Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are an only child…

188 replies

Organictangerine · 14/05/2022 22:22

Would you have preferred a sibling(s)?

No agenda here
I have an only myself at the moment
I have lots of siblings
Just interested to know the experiences of others

OP posts:
MissChanandlerBong80 · 15/05/2022 07:22

EarlGreywithLemon · 15/05/2022 06:43

I hated being an only child then, and hate it now. What I hate is the intensity of parental focus on just me. I have three close friends who are only children. We all feel the same.

I feel the same - that was what I found (and still find) the hardest. I cringe a bit when people say that having undivided parental attention is a positive of being an only. Maybe it is for some people but I found being the sole focus of parental attention absolutely suffocating.

KangarooKenny · 15/05/2022 07:21

Me and my sibling don’t get on, we can’t be in the same room, so having one for company won’t always work.

TulipsGarden · 15/05/2022 06:52

Willyoujustbequiet · 15/05/2022 01:15

I had a sibling, now I'm an only so have experienced both.

I feel desperately sorry for anyone who is an only. When your parents die you are alone, no shared family history or memories. It's truly gut wrenching.

But that doesn't bother me. At all. I have my own family and friends that I've created, and I can remember my childhood without someone else's help. I really don't understand why that's something to pity - but I understand it's something you valued and no longer have, so I'm sorry for that.

My parents both have siblings they're not particularly close to, they see them maybe once or twice a year.

Poyyu23 · 15/05/2022 06:47

I have an only child by choice. I didn’t want her having to deal with a sibling. I have a sister who I never got on with. In childhood we only fought and in our adulthood we lived away from each other ever since I turned 18. The stories of having a close sibling who you are a best friend with are a fantasy for many people. I can only count on one hand a number of friends that are actually close to their siblings.

voxnihili · 15/05/2022 06:47

I’m an only and was desperate for a sibling. I still wish now that I had that close bond with someone. I vowed I wouldn’t have an only. I’ve only been able to have one child and I really hope she doesn’t feel like I did growing up.

stopthepain · 15/05/2022 06:46

I have a db who’s 1 year younger and another who is 9 years younger. The youngest told me he feels like an only child due to the big age gap. He doesn’t share the same memories that our other db and I have together. He isn’t an adult yet so he hasn’t experienced the same things as us.

That's just a bit of warning if you’re considering an age gap of more than 4 years. Due to fertility issues, I may only have 1.

@Organictangerine some of the PP might’ve had cousins that were a similar age to them or lived on a street full of dc. You can’t really ask for opinions without assessing the variables. I imagine most only dc spend loads more time with adults.

autienotnaughty · 15/05/2022 06:45

My sisters were 7/8 years older than me so it was like being an only child. I disliked it especially as they picked on me. We are not close now as adults either. I swore I would never do same so had 18m gap between dd's. They grew up best of friends it was lovely until they hit teens then they hated each other. Now as adults they tolerate each other. Also I had a third child when they were 14/15 so ended up repeating my parents actions! Although ds is fine by himself now he's a bit older I'd love a sibling for him but it's too late now.

ihearttc · 15/05/2022 06:44

I’m an only child and I hated it. I spent my entire childhood feeling so lonely, appreciate that was my family in the 1980’s though.
My parents are now in their 80’s and my Mum has dementia. The entire weight of caring for them has fallen to me. I’ve got nobody to share things with or talk to about things.

EarlGreywithLemon · 15/05/2022 06:43

I hated being an only child then, and hate it now. What I hate is the intensity of parental focus on just me. I have three close friends who are only children. We all feel the same.

DangerouslyBored · 15/05/2022 06:34

DH is an only. He loved it growing up. He has never missed having a sibling. He’s one of the most well rounded, happiest, gregarious people I know.

Marvellousmadness · 15/05/2022 06:26

An only is a lonely imo

Awoooga · 15/05/2022 06:23

That was paragraphed, sorry!

Awoooga · 15/05/2022 06:15

Really interesting comments from onlys who assume their life would have been better just because of siblings. I have a brother 14 months older than me and I spent most of my childhood and all of my teenage years fantasising what it would be like to not have a brother and I’m sure he wished I’d never come along either. We have never gotten on, perhaps as toddlers we played together but after that he made my life a misery. We agreed a truce a few years ago but still barely speak. I love my nephew to pieces but he won’t be a playmate for my child as there’s over a decade age difference so the ‘oh but what about having a cousin’ thing doesn’t really apply here either.
Parents are dead now so can’t say anything about caring for them but I’ve a friend with 2 sisters close in age and she’s the one left to do all the caring for their mum in old age as sisters don’t give a crap, which is arguably more frustrating.
On the other hand of course a lot of siblings do enhance each other’s lives, I just don’t think either situation guarantees anything.

