Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the government have lost touch with reality?

113 replies

AdamRyan · 14/05/2022 10:06

Johnson wants us all back on the office; meanwhile Rees-Mogg is waging war on the civil service, leaving snarky PA notes, telling them to get into the office and cutting 20% of jobs. I can't even imagine how low morale in the civil service must be.

At the same time my industry is finding it very tough to recruit and most applicants expect hybrid/remote working.

I think the government are seriously out of touch with reality here.

IABU - get into the office, workshy stay at home dossiers

IANBU - hybrid/home working is here to stay and they are being dinosaurs

www.google.com/amp/s/www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/boris-johnson-cheese-coffee-wfh-working-home-b2078796.html%3famp

OP posts:
OversBo · 14/05/2022 13:59

I’m cynical too. If people stay at home to work, people with interests in commercial property and sandwich bar chains will lose out financially. And the tax take from petrol and diesel will go down. But it’s better for work life balance and the environment. But tories DGAF about the welfare of the population or tackling the climate crisis and biodiversity emergency.

Rummikub · 14/05/2022 13:47

TarasHarp55 · 14/05/2022 10:23

What perfect timing, go back to the office whilst fuel prices soar......yeah makes sense that.

Also helps reduce risk of climate change if there’s less commuting.

Hybrid working should be available to all.

MarshaBradyo · 14/05/2022 13:44

sst1234 · 14/05/2022 13:12

There is nothing productive about government employing people. It the least kind of productive employment. Public sector has a reputation for a reason.
Also we don’t need 70 people still working on COP26. Yes that event that happened a year ago. And that is a just one example of the bloated inefficient civil service.

I’ve only worked in the private sector

In this instance is it harder to remove people if they are not needed?

In private it’s fairly easy, how about the public sector?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 14/05/2022 13:40

There is nothing productive about government employing people. It the least kind of productive employment

Doesn't that depend what they're actually doing though? After all in the broadest sense government employ teachers, nurses, firefighters and so on

Trouble is they also employ far too many pen pushers, advisers, "partnership facilitators", managers and much else, who suck up money before it gets anywhere near the front line and tend not to bear the brunt when hard decisions have to be made

noblegiraffe · 14/05/2022 13:39

There are apparently 90,000 more civil servants than 2016, but we’ve had Brexit since then. Would be useful to see what departments they are working in.

EvilPea · 14/05/2022 13:37

sst1234 · 14/05/2022 13:12

There is nothing productive about government employing people. It the least kind of productive employment. Public sector has a reputation for a reason.
Also we don’t need 70 people still working on COP26. Yes that event that happened a year ago. And that is a just one example of the bloated inefficient civil service.

I’m not saying don’t pull unnecessary roles or redundant roles. But they are saying there’s 90,000 inefficient bloated roles??

Puzzledandpissedoff · 14/05/2022 13:29

Why would they want to create headlines? What's the end goal of that?

To make it look as if they're being effective, when in fact they're no such thing

There's nothing at all wrong in principle with WFH, which can be an excellent thing where it works for everyone. Unfortunately, among the Civil Service - already infested with a "can't do" ethos - it can too often offer a way to do even less

ChrisReasBathEggs · 14/05/2022 13:21

Eatingpizza · 14/05/2022 10:38

There's probably a lot of conservative / donor money tied up in commercial property.

They are the conservative party. Their aim is not to run the country for the good of it's citizens, but to redistribute money ever upwards, while retaining power.

This will be a combination of distraction - so people focus on anything than the shitjob they are making of just about everything - and putting money in their's and their mates' pockets.

In two days, it will be something else.

