Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Israeli forces attacking funeral procession of a journalist

158 replies

AnxietyForever · 13/05/2022 22:56

I've just seen the videos and have been reading up on this, utterly gobsmacked..
I mean, you'd think they'd have left the funeral take place?

OP posts:
Krabapple · 15/05/2022 06:03

TheGratefulBread · 14/05/2022 07:21

There is always the possibility of a stray bullet.

My point is though, none of us know for sure, we weren't there. We aren't carrying out the investigation. Perhaps best to wait for the investigation to conclude.

However, that's never an option with Israel, people just want to attack without evidence.

Sorry but Isreal are indefensible here and their actions were despicable. That’s why they are being attacked.

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 15/05/2022 02:49

TheGratefulBread · 14/05/2022 07:21

There is always the possibility of a stray bullet.

My point is though, none of us know for sure, we weren't there. We aren't carrying out the investigation. Perhaps best to wait for the investigation to conclude.

However, that's never an option with Israel, people just want to attack without evidence.

The people who were there are sure who was firing at them. The producer who was shot just before her, is sure what happened. The journalist beside her who was shot at when she tried to move her body. They're all clear what happened. You weren't there. They were.
Your apologism and misinformation is disrespectful. Shooting a journalist clearly marked as press in broad daylight and then targeting her funeral is despicable. And there should be more outcry about this, not attempts to lie about what happened. The press deserve to be safe. This isn't just an attack on an individual. It's an attack on press freedom.

Desperatelyseek · 15/05/2022 02:40

It's nothing new.
Shocked its been reported correctly to be honest.
Even more shocked that its on mumsnet..expect it to be deleted soon...

TooBigForMyBoots · 15/05/2022 02:36

In the background of the photo, groups of boys are standing on top of the wall. They look as if they are throwing stones.

In the foreground, adult members of the police force are battering pall bearers. I wish people here would stop excusing the inexcusable.Hmm

SammyScrounge · 15/05/2022 02:10

daretodenim · 14/05/2022 07:10

So we are supposed to believe that Palestinians killed Sherine and the pallbearers were skilled enough to carry the body of their loved one while throwing stones at police?

Aye right.

In the background of the photo, groups of boys are standing on top of the wall. They look as if they are throwing stones. It's a tradition to do that.
I wish people here would not side so zealously with either Israeli forces or Palestinian ones. We aren-t there. We only know what we are told.

TooBigForMyBoots · 15/05/2022 02:01

The funeral procession didn't follow the road blocks that had been set up for them and it became a politically charged procession. You are not allowed to hoist the flag or sing the national anthem or chant politically motivated words.

How very dare mourners at a funeral mourn in a way befitting of the deceased and bereaved! Imagine, carrying a coffin like that. Nope, they all got what they deserved with their violent mourning, rituals and pall bearing.Hmm

RingRingRed · 15/05/2022 01:42

veronicagoldberg · 15/05/2022 00:23

This. Only one side of the story is ever told when it comes to Israel.

Nope, not true at all.

For far too long the world has turned a blind eye to the terrible things Israel is doing. Shame on Israel and shame on the world for allowing it.

MrsTerryPratchett · 15/05/2022 01:30

FlowerArranger · 15/05/2022 00:13

Feeling you are alone against the world surrounded with enemies who want you dead, it's no wonder there is terrible behaviour. It doesn't mean we ignore it and pretend it's not happening.

You are referring to the Palestinians......? You know, the people who have been dispossessed of their land for over 7 decades, the people whose interests and welfare no one seems to care about anymore...

Or are you referring to Israel - an immensely rich state backed and financed by the most powerful nation on earth, a nation with a huge and well equipped army, and (it is rumored...) nuclear capability?

Well quite.

Again antecedents, not excuses. Seeking to understand why something is, doesn't mean you condone it.

veronicagoldberg · 15/05/2022 00:23

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

This. Only one side of the story is ever told when it comes to Israel.

FlowerArranger · 15/05/2022 00:13

Feeling you are alone against the world surrounded with enemies who want you dead, it's no wonder there is terrible behaviour. It doesn't mean we ignore it and pretend it's not happening.

You are referring to the Palestinians......? You know, the people who have been dispossessed of their land for over 7 decades, the people whose interests and welfare no one seems to care about anymore...

Or are you referring to Israel - an immensely rich state backed and financed by the most powerful nation on earth, a nation with a huge and well equipped army, and (it is rumored...) nuclear capability?

MrsTerryPratchett · 14/05/2022 23:56

Finding antecedents for things isn't the same as excusing them.

FairyCakeWings · 14/05/2022 20:46

I hadn't really thought of the 'everyone hates us so there's no point in being nice ' angle.

That seems like such a childish attitude though, something people would usually grow out of as teenagers, and it definitely isn’t a good excuse to be rude especially to locals when you’re in a country that isn’t your own.

Anti semitism is a problem, but no more so than racism in any other form. I don’t see why it needs to be brought up like clockwork on any thread that criticises the actions of the Israeli government.

No one needs to bring up xenophobia every time we criticise the Russian government or racism when we criticise the actions of the North Korean government because no matter how much or how little racism people from those countries might experience, it’s completely irrelevant to the aggressive actions of their governments.

Abhannmor · 14/05/2022 16:13

MrsTerryPratchett · 14/05/2022 14:08

To be clear when I said one of those I meant anti-Semitic lefties. I am a leftie. I do think there's a issue with anti-Semitism and it does worry me. But if my Jewish friends are capable of separating the behaviour of Israel and Judaism, I think I probably can too.

