Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel between ' a rock and a hard place' with dh and ds...

317 replies

Andonandonamdnn · 14/05/2022 01:06

Dh is 62 .
Ds , 25.
Ds is doing a funded post grad professional on the job qualification which means that he gets a minimal.wage ( not a grant) whilst he trains and works and quaifies.
Dh and I both worked all our working lives in public service jobs and in early 60s ( took pension then ) we have a pension for life , of 1.5 k pm dh and 450 pm me.
. We both work ... Me pt ,he 3/4 time in minimum wage jobs to top up income .
Borh dc thro uni , then ds decided on post grad as above. ..
Dc could not afford rent ( v high in area on the temp wage whilst training) so we pay a proportion of his costs and rent to.help him which has meant the need to earn more income.

.. he is texnically a student/ dependnant ?.. he could have lived in cheaper place with students but as he now is doing a professional placement via a school.. we/ he felt he needed a quiet ish flat not one with undergrads who want to party as he needs have quiet to prep in evenings for class. Etc.

Dh works 5 days a week. I work 3 to in part faciltate this and it means we have to be careful.with money.. we cant travel.abroad as hopes/ plannes etc. As we send money eaxh month.. Ive offered to do more work but dh says he does not wantme to as i do a physically hard cleaning job and have some health issues.

.The rock and rhe hard place is this.... ds need s finiancial support till he qualifies next year in order to .stay in this decent quiet ish flat to study etc and go.to.work.5 days a week in school( v few available in a uni city were most places are busy student undergrad places) .. dh has started saying things like .". he is 26 years old .."." when i wasthat age" etc" ,i am in my 60s."." when will.the support end.". hes said to ds he is looking forward to the time he can work less.. he is grumpy a lot.. i think he resents the commitment of the support as he is tired.. its that he feels adult child of 26 wd not need ongoing £ support at this stage of life and whilst he wants to.support him , he also.resents it and it comes to.surface ? I dont know what to to.. he is withdrawn with dc on phone( notes by ds) as he is tired , resentful? , fed up, but also feels he should help.. it seems to.be increasingly hard for dh to do his.
. Ds has said to.me.why is dh like this ( withdrawn on phone) and i feel.stuck between the need to support ds and dh s wish to help him but the fact that this is coupled with tiredness and occasional ( what feels like resenment/ anger/ wanting freedom from supporting adult dc/ occasional pride in it. Its as if the wants tohelp ds but is tired and is starting to resent it at the same time. I dont want either dh or ds to feel bad . Plus we have said we will help.ds and the last thing i want is for ds to feel bad about it.

OP posts:
ZenKaleidoscope · 14/05/2022 09:05

You need to all sit down together and talk it out. How long is the post grad course for?

Tell him you are going to reduce how much you give him in say 6 months so he has time to either get another job, move accommodation or both.

It shouldn't all be on you to work it out though. You all need to have an open discussion about it so it works for all of you.

DysmalRadius · 14/05/2022 09:04

Who is saying that you're sion needs his own flat and can't work weekends? Is it coming from you or your son?

stopthepain · 14/05/2022 09:04

rookiemere · 14/05/2022 08:53

Righto @stopthepain so too old to have a valid world view, but young enough to keep working to subsidise his adult DS?
Look I get it's harder for the younger generation, but it doesn't make it right for a tired 62 year old to be working when he wouldn't have to if a 26 year old would flat share and/or take a part time weekend job.

I agree that if his Ds can’t afford to live in a flat alone then he needs to flat share or continue living with his parents using his bursary. He shouldn’t ask for such a large amount of money. I was just pointing out that OP’s DH’s comparison of himself to his Ds is a bit unfair :)

SolasAnla · 14/05/2022 09:03

Andonandonamdnn
It feels like.. ds needs down time at weekend after work in a challenenging classroom.
It.feels likw dh thinks that but is frustated.

Your son needs "down time" in the career he is choosing to work in and a nice flat while on minimum wage and so cant afford the rent and other costs? Plenty of people juggle work, small children, education, looking after their sick parents and paying their own bills.
DS can look for ways of reducing his bills eg rent with other young professionals.

DH and DS need to have a man to man and work things out between themselves.

FairyCakeWings
Plenty of people in their mid twenties still get some financial support from parents if they’re in full time education, it’s not completely out of the ordinary. No one forced your DH into this, so he needs to learn to be a bit more gracious if he wants to maintain a good relationship with his family.

