Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To comment on a child’s size

132 replies

Psa4today · 14/05/2022 20:27

To ask you honestly if you’d comment on a child’s size, and to ask you to stop

PSA for today.

If you see a child/ toddler or baby you deem to be small, please keep your mouth closed about it. Stop saying to parents ‘oh he or she is tiny’ ‘don’t they eat’ ‘ they’re diddy/ a dot or whatever synonym for small enters your mind. Just don’t do it.

also if you see a child you deem to be too big, don’t comment.

you have NO idea how much your words are hurting parents. You have NO idea why that child so that size and what obstacles they are facing. There are a millions reasons from prematurity, growth restriction, heart conditions, Dwarfism, genetic condition, growth hormone deficiency, rss and severe allergies that make children small and a million more that make them big from thyroid issues to PWS. Every day is a fight for these parents. Don’t make it worse with the need to comment. If you must say something, say ‘they’re lovely’.

i see daily the pain these comments inflict on parents and the children who hear them. if this is you, No excuses, don’t hide behind good intentions. Just stop . All you’re doing in pointing out how different that child looks. Please if this is you, stop

psa over

OP posts:
catmg · 14/05/2022 22:50

"we should reevaluate out throw away comments as you never know, even though the intention is innocent, it could (not definitely will) cause a lot of hurt for that person that day"

I would never intentionally say something to cause hurt or offence, and would be mortified if I unintentionally did so. BUT. if we have to live by your logic nobody's ever going to be able to open their mouths again! The onus is not just on the innocent speaker to think very carefully before making small talk, (am I allowed to say small talk on this subject? ) But also on the recipient to take things in the spirit they are meant! I can't control anyone else's feelings/ reactions.

Psa4today · 14/05/2022 22:50

Roastonsun8 · 14/05/2022 22:28

@Psa4today I think it's you that needs to re read your own posts back. I never told you that I approached anybody child however you are being very dramatic here. I did not tell you I go around commenting on other people's child you have spun your own dramatic narrative WTH. I stated you need to toughen up if a single comment is affecting you for the rest of your life.

Other people are entitled to think differently to yourself OP.

Please read mine… it’s not affecting me. My children are grown up and ‘average’ size.

they are sure, but as it’s widely accepted that it can be hurtful to ask people when and if they are having kids, this is the same.

OP posts:
InChocolateWeTrust · 14/05/2022 22:47

Yanbu.

Voice0fReason · 14/05/2022 22:41

I’m sure she will in time, but she’s on a journey, the beginning of her journey and receipt of a diagnosis. Understandably all she wants/wanted was her child to fit in. She’ll get there. It’s that poem Holland to a T, if you’ve ever read it. It takes time.
Believe me, I know, and I know the poem.
In many ways, I agree that commenting about another child's appearance is generally best avoided.
However, it's a fantasy to believe that it won't happen. So she is the one who needs to deal with this, and not let the comments stay with her for life.

Mulhollandmagoo · 14/05/2022 22:40

I completely agree, I have a preemie!! She's 3 now and still tiny, and people comment all the time, her weight was a huge issue for us when she was a baby, it kept us in hospital, and we were always back and forth to have her weighed and she wasn't gaining any, she was under a dietician for a while, it was such a stressful time for us.

I 100% know it's never meant with any malice, and most people don't know our back story, but it does take me straight back to those days!

custardbear · 14/05/2022 22:38

@Psa4today I do try to educate people about my kids complex issues though, I'm in a research role and have qualifications and experience I guess so get on and do that

Spacemonkey2016 · 14/05/2022 22:30

AlistairCamel · 14/05/2022 21:31

It doesn’t bother me but today my 3 year old came to me sad that she’s ‘little’. She is small for her age and that’s fine but at age 3 all you want is to be a big girl and having someone call you little is upsetting, especially when you can see that you are smaller than others. I realise now she made a comment the other day linking to this as well so it’s playing on her mind.

Same here. My 2 year old DD gets told most days by people how tiny she is, while her brother gets 'oh aren't you so tall?' It's never bothered me, as both statements are true, but she's recently started walking around saying 'I'm big, I'm strong', so I wonder if actually it does affect her slightly.

Roastonsun8 · 14/05/2022 22:28

@Psa4today I think it's you that needs to re read your own posts back. I never told you that I approached anybody child however you are being very dramatic here. I did not tell you I go around commenting on other people's child you have spun your own dramatic narrative WTH. I stated you need to toughen up if a single comment is affecting you for the rest of your life.

Other people are entitled to think differently to yourself OP.

