Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Shut down rude colleague

183 replies

PluralForBell · 15/05/2022 07:36

There is someone at work who constantly comes to me to tell me something negative about my work or about me as a person. She is a lot older than me and extremely domineering and confident, she rules the roost.

The thing she says sometimes have a tiny teeny bit of truth to them but she uses any perceived weaknesses to weaponise it to undermine my confidence and doubt myself.

She is not in my team so can't speak to LM.

I am focusing on my job and am quite good at it based on feedback. I think this woman doesn't like me or feels threatened IDK.

How can I breezily shut her flow of negative comments up while remaining polite and professional?

It's not even so much what she says she just comes to make underhand remarks then leaves again, like spreading her daily poison.

Annoyingly, this stresses me and makes me doubt myself.

How do I remain confident with this co worker but make her daily approaches stop?

OP posts:
SeedyBloomer · 15/05/2022 16:02

People like this are awful. Reply in a way that makes it clear that, despite her best attempts to undermine you, she’s the only one with an issue. “That’s not what others say.” “Oh, really? I am told I do this well.” “This is exactly how I was trained to do it.” “Well, Xyz is happy with my presentation, so that’s all that matters.”

As for her comment on you being big-headed, next time she pulls that nasty shit I think I’d say, “Not big headed at all. It’s a shame you have to say that. I’ve had positive feedback from the others.”

You need to get the arse shield ready. Document comments, dates and any witnesses. You’re going to need to ensure that you can prove this is targeted harassment if this gets any uglier. Not sure if it would help to indicate to her that you are starting to take this seriously? Eg, “Could you put that in an email, please? I think it’s important to keep a record of this.”

EmotionBot9to5 · 15/05/2022 16:01

And that is how i wish id handled my work bully. N3xt time ill be ready.

EmotionBot9to5 · 15/05/2022 16:00

Invite her to dinner?!

I agree that you need to tread carefully around superiors at work but no need to fawn.

If she says anything like the big head comment again, use the "shine a light on it" technique.

I feel like you're trying to belittle me. Is that your intention?

If she says "oh no no no not my intention at all i just .."

Say "im glad to hear that. Glad to hear that! You must FAKE giving her the benefit of the doubt.

If she says, "no, but the nerve of you taking on these big projects like you have ten years experience when people with 20 years experience havent been given the opportunity.... blah blah blah"

When she has finished, say "i feel like "this" is nothing to do with me".

Do not get drawn in any further though
Smile. Walk away. Ask her if she'd like a chocolate. But keep it de-escalated.

Present a not-rattled front. Fake being calm.

V hard. I know.

Ive been in these shoes. I think standing up to beeatches of any age at any age is a skill that will stand you in good stead.

The psychology of the shine a light on it technique is that you show them CALMLY that you have a bit more fight in you than they had thought. But you dont fight. You show control. You show mastery. The key is to not get drawn in. Whatever shitty dig they lob in, say, respond "well this reaction of yours is really nothing to do with me! So i wont take it personally",
but hopefully they'll be cowardly and predictable and say oh no no no not my intention to belittle you.

daisychain01 · 15/05/2022 15:46

The trouble is having the confidence to do the 'grey rock' / changing the subject treatment directly to the more senior person there in front of you 'in the moment' @Moglie

I can imagine them being quite intimidating and confrontational, and once you feed them a line, suddenly it can quickly spiral out of control and then it makes a bad situation even worse.

Moglie · 15/05/2022 15:30

Keep a note of the digs by all means so you can escalate if you need to. I wouldn’t go down the sarcasm route however tempting as you risk looking like the bad guy as your comments can get escalated too.

I’d suggest you see it as an opportunity to manage up. We don’t all use positional authority to manage, it should be mostly about personal and expert authority. Build yours by asking yourself ‘how would I get the best performance out of her?’ And do it.

I’d grit my teeth, proactively ask her in front of witnesses what her view is on some minor things like reports or policy tweaks (not my performance), grey rock the digs and force myself to ignore the judgement underlying her comments. She has no authority to judge your behaviour so don’t give it to her by reacting with arguments or explanation.

eg all my wages on eating out?
you hear - “you spendthrift social butterfly airhead.”and react to that.
But someone who thinks her opinion on their social habits is irrelevant would respond “it does feel like that doesn’t it but it’s so lovely getting out with friends after what we’ve been through, isn’t it?”

So try to manage her insecurity a bit, feed her some crumbs as it’s no skin off your nose to let her give feedback on trivial things and you choose what they are, fairly evaluate what she says if it’s helpful (and say so). And ask her calmly if she realises how negatively she’s coming across if she’s being horrible, as you are sure that’s not her intention, but any useful points are getting lost in this kind of feedback delivery.

And don’t engage with the personal criticism because she’s not your mother so who cares.

badhappening · 15/05/2022 14:56

Er, sorry I don't follow (look confused).
Can you repeat that please - no I still don't follow (look confused).
Can you explain - sorry no, I still don't follow (look confused).
Excuse me, I've got to see Sue/visit the ladies/must respond to this email (looking confused).

She makes you feel very uncomfortable so do it back head on.

Good luck and remember bullies are the biggest cowards.

tsmainsqueeze · 15/05/2022 14:56

PluralForBell · 15/05/2022 08:33

These are all very useful and strike the right one, thank you.

I would never be confrontational but have noticed that I am getting tense every time she makes a beeline for me.

On Friday morning after I delivered a presentation to the department, which I had worked on really hard and, which received a lot of praise from senior colleagues (I am junior) including her team Afterwards, she asked me a question and when I replied she said in a bemused tone, "you are quite the big-headed one aren't you?"

She also told me that I must be spending all my salary on eating out when she overheard me tell a colleague that I was meeting friends for dinner. I don't feel I can go to HR with it as it's all so petty. If it was a comments every now and agin, it wouldn't bother me at all, it's daily. It feel like she intends to put me in my place.

I think that I can shake her off but needed some go-to phrases that subtly signal I am not engaging with her and I am not rattled (I am rattled though).

What a bitch ,she is obviously threatened in some way by you but her behaviour is totally unacceptable.
You say the comments are petty , they may be but it all adds up to potential bullying .
I would keep a diary of every comment , behaviour , from her that is upsetting for you , at the same time i would use some of the very good examples here of replies you can start to give her.
I think in your case i would not confront her alone directly , i would do everything calmly and correctly and gather evidence , she is probably the type to turn this on you and play the victim if confronted with her behaviour .
Good luck , no one should be treated like this at work .

Planterina22 · 15/05/2022 14:50

@2bazookas You can give feedback and not treat someone like a personal
scratching post first.

Muckymaisonette · 15/05/2022 14:50

EmotionBot9to5 · 15/05/2022 14:46

Ha, some of these are so good.
Your level of sincerity shines through.

Yeah that’s better and truthful!

EmotionBot9to5 · 15/05/2022 14:46

Ha, some of these are so good.
Your level of sincerity shines through.

Muckymaisonette · 15/05/2022 14:44

“Your sincerity shines through” then as she walks away “out of your bottom”

EmotionBot9to5 · 15/05/2022 14:43

Teenagequeenwithaloadedgun · 15/05/2022 12:10

'Morning colleague, I see the hitman failed'

Oh that's funny!
I may run in to somebody this summer, big do, she will be there, looking forward to icing me a bit more, if she says anything supercilious to me im going to crack the hitman joke. If she ignores me ill ignore her.

Muckymaisonette · 15/05/2022 14:42

“your observations are the highlight of my working day”
“Such an uplifting comment, my cup runneth over”
”pure gold, how we miss you when you are not here to encourage us”
“so helpful, let me add that to my to-do list”

Joessaysthankyou · 15/05/2022 14:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

RedHorsesAreDangerous · 15/05/2022 14:30

Take her out to dinner?! Are people completely mad?! This woman already basically said she thinks the OP gets paid too much and can afford to eat out all the time....plus give up your personal time with no other witnesses?! Couldn't this be construed as favouritism?! I'm guessing we're not 5alking a coffee and a muffin down the cantee! No, thank you.

As an older member of the workforce I sometimes get a little bit jaded by just how fast new arrivals to the workforce are speeding up the work ladder (there's an NHS Band 7 admin related role on the Isle of Wight that's really suitable for newly qualifieds, apparently, which is a bit of a kick in the face to those of us who had to work for years to get Band 5 or 6 roles) but I'd hope that wouldn't mean I'd be crass enough to offer unwarranted advice to someone I wasn't directly line managing! And besides, if I'm that annoyed, I know where the door is...!!

Definitely get as much as you can in writing/email so you can establish a pattern and gather evidence, and good luck tomorrow.

Oh and if you're not already in one, join a union.

Johnnysgirl · 15/05/2022 14:26

2bazookas · 15/05/2022 14:16

The thing she says sometimes have a tiny teeny bit of truth to them

Then listen and learn.

There's this, too... Could be doing you a favour in the long term, op.
Other people could well have noticed these things too but haven't said anything yet

declutteringmymind · 15/05/2022 14:25

*shit

declutteringmymind · 15/05/2022 14:24

Or my go to 'I just don't give a shot'

Bednobsbroomsticks · 15/05/2022 14:24

Quote the lovely Bridget Jones..

Go away please I am very busy and important

declutteringmymind · 15/05/2022 14:24

'Wow you are observant, I'll know who to call if I need a PI'
' Where do you get the time to analyse things? Maybe I should request a transfer to your office.'

Just bitch her right back.

Muckymaisonette · 15/05/2022 14:23

Either sarcastic -
“Has anyone ever told you that you should be a motivational speaker? No…I thought not!
or resigned -
”Not this old shit again”

MrsSebastianStan · 15/05/2022 14:18

I think, for you, the most important thing is to get it clear in your own head that she is somehow threatened by you, jealous and trying to increase/maintain the distance between you in terms of influence, position etc.

To do this, because you are doing well, she has to try to push you downwards. Secure people pull themselves up. Insecure people push others down.

knowing this really helps. You KNOW she is trying to make herself the one with power. Don’t give it to her. Keep saying to yourself ‘poor old X, it must be awful being so desperate to feel important she’ll belittle people she thinks are threats.’

be kind, agree with her cheerfully, wilfully misconstrue every dig as the compliment it actually is ‘I do feel quite pleased with my performance today, yes thanks!’, ask her proactively for feedback on your work before she opens her gob when she approaches ‘oh here’s X! What did you think of the report on Y proposal?’ and be kind. Just subtly let your brisk compassion for her insecurity show……just a little.

nothing will annoy her more, and you are being the professional you are.

lemongreentea · 15/05/2022 14:17

She sounds annoying OP. Good luck for tomorrow.

2bazookas · 15/05/2022 14:16

The thing she says sometimes have a tiny teeny bit of truth to them

Then listen and learn.

Planterina22 · 15/05/2022 14:14

We have got your back op!! 😊