Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the estate agent should pay.

115 replies

Theheartandtheshape · 13/05/2022 13:48

Moved in 1 year ago and have been such a good tenant that I've just signed for another 12 months at the same rate.

I don't have any contact with the landlord, it is all done via the estate agent.

Before I moved in, I mentioned on the offer form that I have a hamster. I had permission verbally confirmed by the estate agent at the viewing. I followed this up with an email before signing the lease, stating that I wanted to bring my hamster with me, that I had verbal permission but I wanted to check this was OK before signing. The response was "Yes this is correct". The entire content of my email was about the hamster, there were no other questions or issues that "yes this is correct" could have referred to.

I had an inspection 1 week ago and the woman contracted to do the inspection even asked if I wanted to hide the hamster from the photos. I said no, it's all above board, I have consent.

Received an email today from the estate agent from quite a snotty woman who told me that the landlord was concerned seeing the photos, as she was unaware of the hamster and it might invalidate her insurance. The buildings management company have said she needs to pay them £90. I explained that I had permission from the estate agent to keep the hamster and there is no way I'm paying £90. The woman said I have to pay or get rid of my pet.

I forwarded the email chain where the estate agent confirmed permission for a hamster, and the estate agent is now doubling down and saying that because the email doesn't say "the landlord has given permission" it isn't legally binding.

This seems insane and a semantic argument to me.

My view is the estate agent fucked up by not informing the landlord, clearly their employee wanted me to sign the lease last year and didn't speak to the landlord to get permission for the hamster first.

I feel misled, stressed and angry that the landlord will now be angry at me. I also don't have £90.

I've asked the manager to contact me. I hate conflict. Do you think the estate agent should pay the fee, and apologise to me and the landlord?

OP posts:
Foolsrule · 13/05/2022 16:53

name and shame!

RandomUser10093 · 13/05/2022 16:53

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 13/05/2022 16:47

Tell them to pay you the £90 up front and then you'll pay the LL. Or tell them you already have paid so they send you the £90 and then pay LL.

I had a similar issue in a previous flat I rented but I didn't actually ask permission. The previous tenants had a dog so I didn't think the hamster was an issue tbh but it seems it was. Fair enough this was my fuck up but I just told them the hamster was dead and I just hasn't got round to getting rid of the cage.

SlipperyLizard · 13/05/2022 16:44

We rented a house which had been totally gutted & refurbished. When we viewed there were no curtains on the windows, and I asked agent if they were going to be fitted before we moved in, as wouldn’t want to buy them ourselves. Agent said yes. We moved in, no curtains.

Both we & landlord v cross - we’d made it clear we wouldn’t buy, landlord had no intention of fitting them. Agent was basically reckless as to the truth. Agent paid for the curtains.

Agent should pay the £90, as they misled you in saying there was consent.

TheFlis12345 · 13/05/2022 16:41

I would give them you bank details to pay the £90 and tell them you will pass it on once received, just to close the matter. They will say you need to pay first but refuse and say you have acted in good faith previously based on things in writing that they have later denied so you are not prepared to again.

Regularsizedrudy · 13/05/2022 16:39

I would want evidence they had notified the landlord it was THEIR error. Cheeky gits.

gracedentssketty · 13/05/2022 16:38

The estate agent is the landlords agent and was acting as such - the agent had actual or ostensible authority to agree this and did so and you have it in writing. The agent should pay the £90

Leftbutcameback · 13/05/2022 16:25

Living not loving! 😆

purpleme12 · 13/05/2022 16:25

I just wouldn't trust them to refund it at all after the debacle with the emails

Leftbutcameback · 13/05/2022 16:25

And you're right OP, they can't evict you. The biggest risk is at the next renewal in terms of rent increase so it depends how much you like your home and want to keep loving there (with your Cricetinae)

Leftbutcameback · 13/05/2022 16:18

Leaving aside the rights (OP) and wrongs (EA) of this, in order to move forward I would be agreeing to the EA proposal but I would want them to confirm if it's going to be an annual charge, and if so are they going to continue to refund it.

Theheartandtheshape · 13/05/2022 16:12

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 13/05/2022 15:53

So you're saying my landlord might evict me because my estate agent fucked up? And that it's legal to be made homeless because a landlord is "annoyed"?

Outside of Scotland? Yes. A no fault S21 is still perfectly legal. And the 'annoyance' caused by a rodent coudl be very costly. Whether you want to accept that or not.

I am not saying anyone has acted well in this, not the Agent, not you (well your current outrage is blinding you to common sense in my opinion - here if not in real life), not the landlord really! But there does have to be a compromise that everyone can live with. You might get lucky, the landlord might choose to absorb the additional cost themselves. If they were posting here I would be advising them to do that as it would be the easiest resolution. But they don't have to.

Someone has to give and at £90 it isn't the most expensive solution for anyone!

You're wrong.

"You can use a Section 21 notice to evict your tenants either:

after a fixed term tenancy ends - if there’s a written contract
during a tenancy with no fixed end date - known as a ‘periodic’ tenancy"

A landlord can't just kick you out mid contract for no reason.

OP posts:
SolasAnla · 13/05/2022 16:02

Theheartandtheshape · 13/05/2022 15:32

Update!

Manager called and stated that my offer form asked permission and the emails were evidence. Apologised.

But she said they can't pay the management company directly and I'll have to pay the fee, then the estate agent will refund me.

Not happy. I suggested the landlord pay the company and the agent refund the landlord. But they didn't go for that.

You have no contractual obligation to anyone other than the landlord.

