Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are an only child…

188 replies

Organictangerine · 14/05/2022 22:22

Would you have preferred a sibling(s)?

No agenda here
I have an only myself at the moment
I have lots of siblings
Just interested to know the experiences of others

OP posts:
BobLep0nge · 15/05/2022 12:19

Wish I hadn't started reading this thread. Now sat crying into my coffee. I feel awful guilt every single day that my child doesn't have siblings. I desperately wanted another child, but it didn't work out. Plus the fact I'm a single parent. What a crap deal my child has been dealt

The vast majority of people I know who have siblings (including myself) do not get along and won't 'come together when a parent dies or share their care'. I'd much rather have had no siblings.

You need to get over your guilt, it's absolutely pointless.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 15/05/2022 12:16

TheTonEffect · 15/05/2022 04:54

What a defensive reply. The poster is saying they've experienced both. It's a fair point anyway - I know an only who said when her parents die she'd have nothing left to live for. Obviously not the norm but that's how she feels.

Weird. You do know only children have family and friends of their own? I have a child, I may have grandchildren one day. My life happiness doesn't depend on my parents being alive.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 15/05/2022 12:14

Willyoujustbequiet · 15/05/2022 01:15

I had a sibling, now I'm an only so have experienced both.

I feel desperately sorry for anyone who is an only. When your parents die you are alone, no shared family history or memories. It's truly gut wrenching.

Don't feel sorry for me. I don't need your sympathy. I literally do not care about any of that.

TaketheTrain · 15/05/2022 12:09

Oh god. Wish I hadn't started reading this thread. Now sat crying into my coffee.
I feel awful guilt every single day that my child doesn't have siblings. I desperately wanted another child, but it didn't work out. Plus the fact I'm a single parent. What a crap deal my child has been dealt. I'm so, so envious of the full families around me. I feel like I've failed him, not only in his childhood but also it seems into adult hood as well. This properly eats me up, the guilt is absolutely awful.

airforsharon · 15/05/2022 12:06

Thanks @UniversalAunt it's reassuring to see posts from others who've had experience of this kind of situation. Being an 'only' was pretty unusual when i was a child (70s) - like @RainbowsAndPuddings i was the only 'only' in my class - so it can feel like all my peers have siblings to potentially share the care & worry for their parents.
I think it's more common for families to have just one child now, so hopefully this generation of only children will feel less 'odd' as adults. A societal change in attitude to stop expecting adult children to shoulder the care for elderly/frail relatives, combined with significant improvements in social care would help (not convinced either will happen in my lifetime tbh)

Ringo11 · 15/05/2022 11:56

I'm an only child and had to be due to my mum's health issues. My parents would have liked another child and I was always desperate for a sibling but it wasn't to be. I did feel lonely at times in my childhood and if I could have chosen, I would have loved a big brother.

However, I've been blessed with two children (ds then dd) who I am incredibly grateful for and that they have each other.

PandaOrLion · 15/05/2022 11:55

I was ambivalent about it at the time but now I see friends only children I can appreciate what I must have been like, and how it impacts me now - I didn’t learn to share adult attention or to put up with other people and compromise in the way friends children who have siblings have learnt to do.

UpdownUpdownAltogetherNow · 15/05/2022 11:51

I’m an only and I loved it so I now have an only.

Mindfulofmuddle · 15/05/2022 11:50

I did want a sibling as a child, at times, but I think I liked the idea more than I would have liked the reality, with hindsight. As an adult I have realised the true value of having a sibling. To prolong your family life and to help share the overwhelming loss of parents and have someone else to remember the earliest and closest family memories (providing sibling and I had a good relationship, of course, there are no guarantees!). I have chosen to have more than one child myself, because of my experience.

Louise0701 · 15/05/2022 11:49

I had 2 cousins who were only children. They hated it and spent as much time at our house as possible. They’ve both gone on to have 4 children.
my best friend was also an only child who also hated it and she has 3 children.
I always really felt for them all.

sundayweatherwatch · 15/05/2022 11:48

Sorry the only one who helped me with executor duties was my husband (dad was obviously no longer here)

angstridden2 · 15/05/2022 11:48

I’m an only, I always wanted a sibling particularly as I got older and everything was focussed on me. I felt the pressure and became a very, probably over compliant child. I have more than one child but would have liked even more, my adult children are good friends.My DP has several siblings, they are all very close and I envy that. Fortunately I get on well with them so I feel I have kind of got surrogate siblings.My friends are really important to me and I think that is because I have no other family.

