Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Israeli forces attacking funeral procession of a journalist

158 replies

AnxietyForever · 13/05/2022 22:56

I've just seen the videos and have been reading up on this, utterly gobsmacked..
I mean, you'd think they'd have left the funeral take place?

OP posts:
gotthis · 15/05/2022 20:03

I think the issue is that pallbearers were neither throwing stones or carrying flags. They were trying to hold a coffin up, while being beaten around the head and body. No justification for that, is there?

gotthis · 15/05/2022 19:57

What happened at her funeral was terrible. Respect for the dead and the grieving is universal, it must have been so painful, especially for her family and friends. Women have long struggled to get into professions like journalism, and I think she was an inspiration in this regard. War and occupation are patriarchal ideologies, I think, so I believe her to be important to women and feminism, as well as to journalism and the struggle of her people. RIP Shireen

BEAM123 · 15/05/2022 19:47

Can someone please explain to me why they think Palestinian suffering is marginalised in the media? I am serious, because all I ever see, on the media and on social media, is criticism of Israel over this.. If anything I would have to say that the media and social media is very much anti-Israel and pro- Palestinian.

Regardless, I honestly don't think that even people living there really know the truth of what actually happens, except for the incidents that happen to them personally, let alone people sitting in the west.

Regarding the journalist being shot - we should await the results of the investigation. Whoever shot her, it is disgusting.

Regarding the funeral, having read the Israeli media (both left and right wing) to get a balanced view of what they are saying: it seems that one police commander who was not physically present on the day ordered that PLO flags not be allowed at the procession. The police then had to enforce this order but there was not just a few flags but hundreds. It turned nasty, understandably. Mourners - of whom there would have been hundreds if not thousands - started to riot and throw stones. If that got further out of hand it would have escalated very, very quickly hence police squashed it.

I don't agree with their methods but let's face it very few countries have police as gentle and restrained as the British police (and yes that has not always been the case in the UK either).
On the other side I think being faced by hundreds or thousands of angry protestors shouting for blood and revenge is going to be fucking terrifying.

The police commissioner is apparently carrying out an enquiry into the decisions made on the day and in particular into why the commander made the provocative decision to ban flags and order the police to confiscate them, because that was unnecessary.

phishy · 15/05/2022 19:22

Ferngreen · 15/05/2022 18:03

I agree the Palestinian situation is tragic but like many countries -Afghanistan, Ukraine, N Ireland there's no magic wand to make everyone kind and generous - so a practicable solution is needed, the best option. The present stand off the Palestinians have now isnot the best option for them imv.
They have to compromise.

It’s pretty clear you don’t care a hoot for the Palestinians.

EasterIssland · 15/05/2022 19:03

Ferngreen · 15/05/2022 18:03

I agree the Palestinian situation is tragic but like many countries -Afghanistan, Ukraine, N Ireland there's no magic wand to make everyone kind and generous - so a practicable solution is needed, the best option. The present stand off the Palestinians have now isnot the best option for them imv.
They have to compromise.

What kind of compromise would you suggest that doesn’t make them lose their land and be killed ?

EasterIssland · 15/05/2022 19:02

Ferngreen · 15/05/2022 17:53

Whether they came after the war or later there are 8 million israelis - where do you suggest they move to?
No one's come up with a suggestion.

So you’d be happy to kicked out of your house right now so someone from Ukraine can have a life in the uk ?

Ferngreen · 15/05/2022 18:03

I agree the Palestinian situation is tragic but like many countries -Afghanistan, Ukraine, N Ireland there's no magic wand to make everyone kind and generous - so a practicable solution is needed, the best option. The present stand off the Palestinians have now isnot the best option for them imv.
They have to compromise.

AnxietyForever · 15/05/2022 17:58

@Ferngreen Where should the Palestinians move to when Israeli settles are moving into/stealing their homes?
In an ideal world everyone would live in peace obviously, but in this instance it seems the Palestinian people are the ones worse off in this situation !