I once travelled with a group of Israelis in Asia. They behaved atrociously, particularly to the local people. One of them was very chatty with me, really clever and interesting bloke, so I asked him why. I assumed it was because they were all fresh out of the army (and can you imagine how a group of just-released British squaddies would act?). He was a little older (officer). He said, "everyone in the world hates us anyway". That feeling that you only have to answer to yourselves and you are surrounded by people who, to a greater or lesser extent, hate you, is not designed to make behaviour measured and empathetic.

Feeling you are alone against the world surrounded with enemies who want you dead, it's no wonder there is terrible behaviour. It doesn't mean we ignore it and pretend it's not happening.

Good post. I hadn't really thought of the 'everyone hates us so there's no point in being nice ' angle. Antisemitism is certainly a real problem. The Tory Party was riddled with it if Alan Clark's diaries are to be believed. Including Clark himself. Coincidentally I'm just reading Them , adventures with extremists, by Jon Ronson.

The nutbag militia men seem to be terrified of some phantom Jewish conspiracy. Although many also support Israel. Personally I like conspiracy theories ; there's something comforting about them. I just don't believe them. Because if I've learned nothing else in my life I've learnt this : nobody knows wtf is going on.

DashboardConfessional · 14/05/2022 14:22

My point is though, none of us know for sure, we weren't there. We aren't carrying out the investigation. Perhaps best to wait for the investigation to conclude.

Where have I heard that recently. 🤔

MrsTerryPratchett · 14/05/2022 14:08

Abhannmor · 14/05/2022 09:51

I am 'one of those lefties' and cast my very first vote for a Jewish socialist , Solly Kay. He would have been very saddened by this. I have no idea what the answer is tbh. It only seems like yesterday that Israeli people , like Amos Oz , were advising the parties in Northern Ireland about how to make peace. No doubt they too want peace - but they are just too strong to need it ?

To be clear when I said one of those I meant anti-Semitic lefties. I am a leftie. I do think there's a issue with anti-Semitism and it does worry me. But if my Jewish friends are capable of separating the behaviour of Israel and Judaism, I think I probably can too.

I once travelled with a group of Israelis in Asia. They behaved atrociously, particularly to the local people. One of them was very chatty with me, really clever and interesting bloke, so I asked him why. I assumed it was because they were all fresh out of the army (and can you imagine how a group of just-released British squaddies would act?). He was a little older (officer). He said, "everyone in the world hates us anyway". That feeling that you only have to answer to yourselves and you are surrounded by people who, to a greater or lesser extent, hate you, is not designed to make behaviour measured and empathetic.

Feeling you are alone against the world surrounded with enemies who want you dead, it's no wonder there is terrible behaviour. It doesn't mean we ignore it and pretend it's not happening.

clickbaitcow · 14/05/2022 10:51

Absolutely disgusting. Always excuses. No peace for the dead let alone the living. Israeli forces have got away with this for so long that we now have become numb to any news that comes out from there unless there's a new level of low such as attacking civilians and loved ones until the coffin nearly falls of the the journalist that was brutally murdered by this apartheid state for reporting.

noblegiraffe · 14/05/2022 10:20

"They were waving flags and singing the national anthem" is not a reason to attack people carrying a coffin.

If you are not horrified watching the footage because of the flags, then where would you draw the line? What behaviour would you condemn?

IncompleteSenten · 14/05/2022 10:00

There's footage of what the police did.

Is there footage of the stone throwing?

The attack was indefensible.

They beat the pallbearers.

Why? Did they throw stones? Odd choice to beat the people carrying a coffin imo.

Blind defence of all actions of a country is wrong.

Cherrysoup · 14/05/2022 10:00

JolieJ · 14/05/2022 07:59

The world has given Israel impunity to carry on and do whatever while they turn a blind eye, they know they can get away with it so that's why a cold blooded murder of a journalist is nothing new.

RIP Shireen.

Totally, while Israel annexes yet more of Palestine and forcibly carries its people off the land. Absolutely disgraceful.

cakeorwine · 14/05/2022 10:00

From The Jerusalem Post

www.jpost.com/arab-israeli-conflict/article-706638

"The excuse is that Palestinians at the funeral shouted slogans, carried Palestinian flags and threw objects. The problem is that for law enforcement agencies, every problem is often a nail and every solution is the hammer."

cakeorwine · 14/05/2022 09:55

I would be interested to know the reaction in Israel to those images - there might well be a range of views on the circumstances of her death, but I do wonder how these particular scenes with the coffin almost falling on the floor are being seen and discussed? You would hope that no matter what your politics, you can see the horror of those scenes

Abhannmor · 14/05/2022 09:54

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

What a dreadful post. Like the mealy mouthed excuses trotted out by Apartheid era South Africa.

Abhannmor · 14/05/2022 09:51

I am 'one of those lefties' and cast my very first vote for a Jewish socialist , Solly Kay. He would have been very saddened by this. I have no idea what the answer is tbh. It only seems like yesterday that Israeli people , like Amos Oz , were advising the parties in Northern Ireland about how to make peace. No doubt they too want peace - but they are just too strong to need it ?

sashagabadon · 14/05/2022 09:34

It is a very disturbing video. I’ve never seen police attacking pallbearers before and the coffin nearly falling to floor as a result.

cakeorwine · 14/05/2022 09:34

If you want to make sure you create enemies for the future, this is the way to go about it.

How can you create peace in this part of the world? Can you imagine if this kind of thing had happened in Northern Ireland with British troops? Maybe similar scenes did happen - but policing funerals and attacking mourners and the coffin nearly falling on the floor - it is just going to enflame a situation that is already enflamed and continue to create division.

Swipe left for the next trending thread