Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this woman is stupid

407 replies

Wellyboots12 · 13/05/2022 10:36

A few weeks ago I contacted a woman to inform her about her new boyfriends history, they had been together about two weeks at this point so by no means a serious established relationship. He has convictions for domestic abuse, 4 of his children were removed from their mother because of violence toward her from him - one incident saw the then baby caught in the cross fire and hit when he hit the mother.

That woman aside, he has beaten every woman he has ever been in a relationship with. He threw another ex down the stairs infront of her children, and headbutted another woman whilst she was holding her child. He served time in prison.

I sent her screenshots of articles printed in the newspaper and told her about all of the other information I knew. I urged her to do a claires law check if she had any doubts about anything I was telling her, as everything would be on there.

She was receptive and thanked me for letting her know, said she was gobsmacked but wouldn't stand for any of that. She's a professional woman and has had dealings with domestic abuse in her work life.

Fast forward to now and they're all over social media loved up and going on weekend breaks.

AIBU to think she's stupid?

I know only too well how hard it is to break away from an abusive relationship when you've been together for a long time, but if I knew any of this when I met my abuser (different man) I would have been running for the hills.

OP posts:
Wellyboots12 · 13/05/2022 12:23

I've just had a look and she does have children, though they seem to be upper teens / almost adults so sadly social services wouldn't have any interest.

Still, it's all very shit that they are about to witness their mother go through what she will.

I'll have to leave it be now I agree. I wasn't going to contact her a second time anyway. What I would have done was flagged my concerns with social services if her DC were kids, but as they don't seem to be there's nothing more I can do.

I wish her luck, she's going to need it.

OP posts:
Freetodowhatiwant · 13/05/2022 12:23

I had a situation recently where I emailed the new girlfriend (well, according to him this weekend when I accidentally bumped into him he still isn't seeing her as a 'girlfriend') of an ex. I had been sleeping with him too but he had been 'honest' with me about several other people he was sleeping with.

I thought she deserved to know as she technically had only seen him for a couple of months and lived abroad so still had time to more easily detach herself. He and I had been officially boyfriend and girlfriend for 6 months before I found out about him being unfaithful and then had another 3 months of on/off during which time he met her and was sleeping with others.

He is furious with me as he says I have behaved very badly by telling her. I am furious with him as he was lying to everyone, having sex with others and also not always using condoms. She is still continuing to see him. He is definitely still up to his old tricks, as he told me as much when I bumped into him last weekend. I was tempted to do an AIBU to see if people thought I had done the right/wrong thing by emailing her (given that he is so adamant it was the wrong thing) but I feel happy having told everyone the truth. She is being manipulated by him, I am sure, into thinking I am lying and 'the crazy ex' but I am comfortable in the fact I have told the truth and am moving on. I feel a bit sorry for her as she will be in the position I was with him, wondering where he is when he disappears some nights, being love-bombed into thinking she is special to him.

She has chosen to see me as the bad person for telling her rather than see him as the bad person for cheating. I am glad I told her but I can't control what she does with the info.

FabulousKilljoys · 13/05/2022 12:23

I’d like to think that if I was in her shoes I’d have the strength to heed your warnings and move on.

She's been with him 2 weeks. It hardly takes 'strength' to quit a 2 week 'relationship'. Christ 2 weeks into my relationships we'd only been on a couple of dates and I wasn't even sure they were for me!

HRTQueen · 13/05/2022 12:22

I don’t think she is stupid making the wrong decisions yes

he would have probably started already with the lines this relationship is so different to the others

he will be masterful at manipulation no one is immune to being manipulated

PoseyFlump · 13/05/2022 12:21

I'd be using a word a lot stronger than stupid if she has children. IMO anything that happened to them after your warning would be neglect.

BetsHilton · 13/05/2022 12:21

It sounds like @Fullsomefrenchie and @PumpkinsandKittens are the kind of women who would shout abuse at any woman who tried to say anything about ‘their man’ and so wouldn’t listen to a word the op is saying similar to this woman.