Psa4today · 14/05/2022 22:14

lljkk · 14/05/2022 22:10

just say something neutral, like ‘he or she is beautiful’ ‘lovely hair’ ‘beautiful eyes’ ‘

Except MNers are strongly saying elsewhere in this same thread how RUDE it is to comment about someone's appearance. So it seems that 'beautiful hair' etc. is quite insulting after all.

she wants/wanted was her child to fit in.

That's another myth. Many people don't want their kids to fit in, instead they want their kids to be outstanding, exceptional, competitive, tremendous, etc. Ordinary is not desirable, after all.

ps: nothing was inflicted on me when anyone commented that DC were titchy. It was just opinion, chat.

Well then just say ‘they’re lovely’ keep it neutral.

respectfully you can’t tell me what a woman, you’ve never met has said about her child. It is not a myth it is what she expressed. Also that’s a straw man, you are saying parents want their children to be exceptionally talented but this specific example was about a woman who’s child had a significant genetic condition. So it’s apples and oranges.

it’s wonderful you’ve never been impacted by comments but there are others who have. It really is that simple.

OP posts:
lljkk · 14/05/2022 22:10

just say something neutral, like ‘he or she is beautiful’ ‘lovely hair’ ‘beautiful eyes’ ‘

Except MNers are strongly saying elsewhere in this same thread how RUDE it is to comment about someone's appearance. So it seems that 'beautiful hair' etc. is quite insulting after all.

she wants/wanted was her child to fit in.

That's another myth. Many people don't want their kids to fit in, instead they want their kids to be outstanding, exceptional, competitive, tremendous, etc. Ordinary is not desirable, after all.

ps: nothing was inflicted on me when anyone commented that DC were titchy. It was just opinion, chat.

BellePeppa · 14/05/2022 22:10

I wouldn’t dream of commenting on the height or size of a child. My sister once commented on a teenager’s thinness to their mother (in a ‘jokey’ way) and I was so bloody annoyed but she’s not a mother and has a tendency to not think before opening her mouth.

GarlicGnocchi · 14/05/2022 22:08

Absolutely bothers me. My child will have a lifetime of comments about their appearance, why start so young. And why the constant obsession with their eating habits!

Psa4today · 14/05/2022 22:06

Douzy · 14/05/2022 21:54

100% the vast majority don’t have spiteful intentions but sometimes innocent words hurt

That's kind of my view too. I remember as a kid being told 'she has such big strong muscles' and 'look at that huge smile/all those lovely teeth' - both complimentary, apparently, but I wore long sleeves and tried to close my mouth when I smiled for years.

It wasn't a biggie in the great scheme, but I'm mindful more about the child's perception of a comment, than the parent, to be honest.

yeah you’re right, kids take on so much. it just seems the way that the comments seem to be directed at the parents when the child is there. Bizarre.

parents too for babies and toddlers I’d say. Worked with one lady who’s child had CDL and someone said to her oh they’re tiny what’s wrong with them… baby was a few months, diagnosis came at birth and it was one of the first outings post NICU. Mum cried and didn’t leave the house for weeks. I’m sure that person didn’t mean harm, but hurt was caused.

OP posts:
Psa4today · 14/05/2022 22:01

Roastonsun8 · 14/05/2022 21:53

To be Frank. People have asked me and they do still whilst I can see your view point it's not 3rd world problems. You are projecting and if your taking it as far as someones comment will affect you for the rest of your life... you need to toughen up because parenthood is tough and you will recieve a lot of feedback from people it's life. I wouldn't take it to heart unless I thought someone was deliberately being mean. I think you have failed to miss this side of your own argument.

Please read my posts, this doesn’t affect me. My kids are very ‘average’ size wise, no comments either way really so I don’t need to ‘toughen up’ thanks.

that’s great that you wouldn’t but don’t judge others until you’ve walked a mile in their shoes, there are a lot of parents who’ve kids have complex medical conditions like RSS that it does impact, it impacts the kids too. No one wants to be made to feel like they done fit in.

words matter we should all chose them wisely. If you wish to continue saying ‘oh they’re so small’ when you know it could (not will) hurt someone then ok.., personally I wouldn’t.

OP posts:
Flopisfatteningbingforchristmas · 14/05/2022 21:59

My oldest was on 99.8 centile for length, she dropped when height was measured at 2 (apparently quite common). It’s never been an issue for me or for her. She is tall and perfectly healthy. A comment doesn’t bother us. I would rather people knew than people having unreasonable expectations of her behaviour and ability based on her height rather than age.

