Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel between ' a rock and a hard place' with dh and ds...

317 replies

Andonandonamdnn · 14/05/2022 01:06

Dh is 62 .
Ds , 25.
Ds is doing a funded post grad professional on the job qualification which means that he gets a minimal.wage ( not a grant) whilst he trains and works and quaifies.
Dh and I both worked all our working lives in public service jobs and in early 60s ( took pension then ) we have a pension for life , of 1.5 k pm dh and 450 pm me.
. We both work ... Me pt ,he 3/4 time in minimum wage jobs to top up income .
Borh dc thro uni , then ds decided on post grad as above. ..
Dc could not afford rent ( v high in area on the temp wage whilst training) so we pay a proportion of his costs and rent to.help him which has meant the need to earn more income.

.. he is texnically a student/ dependnant ?.. he could have lived in cheaper place with students but as he now is doing a professional placement via a school.. we/ he felt he needed a quiet ish flat not one with undergrads who want to party as he needs have quiet to prep in evenings for class. Etc.

Dh works 5 days a week. I work 3 to in part faciltate this and it means we have to be careful.with money.. we cant travel.abroad as hopes/ plannes etc. As we send money eaxh month.. Ive offered to do more work but dh says he does not wantme to as i do a physically hard cleaning job and have some health issues.

.The rock and rhe hard place is this.... ds need s finiancial support till he qualifies next year in order to .stay in this decent quiet ish flat to study etc and go.to.work.5 days a week in school( v few available in a uni city were most places are busy student undergrad places) .. dh has started saying things like .". he is 26 years old .."." when i wasthat age" etc" ,i am in my 60s."." when will.the support end.". hes said to ds he is looking forward to the time he can work less.. he is grumpy a lot.. i think he resents the commitment of the support as he is tired.. its that he feels adult child of 26 wd not need ongoing £ support at this stage of life and whilst he wants to.support him , he also.resents it and it comes to.surface ? I dont know what to to.. he is withdrawn with dc on phone( notes by ds) as he is tired , resentful? , fed up, but also feels he should help.. it seems to.be increasingly hard for dh to do his.
. Ds has said to.me.why is dh like this ( withdrawn on phone) and i feel.stuck between the need to support ds and dh s wish to help him but the fact that this is coupled with tiredness and occasional ( what feels like resenment/ anger/ wanting freedom from supporting adult dc/ occasional pride in it. Its as if the wants tohelp ds but is tired and is starting to resent it at the same time. I dont want either dh or ds to feel bad . Plus we have said we will help.ds and the last thing i want is for ds to feel bad about it.

OP posts:
stopthepain · 14/05/2022 07:36

I’m guessing he’s doing a PGCE/teacher training? Did he choose a salaried route or a traditional route where you take out a loan? Is his subject eligible for a bursary?

I don’t understand why he is expecting you pay for a flat he lives in by himself. Why can’t he live at your house and commute to lectures and placements? I stayed with my parents during my teacher training. He won’t have time for a part time job so he should’ve considered completing his PGCE closer to home!

Ylvamoon · 14/05/2022 07:31

I am with your husband. You are obviously struggling to support your DS and this needs to be addressed.

Realistically DS has 12 months of "hardship" if you cut the financial support.
If he really wants to finish this course, he will either find a weekend job or move to cheaper accommodation.

Not all bedsits/ house shares are full of undergraduates with a pary going on 24/7.
It's time to cut DS loose!

rwalker · 14/05/2022 07:31

I'm with DH you need to cut the apron strings you talk about him like he's 12 . At 26 He need to sort it himself .

WildCoasts · 14/05/2022 07:30

All the students I know work part-time support themselves. I did post-grad part-time and worked part-time to get through. I'm with your husband here. You should be able to enjoy time as a couple and travel at this time of your lives. What if he decides to do a PhD next?

