Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are an only child…

188 replies

Organictangerine · 14/05/2022 22:22

Would you have preferred a sibling(s)?

No agenda here
I have an only myself at the moment
I have lots of siblings
Just interested to know the experiences of others

OP posts:
dottiedodah · 15/05/2022 11:06

I was an only child .Had many friends, very close to my Cousin .Have lots of friends with issues with Siblings .Sometimes they are a good match ,sometimes not .

LightandMomentary · 15/05/2022 10:31

I was 7 years younger than my dsis, so we both felt like only children growing up. Once we were both adults, it was lovely to feel like I had a sibling, if only to have someone to stick up for me when my Dmum's menopause rages kicked in! I'm sure I would have coped as an only though so I really don't think it makes much difference.

RamsayBoltonsConscience · 15/05/2022 10:26

I'm an only and was perfectly happy with it. I had a close relationship with my cousins, there were 5 of them and I was always quite thankful to be on my own.
As I get older, I do wonder how I will manage the responsibilities of looking after my mum as she gets older (and hold down a full time deputy head job, bearing in mind I currently live 3 1/2 hours away) and whether having a sibling would have helped. However, none of my 5 cousins speak to each other and judging from what I see from my friends, most of the care seems to fall on one sibling more than others.

RainbowsAndPuddings · 15/05/2022 10:24

I'm an only child. And bollocks to those who told me throughout .y life I must have been spoilt - no, I wasn't and we were quite poor.

As a child, I didn't like it and always wanted a sibling. DM couldn't have another for medical reasons. I was the only child in my class with no siblings.

As a teen, hated it a lot as my parents' sole attention was on me (judging me on boyfriends, what I'd decided to study at college, what clothes I wore etc) and I wished there was a sibling they could deflect some of that on to.

As an adult, my relationship with my parents improved, but there was always the guilt of not being there enough.

I felt it more when we went to parties or weddings and people would call their siblings up with them for cake cutting or even sitting at the head table at weddings. Or when friends said "We're having a family party at my sister's today". It felt like a special sibling bond. I had no one for that. Definitely influenced my decision to have more than one child.

Now both my parents have died, I feel very alone. I desperately wish I had a sibling to talk about my parents with.

hitrewind · 15/05/2022 10:12

TylerMonday · 15/05/2022 08:17

What a pointless silly answer!

I always wanted siblings, a brother and a sister would have been great. Now dealing with ASD daughter and elderly parents I do feel particularly lonely. OH is a remaining child with not many in his family either.

It's not pointless or silly at all – it's perfectly honest.

I have no idea what it feels like to have a sibling – I can go on the reports of others, but as has been made very clear on this thread, that experience is enormously varied and unpredictable.

And while I can describe what it's been like to be an only child to people with siblings, I don't imagine they can fully understand the inner, existential sensation of it.

There's really no need to be so dismissive.

I hardly thought about having siblings when I was a kid – but as an adult I have felt it would be nice to have someone who could validate some of my memories. I was in a tough spot a few years ago when both my parents fell ill in different countries at the same time (they're separated) and someone to potentially share that load with would have been a great help.

But honestly I feel the same as @chisanunian – I can try to picture what it might be like to have a sibling, but I don't believe that what I can imagine is even close to the reality.

mumonthehill · 15/05/2022 10:04

I have always been ok with being an only, not missed siblings at all in fact I do not know many people that get on with all their siblings. However, as my parents are now older so much falls to me, celebrations I have to show up there is no one else to do them. Caring responsibility is all mine. However having seen how difficult siblings can find navigating care and death of parents at least I know that I will not have that. Also childhood memories are also only mine, no one to share those with or reminisce with. It’s difficult to miss what you have never had and easy to think of sibling relationships with a rosy glow, which often is not the reality.

gavisconismyfriend · 15/05/2022 09:57

Fine as a child, lots of friends, opportunities my parents couldn’t have afforded for more than one, although both parents v controlling. Trickier as an adult, dad died young and mum v challenging, demanding, jealous of my spending time with anyone but her etc. So it’s not that I wish I had siblings, it’s that I wish I had an easier parent(s)!

FairyCakeWings · 15/05/2022 09:50

I’m an only and I don’t like it.

