Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed by the term sperms donor?

83 replies

Thousandsandhundreds · 13/05/2022 12:56

Recently I've noticed lots of people calling bad fathers sperm donors. My friend jane who has had a falling out with her dad has taken to calling him to her donor. She will say "oh my bloody sperm donor has done ..." He was present throughout her childhood, she turned low contact as an adult due to a big argument

I've always felt it was a bit odd but never said anything as her personal choice of defining her relationship.

Recently her and a group of friends were having a moan about one of the groups exhusband. Jane said "he's just a sperm donor at this point" and the group started to refer to him as her donor rather than exhusband

Eventually at the school gates this mum said to someone else "my kids donor is such a pain" in a jokey way but in earshot of her son

When alone.I said she maybe shouldn't call him that in ear shot of her kid, she said I was uptight and pointed out its fairly common.

I explained that my daughter is donor conceived (which she knew) and that we didn't want her to think a donor is a negative thing. Her donor isn't a bad parent, he is someone who entered into a specific arrangement which didn't including parenting. In my head thats very different to someone who was part of the family unit then didn't fulfill their role, and is simply a poor parent. My daughter for example has conversations about her donor, and hangs out with other donor kids as her situation of having limited medical info, the bio parent link etc is something id think of as specific to donor kids

Since then I've noticed that it is common online, and amongst some of my younger friends.

Since then its clear that they think I was being picky.

Aibu to think its odd to refer to your child's parent as a sperm donor if they aren't?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SmallThingsEverywhere · 15/05/2022 23:45

Holly60 · 15/05/2022 18:29

No because a sperm donor is someone who donated sperm in an arrangement where all parties knew and planned for his involvement to be limited to that donation. For women and couples who have used a sperm donor, that man's role in their lives will be seen to have given a wonderful gift.

An absent father is someone who had sex with a child's mother and now has nothing to do with the resultant child. In a number of cases, the child was planned with the mother believing that the father would take on an equal role and has therefore been disappointed. This often means the absence of the father has a negative impact on the woman.

Two totally different situations.

I was looking at this from the child’s point of view, maybe I should have clarified. They still wont have their biological father involved in their upbringing and this can cause so much emotional damage. I know.
I have a friend who found out that they were the result of sperm donation and it has caused no end of issues for him. He feels completely lost and is abandoned by his father(he calls his sperm donor, his father) and is NC with his biological mum and the man he thought was his father.

SarahAndQuack · 15/05/2022 18:42

Pinkdelight3 · 15/05/2022 14:36

Well, no, because those examples are about facts, biological taxonomy, whereas the disparaging epithet sperm donor is figurative. You know what it means. We just disagree on whether it's okay or not, which is fine.

The OP's precise point is that a small child probably does not know that it's figurative.

That is exactly what she is talking about.

A small child will hear all of these negative references to 'sperm donors' and won't think 'ooh, goodness, what an interesting figurative reference'. They will simply think 'why does that woman think sperm donors are bad? What is bad about me then?'

Holly60 · 15/05/2022 18:31

SmallThingsEverywhere · 13/05/2022 14:09

But a sperm donor is purposefully helping to create a child, that they know they will be abandoning. An absent father also abandons a child. Calling them an official sperm donor makes no difference if the result is the same.

But all parties involved know a sperm donor will not be involved, right from before the baby is conceived.

With absent fathers, it's often not the case. Hence the disgruntlement of women who thought they were having a baby as part of a couple.

Holly60 · 15/05/2022 18:29

SmallThingsEverywhere · 13/05/2022 13:53

What’s the difference between a sperm donor and a man who has no involvement in his children’s lives. They amount to are the same thing.

No because a sperm donor is someone who donated sperm in an arrangement where all parties knew and planned for his involvement to be limited to that donation. For women and couples who have used a sperm donor, that man's role in their lives will be seen to have given a wonderful gift.

An absent father is someone who had sex with a child's mother and now has nothing to do with the resultant child. In a number of cases, the child was planned with the mother believing that the father would take on an equal role and has therefore been disappointed. This often means the absence of the father has a negative impact on the woman.

Two totally different situations.

Mumoblue · 15/05/2022 18:12

I can understand why you would find it annoying.
Personally I think if it’s not in front of the kids, single parents can vent however they like.

It’s not a term I use about my kid’s dad, though. Mostly because I’d rather not think about his sperm ever again.

ohdear10 · 15/05/2022 18:09

This is the same level of annoyance as mothers whose partner works away saying they're like a single parent. Maybe. Probably not even as bad.

ohdear10 · 15/05/2022 18:07

Yabu
It's referring to the fact that they deposited sperm and didn't bring the child up, it has nothing to do with clinical donors. Some people who've used donors may be touchy, but it has nothing to do with you... I don't understand why this would take up this much headspace.

It's obvious that's it's said in an entirely different context. It might be mildly annoying. I can't imagine being bothered for more than a few seconds.

Norgie · 15/05/2022 18:07

@PortiaFimbriata A friend of mine refers to her ex as The Sperminator which makes me giggle.

Thousandsandhundreds · 15/05/2022 17:59

@Pinkdelight3
It's the fact it's being considered as a way to disparage someone and as a disparaging term for bad dads

OP posts:
Pinkdelight3 · 15/05/2022 14:36

Well, no, because those examples are about facts, biological taxonomy, whereas the disparaging epithet sperm donor is figurative. You know what it means. We just disagree on whether it's okay or not, which is fine.

