Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask for your experience of toxic Asian in laws?

40 replies

user0512 · 14/05/2022 19:20

AIBU to ask for your experience of toxic Asian in laws?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Newhome121 · 16/05/2022 14:16

Rubyupbeat · 16/05/2022 11:11

A bengali lady I worked with, highly educated, got married at 28, which was regarded as old, her husband seemed lovely at first, until her wages were made unavailable to her (joint account) then the in laws moved in and the fil started beating her, with the mil cheering him on, her husband did nothing! She was worried about leaving as her own mother was a widow, so had low standing in the community. In the end she left and moved to another European country taking her mum. Latest I've heard, she has got her doctorate and she has remarried and is actually very happy, just had twins.
I mainly worked with Bengali colleagues, and they were in happy marriages, with educated partners like themselves, hopefully breaking the abusive cycle for their own children.

That’s really lovely to hear. There definitely needs to be more stories of Asians who managed to break the cycle.

user0512 · 16/05/2022 13:47

Weefreetiffany · 16/05/2022 13:39

I’d be concerned that once you’ve cleared your debt they will expect you to contribute more to them, which will stop you being able to save to move out and get independence from them. Please be aware it could happen and protect yourself.

This is exactly what was happening. His parents were expecting £600 from us a month (to clear her debt but masked as 'helping' when all she'd do is go out and eat out with his sisters)

OP posts:
Weefreetiffany · 16/05/2022 13:39

I’d be concerned that once you’ve cleared your debt they will expect you to contribute more to them, which will stop you being able to save to move out and get independence from them. Please be aware it could happen and protect yourself.

Classicblunder · 16/05/2022 13:12

In answer to your question though - sadly it is an issue in Asian families to treat DILs this way but it's absolutely not the case in every Asian family. I know women who are genuinely cherished and adored by their parents in law and who enjoy living with them.

Classicblunder · 16/05/2022 13:07

When you say saving to move out, is that really necessary? Can you move out to a room in a shared house? Can you borrow from your parents to get a rental deposit?

user0512 · 16/05/2022 12:30

Lokiju · 16/05/2022 12:28

He's not a good man or husband to let you be treated this way by his family. Cloaking control under 'culture' is not okay. The debt you're clearing - is that his debt or yours?

I couldn't live in such an abusive, toxic atmosphere - I hope you can consider other options, OP.

It's mine. And he is helping clear it.

It's not him that tried to control my finances. It's his parents

OP posts:
Lokiju · 16/05/2022 12:28

He's not a good man or husband to let you be treated this way by his family. Cloaking control under 'culture' is not okay. The debt you're clearing - is that his debt or yours?

I couldn't live in such an abusive, toxic atmosphere - I hope you can consider other options, OP.

user0512 · 16/05/2022 12:08

I don't feel like I need to end my marriage as such, as the relationship I have with my husband is a good one.

The only issues we have stem from the in laws.

We're saving to move out (have had to clear some previous debt off so haven't been able to save until now)

I didn't think it would be like this as a very modern and up-to-date image was portrayed prior to marriage.

I feel like I'm just expected to serve and that's all. I'm not sure if it's normal for Asian in laws to disregard an unwell daughter in law?

They've tried to control my finances but I stood my ground. I feel like as I said, I'm meant to serve. Just constantly giving and that's all.

OP posts:
Classicblunder · 16/05/2022 11:18

Classicblunder · 16/05/2022 10:59

I have only second hand experience of this but that suggests it will only get worse. The only way to fix it is to leave. You can't live with these people and you won't long term so leave right now.

By this I mean leave the ILs, not necessarily your husband if he will leave with you. It sounds like he does get it on some level.

Rubyupbeat · 16/05/2022 11:11

A bengali lady I worked with, highly educated, got married at 28, which was regarded as old, her husband seemed lovely at first, until her wages were made unavailable to her (joint account) then the in laws moved in and the fil started beating her, with the mil cheering him on, her husband did nothing! She was worried about leaving as her own mother was a widow, so had low standing in the community. In the end she left and moved to another European country taking her mum. Latest I've heard, she has got her doctorate and she has remarried and is actually very happy, just had twins.
I mainly worked with Bengali colleagues, and they were in happy marriages, with educated partners like themselves, hopefully breaking the abusive cycle for their own children.

FabFitFifties · 16/05/2022 11:07

Please have extremely serious talk to your husband OP. He needs to put you and your marriage first - that means moving out. I can't see you ever being happy in their home, whether you stick up for yourself or not. The damage is surely done. If my husband would not move out, I would like to think I would leave and make my own life. I'm not Asian and I haven't lived with horrible in laws, but I recognise domestic abuse. Not all abusers are partners and not all abuse is physical. 💐

Fere · 16/05/2022 11:03

Do you have to live with them? I assume that is happening because how else would they know that your husband is helping you.

Classicblunder · 16/05/2022 10:59

I have only second hand experience of this but that suggests it will only get worse. The only way to fix it is to leave. You can't live with these people and you won't long term so leave right now.

Soffana · 16/05/2022 10:53

This sounds horrible. Do you live with them?

