Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are an only child…

188 replies

Organictangerine · 14/05/2022 22:22

Would you have preferred a sibling(s)?

No agenda here
I have an only myself at the moment
I have lots of siblings
Just interested to know the experiences of others

OP posts:
Aquamarine1029 · 15/05/2022 02:13

I'm an only child, 49 years old, and I have never wanted a sibling. I had a brilliant childhood and I wouldn't change a thing. Being an only child is not what makes someone have a sad/lonely childhood.

HeArInGhandsgirl11 · 15/05/2022 02:04

Only child here and my whole life all I wanted was a sibling.. still now I look at friends with siblings and feel jealous. I always knew I wanted more than one DC

Bromeliadh · 15/05/2022 01:41

I feel desperately sorry for anyone who is an only. When your parents die you are alone, no shared family history or memories. It's truly gut wrenching.
Depends if that bothers you I suppose. I’m not bothered about being the only surviving member of my family. Yes I’m the only person left with those memories. But I have lots of memories that only I possess. I’ve spent time at school and work alone, went on holiday alone. Spent time with my ex who’s now dead and other exes who I don’t see any more. I’m the only one who knows I was raped and abused. Lots of stuff that now only exists in my own memory, that my parents never shared or even knew about. And I have a 15 year shared family history with my husband and kids, so it’s not like I don’t have anyone alive who’s shared my life.

Bromeliadh · 15/05/2022 01:29

Nah I wouldn’t want a sibling. I’d only have got half the money from my Dad’s house when he died and that wouldn’t have been enough to buy a property for myself. And my Mum would only do half as much stuff for me as she does now. I’d only get half as much money for Christmas. Better to have it all for myself.

louiseofthelakes · 15/05/2022 01:24

If you do one of those ancestry DNA tests, you'll find out you have thousands of relatives who share your DNA, if that make you feel any better 🙂

Thank you imaginary I have already done that but no one close unfortunately. Although I am a bit obsessed with researching distant relatives on my family tree which I put down to being alone.

Willyoujustbequiet · 15/05/2022 01:15

I had a sibling, now I'm an only so have experienced both.

I feel desperately sorry for anyone who is an only. When your parents die you are alone, no shared family history or memories. It's truly gut wrenching.

MeridasMum · 15/05/2022 01:10

I hated being an only child. I was the only one in my primary school class with no siblings.

My parents never tried to 'make up for it'. We lived in an area with very few neighbourhood children, I don't have cousins, they didn't make friends with similar families, it was a lonely existence, especially in a house with domestic abuse.

It has affected me in so many ways: I struggle to make friends, be a good friend, deal with conflict. Plus I'm on my own in having to deal with really shitty parents.

Luckily, DH and I have created an incredibly happy family; my kids are all really close. I wish I'd had just a fraction of that growing up.

MadameFantabulosa · 15/05/2022 01:09

Yes. Not necessarily growing up but to help deal with my mother after my father’s death, and now, as she’s nearly 90. Not to help physically, but just to be someone I could vent to, and for mutual support. Her youngest brother is closer in age to me than her, and he helps a bit, but won’t go and see her, which would be a huge help.

Notarealmum · 15/05/2022 01:04

Yes!! In the little fantasy world I inhabited in my lonely childhood I had siblings galore.

MoiraQueen · 15/05/2022 00:50

I'm an only child and have always been happy with that, I didn't have a lot as a child and a second child would have been a real struggle for my parents. My mum hated having a sibling, they are not close and she didn't want to inflict one on me. I've always been fine.
DD is an only, not by intention. She is lonely (but mainly because she struggles for friendships), she would have liked a sibling, although there is no guarantee she'd have got on with them and she very much likes her own space.

AledsiPad · 15/05/2022 00:46

As a child, yes I really wanted a sibling. As an adult now I’m grateful I don’t have a sibling who I don’t get along with but have to tolerate as many people seem to.

I had 4 DC because I hated being an only so much as a child… I don’t hate it so much now. I’m dreading being a sole cared for elderly parents though and, even more so, dreading being alone when they’re gone.

HarrietSchulenberg · 15/05/2022 00:34

I am an only child. I hated it and was very jealous of my cousins and friends as their families were all bigger than mine. My parents were entirely focused on me and it made me cautious about my decisions in adult life, eg I would have liked to have lived overseas but didn't feel I could as my Mum would have been heartbroken to lose me. It was bad enough when I left home to go to university. It was exacerbated by my parents dislike for eachother and I worked out as a teenager that they only stayed together for my sake, and they really should have separated years ago.

My parents are now in their 80s and are starting to need more care. There is only one of me and although at the moment they are claiming to cope, in a year or two they will certainly need more help and it will all fall to me.

I have 3 children as I wouldn't wish being an only child on anyone.

Disneyblueeyes · 15/05/2022 00:29

I may be flamed for this, but the fact there are so many pros and cons to having an only child/having more than one makes me question why most children have siblings. I'm a teacher and I can count on one hand how many children are only children out of a class of 32.

I honestly wonder if people really want a second child, or they just have a 2nd to give their first a sibling. Or they have more because it's 'normal'.

Both of which are not good enough reasons to have a child in my opinion. I know one person who had absolutely no money to support a 2nd, and didn't love their husband anymore, but freely admitted they still had a 2nd because they couldn't bear their little boy not having a sibling.

NewandNotImproved · 15/05/2022 00:20

Absolutely not. And I’m childfree.

Having a kid is for the parents own selfish reasons, trying to dress it up an some kind of altruistic act to ‘give’ an existing kid a sibling is just nonsense.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 15/05/2022 00:14

These types of questions are pointless anyway as you'll get replies from people who hated being an only, and replies from people who were fine with it. Just the same as people who loved having siblings, and those who don't get on with their siblings.

At the end of the day every single person is different and will have different experiences. Decisions on how many children you should have need to be YOUR decisions.

I have only one child, and even if DS hated it and begged for a sibling (he doesn't but hypothetically) I still would not have another child. I could not cope with another child, not mentally and not financially. I'm the one that has to raise that child, not DS. It's my decision, not his.

Sockmonkeysloth · 15/05/2022 00:14

I wanted an older brother. Once I figured out that wasn’t possible, hell no. My friends all had younger siblings and they were a pain!

chillidoritto · 15/05/2022 00:09

My mum had me young but then struggled to become pregnant. When I was 5 we moved over to the US for 3 years. The type of visa that went with my dad's job meant my mum couldn't work. The stress free life must have agreed with her - I went out to the US as an only child and returned with 3 little brothers!!

BackToWhereItAllBegan · 14/05/2022 23:48

I have a younger brother that I love to death, I'd literally give my life for him but growing up we were just two people who happened to live in the same house, I don't think I even noticed him for the majority of my childhood.! My DH has two siblings that he hasn't seen since he left home at 16 so he had no interest in large families. We have an 'only' teenage DS, he's a happy and sociable boy, has lots of friends and we're a close threesome so I don't feel that he's ever suffered or feel any guilt on his behalf.

TempsPerdu · 14/05/2022 23:46

Interesting thread. Lots of perfectly happy only children, and some who would have preferred siblings. I’m pretty sure that, had the question been ‘Do your siblings add value to your life?’ or ‘Were you happy as one of 3?’ there would be a similar balance of replies.

Which begs the question of why there remains a unique sense of stigma around only children. All possible permutations of family size, gender balance and age gaps have their own pros and cons, and yet the stereotype of the lonely, self-centred, socially dysfunctional only child persists.

Fwiw DP and I each have one sibling, who we’re not especially close to (mine emigrated), and no cousins to speak of. DD is also an only, mostly through choice and partly through circumstance. We are all perfectly happy and well adjusted.

Blueberrywitch · 14/05/2022 23:38

There were lots of benefits to being an only child, more mature, better conversationalist, great at spending time alone and entertaining myself, a free spirit. But lots of downsides too, including no one to have shared memories with of my childhood now that I’m an adult. But most of my friends are fairly estranged or very indifferent towards their siblings so it’s hard to feel that I’ve missed out on much really.

AnGofsMum · 14/05/2022 23:36

I’m an only child but have lots of cousins who lived nearby so was never a lonely child. I think it also made me very outgoing and able to chat to people and make friends.

I have 2 DCs who are very close - will say that they are each other’s best friend - and they have far fewer friendships than I did at their age as they don’t have to make the effort.

As an adult, I really wish I had a sibling when I see friends who are close to their sisters, help them raise their children etc. My mum, who is normally really fit and well, was quite poorly early this year and I got a taste of what it might be like to bear the emotional burden of caring for her by myself in years to come. DH is great with her but it’s not the same as having that shared family relationship.

Fiddlersgreen · 14/05/2022 23:34

DinosaursEatMan · 14/05/2022 22:35

I hated it and always wanted a sibling. That’s one of the main reasons why I have more than one dc.

This is the same for me too.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 14/05/2022 23:32

I'm an only. Doesn't bother me at all. Never longed for a sibling. Really couldn't care less about all this "shared memories" stuff.

AllFreeOwls · 14/05/2022 23:32

I'm an only and have never had any desire to have a sibling.

Binsk · 14/05/2022 23:29

Yes. I would have liked someone to play with, and as I got older, someone who understands what it's like dealing with my parents!
I have 2 of my own at the moment and do wish I had a similar relationship as a child, when I see them playing together.