Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel between ' a rock and a hard place' with dh and ds...

317 replies

Andonandonamdnn · 14/05/2022 01:06

Dh is 62 .
Ds , 25.
Ds is doing a funded post grad professional on the job qualification which means that he gets a minimal.wage ( not a grant) whilst he trains and works and quaifies.
Dh and I both worked all our working lives in public service jobs and in early 60s ( took pension then ) we have a pension for life , of 1.5 k pm dh and 450 pm me.
. We both work ... Me pt ,he 3/4 time in minimum wage jobs to top up income .
Borh dc thro uni , then ds decided on post grad as above. ..
Dc could not afford rent ( v high in area on the temp wage whilst training) so we pay a proportion of his costs and rent to.help him which has meant the need to earn more income.

.. he is texnically a student/ dependnant ?.. he could have lived in cheaper place with students but as he now is doing a professional placement via a school.. we/ he felt he needed a quiet ish flat not one with undergrads who want to party as he needs have quiet to prep in evenings for class. Etc.

Dh works 5 days a week. I work 3 to in part faciltate this and it means we have to be careful.with money.. we cant travel.abroad as hopes/ plannes etc. As we send money eaxh month.. Ive offered to do more work but dh says he does not wantme to as i do a physically hard cleaning job and have some health issues.

.The rock and rhe hard place is this.... ds need s finiancial support till he qualifies next year in order to .stay in this decent quiet ish flat to study etc and go.to.work.5 days a week in school( v few available in a uni city were most places are busy student undergrad places) .. dh has started saying things like .". he is 26 years old .."." when i wasthat age" etc" ,i am in my 60s."." when will.the support end.". hes said to ds he is looking forward to the time he can work less.. he is grumpy a lot.. i think he resents the commitment of the support as he is tired.. its that he feels adult child of 26 wd not need ongoing £ support at this stage of life and whilst he wants to.support him , he also.resents it and it comes to.surface ? I dont know what to to.. he is withdrawn with dc on phone( notes by ds) as he is tired , resentful? , fed up, but also feels he should help.. it seems to.be increasingly hard for dh to do his.
. Ds has said to.me.why is dh like this ( withdrawn on phone) and i feel.stuck between the need to support ds and dh s wish to help him but the fact that this is coupled with tiredness and occasional ( what feels like resenment/ anger/ wanting freedom from supporting adult dc/ occasional pride in it. Its as if the wants tohelp ds but is tired and is starting to resent it at the same time. I dont want either dh or ds to feel bad . Plus we have said we will help.ds and the last thing i want is for ds to feel bad about it.

OP posts:
Nothappyatwork · 14/05/2022 12:43

I totally agree with @Ferngreen when I had children I expected it to be a lifelong commitment because my life‘s been particularly tough due to lack of parental support and I’ve seen the quite wonderful lives the other people leaved with it. I know which I choose for my children and grandchildren.

TheLightYears · 14/05/2022 12:41

VickyEadieofThigh · 14/05/2022 10:15

@Andonandonamdnn I don't understand why your son won't start earning a proper salary until 2023. I work in teacher training and if he's applying for posts for this September, of course he'd be paid a full salary from then.

Can you give a bit more information?

I agree , it doesnt make sense.
Unless the DS is doing a part time PGCE ...

WhereYouLeftIt · 14/05/2022 12:40

I have only read your posts OP so am probably just echoing other people here, but this in your OP seems to encapsulate the whole thing to me:

"Ds has said to.me.why is dh like this ( withdrawn on phone) and i feel.stuck between the need to support ds and dh s wish to help him but the fact that this is coupled with tiredness and occasional ( what feels like resenment/ anger/ wanting freedom from supporting adult dc/ occasional pride in it. Its as if the wants tohelp ds but is tired and is starting to resent it at the same time. I dont want either dh or ds to feel bad . Plus we have said we will help.ds and the last thing i want is for ds to feel bad about it."

Your son is 26. He asked you why his dad was withdrawn on the phone, and it sounds to me that you did not answer your son's question so that he wouldn't 'feel bad'? Given that your husband has "said to ds he is looking forward to the time he can work less" he really shouldn't have to ask - should he? He already knows, really.

Frankly, at 26 he should have worked it out for himself that he's getting a LOT of financial support from his parents, and he should have worked out for himself that since his dad has actually retired but it still putting in 30ish hours/week in a minimum-wage job - maybe his parents are struggling to provide that level of financial support.

Is your son inclined to shove his head in the sand? Because as I've said, he really should be aware of the financial pressure he is putting on you and your husband. What steps has he taken to finance himself? Yes he is working five days a week, but he has evenings and weekends, no? Has the idea that he could do a second job never been raised? Hospitality is crying out for employees right now, which means evening and weekend bar work, for example, is available. My DS, 23, is doing just that. Why isn't yours? Why is he instead just sitting back and letting his parents fund him from their minimum-wage jobs?