AnotherFuckingName · 15/05/2022 09:49

And agree, I wish we could do away with the spoiled only child shite. I know plenty of people who spoil their children with siblings just as much as I ever was and my children can't share with each other without falling out to save their life so it doesn't mean a thing.

I've had it said to me on here before that it 'explains a lot about me' just because I had a differing opinion to another poster. It's a nasty stereotype.

AnotherFuckingName · 15/05/2022 09:47

No I've never been bothered by it personally.

My husband has a brother he never speaks to and is frankly a horrible person.

And my Dad who has loads of siblings only keeps in touch with one.

Not evidence of anything concrete obviously but shows its no guarantee of anything.

ProfYaffle · 15/05/2022 09:46

As a child it didn't bother me - I had loads of cousins and felt I had the best of both worlds. Family to see at weekends and have holidays/days out with but going home to my own space and my own things.

As an adult it's difficult but mainly because my parents are overbearing. It was difficult when my dc came along, although they were very hands on they were also typically overbearing inlaws/grandparents. They even squabble over how long they each speak to me on the phone and get competitive if one has a few minutes more than the other 🙄

It would definitely be easier if I had siblings to share the burden. My parents are in their 70s now and very fit and healthy but I do dread they becoming frail, I'm not quite sure how I'll cope with that.

UniversalAunt · 15/05/2022 09:44

Flowers @airforsharon I recognise your situation very well.
However you can, draw in help for your caring responsibilities.
I ended up charging up & down the A3 after FT work several evenings a week to keep the plates spinning for divorced elderly parents, it’s all to easy to do too much. I was completely depleted by the long hauls & became seriously ill. Having the ‘only child of divorced parent’ must-be-fair dynamic does not help - that’s another thread entirely.

Oh yes, the ‘spoilt’ only child.
’Oh you must be so spoiled, getting everything you want…’
Bollocks.

UniversalAunt · 15/05/2022 09:34

An upside of being an only child is that self-determination may develop earlier, that reflexive decision making comes easier compared to how I see friends with siblings have to negotiate how the trap doors & tripwires of family dynamics in order to make decisions about everyday matters or looking after parents.

When it came to advocating for my parent, I knew what they wanted & could relay that directly with no double checking or passing it by others for comment or agreement. In this instance, being an only or single designated advocate made matters for me, my parent & HCPs that much more straight forward & matters were quicker to resolve.

I have been gobsmacked as I watch the interactions & negotiations of a sibling group over what I see as small matters e.g. choosing a pub for Sunday lunch, who drives Mum home etc. The rivalries in some families run deep, but then so do loyalties.

I agree that bringing cousins together doesn’t make them buddies, but actions & events around cousinhood may take some planning & effort, & I encourage that.

Chikapu · 15/05/2022 09:15

Roastonsun8 · 14/05/2022 22:54

Family is what you make it, not numbers.

I don't agree with this. When you have siblings your more likely to have more cousins. Siblings are no guarantee of having a good rapport no, but I'm best friends with one of my cousins.

Having cousins is no guarantee of having a good rapport either. I have loads of cousins and barely know them, we've only met a few times and that was years ago.

I grew up with three brothers and hated every bloody minute of it.

airforsharon · 15/05/2022 08:48

ihearttc · 15/05/2022 06:44

I’m an only child and I hated it. I spent my entire childhood feeling so lonely, appreciate that was my family in the 1980’s though.
My parents are now in their 80’s and my Mum has dementia. The entire weight of caring for them has fallen to me. I’ve got nobody to share things with or talk to about things.

This describes the opposite of my childhood, i was v happy as an only though i was close to a cousin who's only 6 months older than me, so i had a kind of sibling relationship there. I'm an introvert & don't think i would've enjoyed being in a busy household. The only thing i disliked was the assumption that i was spoilt - i wasn't, my parents were pretty strict & after they divorced i lived with my mum and things were pretty tight.

