Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you've ever setup a calm down corner and what worked?

39 replies

Muststopeating · 13/05/2022 19:51

Help!

My 3.5 year old DS's constant meltdowns are going to be the end of me (and aren't making him feel good either).

I may put up another post for general parenting advice but for now I'd like to setup a calm down corner for him. (I always offer a cuddle when he's ready or try sniff the cake/blow out the candles, but often it takes him a while to be ready).

Has anyone ever done this with any success and is there anything that's worked particularly well?

I am going to put one of our beanbags in a quiet corner where neither of his sisters can bother him. Certain music can sometimes calm him down so will setup the yoto in that corner. We also have a fidget popper thing. And I plan to make one of those glitter calm down bottles.

Only other things I can think of are some sort of stress ball and/or possibly a weighted blanket (he likes to snuggle and definitely prefers our cosier and thus heavier blanket).

To the best of my knowledge he is NT. He is both very sensitive and extremely stubborn.

If you've had a calm down toy/tool that's worked really well then please help!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JulesRimetStillGleaming · 14/05/2022 13:42

To people who use a child being well behaved at nursery or school to be an indication that they "know how to behave so they should be able to do it at home", I counter with the neurodivergent experience. We want to be well behaved and as a rule, like following rules (as long as they're logical and have a clear purpose) but being in a stimulating environment with other people, lights, sounds and expectations, for any length of time saps all our energy and it makes coping with life in our home environment, where we generally feel safer and have higher expectations of comfort and safety, much harder.

A child that is 'fine' at school and has intense meltdowns at home is highly possibly autistic or ND in some way.

Not saying that OP's son might be but just setting the story straight on what neurodivergence can look like.

NotMyFinestMoment · 13/05/2022 23:16

A nice silky soft rug to walk/sit/lie on, some low lighting, pretty small coloured lights, or mood lamps, a tent/tipi, some silky soft materials/fleece, a pretty projector to project stars or something else on to the ceiling or the inside of a tent. I've found those things were very relaxing for my child (and me!).

InChocolateWeTrust · 13/05/2022 22:47

My suggestion would be to work out what does really matter to you (hitting, carseat, medicine were priorities for me) and let everything else go. When he tipped out the lego I would have said 'Oh, are we making a lovely lego clatter?' and made myself a cup of tea!

The problem with this, is it results in the children who come for a playdate and then leave the house a bomb site. You ask them to tidy up and they don't do as they are told. I don't ask them back.

InChocolateWeTrust · 13/05/2022 22:43

I do see friends with kids or won't do a single thing they are told and it fills me dread.

I completely understand this view OP, I share it. I had similar experiences to you with my elder DC at this age. I persevered with being a bit "strict" and now a couple of years on, it paid off. Like you I wanted to focus on helping DC learn to manage the emotions that arise from (let's face it) having to do as you are told when sometimes it's not what you want. DC is happy and well behaved and school/other parents comment on their good manners etc.

For complicated reasons, health related, I was more "flexible" with younger DC and their behaviour is simply worse.

Our society currently places a low value on obedience in children, but then punishes adults who haven't learned to follow rules. I'm now having to gradually take a firmer stance with second DC and it's definitely a harder problem to fix with an older child.

allboysherebutme · 13/05/2022 22:27

I used to do this when I worked in a school and it helped. X

WTF475878237NC · 13/05/2022 22:17

Makes sense. Try suggesting it as a game when he's feeling good and happy. Let's put our hands on our hearts and slow it down...There are VR /biofeedback games to teach this to kids if you have the spare cash. The unicorn can only fly when you're breathing slowly from the diaphragm etc.

Build up the skill in the calm times first and then gradually he may be able to use it earlier up the red mist scale.

VintageGibbon · 13/05/2022 22:08

Muststopeating · 13/05/2022 21:56

@VintageGibbon thank you, that's nice to know.

Did you have one each or did they share? My eldest doesn't have meltdowns but because she knows all the things she can't do when angry (i.e. hit, throw things etc) I can see that she struggles with what to do when frustrated. I wonder if she could use it too (would be far less frequent) or if it should be a space just for him?

They had one each in separate rooms, so that if they were fighting they each had a place to calm down. Weirdly, to this day (they are now adults) they gravitate towards the same chairs in the same rooms that they had as their calm places when they were toddlers. I've only just realised this, answering your question! Grin

SunnyCoco · 13/05/2022 22:05

Hi OP

Just wanted to send you some support as I think you sound like you're trying really hard and you sound like a kind and caring parent

You're doing the right things, I'm sure - I think it's just hard with a workaholic partner and 3 kiddos under 5.

