Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To comment on a child’s size

132 replies

Psa4today · 14/05/2022 20:27

To ask you honestly if you’d comment on a child’s size, and to ask you to stop

PSA for today.

If you see a child/ toddler or baby you deem to be small, please keep your mouth closed about it. Stop saying to parents ‘oh he or she is tiny’ ‘don’t they eat’ ‘ they’re diddy/ a dot or whatever synonym for small enters your mind. Just don’t do it.

also if you see a child you deem to be too big, don’t comment.

you have NO idea how much your words are hurting parents. You have NO idea why that child so that size and what obstacles they are facing. There are a millions reasons from prematurity, growth restriction, heart conditions, Dwarfism, genetic condition, growth hormone deficiency, rss and severe allergies that make children small and a million more that make them big from thyroid issues to PWS. Every day is a fight for these parents. Don’t make it worse with the need to comment. If you must say something, say ‘they’re lovely’.

i see daily the pain these comments inflict on parents and the children who hear them. if this is you, No excuses, don’t hide behind good intentions. Just stop . All you’re doing in pointing out how different that child looks. Please if this is you, stop

psa over

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EmpressaurusWitchDoesntBurn · 16/05/2022 16:47

If an adult made a personal remark about a child's height - "Ooh, aren't you tiny!" and the child, sick of comments about their height, responded with "Ooh, aren't you fat!" - knowing exactly what they were saying - would the child be expected to apologise or could it be viewed as tit for tat?

ShitHair · 16/05/2022 16:00

Voice0fReason · 15/05/2022 21:01

Because of ransoms always asking me how old my daughter is I now lie and say she 2 instead of 3. That's my way of coping with it, but it shouldn't have to be.
You might want to consider the effect on your daughter to hear you say that.

Don't worry. I don't do it when she's in ear shot. This is usually in the park when she's running around away from me.

Thanks for only picking that part of my post out to respond to though 🤦‍♀️

Sirzy · 16/05/2022 07:27

No matter what children will pick up on differences and how they differ to their peers. If parents make a big thing about their height or whatever else then that is what will rub off on the child most.

you can’t control what other people say and do, you can control how you respond to things though. Don’t let your child pick up on negative emotions.

lljkk · 16/05/2022 07:07

you never know when you may unintentionally cause upset

Ah well, there's this true story. Shows that simply commenting on clothing turns out to be "unacceptable comments on appearance" too. And maybe commenting on behaviour too. I don't know if I caused upset either, tbh, the parents had a 'reputation' for being thick-skinned, anyway.

We were very new to town/school on day DC1 started reception. At time, DD was a quite short for age, almost 3yo. A boy in the playground was in school playground & obviously shorter than DD. He was quite exhuberant, with body language that fit 2-3yo. I said something to DD about how cute it was that he had dressed up to match outfit of an older sibling starting school.

Turns out tiny boy was 4yo & starting school. Parent gossip (small town) was that there was no known reason for the lad's short stature, he just seemed to be on a different growth curve than others. Left school in yr3 or yr4, I sometimes wonder how his height turned out.

Voice0fReason · 15/05/2022 21:13

MN is full of rants and hills to die on. This is mine. That is a primary focus, counselling, especially for parents of children who have life altering genetic conditions.

But it's not your hill is it. You are talking on behalf of other parents. You don't live it. This approach, commendable in intent, isn't the most supportive to help these parents.
It is generally better if people keep their comments about other people's children's appearance to themselves, however, in no reality is that ever going to happen. So those parents need to develop responses to people who do make comments.

Voice0fReason · 15/05/2022 21:01

Because of ransoms always asking me how old my daughter is I now lie and say she 2 instead of 3. That's my way of coping with it, but it shouldn't have to be.
You might want to consider the effect on your daughter to hear you say that.

PaddlingLikeADuck · 15/05/2022 17:11

As a mother of a small 4 year old boy I understand.

Someone asked me if he was 2 the other day followed by”Oh he’s small isn’t he?!”

I laughed it off on the outside but I just wanted to cry on the inside 😢

LookingGlassMilk · 15/05/2022 17:08

My kids are all small and I used to get so many comments about it. My youngest two are particularly small. They were both right at the bottom of the percentile charts when they were toddlers. I got lots of comments about both of them but I got more about my ds than my dd, because I think it's more socially acceptable to be a tiny little girl than a tiny little boy.

All my kids started off at a normal size, they were huge big chubby babies, but then at around 6-9 months old their growth slowed right down, and didn't start up properly again until they were around 2. Ds2 was investigated for it and they said it was a constitutional delay.