What resonates about @ihearttc post is my situation now. My mum is 2 hours drive in one direction, my dad & stepmum 2 hours in the other. Neither had more children so i'm the only carer if things go tits up with them heathwise (already is with my mum). I'm a LP with 3 dcs still at home, so i have my hands full here. I sometimes wish i had a sibling to share the responsibility for my parents with, but then not all siblings get on, some move countries etc - i think tbh i'd find it harder if i HAD a sibling but they buggered off & left it all to me anyway 😄

TeddyisMydog · 15/05/2022 08:30

My dp has 3 brothers, all 2 years apart in age.
His mum is extremely unwell (in a hospice) it's definitely helped them to have siblings, as there is more than 1 of them to sit with her, to get her shopping, for her to talk to. He would never have managed if it was just him for example

TeddyisMydog · 15/05/2022 08:27

My sibling is 7 years older than me and I always felt like an older child (for example by the time I was 7, he was 14 out with friends not wanting to play dolls with me)
I would have preferred someone close in age. I was awfully lonely and I hated it.

CrunchyCarrot · 15/05/2022 08:24

I'm an only and have always been happy to be that way. My DP is also an only and also OK with it. Neither of us were ever lonely as we are both good at filling our time with many interests.

TylerMonday · 15/05/2022 08:17

chisanunian · 14/05/2022 22:24

Impossible to say, because I've never had one, so I wouldn't know whether I'd prefer it or not.

What a pointless silly answer!

I always wanted siblings, a brother and a sister would have been great. Now dealing with ASD daughter and elderly parents I do feel particularly lonely. OH is a remaining child with not many in his family either.

cafedesreves · 15/05/2022 08:16

NewandNotImproved · 15/05/2022 00:20

Absolutely not. And I’m childfree.

Having a kid is for the parents own selfish reasons, trying to dress it up an some kind of altruistic act to ‘give’ an existing kid a sibling is just nonsense.

That's not true. I absolutely adore having siblings

GoFishandChips · 15/05/2022 08:11

If people can have more than one child, I'd ask them to definitely do it.

I hope you mean more than biologically they can, as in if they can afford to both financially and emotionally.

And OP it's not the same as going to South America, you can read about the culture of a country from multiple sources you can't predict a future child's personality and relationship. All those saying they wished they had a sibling will have an invented an ideal of how their sibling would behave, like teens and a fantasy boyfriend.

If you have another child it has to be because it's best for the family as a whole and if you're doing the birthing and principal childcare it has to be something you want, not a gift for your existing child.

XmasElf10 · 15/05/2022 07:53

My mum was an only and says her childhood was bitterly lonely. My DD is an only and she loves it (she’s 11).

Cervinia · 15/05/2022 07:48

I have two siblings, but I’m the only one that does all the mental and physical load of the elderlies. I struggle to see the benefit of being one of three. Now maybe if I’d had a sister instead of two brothers it would be different.

that said DDs BF is an only one, very happy as one, but he finds it really difficult to see any perspective other than his own or share or not to have his own way.

no right or wrong IMO, some siblings are worth having and some aren’t.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 15/05/2022 07:40

ihearttc · 15/05/2022 06:44

I’m an only child and I hated it. I spent my entire childhood feeling so lonely, appreciate that was my family in the 1980’s though.
My parents are now in their 80’s and my Mum has dementia. The entire weight of caring for them has fallen to me. I’ve got nobody to share things with or talk to about things.

I can see that that is very tough, but having siblings doesn't equal help with ageing parents, especially if the siblings are male (shouldn't be the case, of course, but often is). I have 3 sibs, and 2 of them were completely useless at helping with my parents - one of them made things worse by doing fuck all 99% of the time, then occasionally swanning down to demand why "nobody" had sorted x or y for Mum. The only sib who was any use was my DSis, who lives abroad so, though she was a great emotional support and did all she could from a distance, almost all the practical side fell to me.

HousePlantNeglect · 15/05/2022 07:25

I’m an only and I thoroughly dislike it.

I found childhood very lonely despite having lots of cousins to play with. I also find the same as an adult despite having good friends and my DH having a lovely immediate family.

My situation could be impacted by the fact that my Mum is a single parent and I had a tricky time with her growing up. I find with no sibling or other parent around our relationship is very intense and her truth is ‘the truth’. Perhaps my feeling about being an only would be different if I had another parent.

My DH and his siblings have a shared history and a shared understanding of their past that is often really helpful for him especially with parents getting older and passing away.

But there are plenty of people out there who love being an only. I think more depends on your upbringing that the number of siblings that you have.