Keep being kind and calm and I hope things will ease for you x

Muststopeating · 13/05/2022 21:56

@VintageGibbon thank you, that's nice to know.

Did you have one each or did they share? My eldest doesn't have meltdowns but because she knows all the things she can't do when angry (i.e. hit, throw things etc) I can see that she struggles with what to do when frustrated. I wonder if she could use it too (would be far less frequent) or if it should be a space just for him?

OP posts:
Muststopeating · 13/05/2022 21:53

@carefullycourageous totally agree about the sliding scale and you are right, mine needs to be adjusted.

@WTF475878237NC ooo I like the socks, junkmail idea they are brilliant. We do try breathing, but he only wants to do that at the point when he's decided he wants to calm down but is struggling to (if that makes sense). Then I sit and do thst with him while holding his hands or cuddling him.

OP posts:
PinkBuffalo · 13/05/2022 21:53

Weighted blanket and big soft toys to hug and squash
I am mid - late 30s these things still help me. Also snacks are good

itsgettingweird · 13/05/2022 21:47

WhatTheWhoTheWhatThe · 13/05/2022 20:11

I’d put the bean bag in a tent/make shift den. Some children like sensory light toys, weighted blanket (no more than 10% of his body weight) or a Lycra body sock, stress ball is good too but also a box of just different tactile items some kids like to squish others like soft materials to run their hands over.

Agree with all this.

The tents work well because they block all external influences

WTF475878237NC · 13/05/2022 21:47

Haven't rtft but have had success with things in the den like rolled up socks to throw about, bubbles to blow and practice deep breathing until they pop/hit the floor, junk mail to rip up etc... basically physical ways to let off steam and then emotionally regulate.

How to talk so kids will listen and listen so kids will talk is good. As is the book you wish your parents had read. Improving your own management of emotions and keeping things focused on the positive is really important.

Best of luck.

carefullycourageous · 13/05/2022 21:46

I really don't want to be in control. But I do see friends with kids or won't do a single thing they are told and it fills me dread.

Earlier I nearly posted 'what are you afraid will happen if you stop trying to control him?' and then didn't because I worried I sounded like a pop psychologist.

It is a sliding scale, not a binary choice between total control and a total tearaway. My suggestion would be to work out what does really matter to you (hitting, carseat, medicine were priorities for me) and let everything else go. When he tipped out the lego I would have said 'Oh, are we making a lovely lego clatter?' and made myself a cup of tea!

VintageGibbon · 13/05/2022 21:45

I did. An armchair with a blanket, cushions, soft toys, favourite picture books and a little table beside it with room for a drink and snack. If DSs ever had melt downs I'd very gently suggest they snuggled down until they felt calm. Usually worked really quickly. Teaching them to self-regulate their emotions and soothe themselves out of anger and distress is really productive. We never had teenage tantrums either. They knew how to destress.

Muststopeating · 13/05/2022 21:41

@MakeItRain i do use the choices thing for getting ready etc... so socks or trousers first etc, but its a good point and I should think about how I can use it more. I definitely think he needs to feel in control and to @carefullycourageous point then I guess we are clashing there.

Lots of great suggestions there and a few we don't have. Will see how he feels about the concept of the space generally and then look at adding some of these.

OP posts:
Muststopeating · 13/05/2022 21:38

SafelySoftly · 13/05/2022 21:29

Is he a good sleeper? Assuming he’s NT then I think sleep/not doing too much stuff is key.

@SafelySoftly yes he is. He generally sleeps 11.5 - 12 hours a night.

If he has had a bad night for any reason then I am always mindful that tiredness will make him much more emotive and avoid extra battles. Plan in more quiet time etc. He does 3 days a week at nursery and we always know the end of day 2 will be epic so I/we try to make it easier.

OP posts:
Muststopeating · 13/05/2022 21:34

@carefullycourageous you know I thought about that as I wrote it and I do know how it sounds. But I swear I am mostly quite calm.

I genuinely think its more to do with the fact he had such a solid understanding of right and wrong. And violence is one thing Ive always had zero tolerance for. (The consequence is a time out on the thinking step but I've always been consistent about it).

I take on board your points and @bellac11 about not worthwhile battles and will reevaluate what's important. It is absolutely true that the tantrum is worse than picking up the lego. It is also very valid that the initial warning is negative and I should reconsider that approach. (Also hadn't thought of freezing bananas which will make me feel much better about that). As I said I don't make them finish their dinner.

I do work hard to encourage and praise nice behaviours. The kids are brillaint at sharing and generally play really well together (until tiredness/hunger etc kicks in) and also quite good at compromising with each other and with me. They are kind, caring, compassionate kids. If I can just help him find a way to cope with these big feelings then they'd be positively easy.