All their posts are trying to find something ‘odd’ about the op or making weird connections/ trying to make her out to be some kind of social media stalker so they can dismiss what she’s actually saying which is that factually this man is a abuser and this woman is staying with him regardless which yes is completely stupid and foolish.

YANBU @Wellyboots12 you did your best.

ZealAndArdour · 13/05/2022 12:19

You have done the right thing OP. I’d like to think that if I was in her shoes I’d have the strength to heed your warnings and move on.

Perhaps she already feels unsafe and she doesn’t want to rock the boat, but she’s looking for her out, or trying to find a way to make him lose interest so he thinks it’s his idea to end things.

Lots of women enter into relationships with these men thinking they’ll be the one that changes him, the ego (or the love bombing) let’s them believe he wouldn’t treat them that way, and that there must have been something wrong with those other women that he abused, that they did something to deserve it or they’re lesser in some way. It’s foolish, but complex.

FabulousKilljoys · 13/05/2022 12:19

Wellyboots12 · 13/05/2022 11:56

I do acknowledge that stupid was a harsh word to use and perhaps it's not fair to call somebody stupid. I woukdnt say that to her diredtly but can't help but think it.

I don't think it's harsh at all. And I would absolutely tell someone they're stupid to their face. If I said hey don't go in that house the floor is about to give way, and someone said oh no it's fine and they went in, I'd tell them they were bloody stupid and have zero sympathy if they broke their neck.

TyrannosaurusRegina · 13/05/2022 12:16

You tried to do the right thing and good for you for looking out for other women. Yes, I agree she's stupid, it's not like she was in a long term relationship and faced with this info - it was 2 weeks in, she could have just cut him off without a second thought. Frustrating but I'd just leave it now, you've done all you can.

namechangetheworld · 13/05/2022 12:13

MNetters tossing around phrases like "victim blaming" and "abusive" in an attempt to one-up the OP is getting really tedious, especially since neither of them apply here.

The woman is not a victim (yet) and the OP is not being abusive towards her by pointing out that she's stupid to ignore this man's past. She is being incredibly foolish, and I pray she doesn't have children. You did the right thing OP.

BewareTheBeardedDragon · 13/05/2022 12:10

I'm astounded and horrified by many posts on this thread attacking you either directly or indirectly for telling her OP. How depressing that this attitude is apparently so common.

Clare's law exists for exactly this reason - to try to prevent further harm by a violent man by arming women with the knowledge of his crimes. Of course you were right to warn her. From her response it is clear that she is deluded and believes that she can prevent it happening to her. This belief makes her vulnerable and sadly she will learn that she cannot protect herself. She's not stupid persay - but she is pursuing an undeniably stupid course of action by continuing to associate with him knowing what she now does.

I wish I'd known at the outset what my ex was like. I hope that if I'd known I would not have pursued the relationship.

BellePeppa · 13/05/2022 12:09

HikingforScenery · 13/05/2022 11:52

Would you call the woman who has four children with him stupid? Yabu for calling her stupid.

What do have against the word stupid being directed at a woman making bad choices when given hard evidence? The dictionary definition for stupid is:

Having or showing a great lack of intelligence or common sense.

BellePeppa · 13/05/2022 12:05

Wellyboots12 · 13/05/2022 11:56

I do acknowledge that stupid was a harsh word to use and perhaps it's not fair to call somebody stupid. I woukdnt say that to her diredtly but can't help but think it.

She is stupid.

HikingforScenery · 13/05/2022 12:04

I do agree you absolutely did the right thing by telling her

Stapleton143 · 13/05/2022 12:03

If you know his violent behaviour then that’s your duty to tell that woman, and if she ignores it then she is stupid, especially 2 weeks in.

drpet49 · 13/05/2022 12:02

“Yes, she's stupid. People will tell you it's victim blaming and love bombing and manipulation tactics, but she was 2 weeks in and faced with irrefutable evidence.”