Sunshinelove111 · 16/05/2022 10:50

Awful. Check out myavaas on instAgram . You need to move out ASAP and don’t worry about trying to impress them, protect your mental health and marriage as even when you move out it’s hard moving on completely from their nastiness or emotional abuse. Have boundaries and be unapologetic about it - being respected is better than being liked. If they’re asking for extra financial contributions, maybe consider renting.

cottagegardenflower · 16/05/2022 10:39

Was it an arranged marriage, and do you live all under the same roof? If so I would push to have your own home or look about leaving. Your husband shouldn't allow you to be bullied

Newhome121 · 16/05/2022 10:21

It sounds awful. My advice is be a bitch to them! Seriously they already seem annoyed so what harm could it do?

i have to go and take little one out now but feel free to keep posting on here how you feel and it does really help. You have to accept they won’t like you - nothing you have done it’s just jealously seeing their brother /son taking care of his wife.

Chat later and hope you feel better x

user0512 · 16/05/2022 10:18

Newhome121 · 16/05/2022 10:14

I wish I had been stronger in the early days and questioned all her bullshit. Like DH wasn’t allowed to make me tea, I had to “serve” him before I poured my own dinner and she would keep commenting on my breasts and bum being too big! I was a skinny size 6 then. I really hate all of them.

Funny thing is she always tells me I’m the only DIL who is like this and others respect, love and do whatever the MIL demands. Thank god for the internet or I would actually believe her that I’m the trouble maker.

Gosh, it sounds like you lived in my shoes. I fractured my foot a bit at work on Friday and all of his family have a face on because he's made me food and tea whilst they've COMPLETELY ignored me. Not even once asked if I want something or if I'm okay. Yet when my sister in laws have been unwell I've literally been a nurse to them. When my MIL's mum died I even massaged her feet for her. I feel like I've done this to myself, because I've been 'too nice' from the start and they've taken advantage of this.

They've all got a face on because they're having to do the chores around the house and she's having to cook everyday. I've always done my part and more, but my foot hurts and I physically cannot do it.

I've got no friends (I moved from down south to up north when I got married) and it's been so lonely.

OP posts:
Newhome121 · 16/05/2022 10:14

I wish I had been stronger in the early days and questioned all her bullshit. Like DH wasn’t allowed to make me tea, I had to “serve” him before I poured my own dinner and she would keep commenting on my breasts and bum being too big! I was a skinny size 6 then. I really hate all of them.

Funny thing is she always tells me I’m the only DIL who is like this and others respect, love and do whatever the MIL demands. Thank god for the internet or I would actually believe her that I’m the trouble maker.

user0512 · 16/05/2022 10:12

Newhome121 · 16/05/2022 10:10

I’ve been married for 10 years. We’re Indians.

I'm Indian and my in laws are Pakistani. They're quite old-school in their thinking. But like your in laws, they tried to paint a 'we're very modern and accepting' image. Far from it to be honest.

How did you manage to make your marriage work despite all of this?

OP posts:
Newhome121 · 16/05/2022 10:10

I’ve been married for 10 years. We’re Indians.

user0512 · 16/05/2022 10:08

Newhome121 · 16/05/2022 10:06

I absolutely hate my Inlaws. They also made it sound like they were very modern abs made my parents feel like they were backwards. In truth my Inlaws are the “backwards”. On the outside they look wonderful: both their daughters married outside their culture so have freedom and my Inlaws think they’re amazing. Myself and DH are controlled so much. We lived with them for first year of marriage and I’m not exaggerating but she literally stopped me making tea and food. She would stare at me and frown. She tried to get DH and be divorced and told me I have to leave my child with her! I told her to F off!

she is a completely horrible woman. I only get through the tough times by thinking she will die one day. I absolutely hate her she has caused nothing but misery in my marriage and life. They always make me out to be the disrespectful DIL because I’ve stopped putting up with their crap. Their own daughters don’t put up with abutting so why should I be?

That sound awful. The first year of marriage is hard enough as it is, without adding all of this to the mix! What ethnicity or culture are you from if you don't mind me asking? X

OP posts:
Newhome121 · 16/05/2022 10:06

I absolutely hate my Inlaws. They also made it sound like they were very modern abs made my parents feel like they were backwards. In truth my Inlaws are the “backwards”. On the outside they look wonderful: both their daughters married outside their culture so have freedom and my Inlaws think they’re amazing. Myself and DH are controlled so much. We lived with them for first year of marriage and I’m not exaggerating but she literally stopped me making tea and food. She would stare at me and frown. She tried to get DH and be divorced and told me I have to leave my child with her! I told her to F off!

she is a completely horrible woman. I only get through the tough times by thinking she will die one day. I absolutely hate her she has caused nothing but misery in my marriage and life. They always make me out to be the disrespectful DIL because I’ve stopped putting up with their crap. Their own daughters don’t put up with abutting so why should I be?

user0512 · 16/05/2022 09:58

Weefreetiffany · 16/05/2022 09:56

you deserve basic care and kindness, especially when injured. This kind of gaslighting and abuse is unlikely to get better and there’s no excuse for it at all. What do you want from the situation? What would you say if a friend told you they were having this experience with their in laws?

This has made me think. I would tell the friend to prioritise their mental well-being and to stop watering dead plants. I've never thought of it like this before. I went above and beyond yet it still wasn't enough, so I guess it will never be enough

OP posts:
Weefreetiffany · 16/05/2022 09:56

you deserve basic care and kindness, especially when injured. This kind of gaslighting and abuse is unlikely to get better and there’s no excuse for it at all. What do you want from the situation? What would you say if a friend told you they were having this experience with their in laws?