Your son sounds very passive in all this, leaving it to you and your husband. Why wouldn't your husband feel resentful about that? And I also have to ask - what do you feel about continuing in "a physically hard cleaning job" with your health issues to finance your son? Because rationally, you too should feel resentment. Your husband has stopped you for working more because of your health issues, it sounds to me as if he'd rather you didn't work at all but financially you have to - and I expect your husband resents that! (As my dad would.)

I guess I'm trying to say that it is perfectly rational for your husband to resent
this situation, resent it for his own sake and also for the burden placed on his wife. And maybe, instead of you worrying about your son 'feeling bad' (no evidence that he would, in my opinion), you should stop infantilising your son and back up your husband and point out to your 26-year-old son that he needs to step up a bit more because you and his dad just cannot do this any longer. He's an adult and he needs to take on adult responsibility. Once he does I would expect the relationship between DH and DS to improve. This financial dependency is the root cause of any problems in the relationship.

Our other dc is about to leave uni and has asked.to.come home for.a while and i think that he is perhaps overwhelmed.
Yes, your husband is feeling overwhelmed. Has your other DC made any indication of what they will be doing once home? Because they need to know that you and your husband are financially struggling and that they cannot just come home , doss, and hoover all the food from the fridge. They might think that's exactly what they can do given how their older sibling is being catered to, but you need to accept right now that you cannot do that and make no offers. Can you do that?

ShandaLear · 14/05/2022 12:21

You need to stop mollycoddling him. You’re really doing him no favours by not letting him grow up. How do you expect him to stand on his own 2 feet when he has no idea how to because he is still being supported by you? I did part time jobs all the way through Uni, and then worked nights in a bar during my first low paid job at a university. I now teach students and that’s what they all do. Most of them aren’t that rowdy after first year; they all have jobs in supermarkets, clothes shops, care homes or bars. Your son hasn’t even they maturity they have. Is he not mortified to be still sponging off his parents at 26? An apprenticeship may not pay a high salary, but it is perfectly adequate to live on for a year or two when you don’t have any dependents.

toconclude · 14/05/2022 12:16

StaplesCorner · 14/05/2022 10:21

Your husband is 62. 2 years older than me. I didn’t realise I was entitled to stop work and take holidays abroad and that if I didn’t get this, people would rally round saying oh you poor thing you must be soooo tired. Where do I sign up for this?

Read the bloody post, why don't you. He's still working and that's why he's tired. But yeah, how entitled to want to retire before the statutory age after decades in work - parents probably not graduates so already worked more than forty years. Got it.

Clucking Bell.

Maurepas · 14/05/2022 12:11

A long shot - but could he get a job for the next academic year Sept 2022 - July 2023 at a ''private'' boarding school ? A lot of them provide accommodation to staff if they are located in rural areas. They also need staff to supervise pupils during non teaching hours - being on the premises at night etc.

rookiemere · 14/05/2022 12:03

It's one thing to work until 67 because you need to in order to have an adequate pension. Quite another to have the means to retire but be unable to do so because you're subsidising a 26 year old man.

Sounds like your DH got resentful around the time he found out this arrangement was expected to last for yet another year. I'd encourage your DS to find a flat share and be truthful with him when he asks about his DF "Yes I think your father is finding working to be very tiring these days and wishes he could afford to retire." If that doesn't prompt the young man into action, goodness knows what will.

Andonandonamdnn · 14/05/2022 12:02

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus low mood was not ro do with the houswmates only.. however , had been isolated in the house for months.. quite toxic... it waa with a group of nosiey , rude young men.. he retreated to.his room to.try and deal with it for some months as the tennancy held him there. In the the end , that and another peesonal thing wore him down a bit.it wasnt a mental health thing but rather erosion of confidece as well as another private thing on top.

OP posts:
Cervinia · 14/05/2022 11:57

Stop infantilising him. DS's girlfriend trained to be a secondary school teacher with absolutely no help from anyone, her mum had passed away, her dad a drifter. She worked weekends and holidays in a very busy hotel to pay her bills. She's now qualified and has never felt as well off.

toconclude · 14/05/2022 11:57

Ferngreen · 14/05/2022 06:17

The retirement age is 67 - you both work part time. I would say with your big pensions you should get on with it and subsidise DS- this isn't the 1980s/90s with jobs for life - DCs need help if you can give it - it's only another year or so.
I have adult DCs in their late 30s and help towards housing and anything else btw.

2k a month between two is a "big pension"? Blimey. FYI it's an average wage for one person. What you mean is, how dare those evul boomerz expect anything like a nice life after a lifetime of work, paying a mortgage (which all being well they will pass on as property tax free), bringing up the son etc? Work til you drop and give your kids your money.
Yes, the 80s/90s. Jobs for life. Must have dreamt DH being made redundant twice in that period.
And if you are still regulalry subsidizing your kids in their late thirties your choice but it's frankly ridiculous. Nice gifts, yes.

whynotwhatknot · 14/05/2022 11:56

Sorry i think youve spoiled him-did you pay for his travel for his gap year aswell

i dont know how a date can change for graduating isnt it usually set-youre in your 60's working till so you can pay for your sons rent its not normal sorry he can start taking care of himself

SorryPardonWhat · 14/05/2022 11:55

I'm with your DH. Uni libraries are often open till midnight. He can work in there and live in shared accommodation. You should not be working extra hours to support him. He can work extra hours - he's 26!

I do sympathise. I have a DS too and am way too soft on him. I need other people to point this out to me sometimes too!

grapewines · 14/05/2022 11:54

mycatisannoying · 14/05/2022 11:10

He needs to live as normal students do, and not a 'wrapped in cotton wool' version of one.

Yeah, this. He is 26 and sounds entitled and spoiled.

I'm with your husband. Time for your son to support himself.

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 14/05/2022 11:49

Oh come on! When I was 22 I started my teaching postgrad while living in my own flat. Did placement from 8-5 every day, went home and ate then worked in a supermarket 6:30-11:30. Worked in a bar Sat night to top up. Never occurred to me as a grown woman to ask the bank of Mummy and Daddy for support. Your DH is right.

maskersanonymous · 14/05/2022 11:46

If he really needs downtime and doesn't have the funds then he needs to be creative about where and how he lives. There are charities which match young people and older people with spare rooms who need a little support, just one thought I had that could work. He really doesn't need his own flat (and his mother paying for it!). You aren't actually helping him become an independent adult and your husband is probably right to be fed up with it at this point.

BronwenFrideswide · 14/05/2022 11:38

What is your son doing in the school holidays to earn money to help fund himself during term time?

If course your husband is feeling resentful, he's tired, no doubt he is also worried about how much YOU both have to live on and the pressure than creates.

Glad to see your son is looking for a flat share but he also needs to find extra work to supplement his income at the moment he sounds incredibly selfish and the burden he is putting on you and your husband is completely unfair.

LuckySantangelo35 · 14/05/2022 11:27

@EmbarrassingHadrosaurus

Still laughing at your post that the son being pissed off at being woken by people shagging in his house share could possibly constitute a mental health diagnosis!

And that he could claim PIP for it as well!

🤣🤣🤣

HoppingPavlova · 14/05/2022 11:27

In which case, it's plausibly too late to help him now but if he has a mental health diagnosis he might want to explore whether there is a scheme to support him to continue in the workplace or to provide a history if he later wants to claims PIP to facilitate this.

???? Having a low mood because your housemates are keeping you awake with loud sex and parties does not mean a mental health condition and PIP claim! A normal person may look to solve it with decent ear plugs instead.

Testina · 14/05/2022 11:23

Another difference for his generation, 2020 vs 1980.

Noise cancelling headphones!!!

And now you’ve said he’s a trainee teacher, peace to study is even more of an odd thing to worry about - all my teacher friends can just continue to work in school after kick out.

LuckySantangelo35 · 14/05/2022 11:21

Testina · 14/05/2022 11:13

Oh come on, being pissed off cos you’re kept awake by the next room shagging is not a mental health issue!

EXACTLY!!

Babyroobs · 14/05/2022 11:20

Sorry but at this age you need to step back. Having said that, you ahve 2k in pensions coming in each month and 2 x wages so where is all that money going? Do you still have a high mortgage to pay or something?

Testina · 14/05/2022 11:20

howtomoveforwards · 14/05/2022 11:16

He could live it’s others doing the same qualification, surely? Not all student houses are full of people partying. Many degrees these days involve placements.

Great suggestion. It’s not like he’s doing something really niche!

HoppingPavlova · 14/05/2022 11:19

It feels like.. ds needs down time at weekend after work in a challenging classroom.

I’ve read it all now. At 26yo I didn’t get weekends off, or indeed any day, worked weeks on end, and seemingly 24/7 and wouldn’t have understood the term ‘down time’. If I wasn’t on my feet working I was sleeping in a little room on a bunk someone had likely recently had sex on and genuinely trying g to figure out if I last had a shower 2hrs ago or whether that was 26hr ago as hours and days just blended. I lived.

Seriously, even if noisy, all your son needs is a bedroom to prep work in and if he can’t manage that there is something wrong. Down time shouldn’t need to exist at that age.

Kennykenkencat · 14/05/2022 11:17

I.feel.sorry for dc generation .. as someone said our salries were 12k each in the 80s and our first house 18k

I was never on more than £4,500 in the 80s and Dh was on not much more.

I do think my Dd would laugh at the idea of needing 2 days off to recover from only 5 days work. She is self employed and today is her 8th day of working in a row and she is definitely booked in for work until 24th May
Today her work hours are 10am-11.30pm then it is an hours drive back and she has to be at work for 7am tomorrow morning.
She is saving for her 2nd place

howtomoveforwards · 14/05/2022 11:16

He could live it’s others doing the same qualification, surely? Not all student houses are full of people partying. Many degrees these days involve placements.

Swipe left for the next trending thread