The comments aren't as common now that they're older. Ds is 11 now and most people know better than to comment on how small he is in front of him.

I did find it quite annoying at the time. I wasn't offended, but hearing it all the time got a bit wearing. I think I would have found it much more difficult if I was also trying to come to terms with a more serious diagnosis than constitutional delay, such as a genetic condition.

Psa4today · 15/05/2022 14:26

Giraffesandbottoms · 15/05/2022 13:30

@Flopisfatteningbingforchristmas

they don’t even seem to have a HV team, it’s all very concerning. Could try to find out who their gp is but not sure how to do that and I’m convinced the mother had very bad postpartum psychosis and during an episode of rage/refusing to feed the baby/hiding with the baby in a room her husband called the GP to get help. He called back later and the mother said she was fine. End of discussions 0 help given. Tbh was very eye opening about the total lack of support in this area where mothers need mental health support and it can be dangerous for the children but no one is there to assist.

Could you call social services? That might seem like an appropriate next step in this instance, especially as mum seems to be struggling

OP posts:
threecupsofteaminimum · 15/05/2022 14:10

sorry to say but you don’t seem very nice. Posters have said, even if you don’t agree, that they’ve had these comments and it’s negatively impacted them or their child, that in itself should be enough of a reason to reconsider commenting on a child’s size.

Obviously you don't know me and you're wrong.

A good parent protects their children from nasty stuff when they're children, it seems as if you're doing the exact opposite. If you don't like constructive criticism then you're on the wrong forum, it isn't an echo chamber of agreement. You're having issues and some of us are making suggestions on how to stop that. If you don't like it maybe have an inward look at why.

Giraffesandbottoms · 15/05/2022 13:30

@Flopisfatteningbingforchristmas

they don’t even seem to have a HV team, it’s all very concerning. Could try to find out who their gp is but not sure how to do that and I’m convinced the mother had very bad postpartum psychosis and during an episode of rage/refusing to feed the baby/hiding with the baby in a room her husband called the GP to get help. He called back later and the mother said she was fine. End of discussions 0 help given. Tbh was very eye opening about the total lack of support in this area where mothers need mental health support and it can be dangerous for the children but no one is there to assist.

Psa4today · 15/05/2022 11:38

Imaginary · 15/05/2022 10:57

YABU because you think you can just tell people what they should do without giving more details about why.
Also it's common courtesy to expand acronyms you are using, because not everyone is familiar with them (CDL? RSS?).

russell silver syndrome and Cornelia de Lange syndrome a quick google will tell you why comments on kids with these conditions to name a few would hurt

OP posts:
zingally · 15/05/2022 10:58

Aged maybe 8 or 9, I went swimming with my then-best friend and her mum. Afterwards, we were in the showers by the pool, just rinsing off, when the mum comes over to me, pats me on the stomach and says, "got a bit of a belly there!"

Who does that to a 9 year old?! I've remembered it for nearly 30 years, and do think that was the start of my self-consciousness over my belly (I have a bit of an over-hang over the top of my belly button, and have since childhood).

What was ironic, her daughter - my friend - was always a large chunk chubbier than I ever was.

Adults can be awful. I suspect she forgot the comment within 5 minutes of making it. But for me it was the start of 30 years of self-consciousness.

Imaginary · 15/05/2022 10:57

YABU because you think you can just tell people what they should do without giving more details about why.
Also it's common courtesy to expand acronyms you are using, because not everyone is familiar with them (CDL? RSS?).

EmpressaurusWitchDoesntBurn · 15/05/2022 10:37

I’m short & always looked younger than I was as a kid. While it doesn’t bother me now, I hated people commenting on my height back then.

I wanted to answer adult comments like “Aren’t you little?” with responses like “Aren’t you fat?” or “Don’t you have a big nose?” but knew that would get me into shit so had to put up with glaring at them.

Flopisfatteningbingforchristmas · 15/05/2022 10:34

Giraffesandbottoms · 15/05/2022 10:07

@Flopisfatteningbingforchristmas

yes, the baby is related to me and it’s an extremely upsetting situation. He is very behind developmentally and they take 0 action and it’s very hard not to say anything because it doesn’t seem like the parents care/notice.

That is a very difficult situation. I would consider leaving an anonymous message of concern with the HV team.

Psa4today · 15/05/2022 10:29

Giraffesandbottoms · 15/05/2022 10:07

@Flopisfatteningbingforchristmas

yes, the baby is related to me and it’s an extremely upsetting situation. He is very behind developmentally and they take 0 action and it’s very hard not to say anything because it doesn’t seem like the parents care/notice.

From what you’ve said, this does seem like a different situation, teetering into neglect and a safe guarding issue and you were a trusted friend sharing a welfare concern, id say that’s different, akin to if you’d noticed someone’s teen may well be dealing with anorexia so you mention some concerns to the parent- still wouldn’t agree with saying it in front of the teen though.

OP posts:
Psa4today · 15/05/2022 10:26

threecupsofteaminimum · 15/05/2022 10:23

Perhaps then you are blessed. Some people do have to care about their children size for a variety of different reasons.

I am blessed in that I adore my DS and all his quirks and I won't go into detail as it's none of,your business. Perhaps you could try to inject some good nature into your demeanour by smiling and ignoring these 'constant remarks' if they indeed are that you're so concerned with. I find it hard to believe personally, I think you're being totally over sensitive and creating a big issue in your mind which doesn't exist or matter.

last time it doesn’t affect me but it does some.

sorry to say but you don’t seem very nice. Posters have said, even if you don’t agree, that they’ve had these comments and it’s negatively impacted them or their child, that in itself should be enough of a reason to reconsider commenting on a child’s size.

OP posts:
threecupsofteaminimum · 15/05/2022 10:23

Either that or adjust your diet.

threecupsofteaminimum · 15/05/2022 10:23

Perhaps then you are blessed. Some people do have to care about their children size for a variety of different reasons.

I am blessed in that I adore my DS and all his quirks and I won't go into detail as it's none of,your business. Perhaps you could try to inject some good nature into your demeanour by smiling and ignoring these 'constant remarks' if they indeed are that you're so concerned with. I find it hard to believe personally, I think you're being totally over sensitive and creating a big issue in your mind which doesn't exist or matter.

BungleandGeorge · 15/05/2022 10:23

I understand what you’re saying but more worried about the effect on the children tbh. Hearing multiple times a day how short/tall/thin/fat or whatever they are is setting them up for body issues. They’re absolutely bombarded with it now through society and the internet as it is

HangingOver · 15/05/2022 10:11

Oh dear. I'm pretty sure I've said something like, "oh bless, he's so weeny!" about every single newborn I've ever held. Not because the baby was small because babies are small. I don't have kids so they all looks small to me!

Giraffesandbottoms · 15/05/2022 10:07

@Flopisfatteningbingforchristmas

yes, the baby is related to me and it’s an extremely upsetting situation. He is very behind developmentally and they take 0 action and it’s very hard not to say anything because it doesn’t seem like the parents care/notice.

Flopisfatteningbingforchristmas · 15/05/2022 10:00

Giraffesandbottoms · 15/05/2022 09:19

I know 2 people whose babies had serious failure to thrive and the parents were borderline negligent/in denial about it. One of the mothers, when her child was 3 and still under the 3% said she was relieved to see her daughter hadn’t jumped up %. Yeh I did make comments because I do know the ins and outs of the situation and they haven’t bothered seeing a paedatrician or anything else (I can’t speak to her anymore as her parenting is just so upsetting to witness). Funnily enough the other one’s (related to me) baby is now massively overweight since stopping breastfeeding as clearly it wasn’t working and her baby was skeletal until started solid food. I tried many, many times to help by explaining you’re not supposed to BF every 4 hours it’s on demand and they misunderstood what the hospital was saying, whilst watching them trying to comfort a screaming newborn in other ways before feeding them (baby born at 7lbs dropped off the scale they didn’t see a HV once).

it isn’t always appropriate to say nothing. Some parents are just irresponsible.

If her baby is overweight that is a massive issue too.

Giraffesandbottoms · 15/05/2022 09:19

I know 2 people whose babies had serious failure to thrive and the parents were borderline negligent/in denial about it. One of the mothers, when her child was 3 and still under the 3% said she was relieved to see her daughter hadn’t jumped up %. Yeh I did make comments because I do know the ins and outs of the situation and they haven’t bothered seeing a paedatrician or anything else (I can’t speak to her anymore as her parenting is just so upsetting to witness). Funnily enough the other one’s (related to me) baby is now massively overweight since stopping breastfeeding as clearly it wasn’t working and her baby was skeletal until started solid food. I tried many, many times to help by explaining you’re not supposed to BF every 4 hours it’s on demand and they misunderstood what the hospital was saying, whilst watching them trying to comfort a screaming newborn in other ways before feeding them (baby born at 7lbs dropped off the scale they didn’t see a HV once).

it isn’t always appropriate to say nothing. Some parents are just irresponsible.