Doingmybest12 · 14/05/2022 07:19

I feel like something is missing from your post as if you both agreed and there is an end in a year's time then your husband being fed up now means something has changed . Is your son not appreciating what you are doing? Is he not putting the work in? Is he away on holiday subsidised by you? Is he feeling you are over indulgent towards your son? Are you talking about further support? Hopefully it will all be over in a year and your son will be independent. I would hope your son is doing everything he can to make you feel appreciated.

rookiemere · 14/05/2022 07:17

Just because pension age has changed to 67, it doesn't mean people are any physically younger or able to continue in tough jobs when they get older.

I do feel sorry for the younger generation who won't have my option of retiring at 60 with a semi decent pension (hopefully) topped up by the state pension once I'm 67.

Of course the DH is frustrated. He's 62 and were he not subsidising his 25 year old would presumably have retired.
If DS moved to a shared flat , could he afford to retire? That's the nub of it. Yes DS is working hard and not earning much, but he's 25. I lived in some pretty grotty shared accommodation as a student and when graduated for a bit. That's life. Also there are so many pt gigs at the minute- yes he's working hard but a few hours of deliveroo or table waiting won't kill him if he absolutely has to have a solo flat.

PermanentTemporary · 14/05/2022 07:16

I think you need to listen to your dh. And stop getting involved with the details of your ds's arrangements.

I would have a chat with your dh and fix a time for the subsidy to stop - 3 months? That's long enough for ds to sort out an alternative plan. Leave the details to him to work out. Start planning what you will do with your dh - give up work completely maybe?

bakewellbride · 14/05/2022 07:14

Your son is a few years off 30 and needs to grow up and support himself. 26 is an age when it wouldn't be weird for him to have a family of his own!

I did teacher training while living in a flatshare. It was hard, I was 23 and was hundreds of miles away from any family but I did it and learned a lot about adulthood along the way.

Gizacluethen · 14/05/2022 07:10

Your DS is a full grown man and should not be taking money off his retired parents. Supporting your child through uni usually means until they're 21/22 not 27. God I'm the same age and own a company, a house and have a baby. I can't imagine still asking daddy for pocket money.

MsTSwift · 14/05/2022 07:08

This reminds me of one of those enormous baby birds sitting in the nest whilst 2 tiny parents fly about feeding him…

Indicatrice · 14/05/2022 07:08

Your son needs to get a PT job, lots of us managed one during further education.

Did he have help whilst he was at university as well?

Apollonia1 · 14/05/2022 06:55

I'm normally on the side of parents helping their children.

But in this case I think it's terrible he has his 60-something mum with health issues, working a physically-demanding job, just to send him money!

As a student, he can't afford a flat on this own. He should look to share with other masters students or perhaps just one other person. Where is he doing the course - could he move back home with you until it's completed?
Is he very grateful for the work you're doing to support him?

Fluffruff · 14/05/2022 06:42

I think your son needs to stand on his own two feet more. There are many options other than noisy student flats. He could find a flatshare with just one other person for example.

whiteroseredrose · 14/05/2022 06:25

If your son is doing a PGCE I feel for him. It nearly killed me.

The volume of work was massive.

I only stopped briefly when DH put food in front of me or I had 5 - 6 hours sleep at night.

You're very lucky to have those guaranteed pensions. Your DS will not be so lucky.

Your DH agreed to help your DS so needs to honour that commitment until the studies are over, then no more.

DSGR · 14/05/2022 06:24

The issue is you’ve said you will help.
so you need to
commit to that and see this bit through but then make clear to your son he’s on his own. Set a deadline.
but you also need to have a word with DH about his attitude as it’s all going to be damaging

Ferngreen · 14/05/2022 06:17

The retirement age is 67 - you both work part time. I would say with your big pensions you should get on with it and subsidise DS- this isn't the 1980s/90s with jobs for life - DCs need help if you can give it - it's only another year or so.
I have adult DCs in their late 30s and help towards housing and anything else btw.

