Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To comment on a child’s size

132 replies

Psa4today · 14/05/2022 20:27

To ask you honestly if you’d comment on a child’s size, and to ask you to stop

PSA for today.

If you see a child/ toddler or baby you deem to be small, please keep your mouth closed about it. Stop saying to parents ‘oh he or she is tiny’ ‘don’t they eat’ ‘ they’re diddy/ a dot or whatever synonym for small enters your mind. Just don’t do it.

also if you see a child you deem to be too big, don’t comment.

you have NO idea how much your words are hurting parents. You have NO idea why that child so that size and what obstacles they are facing. There are a millions reasons from prematurity, growth restriction, heart conditions, Dwarfism, genetic condition, growth hormone deficiency, rss and severe allergies that make children small and a million more that make them big from thyroid issues to PWS. Every day is a fight for these parents. Don’t make it worse with the need to comment. If you must say something, say ‘they’re lovely’.

i see daily the pain these comments inflict on parents and the children who hear them. if this is you, No excuses, don’t hide behind good intentions. Just stop . All you’re doing in pointing out how different that child looks. Please if this is you, stop

psa over

OP posts:
Psa4today · 14/05/2022 21:36

It doesn’t bother me, I’m not impacted by this my children are very ‘average’ however in my day to day I encounter many parents who are deeply hurt by these sort of comments, so whilst it’s fantastic that PPs are very matter of fact and not phased in the slightest by comments, it doesn’t mean that all people feel the same way. I’d liken it to the ‘when are you having kids question’ some people, like me, aren’t phased, don’t care if they are asked inevitably it’s asked to a person who’s struggling and it hurts like hell. So it’s best not to ask or pass comment. There are a million and one neutral small talk passing comments you can say, personally I wouldn’t want to chance inflicting hurt, that’s why I don’t ask ‘why don’t you have kids or when are you having kids’ and likewise, I’d never pass comment on a child’s size.

if you are one of those people that do, maybe 9/10 parents are like the PPs who aren’t fussed but one day you’ll encounter that 1:10 and you will say it to the wrong person and you will cause some real hurt. Please reconsider your small talk.

OP posts:
NeedAHoliday2021 · 14/05/2022 21:34

Meh, Dd is very slim - age 14 and 5’4” with 26” bra band but that doesn’t exist so adapt 28”. She gets comments now and I did as she grew up. Yabu to expect people not to comment. I’ve educated Dd about genes and pointed out while she’s technically underweight re bmi, bmi is based on averages and she’s got my dad’s side body shape.

people will bleat on about not judging others but the reality is we judge each other on so many levels and some people are bad at being diplomatic. Your mn post won’t change that.

custardbear · 14/05/2022 21:32

I suspect most people really don't give a hoot, often it's something to make light conversation about. Maybe enlighten them about birth size, genetics etc and make an intelligent conversation out if it if you've the information, if they're not interested hopefully they won't ask
Again 🤐😁

AlistairCamel · 14/05/2022 21:31

It doesn’t bother me but today my 3 year old came to me sad that she’s ‘little’. She is small for her age and that’s fine but at age 3 all you want is to be a big girl and having someone call you little is upsetting, especially when you can see that you are smaller than others. I realise now she made a comment the other day linking to this as well so it’s playing on her mind.

Magenta82 · 14/05/2022 21:28

My DD was 4lb 11oz 0.4th centile at birth, since 2 weeks she has consistently tracked just below the 9th centile for weight, length and head circumference.

I had her tongue tie cut at 4 weeks, the nurse who came into help asked how many days she was, thinking she was really new.

She is tiny, she will probably always be tiny, but I'm 5' and DP claims he is 5' 9'', (I'm fairly sure he is exaggerating by at least an inch!) so she was never going to be a giant.

It's not upsetting it's just a fact.