Agree with this.

bedsidetab · 14/05/2022 13:12

They mucked up my driving license renewal but did fix it fast after I complained.

sst1234 · 14/05/2022 13:12

EvilPea · 14/05/2022 10:47

Surely government employing people is a good thing

they pay tax, they go out and spend money (more tax), buy things (more tax).

happy productive society.

my view is this and the threat of privatising the passport office is to keep people in line, don’t go against the government.
but I am cynical by nature

There is nothing productive about government employing people. It the least kind of productive employment. Public sector has a reputation for a reason.
Also we don’t need 70 people still working on COP26. Yes that event that happened a year ago. And that is a just one example of the bloated inefficient civil service.

Peregrina · 14/05/2022 13:09

I don't know about the Passport Office, but I had to renew my Driving Licence in December 2020. I got it back by return of post. I was absolutely stunned.

bedsidetab · 14/05/2022 12:46

How efficient was the passport office etc pre covid?

josil · 14/05/2022 12:35

@worriedatthistime agree completely with your post.

josil · 14/05/2022 12:34

I actually agree with Boris on this one, how can someone learn and develop when they're at home?

I also think it depends on your role, but what happens when you work in a role that relies on experience and someone is new to the role - for at least the first three years I. My workplace, it's crucial to be around others to become competent,

So I guess what I'm saying is it's impossible to generalise because it depends on the antiretroviral of the business.

I manage a team and one member of staff supposedly has 25 years experience on the sector but still needs to be watched over so I think a hybrid model if anything is best,

Not to mention mental health. It is affected IMO without having a work/home divide for many people.

worriedatthistime · 14/05/2022 12:32

Some of these people clearly aren't working well from home as in a shambles hmrc , dvla and passport office
Some jobs can easily be done from home others not
Gdpr is also a big concern people seem to of forgotten about with many people now having this sort of paperwork and computers containing a lot of personal information .
If you don't want to go back fo the office find a wfh job its that simple
Some people love wfh , others hate it as i mixes work and family and not all have space for an office at home

bedsidetab · 14/05/2022 11:48

@Badbadbunny I heard a radio announcement about it this week re TFL

"We continue to rebuild ridership on all our services – with the Tube now seeing more than two thirds of ridership on weekdays compared to pre-pandemic levels and buses consistently being 75-80 per cent of pre-pandemic levels."

I don't know about train journey specifically to London but I believe train passenger numbers are about 60%.

I can't see anything saying 50%?

I also never said wfh wasn't having an impact just not the only one. We have a huge demographic shift due to an ageing population. There are job shortages & approx 300k of over 50 workers are now economically inactive. That will all have an impact.

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 14/05/2022 11:28

The government have no policies. They just say stuff to generate controversial headlines one day then completely forget about it the next.

Badbadbunny · 14/05/2022 11:27

bedsidetab · 14/05/2022 11:19

It's ALL about preserving public transport, especially in London and other big cities. The passenger numbers of commuters is massively down and the loss of income isn't sustainable.

Numbers are back to about 72% of pre-pandemic numbers. However this is not just because of more wfh. Loads of Londoners wfh pre covid. People have moved out of London & it's estimated 700k foreign born residents have left to go home. I used to get the bus to work & started walking, I won't change back.

Then you have the weekend & evening trips into town. The growth in online shopping means less trips into town for shopping. Plus the impact on people's budgets means less disposable income.

That's overall numbers. The number of leisure travellers has increased over and above pre-covid levels, but commuter numbers are well down, in some areas as low as 50% pre covid. If that continues, the number/frequency/length of trains in the cities on primarily commuter routes will have to reduce and maybe some of the trains will be redeployed to busier leisure routes - but more likely is that the leisure routes already had spare capacity so they're just a bit fuller and don't need more/longer trains. If, say, commuter numbers are down 50% in London, then we're going to see some major reductions in commuter trains, regardless of whether leisure has increased - not many tourists/sightseeing will want the 6:45 from Hemel Hempstead or Watford or whichever commuter town, to London will they, and with fewer commuters, instead of it being, say, every 15 minutes, it could well become half hourly or even hourly according to passenger numbers and/or may need to make more stops on the way rather than being semi-direct.

manysummersago · 14/05/2022 11:25

Here we go.

echt · 14/05/2022 11:24

manysummersago · 14/05/2022 10:20

I don’t know, to be honest.

I know everyone on MN insists they are much more productive WFH, but I’m not sure that this is the reality.

And what makes you think this about something you're not sure about?

And "everyone" on MN thinks they're more productive? What utter shite.

Badbadbunny · 14/05/2022 11:22

Minikievs · 14/05/2022 11:08

I am definitely not. I went back into the office in July 2020 and have been there ever since.
I cannot work from home. I get distracted. Do nothing. WFH for a couple of months early 2020 with primary school aged kids nearly gave me a nervous breakdown.
I appreciate not everyone is the same but I'm sure I'm not alone with being far more productive in the office than at home.

My DS says the same. He's at Uni at the moment but absolutely hates the idea of WFH. He's already suffered a full year of being virtually trapped in his student flat at Uni last year when the Uni closed down for Covid, all staff stayed home, library and other communal spaces were locked, for most of the academic year. He hated it. He's coming to the end of his second year and it's not been much better - still lots of lecturers/staff WFH so lots of lectures/seminars still online only, but at least the library has been open which is where he spends most of his "working/studying" time - he can't bear to stay in his room despite having a decent sized desk etc - he'd rather take a couple of rucksacks to the library! He's been looking at graduate jobs and is despairing at the amount that are WFH positions - he just doesn't know how he'd ever get trained up and working with other staff if they're all WFH - he barely knows any of his fellow students as they're really not working/studying together as they used to pre covid.

bedsidetab · 14/05/2022 11:19

It's ALL about preserving public transport, especially in London and other big cities. The passenger numbers of commuters is massively down and the loss of income isn't sustainable.

Numbers are back to about 72% of pre-pandemic numbers. However this is not just because of more wfh. Loads of Londoners wfh pre covid. People have moved out of London & it's estimated 700k foreign born residents have left to go home. I used to get the bus to work & started walking, I won't change back.

Then you have the weekend & evening trips into town. The growth in online shopping means less trips into town for shopping. Plus the impact on people's budgets means less disposable income.

CapMarvel · 14/05/2022 11:19

I mean, look at who is running things at the moment and it's pretty obvious why the UK is in such a mess.

Boris, Mogg, Sunak are all silver spoon eton twats who have NO understanding of what life is like for most people in the UK.

Dominic Rabb, Ben Wallace, Shapps and James Cleverley do not have a brain cell between them.

The less said about Gove, Dowden and Patel the better.

Utter shitshow.

PenguinIce · 14/05/2022 11:18

Where I am most of the Local Government offices are being sold off to fill the gap from loss of Central Government funding. Staff have no choice but to wfh as there is not enough office space left.

Badbadbunny · 14/05/2022 11:18

HMRC are a shambles - they've now resorted to spurious reasons for not dealing with correspondence so they can "tick their boxes" re the targets/deadlines.

I've just had yet another "rejection" message from HMRC re a PAYE tax code change request I submitted, saying they can't match the client details I gave on the online form, against their database. I checked and double checked before I submitted it and I've since double checked the data from the screen print I took upon submission - every last detail matches. Whoever it was allocated to just couldn't be arsed to deal with it so ticked the "reject" button instead. If it happens once, you accept it, but this latest one is about the 20th I've had. Funny thing is that when I submit again with exactly the same data, it gets processed! I've had enough and have made a formal complaint now, sending copies of all the original submissions and their rejection messages.

That's not the only case either. There've been other instances where I've written to them, i.e. to make a claim for a capital loss, only to get a curt/short rejection letter saying it must be done on an SA return. Again, I have to waste my time by writing back citing the relevant law/regs saying such a claim can be made by letter. It's just laziness on their part that they can't be bothered to do something, so they just bat it back in the knowledge that next time it comes, it'll land on someone else's desk!

Swipe left for the next trending thread