Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I invite her?

65 replies

Fitmumtiredmum · 14/05/2022 20:16

Our sister in law has deleted us from allsocial media and has stopped responding to any of our messages. She hasn’t met her new nephew who is 6months old and hasn’t seen her niece for a year.

She won’t tell us why. Her husband said he wants to meet up with my husband (they are brothers) to talk about it as it’s “really complicated”, long story short my husband works odd shifts and they haven’t been able to arrange a time. I don’t know why he can’t call him or text about it?

Basically, I now don’t want to go to a family friends wedding as it will be very awkward.
I am also planning our sons christening, her husband is my daughters godparent but I don’t even want to invite her along to my sons christening now. I bought Easter eggs and a Xmas present and pretended they were from them for my daughter.

Am I being unreasonable to only invite my husbands brother and not his wife to our babies christening and how would you deal with this long term?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
whynotwhatknot · 15/05/2022 20:55

seems a very odd thing to contact his ex and stir things-idont see how going on holiday shoudl equate to paying more cms unless hes underpaying

SunshineAndFizz · 15/05/2022 18:51

Wait for the husbands to meet and find out the full story. Then make your decision. Only way - could be anything.

Poppymonty3 · 15/05/2022 18:40

Ring the brother and straight up ask him on the phone why she blocked you.

I would not invite her, she clearly doesn't want anything to do with you so don't waste your time on her. Don't chase people

TabithaTittlemouse · 15/05/2022 18:36

You want to punish her but don’t know that she is gone no contact out of spite or if something is wrong.

I think it would be really rude to not at least put her name on the invite even if you know that she won’t come.

watchingrnfire · 15/05/2022 18:29

If she's screenshotting your socials to
Your dh ex partner. I would immediately block sil so she ain't able to see any of your posts and can't stir anything

Fitmumtiredmum · 15/05/2022 08:46

No she only met his daughters mum once years ago but does follow her on social media.

She’s distanced herself for about a year, never comes over it’s always just her husband when we do arrange a meet up. The only message she responded to was about her dog that died a couple of months ago. It was after this that she randomly deleted us both from social media.

We’ve never had a fall out or bad words in the 9years we have known each other and always got on well. She was miserable at our wedding in Aug 2020 and ended up leaving early. We bought her a lovely gift for her 40th last year but didn’t get invited to celebrate it with them when others did.

OP posts:
StageRage · 15/05/2022 08:30

So she has replied to you recently.

Look, most of us said your DH needs to make the effort to MEET his brother. They can meet half way. Meet for breakfast. In the middle of the night on a Sunday, or whatever. It would be really unfair to start ‘retaliating’ by not inviting her to things before you know what is going on.

Was she close with your DH’s ex?

knockyknees · 15/05/2022 08:30

In light of your latest update I would not invite SIL (and by extension BIL most likely as well). She's blocked you, won't respond to any communication, and seems to be deliberately causing trouble with extended family members. If someone is so determined to cut all contact with you, them like hell would I keep trying to invite them to things, or maintain a relationship.

If BIL is so determined to have a discussion, then he needs to facilitate it, by either phoning his brother or rearranging his (work) schedule to meet his brother. IMO your DH doesn't have to go out of his way to do anything as he's not the one causing the problem.

Fitmumtiredmum · 15/05/2022 08:19

Thank you everyone, we do live an hours drive away from them and both the brothers work completely opposite times but I agree a phone call should have happened. It’s his brother who won’t call and is adamant they meet to discuss it.

SIL already has a son of her own (he’s 13) from a previous relationship and they have said they have never wanted another child together. She has 2 French bull dogs and sadly lost one a couple of months ago. We sent a condolence card at the time and I text her, she did reply to that message.

One thing happened is that SIL has also been stirring things with my husbands daughters mum. Which is really odd as they have only ever met once! Husbands daughter lives a 5hr drive away. SIL told her that we are going on holiday and sent her a screenshot of my fb post looking for recommendations, and so she is now wanting more cms money. Again, we messaged her about this (not in an argumentative way) and she just ignored it.

I think inviting her is probably the best thing to do

OP posts:
Pompom2367 · 15/05/2022 07:58

Your husband and his brother need to meet before deciding the

R41NB0W2022 · 15/05/2022 07:52

I too would suggest they’re having fertility struggles.

I have recently been through fertility struggles (currently pregnant thankfully), but I can tell you that it has been the toughest experience I’ve ever been through.