OP posts:
Ferngreen · 15/05/2022 17:53

Whether they came after the war or later there are 8 million israelis - where do you suggest they move to?
No one's come up with a suggestion.

AnxietyForever · 15/05/2022 17:52

roarfeckingroarr · 15/05/2022 17:23

The app is so shit now.

I asked what the bombardment of Gaza was in response to?

Extensive Palestinian terrorism.

Get of the thread then, and maybe go watch/read up on what this thread is about and then come back, and maybe just maybe you can admit the disgusting behaviour that was show to the world by the Israeli soldiers. The world is finally waking up to this barbaric behaviour

OP posts:
Andariego · 15/05/2022 17:49

Total bollocks - Israel is a democracy. It actually treats women as equals which is diametrically opppsed to the countries who want to destroy Israel

You are the one talking total bollocks - Israel is not a democracy. A democracy by definition is a society that favours equal rights, freedom of speech and fair trials - including for minorities. It is written in black and white Israel’s desire to have a pure Jewish State, hence why black Ethiopian Jewish immigrants were injected with contraceptives without knowledge or consent upon arrival and on a three monthly basis but American (and other) Jewish immigrants weren’t.

But hey, if the right kind of Israeli woman is treated equally to the right kind of Israeli man then all is well, right?

AnxietyForever · 15/05/2022 17:47

roarfeckingroarr · 15/05/2022 17:16

I believe in the state of Israel and its right to exist. So long as Hamas are in power, Palestine is directly opposed to this. Hamas have been offered a two state solution, they reject it and call for the destruction of Israel.

I'm not defending what happened at the funeral because I don't know enough about what happened to give an opinion.

Have you not seen the videos?
Maybe watch the videos and then tell us your view, like a previous poster said, you can support Israel but also condemn the actions of the Israeli soldiers. Not hard is it?

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 15/05/2022 17:31

Total bollocks - Israel is a democracy. It actually treats women as equals which is diametrically opppsed to the countries who want to destroy Israel

It's a democracy - but attacking pall bearers at a funeral isn't something a democracy should be doing.

roarfeckingroarr · 15/05/2022 17:23

The app is so shit now.

I asked what the bombardment of Gaza was in response to?

Extensive Palestinian terrorism.

roarfeckingroarr · 15/05/2022 17:19

StoneofDestiny · 15/05/2022 13:57

I hate the anti Israel bias on here. If they weren't constantly bombarded by rockets and a Palestinian leadership pledged to erasing Israel entirely

how quickly and conveniently you have forgotten the Israeli bombardment of Ghazza, including schools, hospitals and nurseries

And what was that in response to.::

roarfeckingroarr · 15/05/2022 17:18

FlowerArranger · 15/05/2022 13:37

Israel isn’t a democracy, it isn’t civilised and they have lied time upon time to create false rhetorics. This isn’t an equal conflict or war - it’s apartheid, oppressed and oppressor. Israel is indefensible and finally after years of western military funding and conveniently looking the other way, the world is waking up to what is happening and there is rightly uproar. It’s not “anti-Israel bias”, it’s standing up for what is right.

Whilst I agree with the first part,@Andariego , I fear that the world will just go back to sleep again in a few days time, when all the furore about this despicable attack will have faded.

'The World' is perfectly aware of what has been happening to the people of Palestibe all these years. But they do not care.

Total bollocks - Israel is a democracy. It actually treats women as equals which is diametrically opppsed to the countries who want to destroy Israel.

roarfeckingroarr · 15/05/2022 17:16

I believe in the state of Israel and its right to exist. So long as Hamas are in power, Palestine is directly opposed to this. Hamas have been offered a two state solution, they reject it and call for the destruction of Israel.

I'm not defending what happened at the funeral because I don't know enough about what happened to give an opinion.

mubarak86 · 15/05/2022 17:03

Utterly disgusting and shameful behaviour on the part of the IDF and those who attempt to defend them.
Oh, and 8 million Jews did not turn up in Palestine post WW2!