I would write back and say that you view any discussion between the Landlord and an other party to be private business correspondance. That negotiations involving the contractual relationship between the Landlord and an other party should not involve you as the tenant. That any payments due would remain a private business matter for your Landlord. You believe that it would not be proper for you to be involved in any agreement between the landlord and management company.

Therefore you trust that the agent will cease to enter into correspondance with you on this matter.

Or pay the money yourselves.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 13/05/2022 15:53

So you're saying my landlord might evict me because my estate agent fucked up? And that it's legal to be made homeless because a landlord is "annoyed"?

Outside of Scotland? Yes. A no fault S21 is still perfectly legal. And the 'annoyance' caused by a rodent coudl be very costly. Whether you want to accept that or not.

I am not saying anyone has acted well in this, not the Agent, not you (well your current outrage is blinding you to common sense in my opinion - here if not in real life), not the landlord really! But there does have to be a compromise that everyone can live with. You might get lucky, the landlord might choose to absorb the additional cost themselves. If they were posting here I would be advising them to do that as it would be the easiest resolution. But they don't have to.

Someone has to give and at £90 it isn't the most expensive solution for anyone!

Purplespup16 · 13/05/2022 15:52

I’d reply back once more with something along the lines of this below, then don’t reply to any other emails and save ALL the emails! She’s trying to harangue you into compliance.

Dear X,

As stated in previous emails, permission was sought and obtained in written form in the form of email, received from [email protected] on this date at this time as I have provided. I will not being paying any fee with regards to said hamster. I will not reply to any other correspondence or phone calls regarding this matter.

Sincerely,
TheHearandtheShape

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 13/05/2022 15:49

Nocutenamesleft · 13/05/2022 15:44

I used to be a lettings agent

Im almost certain there is no ‘clause’ in the insurance that a hamster would change!

I woild also get them to look at the admin fee. The only thing I could possibly think would be an admin fee for the new year contract

but if this had been me. It would of been my fault and I would take it on the chin. You’ve got written proof and all you have to say is how was I to know you hadn’t got confirmation that the landlord said it was ok.

they’re talking out of their ass basically.

Yes, the Agent is.

But the Landlord has a point. And OP will need to make this issue go away for the landlord to be able to relaxe about it. The Agent's email seems reasonable to me. They are owning the error.

They are still asking for a banned fee though. So OP could just say no.

But then the landlord will be entitled to increase the rent a little bit more than they would have done otherwise. Which will cost more in the long run. Or to issue a S21 and get a tenant without a pet, as per the various isues raised.

OP has choices.

As does the landlord!

Theheartandtheshape · 13/05/2022 15:46

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 13/05/2022 15:44

This is the common sense approach rather than the standing on your perceived rights approach. I did supply links that explained what I meant.

The main difference is agreeing a compromise that is relatively cheap and remaining in the property or refusing and being given a no fault S21 because you have annoyed the landlord. Especially a landlord who has cause to be annoyed and is not being unreasonable.

So you're saying my landlord might evict me because my estate agent fucked up? And that it's legal to be made homeless because a landlord is "annoyed"?

OP posts:
pedropony76 · 13/05/2022 15:45

Soubriquet · 13/05/2022 14:24

If they are that insistent, say you rehomed the hamster and hide it every time.

We aren’t supposed to have a cat. The dogs are fine but the last tenant had a cat that weed on their new carpets.

Whenever we have a house inspection, we bundle them cat and all cat related products in the car and one person stays with the house whilst the other drives off with the cat.

4 years later, and they are still none the wiser.

My cat is fully litter trained. She has not ever weed on a carpet

I don’t know why this made me laugh so much😂

I’m just imagining one person staying at home for the inspection whilst one drives off with the cat🤣

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 13/05/2022 15:45

purpleme12 · 13/05/2022 15:42

@SamphirethePogoingStickerist but OP didn't lie!!

And I didn't say she had!

But other posters suggested it... and other daft actions too!

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 13/05/2022 15:44

Theheartandtheshape · 13/05/2022 15:39

Sorry what is this? Why should my rent increase by £90 because I have a hamster I already had written permission to keep?

This is the common sense approach rather than the standing on your perceived rights approach. I did supply links that explained what I meant.

The main difference is agreeing a compromise that is relatively cheap and remaining in the property or refusing and being given a no fault S21 because you have annoyed the landlord. Especially a landlord who has cause to be annoyed and is not being unreasonable.

Nocutenamesleft · 13/05/2022 15:44

I used to be a lettings agent

Im almost certain there is no ‘clause’ in the insurance that a hamster would change!

I woild also get them to look at the admin fee. The only thing I could possibly think would be an admin fee for the new year contract

but if this had been me. It would of been my fault and I would take it on the chin. You’ve got written proof and all you have to say is how was I to know you hadn’t got confirmation that the landlord said it was ok.

they’re talking out of their ass basically.

purpleme12 · 13/05/2022 15:44

I cannot believe these agents!
There's no way you should pay it if it's their error!
And no way you can trust them to refund you it either!

SarahSissions · 13/05/2022 15:42

The management company will have a generic pet policy written to cover mainly cats and dogs that will just want the animal to be identifiable so they can issue permission for that animal (rather than general permission for all animals) which is why they want breed and gender.

the admin fee is fairly typical to cover the work required by an individual property so it isn’t paid for by the whole block. It’s between you and the EA who pays it but it sounds like they are going to grant permission so I’d just give what they want.

I don’t know why when they woman suggested you move the cage for a photo you wouldn’t just yo avoid highlighting the issue again.

naomi81 · 13/05/2022 15:42

Have you read your contract? That's you read and signed

purpleme12 · 13/05/2022 15:42

@SamphirethePogoingStickerist but OP didn't lie!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread