Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Why don't/can't you just..."

26 replies

HangingOver · 13/05/2022 11:44

I am prepared to hear that IABU as:

a) I hear this expression all the time and
b) I've never heard of anyone else be irritated by it!

...but, AIBU to find the expression 'Why can't you/we just...' a bit patronising? There's a guy at work that says this ALL this time, often in relation to things he doesn't know much about.

In fact, now I think of it, more often than not, when I hear this expression, the speaker is usually suggesting an overly simple solution to a problem, which I've already thought of and discounted/taken into account.

And even if the person has a point that's not been thought of... I think I usually would say something like, "Ah ok, so the system doesn't allow us to do X. That's a shame".

Or am I just being prickly?

OP posts:
Mariposista · 13/05/2022 12:00

This really irritates me too as it seem like disrespect for my decision or situation.
Two examples which annoyed me that I can think of.

My dear 90 year old gran had an exemption from wearing a mask as she has breathing problems caused by her heart condition. And people would say 'couldn't she try/can't you just (insert solution)'. NO! Exemption is exemption, and it's causing her enough stress as it is.

I was recently in the garage having my car mirror put back on after some charming sod yanked it off overnight in the car park. Someone via WhatsApp asked if I could email them a document, and I said I can't atm but I can in 1 hour when I will be home. 'Can't you just do it on the phone?' I HAVE SAID I CAN'T SO RESPECT THAT!