LakieLady · 15/05/2022 16:53

"Yes it's an unfair story but why don't the many rich Arab countries help Palestine?"

I'm struggling to think how they could help the Palestinians without it being perceived as an aggressive act by the Israeli government, tbh @Ferngreen .

Giving them funding or arms would surely be seen as such, as would trying to reclaim the land they've been forced from.

Andariego · 15/05/2022 16:19

@Ferngreen Why should that be a problem for the Palestinians, who had no involvement in the death camps whatsoever? Palestinians welcomed Jewish refugees with open arms in 1947 after the suffering they went through, and look how they have been treated ever since. This is what many, including myself, find so galling - how can you make millions of people suffer after your own suffered so much at the hands of others? How are millions of Israelis complicit with living in an apartheid state for their own benefit, knowing how their own people have been treated in the past? How can you believe in and fight for a state that sees no issue in killing thousands of innocents, in sterilising women without consent to ensure a pure Jewish State, who persecute and abuse on a daily basis?

There are over 5 million Palestinians currently living in the West Bank and Gaza in truly awful conditions, and each day Israelis are illegally taking more and more land and property to accommodate for their ever growing population of Jewish immigrants. Why should millions of people, who have done nothing “wrong” other than be born Palestinian, have to put up and shut up to make room for others who view them as dirt on their shoe and an inconvenience to how they want their world to ideally be? Would you “compromise” and be forced out, eventually seeing total erasure of your heritage or would you fight for the freedom of yourself, your family and for all those who have been killed at the hands of the IDF before you to try and protect your own?

MissyB1 · 15/05/2022 16:15

whilst the Holocaust was abhorrent that doesn’t give Israel the right to persecute and annex Palestine.

yep that sums it up nicely.

Daftasabroom · 15/05/2022 16:07

@Ferngreen unfortunately your knowledge of history is pretty slim. The vast majority of Jewish Israeli citizens are migrants, and while the Holocaust is abhorrent that doesn't give Israel the right to persecute and annex Palestine.

Britain has as much a hand in this as any other nation (not good BTW).

pixels123 · 15/05/2022 15:58

And can I remind you that most people who moved to Israel in recent years were not in death camps.

pixels123 · 15/05/2022 15:57

Ferngreen · 15/05/2022 15:32

We can argue and rant about what's fair and who's in the wrong til the cows come home but for all those anti Israeli - where do you suggest they move to if you want Palestine returned to the Palestinians. Who is going to take 8 million people??

The Jews went there after the war when they wanted to leave the death camps and the countries that had tried to annihilate them - it was a difficult problem - so I suppose you wanted them to stay at the deathcamps??

Imv it's like the NOrthern Ireland problem - there is no happy resolution to the problem - everyone cannot be made happy.

So you must compromise.

Palestinian terrorists desist. The UN or someone arranges a shuffling of land to allow Palestinians to return. But the terrorists won't desist. So stalemate.

It is a highly complex issue, I have debated it for years with friends.

The Palestinians have very little land left and while I do not agree with war (let's call it war and not terrorism), I'm not sure what else the Palestinians are meant to do. At the rate Israel is expanding there will be no Palestinian land left. Until the world intervenes then war will continue. Israel will win, they know this.

A 2 state solution seems the best idea, but the seed of hate is deep and I doubt it will work.

Ferngreen · 15/05/2022 15:32

We can argue and rant about what's fair and who's in the wrong til the cows come home but for all those anti Israeli - where do you suggest they move to if you want Palestine returned to the Palestinians. Who is going to take 8 million people??

The Jews went there after the war when they wanted to leave the death camps and the countries that had tried to annihilate them - it was a difficult problem - so I suppose you wanted them to stay at the deathcamps??

Imv it's like the NOrthern Ireland problem - there is no happy resolution to the problem - everyone cannot be made happy.

So you must compromise.

Palestinian terrorists desist. The UN or someone arranges a shuffling of land to allow Palestinians to return. But the terrorists won't desist. So stalemate.

Swipe left for the next trending thread