Douzy · 14/05/2022 21:27

I can see that people have different views, but I have a rule for myself, which is to never comment on a child's body shape, ever, period. Tall, small, thin, bigger, whatever. I have zero idea what that child might listen to, find negative, or store up for the future.

My neighbour's daughter is unusually tall and very slim, and she's sick to death of people mentioning it, but you'd never know it, as she's a quiet kid who doesn't speak up much.

Likewise, I wouldn't volunteer anything about their child's appearance to a parent, unless they sought it out. I'm not saying it's wrong, per se; it's just that it's hardly going to be news to them! Thinking about it, none of my friends do either.

CheshireCats · 14/05/2022 21:22

All three of mine were small. 2nd centile/8th centile/15th centile .
I am also small.
I had all these comments for all three and didn't mind at all. YABU.

NiceTwin · 14/05/2022 21:16

My first was a little dot of a thing, still is at 20.
Didn't bother me in the slightest that people mentioned it.

Why does it bother you so much op?

Maray1967 · 14/05/2022 21:10

Yes, I can still remember a good friend commenting on how small DS2 was when she saw him. He was 7 lb 4 at birth, hers were all 9lb plus. Even though he was fine it still bothered me for quite a while. I know she didn’t mean it badly in any way but if I found it upsetting I can imagine how people must feel whose children will always be smaller than others due to a condition.

StephMum92 · 14/05/2022 20:58

I get these comments all the time and they drive me insane! My DD is 12 weeks old, was 5lb when born and now nearly 11lb but is still referred to by everyone as tiny! Or when out in the supermarket I get 'wow she's a new one' a lot. I feel like even family judge why she's so small like she isn't being fed or something even though she is and even HV said she's doing well. She'll never be tall, I'm 4ft 8in and DP 5ft 10in. I also get the 'wow she holds her head up so well' as if because she's not massive she won't be able to do anything.

KnottyKnitting · 14/05/2022 20:56

Totally agree- a child I know has Marfan's syndrome and is very very tall for her age. She spends her time being teased at school and people commenting on her height. She has other health conditions and really could do without adults who should know better making her feel even more self conscious than she already is.

Applegreenb · 14/05/2022 20:52

I am really tall for a women and it doesn’t bother me when people mention it. My DC are all super tall and again we get comments but it doesn’t bother me.

i did how ever have a tiny baby bump due to the height so I hid it well. I hated when people told me I had a small bump so I completely get if you are sensitive about something then even an innocent comment can upset you.

Psa4today · 14/05/2022 20:51

KarrotKake · 14/05/2022 20:48

It is always worth clarifying things that are at the edges of normal if you are going to give advice. The number of people who don't actually know the difference between kg and lb, or convert them incorrectly, is not insignificant, and getting someone to double check is never a bad thing.

And yes, I have one of those small kids (as in frequently got asked if I had twins when they were 2 and 4).

No that makes sense from an admin POV, totally but I think the hurt came from half a dozen mums came on after she clarified that weight was correct to point out how small the child was and how their kids were in comparison, thoughtless and quite hurtful

OP posts:
Thinkbiglittleone · 14/05/2022 20:51

Some people are happy to acknowledge how 'diddy' their DC is & agree how gorgeous they are and maybe discuss why they're so diddy or happy to make a jokey comment about nah ndver feed them, am I meant to? How about you do you and leave everyone else to live their own lives??

That's is fine for people to follow another's lead, if a parent is happy to crack jokes about their child's appearance, by all means, join in if that your tiny, but don't assume I want your ridiculous comments about my child appearance, I don't.

While I understand it's a fact, a large percentage of the British public are overweight, I don't stop them in the street to tell them they are overweight, but by some peoples theories that would be fine and not offensive at all Hmm

KarrotKake · 14/05/2022 20:48

It is always worth clarifying things that are at the edges of normal if you are going to give advice. The number of people who don't actually know the difference between kg and lb, or convert them incorrectly, is not insignificant, and getting someone to double check is never a bad thing.