Sorry what should the son "be" if dad needs to be gracious while working 5 days a week to fund his son's life choices?

Twin24 · 14/05/2022 09:03

Your dh has a point. At 26 why is your son making life choices that rely on him taking so much money from his parents? When does your dh get to slow down and enjoy the retirement he's worked so hard for?

If ds couldn't afford to keep going on studying in the way he is accustomed to then perhaps he shouldn't have chosen to do it.

Lovely to see the causal ageism on the thread, as always appears when threads involve anyone over the age of 50.

Andromachehadabadday · 14/05/2022 09:00

Also @stopthepain he does have time for a part time job. Because his weekends are currently filled with him relaxing. That’s when he could work.

PlantingTrees · 14/05/2022 09:00

Your son is a mature student. He needs to fund himself. I can’t believe he work let you and his dad carry on working and just be funded to live in a luxury flat. Where’s his sense of pride?

Andromachehadabadday · 14/05/2022 08:58

rookiemere · 14/05/2022 08:53

Righto @stopthepain so too old to have a valid world view, but young enough to keep working to subsidise his adult DS?
Look I get it's harder for the younger generation, but it doesn't make it right for a tired 62 year old to be working when he wouldn't have to if a 26 year old would flat share and/or take a part time weekend job.

That sums it up

Andromachehadabadday · 14/05/2022 08:58

stopthepain · 14/05/2022 08:02

Also, just to add to my last post. I was 23 and my parents were in their mid 40s during my PGCE (I’m nearly 26 now). They understand how f’ed up my generation is. You and your DH are a generation older than my parents. The economy was very different when you were young.

When your DH was in his 20s in the early 80s, the average salary was £8-10k a year and the average house was around £34k. Nowadays, the average salary is £38k and the average house is £260k.

Your DH is an old man who is out of touch.

I am 40. I think this is ridiculous. The parents in their 60s

its not out of touch to expect an adult to support themselves if they choose to continue to study in to their lates 20s but also want their own place and weekends to chill out.

I am fully supporting my dd through uni from this September. Because she is only 18. I won’t be doing it in 8 years time.

Malbecfan · 14/05/2022 08:53

Is your DS doing school-based training? The PGCE is only one year and whilst it's hard work, it's possible to work alongside it. School-based takes longer but I thought you could earn on the job.

I did my PGCE in 1993 having already bought a little house. I didn't have to pay fees then, but I didn't earn anything either. I spent most evenings playing in the band for shows and managed to pay my mortgage and bills using that. I took planning into the pit with me and between numbers I was reading stuff, marking & planning (and knackered).

My DD's BF is doing his PGCE now. He is back with his parents but goes to stay with her every other weekend, a 3 hour round trip, and they definitely don't spend all the time working. DD herself is doing a PhD. She is 22 and funding everything herself. I have guaranteed her portion of her rent but so far it hasn't cost anything. DD is sharing with 4 others. 2 of them are PhD students, one is another PGCE student and one works at the uni. Their house isn't rowdy as they all respect one another. However, they do arrange house meals every couple of weeks - tonight they are all watching Eurovision together.

TL:DR your husband is correct. Your DS needs some tough love. He doesn't need to live in a monastery and if lesson planning is taking entire weekends, he's not doing it efficiently.

rookiemere · 14/05/2022 08:53

Righto @stopthepain so too old to have a valid world view, but young enough to keep working to subsidise his adult DS?
Look I get it's harder for the younger generation, but it doesn't make it right for a tired 62 year old to be working when he wouldn't have to if a 26 year old would flat share and/or take a part time weekend job.

WimpoleHat · 14/05/2022 08:51

i do a physically hard cleaning job and have some health issues.

This jumped out at me. So you have retired from the public sector and are now doing physical work to help your son? On that basis, he needs to be in a house share and working in the pub at the weekends or whatever, not allowing his parents to take on the extra work for him. I agree with your DH here. I’d have a word with your DS and set a hard deadline for the support to end.

Beautiful3 · 14/05/2022 08:49

I agree with your husband. You diet know how much tine you both have left. You should be going on holidays and relaxing more, and not watching the pennies. I'm afraid you've spoiled your son. He should be in a flat share and working part time until he gets his dream job. I have studied 3 separate university courses while working, it is achievable. I don't know anyone who had a flat to themselves and didn't work! Think you need to change things for his next academic year. Listen to your husband. Your son needs to stand on his own two feet, he is more capable than you realise.

stopthepain · 14/05/2022 08:41

rookiemere · 14/05/2022 08:12

Well perhaps the old man @stopthepain could be allowed to retire then ?

