her mad that you don’t seem to notice the insults.

You eat out too much?
”I know, right? I should cut back but then again it makes me happy.”

She cheerful, kind, dumb. She will go crazy or get bored and anyone watching you will be impressed with you.

DodgyKneesCyril · 15/05/2022 13:28

midsomermurderess · 15/05/2022 12:47

I can't believe that people, well women, think that 'tinkly laugh' is a strategy for dealing with a passive aggressive cunt.

Always accompanied by a "breezy reply" 🙄

DangerouslyBored · 15/05/2022 13:27

Goldengoosey · 15/05/2022 12:58

I’d be tempted to tell her to F off but I actually think some of the suggestions you have had are great. As soon as she approaches adopt your bright and breezy face and take out your notebook and jot down what she says. For good measure read it back to her and then close your book and say Noted. She will soon become quite uncomfortable and hopefully think twice about continuing this shitty behaviour with you. Don’t explain what you’re doing. Just write all comments down and date.

She sounds a right nasty piece of work.

Love this. Such great advice

DangerouslyBored · 15/05/2022 13:25

PluralForBell · 15/05/2022 08:33

These are all very useful and strike the right one, thank you.

I would never be confrontational but have noticed that I am getting tense every time she makes a beeline for me.

On Friday morning after I delivered a presentation to the department, which I had worked on really hard and, which received a lot of praise from senior colleagues (I am junior) including her team Afterwards, she asked me a question and when I replied she said in a bemused tone, "you are quite the big-headed one aren't you?"

She also told me that I must be spending all my salary on eating out when she overheard me tell a colleague that I was meeting friends for dinner. I don't feel I can go to HR with it as it's all so petty. If it was a comments every now and agin, it wouldn't bother me at all, it's daily. It feel like she intends to put me in my place.

I think that I can shake her off but needed some go-to phrases that subtly signal I am not engaging with her and I am not rattled (I am rattled though).

This woman is jealous of you. I know the signs v well. "you are quite the big-headed one aren't you?" Jealousy. Making comments about your social life, jealousy. It eats people up and makes them extremely toxic.

Marmalade201928 · 15/05/2022 13:24

@KitKattaktik

The senior colleague has already primed herself for a fight with the young OP. She obviously has much experience in attacking her perceived future enemies. If OP takes her out to dinner, this will genuinely disarm her and cause her embarrassment. Besides she already quipped about OP spending all her wages on eating out; this is the perfect opening to take her along as well.

If you insist on doing the right honourable thing and hitting back, then be warned one should understand and scout out the field of battle first. Is she on good terms with the decision makers? If the company has to choose one of them, who would it be? Would the company care if she said some stupid remarks? It's not simple, the payoff is questionable, and since this is not a case of blatant discrimination or harassment, probably not worth it.

midsomermurderess · 15/05/2022 13:16

Ask to have a private word with her. Set out the things she does and tell her they (not her) make you uncomfortable /belittled. Say you want to understand what's going on, could she explain. If she can't, tell her you aren't going to let it go, you are going to arrange a meeting with a superior so whatever is going on can be sorted.
All the other stuff, you're playing along her, it never works. Passive aggression needs to be pulled out from under it's rock. Go to the root of it. Yes, it's terrifying, but no where near as bad as putting up with this corrosive shit. For all you know, you/her superior knows she has form and might be pleased to be able to do something.

KitKattaktik · 15/05/2022 13:15

Marmalade201928 · 15/05/2022 12:20

You don't need to make enemies with her. She's threatened by you, and is your senior. Do the right thing. Invite her out to dinner and get to know her and if not friends at least understand each other better. I see no long-term gain for you to start a war of attrition against her in the work place.

take a bully out for dinner? You're having a laugh. The enmity is coming from her, not OP!!

SerendipityJane · 15/05/2022 13:10

Trouble is people with bad intent like that never tend to commit anything to writing as they know it creates an audit trail.

You don't need them to create an audit trail. You do it for them as suggested.

Wishihadanalgorithm · 15/05/2022 13:08

I would get yourself a copy of the grievance policy and read it. Then I would record all of her shitty comments. As many as you can recall, including dates, times and who was present (probably no one else!). Armed with info and evidence I would speak to your line manager and say the company has a duty of care to protect you from work place bullying. They either step in now or your raise a grievance against her (and possibly your LM for doing nothing - maybe not state that at this point though).

I would not engage with her in any way,when she comes to you, you turn away or pick up the phone or walk away.

This woman is jealous and you won’t make friends with her, she won’t respect you and she won’t leave you alone until she has to.

Be professional, don’t play games and don’t give her anything which she can use against you. Good luck.

bumblingbovine49 · 15/05/2022 13:07

Bunce1 · 15/05/2022 08:39

I would say-

“could you repeat that please?” In a slightly neutral tone and get her to repeat what she says. She won’t. She will be embarrassed I think.

Do this, make out you can't quite hear and get her to repeat it. Then if she has the balls to repeat it, maybe repeat what she says slowly as if you are working out what she means. Maybe say something like ' oh you think I have a big head, oh ok', and then move away

The idea is to get her to repeat what she says, ideally in front of others or to draw attention to. You need to be able to be nonchalant about it though. Don't come across as angry or upset, more bemused or puzzled if you can. This will hopefully start to embarrass her and she may stop. If it doesn't go to HR but you need to keep a log of all the things she says and get whatever you can from her in writing

TheFairyNamedMary · 15/05/2022 13:01

I ignore the colleague who tries to put me down in front of others. Hasn’t stopped them trying but the satisfaction I few bit saying anything is great. The moment she starts I carry on with work, when she stops I engage as normal

Goldengoosey · 15/05/2022 12:58

I’d be tempted to tell her to F off but I actually think some of the suggestions you have had are great. As soon as she approaches adopt your bright and breezy face and take out your notebook and jot down what she says. For good measure read it back to her and then close your book and say Noted. She will soon become quite uncomfortable and hopefully think twice about continuing this shitty behaviour with you. Don’t explain what you’re doing. Just write all comments down and date.

She sounds a right nasty piece of work.

TylerMonday · 15/05/2022 12:57

I’ve been through similar and it’s difficult. It was someone higher and well respected but I knew she didn’t like me. If I saw her come over I’d not look up and concentrate on what I was doing. She sort of demanded attention and I wasn’t giving it to her. She didn’t like that I didn’t shower her with compliments (like some did) and blow air up her arse.

User310 · 15/05/2022 12:54

Op, I had this with a colleague. I am completely non confrontational, hate awkwardness etc. But one day, very similar to your comment I ended up retorting ‘well yeah, because I’m cool as fuck’. I have no idea what came over me. I would never normally say anything like this but it just spewed out.

long story short, the comments stopped after that. She still hates me, but secretly now!

Hoolahulahoop · 15/05/2022 12:51

This scenario is happening to me at the moment and it's very tricky. I asked for advice recently. I have gone for a grey rock approach. Tell them very little. Walk away and be busy. But it's so hard.

loobylou10 · 15/05/2022 12:50

@midsomermurderess - me neither. It's not a tinkly laughing matter, nor is it time for a witty 'retort'. She needs calling out and needs to be made to say exactly what she means.