And yes, I have one of those small kids (as in frequently got asked if I had twins when they were 2 and 4).

danny735 · 14/05/2022 20:48

DD is 98th centile and I have been upset by some comments. I agree 100%

prettylittlethingss · 14/05/2022 20:46

YANBU. My little boy is fairly small ( not that small though) and I had a stranger ask me how old he was, I said 4 months and she responded 'was he premature?'
It made me paranoid I wasn't producing enough milk and he wasn't growing enough.

Psa4today · 14/05/2022 20:45

LoveSpringDaffs · 14/05/2022 20:38

YABU because you feel you can speak for everyone, you can't. Some people are happy to acknowledge how 'diddy' their DC is & agree how gorgeous they are and maybe discuss why they're so diddy or happy to make a jokey comment about nah ndver feed them, am I meant to? How about you do you and leave everyone else to live their own lives??

I’m not speaking about my child/
children but many of the parents I encounter. But some are hurt and as you don’t know who is who, isn’t it kinder to just say something neutral, like ‘he or she is beautiful’ ‘lovely hair’ ‘beautiful eyes’ ‘they’re lovely’ or something like that

OP posts:
Psa4today · 14/05/2022 20:42

DressingGownofDoom · 14/05/2022 20:37

YABU to assume everyone feels the same as you but YANBU in that everyone should learn to keep their traps shut about other peoples appearance.

It doesn’t affect me personally I’m not personally touched by the issue.

it’s just a little reminder that we should reevaluate out throw away comments as you never know, even though the intention is innocent, it could (not definitely will) cause a lot of hurt for that person that day, and I know most wouldn’t actually want to do that

OP posts:
Loginmystery · 14/05/2022 20:42

I totally agree with you op.
it’s not acceptable at all.

Sirzy · 14/05/2022 20:42

When asking for advice of things like car seats then clarifying the weight/height is important to ensure the right advice is given. That’s why most people would start something like that with “my Ds is small for his age and only weighs….” To clarify it.

Psa4today · 14/05/2022 20:40

Sexnotgender · 14/05/2022 20:35

Those comments will never leave that woman.

That feels a little OTT.

My oldest is very small (<0.4th centile) and many many people commented how little she was.
Didn’t bother me in the slightest.

Don’t assume everyone is the same.

But that’s you isn’t it you’re ok with the comments but many aren’t and words matter we should all chose them wisely. You also shouldn’t assume everyone is the same, in my line of (volunteer) work, it’s the #1 thing I here time and time again, it does cause a lot of hurt for just throw away comments.

you don’t know that woman’s journey and how much she’s struggling so I think it’s unfair to say that.

OP posts:
Somuchgoo · 14/05/2022 20:40

Sirzy · 14/05/2022 20:32

I think like most things it depends upon context and intention.

Ds is small for his age. He has been underweight most of his life and is now mainly tube fed. Personally I have never had issue with people commenting that he is small, he is. It’s a fact.

Same! Even down to the tube feeding (though that's due to her already smallish appetite disappearing after major surgery).

She is small, it's a fact.

Pointing and starting, or going on about it is rude though obviously.

tilder · 14/05/2022 20:40

Sexnotgender · 14/05/2022 20:35

Those comments will never leave that woman.

That feels a little OTT.

My oldest is very small (<0.4th centile) and many many people commented how little she was.
Didn’t bother me in the slightest.

Don’t assume everyone is the same.

Might not bother you. How do you know it doesn't bother your child?

IME most people don't comment on overweight children. But small, slight, skinny appears to be fair game.

LoveSpringDaffs · 14/05/2022 20:38

YABU because you feel you can speak for everyone, you can't. Some people are happy to acknowledge how 'diddy' their DC is & agree how gorgeous they are and maybe discuss why they're so diddy or happy to make a jokey comment about nah ndver feed them, am I meant to? How about you do you and leave everyone else to live their own lives??

Swipe left for the next trending thread