I meant “old” as in “back in my day…” and “today’s youth have it easy.” 😂

Wheredoestheblackfluffcomefrom · 14/05/2022 08:37

The end is in sight. Agree an end date to
stop paying him. Tell DH it’s not much longer.

seven201 · 14/05/2022 08:36

DS is young enough to be living in a house share and getting a part time job. It's ludicrous that you're both working so much extra just to fund him living by himself. Does your DS know you're both working purely to fund him? It has to stop.

Hankunamatata · 14/05/2022 08:31

Your worried ds will give up the course if your withdraw money?
You need to sit down with ds, draw up a budget, work out how much he needs to get as a loan to cover himself for the next year if he isnt willing to work weekends.

He could try and get some tutoring work, especially if in an area that had grammar school entry

Hankunamatata · 14/05/2022 08:27

Nearly all trainee teachers I know supplemented their income with night and weekend work.

Lolllllllllllll · 14/05/2022 08:26

Did your husband actually agree to help him?

Hankunamatata · 14/05/2022 08:26

Sorry but you and dh are being ridiculous funding your 25 year old at the expense of your lifestyle and health. HE chose to do this qualification then HE should have worked out the finances. When your a postgrad you take loans, live in shared accommodation with other postgraduate students or training teachers.

crosbystillsandmash · 14/05/2022 08:19

I can't get past 'he wants to chill out at the weekend'
Don't we all mate!!!

When I did my teaching degree, there were single parents on the course, working part time, juggling goodness knows what at the same time.
I was pregnant and living in a noisy household and also juggling work.

Stop enabling your son. He's 26 ffs!
Your dh has every right to be totally sick of it.

rookiemere · 14/05/2022 08:12

Well perhaps the old man @stopthepain could be allowed to retire then ?

stopthepain · 14/05/2022 08:02

Also, just to add to my last post. I was 23 and my parents were in their mid 40s during my PGCE (I’m nearly 26 now). They understand how f’ed up my generation is. You and your DH are a generation older than my parents. The economy was very different when you were young.

When your DH was in his 20s in the early 80s, the average salary was £8-10k a year and the average house was around £34k. Nowadays, the average salary is £38k and the average house is £260k.

Your DH is an old man who is out of touch.

DonAlfonso · 14/05/2022 07:45

MsTSwift · 14/05/2022 07:08

This reminds me of one of those enormous baby birds sitting in the nest whilst 2 tiny parents fly about feeding him…

Yes, exactly this.

I started reading this expecting to be in favour of supporting your son as much as possible, but honestly, it’s madness! You’re over 60 and doing a hard physical job in order to send money to a healthy 26yo so that he doesn’t have to share a flat.

Does your DS actually know what a strain this all is? Kids (“kids”-he’s 26!) sometimes don’t think about it and just assume mum and dad can supply whatever is required.

I noticed you said that you were worried DS might drop out without all your support, and that he’s a bit older than he might be for this course- was there a period when things weren’t going so well for him?

Goldengoosey · 14/05/2022 07:44

I think your son is selfish and you seem blinded by the impact on both you and your husband. If your son wanted to do a post grad qualification he should have worked out how he could achieve this without relying on his parents to work to fund him.

Why is your son not working? Lots of people on this thread did qualifications whilst working, including me. I worked full time in a high pressured public sector job alongside doing a Masters part-time. It’s hard but doable especially when you’re young.

Your son needs to make some sacrifices, not you and your husband. He is young. At 26 if this is his choice he needs to work to fund it. When I left home I had a flatshare with a friend. Would I have preferred my own quiet flat? Of course I would but I couldn’t afford it. Loads of people do very intense degrees/masters/PhDs whilst working and flat sharing. This idea that your son needs downtime at weekend so can’t work is ludicrous. Great if you can afford it, but he can’t. Simple. He doesn’t seem very bright if he can’t work out why his dad is pissed off.

I think it’s great you want to help your son but he doesn’t seem to be doing anything to help himself. Does he not realise the pressure he is putting his parents under?

How much money are you actually giving him? As you both seem to be doing a lot of hours every week on top of your pensions.

It is unclear from the OP. Do you have another child as you said put both through uni. If so, what does your other child think of this set up? Can I also check does this mean your son has been a full time student since leaving school? Has he ever worked and been financially independent?

Swipe left for the next trending thread