I do accept that I am part of the problem here. And I definitely could have avoided some of todays meltdowns. But other days we can be having a lovrly day, everything has gone his way and I'll look up as he's walking into the room and he'll completely lose it because he was playing a hiding game or something.

I really don't want to be in control. But I do see friends with kids or won't do a single thing they are told and it fills me dread.

OP posts:
SafelySoftly · 13/05/2022 21:29

Is he a good sleeper? Assuming he’s NT then I think sleep/not doing too much stuff is key.

Muststopeating · 13/05/2022 21:21

@Siameasy @TheVolturi thanks. Great siggestions. Will look into them. And can completely picture the launching of the jar. That must have been grim.

OP posts:
carefullycourageous · 13/05/2022 21:20

I'm not wanting to be unkind OP but I think you should have a think if the cause of the tantrums is your attempts to control and if you let go a bit and are less strict, things might calm down and ultimately be easier.

This is not great sounding: Truggers tend to be knowing he's done slmething wrong (i.e. if he hurts his baby sister by accident he gets very worked up before I've said a word) as he is worrying about your reaction here.

Muststopeating · 13/05/2022 21:16

@Mrsteapot42 i think I need to educate myself more as I would say he doesn't fit with my udnerstanding of autisim but I may well be very ignorant.

He is extremely affectionate, has huge amounts of empathy and can read emotions incredibly well.

He does hugely overthink things, if we watch a film or even read a new book he gets very very invested and asks a phenomenal amount of questions and gets almost nervous about what's coming. He is intensely stubborn (which is why standoffs are a bad move and asking him to do something, explaining the consequences and walking away works better but still stresses him out).

Truggers tend to be knowing he's done slmething wrong (i.e. if he hurts his baby sister by accident he gets very worked up before I've said a word), too many people (though this seems to only be at our house, he's fine in a supermarket or soft play etc so I think its when those people might all want to talk to him). Or the panic of a timedown situation, but if i never time bound anything then nothing would be done.

OP posts:
MakeItRain · 13/05/2022 21:14

Sometimes, when it comes to the ultimatums it can help to give a "choice" of two possibilities. Neither of which might be appealling (and both are something you want to happen) but making the choice can give more of a feeling of control (not saying it always helps, but I have seen this work). Also lots of children manage at school or nursery because they can be so much more structured and routine driven, but also because children mask their anxieties there but feel much more secure with letting them out at home.

In terms of calming objects - Some children love music via headphones/ stress type "puzzles" or fidget spinners/ fish tanks to watch/ rain shakers/ kaleidoscopes/ keys and padlocks/ sorting toys or cars/Playdough or plasticine/ torches/ a tray of lavender/mint etc. Basically sensory experiences can often help with calming. (Though some will want to avoid different sensory experiences so it's often a case of try it and see.)

bellac11 · 13/05/2022 21:11

I dont think those are worthwhile battles at his age. If he wants a banana and only eats half, so what, I dont always finish all my dinner either, he'll soon learn how much he can manage

Similarly with the lego, I think a 'warning' is a big negative, why not encourage playtime with the lego but weave the tidying up into the playing as you go without it being so 'heavy'

carefullycourageous · 13/05/2022 21:10

Muststopeating · 13/05/2022 21:07

@carefullycourageous so the standoffs will be something like... he's about to empty an entire box of lego (just for kicks, not to play with). I will warn him that if he does that then he will have to tidy it up. I will warn him several times. If he does it anyway then I will make him tidy it up.

Or tonight, he wanted a banana. I suggested that he have half. He wanted a whole one. I said that wss fine but if he had it, he had to eat it because we don't wsste food. So he had to sit until he'd finished it. I only do that in very specific circumstances. I never make them finish their dinner (bht don't offer alternatives and encourage them to try everything etc).

I 100% believe in picking my battles. And I do try not to present an ultimatum if its not worth it or important. I al also very consistent at giving warnings before the end of an activity or before getting ready etc. But he's testing and testing more and more and blatantly ignoring me at times. So at what point is it flexibility vs just giving in.

I am very open to new approaches and auggestions. I will ask the nursery more specifically about their approach to getting things done.

I have 3 under 5, a DH who works away and a job so my patience is not always on point, but I am trying.

These two things are not things I would pick a battle over. I don;t think nursery would either.

I think maybe you should rethink.

Tipping lego out - normal - just cheerfully get him to tidy up later.
Eating half a banana - normal - just freeze the other half and shove in a smoothie later.

I get that you are stressed but surely these meltdowns are more tiring than putting some lego back in the box?

Swipe left for the next trending thread