SarahAndQuack · 14/05/2022 14:23

Pinkdelight3 · 14/05/2022 14:00

misuse of actual words

I guess this is where we disagree. I think they're different uses, not right and wrong, and I'm not in favour of policing other people's language to this extent.

But they're not.

I'm all for language being flexible and not policing other's words, but you're not talking about a situation where you can kind of see why someone calls a pelargonium a geranium and you can kind of see why, you're talking about someone saying 'well I'm going to call cows swans now, so they are just different uses and there's no right and wrong'.

A dad who buggers off is not a sperm donor.

Pinkdelight3 · 14/05/2022 14:00

misuse of actual words

I guess this is where we disagree. I think they're different uses, not right and wrong, and I'm not in favour of policing other people's language to this extent.

JudyJ · 14/05/2022 09:29

Agree, JulesRimet! My objection isn't about "taking offence", it's about my 4 year old (who is just starting to become aware his family is "different" although we have talked about it since birth) hearing this sort of talk and getting confused and negative ideas about the nature of his birth. Or thinking that other kids are donor conceived (I'm trying really hard to make sure he knows other children in the same situation) when their situation isn't the same at all (has similarities, sure, but not the same). Donor conception comes with loads of complexities and I've spent hours reading about it, attending implications counselling, and thinking carefully about the language I use and how to talk about it with my son - having others use the term carelessly and incorrectly in front of him undermines this.

I'm not in anyway trying to take away from those who have been abandoned by a partner or a parent, that obviously comes with its own difficulties and complexities but you can't say it's the same because it just isn't, no matter how much you try to say it is.

JulesRimetStillGleaming · 14/05/2022 07:57

Agree with you. Am also trying to conceive with an actual sperm donor and the difference between that and a failed relationship is stark and important. If I do have donor conceived children, I wouldn't want them hearing this way if talking. It's also terrible for the children to hear their other parent being talked about like this.

Bizawit · 13/05/2022 22:12

PortiaFimbriata · 13/05/2022 20:05

Could we make a push for adopting Sperm Dumper? Expresses the sentiment without the positive connotations of "donor"

Brilliant 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 This is much more factually accurate

Bizawit · 13/05/2022 22:06

SmallThingsEverywhere · 13/05/2022 14:54

I’m saying the result is the same. In both situations both fathers could be called sperm donors.

But the result isn’t remotely the same. One results in a broken family, betrayal, heartache.
The other results in joy and gratitude: providing a couple or single woman the option to have a family.

GeraltsLeftPec · 13/05/2022 21:53

I never saw it this way til I read your post. I'll never use the term this way again. I'm glad I've seen your post - thank you. X ps you're definitely not being unreasonable, this is a really good point.

SarahAndQuack · 13/05/2022 21:41

Grin Sperm dumper is genius! Though does risk sounding like something evangelical Christians would say about the evils of masturbation.

But, @KettrickenSmiled, what do you mean by 'the positive kind of donation'? There's sperm donation (which of course could be a positive of negative experience for all sorts of reasons, and could be part of a very sad situation or part of a very happy one). And there's having a biological male parent who fucks off. The latter is not any kind of 'donation'.

JumpingPiglets · 13/05/2022 21:17

I agree OP. My son is a donor baby. Sperm donors do a wonderful and generous thing; no-one is left in the lurch, or deceived. I think it is ghastly and horrible to appropriate this term for men who abandon their children

KettrickenSmiled · 13/05/2022 20:45

I don't agree with the fact that it's seen as the worst possible thing you could call your parent

But this is a whole new level of semantics! - because I don't see the (benign, clinical) sperm donor as a parent.
Biologically - yes, But in any other sense? No.

My beloved (step)dad was very much a parent. My birth father? - not at all.
I'm sticking with Sperm Dumper for him - it's brilliant, & makes a clear differentiation between benign or neglectful/abusive 'donation'.

KettrickenSmiled · 13/05/2022 20:41

@PortiaFimbriata -Sperm Dumper is actually perfect!

AND, surely, pleases both sides of this fence?

KettrickenSmiled · 13/05/2022 20:39

I guess this my point though. Sperm donation shouldn't be used as a way to express hurt and disappointment? I don't agree with the fact that it's seen as the worst possible thing you could call your parent

My male parent was what PP would negatively call a sperm donor, Thousands,
In what way does your distaste for the term outweigh my (& my mother's) dismay, hurt, & in her case financial & emotional deprivation, if I chose to use the term about him?

fwiw I don't - if I refer to him, it tends to be "the man who attended my conception." Is that ok with you - because your clinical sperm donor did not?

AnuSTart · 13/05/2022 20:07

People can call their exes whatever the f they like. Ideally not in front of the kids. I would judge that.

PortiaFimbriata · 13/05/2022 20:05

Could we make a push for adopting Sperm Dumper? Expresses the sentiment without the positive connotations of "donor"

SarahAndQuack · 13/05/2022 20:01

Pinkdelight3 · 13/05/2022 19:55

But this is exactly the same thing - this exact phrase describes both a deadbeat dad or the nice sperm donor. So this just demonstrates it's not about the words you use but the context in which you use them. Using the same words for a different thing doesn't intrinsically imply comparison. They are not talking about the OP or their DC and taking offence at it is just looking for problems.

No, it doesn't.

Do you really not get that they're different?

You could also describe the male surgeon who did a c-section as 'the man who contributed towards my birth'. Or the IVF tech. Or the bloke who introduced you to your wife. Just because someone's come up with a very bland statement (which, obviously, is comforting in its blandness to them), doesn't mean you've proved some deep, meaningful point about misuse of actual words.

Swipe left for the next trending thread