As others have said, parents getting needier is hard as an only, I always felt guilty going away as I knew there was no one to visit elderly mum. I certainly wouldn’t choose to have one child, but if that’s the hand that life deals you, it isn’t the end of the world!

sundayweatherwatch · 15/05/2022 11:47

Bluevelvetsofa · 15/05/2022 11:11

I wanted a sibling, although I had plenty of friends very close by. I was the youngest by far, of all the cousins too, so they weren’t playmates.

I would have liked someone to share the burden when my dad died unexpectedly and to help look after my mum subsequently. Arranging things on your own can be very lonely.

I'm one of 4 and was the only one of us appointed executor when my DF died. DF's friend was co-executor so I had to get his signatures for everything but I did all the work on my own (which was a lot as DF was still working when he died) and the only one who properly helped with this was my DF. I had horrendous rows with two of my siblings who got pretty bad about money during the process which was awful!

AssignedSlytherinAtBirth · 15/05/2022 11:45

TLDR -just make sure your only gets plenty of chance to socialise with kids of different ages.
I never wanted a sibling and used to pity my friends who had to share their parents with siblings. By best friend at school used to find her sister really annoying. Now as an adult I enjoy my own company. I only wanted one dch but had twins, which I'm glad about, but they don't get on. I had a supportive church environment growing up and they helped me when my parents were ill, and when they died, so I never felt I was facing that alone. I always found it hard to make friends, and still don't feel comfortable in a group, but I'm OK one to one and have a few close-ish friends. But I have no idea what a sibling relationship feels like, so don't miss it. I love The Other One on tv! DH doesn't see or get on with his siblings so there's no guarantee.

sundayweatherwatch · 15/05/2022 11:43

Following on from that, my DH was by FAR the biggest support when my father was dying.

sundayweatherwatch · 15/05/2022 11:41

DH and I have 4 siblings between us and of the 2 with kids, none of them live in the same country as us (one in Scotland and another across the world). Lots of siblings for the parents does not equal lots of cousins close by.

I hate threads like this as it makes me question having an only, despite it being best for my MH - plus DC was prem and pregnancy was one of the worst experiences of my life. I'm also now early 40s (child is nearly 4). Mum guilt is made worse by having moved during lockdowns and having no cousins nearby (although my sibling is hoping for their own baby asap and they live quite close).

I always get in a complete tizz reading these threads as I tend to focus on the negative 'only child' stories, but what I do take from them is that you absolutely cannot call it. Everybody is different, everybody's situation is different, everybody's perspective is different. I grew up in a large family and hated the chaos, I felt that my eating disorder went undetected because there were lots of other siblings with their own problems which divided our parents attention. I was in my sister's shadow for many years, we also hated each other and fought terribly for the most part, she also introduced the concept of eating disorders to me and gave me my first recreational drug (these became my two biggest regrets in life). We get on now but live opposite sides of the world and despite that, still manage to fight when we get together!

Regarding old age, well I'm hoping that we will have a good inheritance fund to hand over to our only and I definitely don't want DC caring for us in old age. I hope to be like my maternal grandmother, she lived to 90 and was still driving herself around and living independently.

You cannot guarantee siblings will support in later life - many move miles away. That certainly has happened a LOT in my family as my parents moved from Southern Hemisphere to UK (leaving behind their parents) and my sister lives far far away from my mum and was no help when our father passed.

chisanunian · 15/05/2022 11:36

Aquamarine1029 · 15/05/2022 02:15

🙄

Save your pity, thank you very much. How absurd.

It's not pity. It's not absurd. When I read this post I was actually thinking 'thank God that someone actually understands what it's like for once' because people just don't get it.