I acted similarly to your SIL. I came off social media to avoid seeing pictures of babies as it was so painful. I removed WhatsApp so I could stop getting hundreds of pictures or invites to multiple baby showers. I also avoided much contact with my friends or family, because I was having hospital treatment and I was in mental survival mode. I begged my husband not to tell anyone as when I did see people I didn’t want them to constantly talk about it and I certainly didn’t want to hear their unsolicited advice, ‘Have you tried…’
Some people might not understand that way of coping but equally I’m trying to point out that for others it’s the only way to survive - to focus on your own journey, avoid triggers and keep waking up each day. Some people might also read my message and think it’s selfish to not allow my husband to talk to anyone but I did say to him multiple times that if he was struggling then he could. However, it is different for the woman as it’s her body. My husband just went off to work, socialised on the weekend, not much in his routine life changed. Whereas I had to have appointments, time in hospital etc. so please consider why your SIL is so absent and only your BIL is talking.

We recently told our friends and families about our pregnancy and I explained the journey we had been on and apologised for missing out on events. Thankfully no one was annoyed at us and they all understood that I made the decisions for my mental health.

Some are suggesting that your husband talks to your BIL - I think this should be done without pressure, ensure that they know you are both there and no matter what they’re going through, you’ll both still be there for both of them.

As for the events, I think you should attend the wedding - the SIL will most likely cancel. The christening - again she will most likely cancel.

girlmom21 · 15/05/2022 07:19

Your husband needs to go and see his brother. Don't exclude her.

TidyDancer · 15/05/2022 07:13

The obvious answer to this is as others have already pointed out, she's struggling with infertility and she doesn't want to be around you because of the DCs. It could be something else, but that jumps out at me. If this is the case, it's completely understandable and you do need to be sensitive and tolerant of however long it takes her. No confrontation.

Are you the types to post everything on Facebook, loads of baby photos and updates? If so, that would explain why she's deleted you.

SD1978 · 15/05/2022 07:05

Your husband could put a bit more effort in to meet up- the shift work is an excuse. Not a reason. There is something obviously up, your husband needs to prioritise finding out, then you'll know what the deal is at family events.

UnsuitableHat · 15/05/2022 06:56

Agree about being the bigger person, but not sure about inviting her to things as if nothing’s happened when she’s blocked/ignored you without explanation. When we treat other people as if they don’t exist or don’t matter, whatever our reasons, there are consequences. However try to find the course of action least painful to you. It’s a shame your DH and his brother haven’t found time for that conversation.

redfairy · 15/05/2022 06:55

Do you want to make things better or worse? What will not inviting her to the Christening acheive towards that? And get those brothers talking.

Jurassicparkinajug · 15/05/2022 06:45

I agree with what the others have said, your dh needs to prioritise that meeting now before the wedding and stop making excuses. You have no idea what's happened, one of you may have said something very offensive unknowingly or it might be mental health issues and they need your support. Don't avoid them or not invite them as this could fuel things and cause an even bigger risk. Make the effort to find out what it is first. You can always find time for something important like this. Do it straight away.

threecupsofteaminimum · 15/05/2022 00:14

I think the penny's dropped re, the OP non return.

I thought the exact same thing, she could have mc'd or other fertility related stuff going on.

Mellowyellow222 · 14/05/2022 23:42

She is behaving badly. There might be a good reason, there might not. It doesn’t sound like it is anything you have done or said.

stay calm, take the high road, keep inviting her to things.

unless they divorce, she will alway be in your family. Best to keep things as civil as possible

Mrsteapot42 · 14/05/2022 23:40

I'm someone who wouldn't notice if someone wasn't following me on social media. I also don't understand why you needed to pretend to buy a present off them for your kids. You've immediately jumped to the conclusion of not inviting her. All makes you sound a bit of a drama llama.

She could have left your BIL for all you know.

Kite22 · 14/05/2022 23:31

NeedAHoliday2021 · 14/05/2022 22:14

I would be truly concerned if my db called and said that. I cannot imagine not prioritising that conversation and making time for my db. It suggests it’s not personal but perhaps something db needs support with imo.

This 100%

I'm not especially close to either of my siblings, but if I had a message like that, I would totally prioritise making time to see them.

HollowTalk · 14/05/2022 23:27

The two men clearly need a conversation. It sounds like your brother-in-law wants that and your husband keeps putting it off. Until that happens this won't be resolved.

PurpleDaisies · 14/05/2022 23:07

Not inviting her will just make it more awkward, not less.

watchingrnfire · 14/05/2022 23:07

Seems like she won't come even if you do invite her. So just invite both of them, why give her a reason by purposely excluding her which will then mean her husband won't turn up either.

Tell your dh to call his brother n speak if they can't arrange a date

Nanny0gg · 14/05/2022 22:59

Why hasn't your husband made the time to meet his brother?

Swipe left for the next trending thread