SugarNspices · 15/05/2022 06:14

I've got lots of sisters and I loved it. When mum and dad where being "mean" (disciplining us really) it was a great comfort to have them cuddle and talk to each other. They do have easy going personalities generally and are down to earth we have similar sense of humours too. To be honest our parents where very strict with us in a lot of areas and it's good therapy to talk about and share it with them (at least we were treated the same though) This helps because we are able to still love them and have a fairly good relationship now. Having 4 sisters also means none of us have to have the parents full attention which suits us all fine and it be so much easier when they get very old. It really depends on circumstances and how close you where to you parents and siblings I think.

PanettoneMoly · 15/05/2022 06:12

Only child, never wanted a sibling. Helped that my best friend as a child was an only too (we’ll youngest with a big age gap so her brother was 20-odd when she was a child).

On the rationale around having more than one child so they can share provision of care in old age, my dad had to look after both of his elderly parents alone as his sister was living aboard and then, when she moved back to the UK, lived at the other end of the country and visited every couple of months or so, so it doesn’t always work out exactly as planned.

MissChanandlerBong80 · 15/05/2022 05:58

Absolutely hated it, particularly as I got older - from about 9 onwards. All I wanted in the world was a sibling, well into my adult years. I relate to a lot of what’s written in this article:

theweek.com/articles/684148/im-only-child-ill-always-wish-wasnt-?amp

But it’s nice to see that lots of people on this thread have good experiences of being onlies.

TedMullins · 15/05/2022 05:51

No, I’d have hated having a sibling. I’m not close to cousins either and have a tiny family but I’m fine with it, if anything I’m glad I don’t have the pressures and obligations people with bigger families seem to have. My parents have never placed any expectations on me. Couldn’t care less about “sharing memories” when my parents die or being the last surviving family member. I don’t want kids either.

NC10012 · 15/05/2022 05:43

I had 3 siblings. But my DP was an only child and said they really felt lonely and would have liked a sibling.

TheTonEffect · 15/05/2022 04:54

Aquamarine1029 · 15/05/2022 02:15

🙄

Save your pity, thank you very much. How absurd.

What a defensive reply. The poster is saying they've experienced both. It's a fair point anyway - I know an only who said when her parents die she'd have nothing left to live for. Obviously not the norm but that's how she feels.

brokengoalposts · 15/05/2022 04:17

My dad was an only child, he hated it. His parents had their own business and worked a lot, he spent a lot of time alone and holidays were always just him and one of his parents. He dreamt of 4 kids but my mum refused to have anymore after 2.

After his parents died, he doesn't get to talk about his childhood with anyone who understands, he'll tell us stories but we can't join in with him and although that isn't guaranteed, obviously, he'd have loved a sibling to reminisce with

unicornpower · 15/05/2022 03:56

Yes I was desperate for a sibling, my parents were older and it could be quite lonely. They did their best but I know I’m faced with their old age on my own. I’m hoping to give my DD a sibling

girljulian · 15/05/2022 03:31

I was an only child until I was five, which doesn’t sound a great age, but I remember being jealous when my parents announced they were having another baby, didn’t like the idea then and never warmed to it! I’d have preferred staying an only.

UniversalAunt · 15/05/2022 03:25

Swings & roundabouts.

When things were tough as a only child carer for elderly/demented parents, I yearned for someone as close to them to share the worries & burdens of care, as well as the sharing of everyday triumphs & downfalls. Yet I see friends with siblings carrying the load alone as I did, & lonely in the presence of siblings, so there are no guarantees. Swings & roundabouts.

I see friends with siblings who enjoy strong loving bonds that sustain & enhance their lives as I have friends are still fighting or playing out childhood grievances & hostilities as adults. Swings & roundabouts.

One thing is helpful, if possible, for only children is to spend time together to build childhood experiences & adventures with cousins. These bonds may last a lifetime full of shared memories & support with out the grist/grind of sibling relationships.

Cameleongirl · 15/05/2022 02:40

I’m an only and growing up I did slightly envy friends in larger families. Day to day it was fine, holidays with my parents could be abit lonely unless I met someone my own age.

Now I’m dealing with my remaining elderly parent, his health issues, etc. and it’s hard doing it on my own. But that’s mainly because of his awkward temperament. 😂 It would be nice to have a sibling to share this with, but oh well.

I”m not too worried about my shared family history, I have cousins and I’m not going to forget. I did want a slightly larger family myself and have two. They bicker but essentially get on OK, I can see them getting closer as they get older, they respect one another.

Aquamarine1029 · 15/05/2022 02:15

Willyoujustbequiet · 15/05/2022 01:15

I had a sibling, now I'm an only so have experienced both.

I feel desperately sorry for anyone who is an only. When your parents die you are alone, no shared family history or memories. It's truly gut wrenching.

🙄

Save your pity, thank you very much. How absurd.