I have been through the gut wrenching experience of knowing that I was the only person from my family left alive, and I wouldn't wish it on anyone. No parents, no siblings, no grandparents, no aunts, uncles, cousins - nobody at all. I was literally alone in the world. The only consolation is that I now have a daughter.

Electricmouse · 15/05/2022 11:34

I didn't have a great childhood but being an only wasn't the issue. Didn't mind it at all. No cousins either, no family members anywhere near my age.i know what people mean though, I don't known any different so have nothing to compare it to.

AnnaMagnani · 15/05/2022 11:30

Never wanted siblings.

Married DH who has siblings - I look at him and them and think 'I was right!'

Wished I had someone to share the burden when my Dad died. When DH's dad died his siblings were nothing but a pain in the arse that every decision had to be checked with and a continual consciousness that no toes were being stepped on.

Gave me a new perspective - when my Mum is ill it's exhausting but it's just her and me together and we are so close, and I don't have to worry about anyone else's feelings.

BernardsarenotalwaysSaints · 15/05/2022 11:30

No, I loved my childhood. I do have a stepbrother though, so had the best of both worlds as saw him every holiday when I was with my Mum.

It also made it far easier when my Dad died as I just got on & sorted everything. Dh went through hell because of his sister when MIL died (& that was without an inheritance for her to argue about as FIL is alive).

Disneyblueeyes · 15/05/2022 11:29

This is an interesting read. I have two older brothers and I'm not close to either really. One of them was awful to me growing up, the other a complete introvert who would have been happy without either of us two.
I get on with them now and it's good to know I've got their support with our parents, however I do worry about my DD who is likely to be an only because I don't have much interest in having another.

I feel guilty about this but I don't want another because I can't be bothered with pregnancy and the newborn stage. I struggle with anxiety and I just want to look forward to nice holidays now, not more children to run around after. I want my life back now to be honest.

However now I think about my daughter growing up without a sibling and without someone else to bounce off and help when we're old and grey, and I suddenly feel selfish.

Thing is though, if she felt lonely I'd do something about it. She'd go to lots of clubs (which we could afford to do), we could afford for her to go to private school so more opportunities. She already has 3 cousins with probably more to come. We have friends with children as well we could potentially go on holiday with etc.

Also with the online presence children have now, I can imagine she'll spend alot of her evenings playing with her classmates online, not with her little brother or sister playing with Lego.

fortifiedwithtea · 15/05/2022 11:24

I am an only child. Desperately wanted a sibling, I was very lonely as a child. Naturally I am quite shy, I feel I missed out on social skills. I am also quite black and white, not many shades of grey with me. If I had had a sibling maybe I would have been more open / tolerant of others point of view.

as an adult and already dealt with one parent death, I wish I had a sibling to share the burden.

i was determined to have more than one dc. As it turns out DD1 wishes she was an only. Had dd2 with fertility treatment and wish I had not forced nature. Dd2 has complex needs and I will worry about her everyday that I am on this earth.

chisanunian · 15/05/2022 11:23

SomersetONeil · 14/05/2022 22:46

FFS. The OP is asking for opinions from people with experience.

There's no need to swear. I do have experience of being an only child - I am one. My dc is one. How much more experience does it take? The OP was asking for comments from only children, so I answered.

Would I have liked a sibling to play with when I was a kid? Maybe I would and maybe I wouldn't. Because there's no way of knowing whether we would have got on amicably or fought like cat and dog. So I can't answer.

Would I have liked a sibling to help me sort out my parents house after their deaths? Yes, I would. But since I've never had a sibling, how would I know whether they would have been kind, supportive and comforting, or the opposite, and been a nightmare who fought over inheritance. So I can't answer that either.

As I said, I can't answer the question, because I don't know what it is like to have a sibling.

Bluevelvetsofa · 15/05/2022 11:11

I wanted a sibling, although I had plenty of friends very close by. I was the youngest by far, of all the cousins too, so they weren’t playmates.

I would have liked someone to share the burden when my dad died unexpectedly and to help look after my mum subsequently. Arranging things on your own can be very lonely.

11stonesomething · 15/05/2022 11:10

This reply has been deleted

This post has been withdrawn at the poster's request.