Douzy · 14/05/2022 21:54

100% the vast majority don’t have spiteful intentions but sometimes innocent words hurt

That's kind of my view too. I remember as a kid being told 'she has such big strong muscles' and 'look at that huge smile/all those lovely teeth' - both complimentary, apparently, but I wore long sleeves and tried to close my mouth when I smiled for years.

It wasn't a biggie in the great scheme, but I'm mindful more about the child's perception of a comment, than the parent, to be honest.

Roastonsun8 · 14/05/2022 21:53

To be Frank. People have asked me and they do still whilst I can see your view point it's not 3rd world problems. You are projecting and if your taking it as far as someones comment will affect you for the rest of your life... you need to toughen up because parenthood is tough and you will recieve a lot of feedback from people it's life. I wouldn't take it to heart unless I thought someone was deliberately being mean. I think you have failed to miss this side of your own argument.

Psa4today · 14/05/2022 21:50

AllyCatTown · 14/05/2022 21:45

I think quite often people are just trying to make conversation- all be it sometimes in a clumsy way. I do try to avoid things that might offend others but it can sometimes be hard to know what others might be sensitive about. If they don’t think of small or big as bad things they might not realise it could be taken as an insult.

100% the vast majority don’t have spiteful intentions but sometimes innocent words hurt.

if anyone is in doubt, please have a look on growth restriction forums and you’ll see countless comments of innocent comments inflicting hurt.

OP posts:
Douzy · 14/05/2022 21:49

I think I have a general view that I don't want strangers commenting about my height/build/whatever, so unless prodded for a viewpoint, I don't comment about a child's appearance either. Other than 'cool tee shirt' or something naff and cheesy like that Grin

Psa4today · 14/05/2022 21:48

Roastonsun8 · 14/05/2022 21:47

I this is more of your own personal issue and your over projecting onto others. In life you have to have a thicker skin sometimes. You can't take every little comment to heart its someone's intention unless a person is being malicious of course that's a different matter.

except it’s not. Would you say the same about the ‘when are you having children’ question? That’s always viewed as MN no no… honestly this is no different.

OP posts:
Roastonsun8 · 14/05/2022 21:47

I this is more of your own personal issue and your over projecting onto others. In life you have to have a thicker skin sometimes. You can't take every little comment to heart its someone's intention unless a person is being malicious of course that's a different matter.

AllyCatTown · 14/05/2022 21:45

I think quite often people are just trying to make conversation- all be it sometimes in a clumsy way. I do try to avoid things that might offend others but it can sometimes be hard to know what others might be sensitive about. If they don’t think of small or big as bad things they might not realise it could be taken as an insult.

Psa4today · 14/05/2022 21:42

Voice0fReason · 14/05/2022 21:38

Those comments will never leave that woman.
I speak as someone who has always looked different, always stood out and had comments about how I look.
That woman needs to learn to deal with the comments. She is not doing herself or her child any favours by getting so upset by what are probably mostly, well-meaning, if insensitive comments. I also know only too well, how rude some people can be.
I am glad my mum wasn't so fragile. She modelled to me how to deal with the comments.

I’m sure she will in time, but she’s on a journey, the beginning of her journey and receipt of a diagnosis. Understandably all she wants/wanted was her child to fit in. She’ll get there. It’s that poem Holland to a T, if you’ve ever read it. It takes time.

OP posts:
Psa4today · 14/05/2022 21:39

custardbear · 14/05/2022 21:32

I suspect most people really don't give a hoot, often it's something to make light conversation about. Maybe enlighten them about birth size, genetics etc and make an intelligent conversation out if it if you've the information, if they're not interested hopefully they won't ask
Again 🤐😁

That’s my point, most don’t but some do.

it’s not the job of parents of children who have complex health issues to educate bystanders on a regular basis, can you imagine how exhausting that would be.

i think PPs who think it’s acceptable even when posters have said, yes this hurts me, need to reflect on WHY they need to comment. It’s not acceptable to comment on an adults body, why are we so comfortable commenting on a child’s.

OP posts:
Voice0fReason · 14/05/2022 21:38

Those comments will never leave that woman.
I speak as someone who has always looked different, always stood out and had comments about how I look.
That woman needs to learn to deal with the comments. She is not doing herself or her child any favours by getting so upset by what are probably mostly, well-meaning, if insensitive comments. I also know only too well, how rude some people can be.
I am glad my mum wasn't so fragile. She modelled to me how to deal with the comments.

Swipe left for the next trending thread