^Completely agree with this. I would have no sympathy for her.

blueagain · 13/05/2022 12:02

Good for you for trying OP. She’s had the info and acknowledged it. You’ve done your best. Nothing more you can do and yes she’s stupid.

AchatAVendre · 13/05/2022 12:01

Thanks for doing this OP. Society is the biggest and most effective preventer of violence.

I've just been reading the book about Malcolm Webster, the wife killer, after watching the tv programmes on C4. The book goes into a lot more detail about why he targetted the women he did and how some of the ones he was seeing at the same time have resumed writing to him now that he's in jail until he reaches 82 for murder/attempted murder.

These men study their victims, gradually erode their boundaries and drop anyone not "responsive" enough. Its really worrying that your friend is so far invested this soon, and I wonder if she had any childhood trauma that would have rendered her vulnerable. He's probably fed her a pack of lies already.

Could you go to the police and suggest they issue her with an Osman letter, especially since he has a criminal record of violence against women? I know the admin bar is high to achieve for the police, but it might be worth a go. An Osman letter is a letter to the potential victim delivered in person by the police stating that they think she is in danger from this particular individual.

As for the shoot the messenger types, I have no words. Gullibility is a form of stupidity when you put yourself at risk when you have free choice not to. For some reason, there are women out there who prefer to attack other women for warning them but not the person who is really putting them in danger.

I bet if you had reversed the sexes in your OP, the same posters would be clamouring to save the poor man at the hands of the deranged, dangerous woman...

AryaStarkWolf · 13/05/2022 11:59

You were right to warn her but that's all you can do really

HorseInTheHouse · 13/05/2022 11:58

It's not abuse to be frustrated on an anonymous internet forum. It must be horrible to see someone in danger like that, warn them and have your warning ignored and know that something horrible IS going to happen and there's nothing more you can do to prevent it.

OP, you did a really good thing and you probably have helped this woman. Even though she's not acting immediately, like PPs said you have planted that seed. I also find it hard to believe that a woman would willingly be with a man who is a convicted abuser after having been made aware of that fact. But it is what it is, I can see that people are likely to be defensive because nobody wants to think they've been duped. Even if she's deluding herself now, you may still have saved her considerable harm by putting her on alert so that she will be quicker to respond to the signs and less likely to forgive early incidents.

I hope she is able to get away without suffering too much harm first and good for you for doing your best to help.

Wellyboots12 · 13/05/2022 11:56

I do acknowledge that stupid was a harsh word to use and perhaps it's not fair to call somebody stupid. I woukdnt say that to her diredtly but can't help but think it.

OP posts:
Wellyboots12 · 13/05/2022 11:54

HikingforScenery · 13/05/2022 11:52

Would you call the woman who has four children with him stupid? Yabu for calling her stupid.

If she was aware of what he'd done to previous partners, and children, when she met him then yes I would.

Or in my own case - if somebody had warned me that my ex would be an abusive rapist, when I met him, and I proceeded regardless of seeing concrete evidence of this. I would feel pretty stupid myself and wouldn't blame others for thinking it of me.

OP posts:
HikingforScenery · 13/05/2022 11:52

Would you call the woman who has four children with him stupid? Yabu for calling her stupid.

PurassicJark · 13/05/2022 11:48

People are talking about how this woman would feel if she saw this thread. Maybe it might give her the kick to realise she's being a fool and ignoring the fact a man who has a criminal record is now going on holidays with her. If she thinks she will be the one he doesn't beat up, she is severely mistaken. She could be the one that ends up dead.

FlowerArranger · 13/05/2022 11:48

I think you did the right and brave thing, @Wellyboots12

The woman may be too loved up to head what she now knows, but she'll be more likely to spot things that aren't right before it gets to the point where she is in real danger. Hopefully she'll be strong and financially independent enough to leave at that point.

You've done all you can.