MrsMo21 · 14/05/2022 06:16

It sounds as though your son is perhaps doing a PGCE? Masters in Education? Both are unpaid so I understand why he needs help; I needed some from my parents during this time (I was younger than him though).

If so, he can move back to shared accommodation. We all did it during ours and yes it’s noisy sometimes but you can absolutely teach/study/plan etc in that environment. Most of us lived in grim places in London during ours, needs must and all that. I think it cost £500 (was about 7 years ago) a month all in (you can imagine the state of the place for that money) which my Mum paid half of and I covered the rest in grants. Spending money was my loan which was £1600 per 16 weeks. Of course it was tight and I ate beans from the tin more than once but welcome to taking responsibility for your life choices 🤷🏻‍♀️
He can’t get a weekend job after working in a school all week, you’re right it’s not sustainable and it’ll affect his wellbeing. I did tutor though which made me extra money each month so he can do this after school with no problem as it’s just an extension of his day. He needs to do this.

26 seems quite late to be starting this when his undergrad will have potentially finished at 21. I agree with your husband that there has to be a line drawn, I also see your need to support but I really think by the sounds of it you can pull it right back. His life sounds very cushty for a student!!!

user1497787065 · 14/05/2022 06:03

So you have pension income of almost 2k per month you both work still and resent topping up your son's income?

How much do you pay him per month?

FairyCakeWings · 14/05/2022 06:03

Your ds might be old enough to deal with financing himself, but that’s not the point. The point is your husband chose to support his ds with his adult education and now he doesn’t want to anymore he’s taking his resentment out his ds. That is a horrible way to behave for anyone, but a man in his sixties should have more sense.

Plenty of people in their mid twenties still get some financial support from parents if they’re in full time education, it’s not completely out of the ordinary. No one forced your DH into this, so he needs to learn to be a bit more gracious if he wants to maintain a good relationship with his family.

Namenic · 14/05/2022 06:00

If he works in a classroom do they have school holidays? Could he do tutoring in these or over the weekend?

Moonface123 · 14/05/2022 05:55

Theres a saying " When you walk down the middle of the road you get hit by both sides. "
I' m with your husband, at 26 your son is more than capable of financing himself. At that age l was working a full time job in the day, and also an evening job, to finance myself.

orangeisthenewpuce · 14/05/2022 05:50

The fact that you've funded your son to do what he wants this far in life is wrong imo. It was his choice to continue in education, it was up to him to fund it. I'm with your husband. Your son needs to move to cheaper accommodation and get a weekend job.

Paq · 14/05/2022 05:48

At 26 he will have so much more energy than you. It's really not a hardship to get a house share with other young professionals and an evening/weekend job.

I know solicitors and accountants who did that post uni and during their professional qualification time when they weren't earning much. They just got on with it.

KatherineJaneway · 14/05/2022 05:41

Your dh is right. If sounds like you are both spoiling him and giving him unrealistic expectations. How quickly will he get a job once qualified?

He could move into a quiet flat share, there are plenty of them about that are not party central.

I'd be sitting the three of you down, saying you need to cut back support and walking through his plans to support himself. What you don't want is his training to end then he takes 'time off' for a rest before job hunting for example.

MrsTerryPratchett · 14/05/2022 05:24

Andonandonamdnn · 14/05/2022 01:35

It feels like.. ds needs down time at weekend after work in a challenenging classroom.
It.feels likw dh thinks that but is frustated.

It feelslike if dh tells ds this ds may give his training and a chance of good earning potential .. up ... 😟

If he does this, he doesn't want it enough. You and DH work extra, in your 60s and DS is the one who needs quiet space and down time? Nope.

I did a degree and two jobs at that age. Including a memorable 24 hour shift from Sunday to Monday and then straight to lectures with no sleep. Plus an evening job. Oh and it was a science degree and the jobs were homeless shelters. Not easy.

I'm guessing only child, very spoiled mummy's boy. Can do no wrong. No woman is good enough (or man).

Swipe left for the next trending thread