Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why women box?

196 replies

Choufleurfromage · 13/05/2022 06:30

Not a fan of boxing as a 'sport' in general and given the hysteria over football/rugby tacking and head injuries, am surprised such a violent contact sport is still allowed.
Also, at the risk of being oxymoronic, I really do think women shouldn't be banned from doing stuff, but boxing is just so uncouth, ugly and violent, I cannot understand why women would want to do it; ok, it offers opportunities for disadvantaged youngsters (plenty of evidence of this), it creates discipline and focus, but it is still 2 people battering each other for no reason...
I am sure iabu, and am not suggesting women only pursue 'dainty' sports or activities, but boxing?

OP posts:
dottiedodah · 13/05/2022 10:34

Mckmck I do have a daughter actually ,and she is not interested in hitting someone else "skilfully" or otherwise .Oddly nor is her brother! I said I hated Boxing generally ,male/female .Just it seems sad that young girls (or boys) want to take up a hobby like this, where injuries are rife . Football ,Motorsports ,any thing like this can be rough ,but is usually accidental . I would like to see Boxing banned . The famous Boxer Mohammed Ali suffered from Parkinsons disease ,which has been argued could have been caused by his Boxing Career.Head injuries are also common, and under reported .In an era where "being kind" is advised .Why are youngsters still being encouraged to get involved in a sport like this?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 13/05/2022 10:32

Tamzo85 · 13/05/2022 10:08

Don’t you worry that it may give you a false sense of security though? I mean if you’ve never really had a man go for you with intention then why do you think boxing will help? I doubt men sparring or training with you give you a real sense of what it would be like.

I worry younger women may put them in situations which are dangerous with a false sense of security because of stuff like this. The reality is unless your a world class boxer your boxing class is unlikely to help you that much against a stronger faster man who really wants to hurt you.

When I trained, the point was that the security/self defence was in being fit enough to dodge and run away and only if you were already in physical contact with them, being potentially able to disable for a couple of seconds with full strength punches so they would let go and you could run away.

CapMarvel · 13/05/2022 10:25

...because they want to?

KettrickenSmiled · 13/05/2022 10:20

Fighting isn't an exercise in trying to give somebody else permanent damage. It's an exercise in fighting your own doubts, your own feeling of weakness, your pain, the voices of those who told you you were crap and shouldn't think of yourself as anything special, your temptation to give up and walk away and in, most of all, getting back up again.

You spar or box with an opponent; but the true fight is in your head.

Great post.

Tamzo85 · 13/05/2022 10:08

Ceridwenn · 13/05/2022 09:05

I guess for me too, when I'm jogging through the woods of an evening, I want to know I at least stand a bit more of a chance (compared to the 20 something me), if someone should try to grab me. It's why my daughter also trains with me. I don't want to put my trust in men to short out their violence. It wont happen.

Don’t you worry that it may give you a false sense of security though? I mean if you’ve never really had a man go for you with intention then why do you think boxing will help? I doubt men sparring or training with you give you a real sense of what it would be like.

I worry younger women may put them in situations which are dangerous with a false sense of security because of stuff like this. The reality is unless your a world class boxer your boxing class is unlikely to help you that much against a stronger faster man who really wants to hurt you.

Tamzo85 · 13/05/2022 10:05

Thepeopleversuswork · 13/05/2022 09:10

I can totally understand why women box. Taking back a sense of power and control, and being able to match men physically and defend themselves.

I personally probably wouldn't do it because of the risk of injury, but I can completely relate to those who want to do it.

I also think your post is very sexist and lacking in consistency. You say women shouldn't be banned from doing it (of course they shouldn't) but they go on to use language that implies that it is coarse and unfeminine. Why is that even relevant, if you don't draw a distinction between things which men and women do?

@Thepeopleversuswork
Thats the thing though - it’s a false sense of power and control and they still won’t be able to match men physically. If your doing it for excersise that’s one thing but it could bring a false sense of security that you may actually be able to take on a strong man when in reality you will likely being shocked and overpowered quite easily.
Fancy sparring with men where they don’t go full tilt can’t really prepare you for that. That kind of thinking is dangerous imo

anywhichwaytoo · 13/05/2022 10:05

BishyBarnyBee · 13/05/2022 06:59

I agree with you OP. Traditional boxing is a horrendous sport where the ultimate aim is to give the opponent concussion. It causes enormous long term.damage to the brain. The famous discipline and training could be found more positively in any of the wide range of martial arts that don't involve hurting your opponent.
There is something quite unpleasant about people wanting to watch something where the whole point is to see someone get hurt. The added dimension of it being two women makes it even more unpleasant and I'd question the motivation of some viewers.
Being excited about equality for women in boxing is like being excited about women's right to be serial killers. It's not progress to mimic the most offensive aspects of masculine culture.

💯

Electricmouse · 13/05/2022 10:05

My partner is a boxer.
She says because she likes it.
HTH.

KettrickenSmiled · 13/05/2022 10:02

veronicagoldberg · 13/05/2022 06:59

Well aren't you a peach, OP? Maybe you should channel some of your anger into boxing.

😂😂😂😍

anywhichwaytoo · 13/05/2022 10:02

YANBU.

I can't stand boxing - what sort of message is this sending to young boys and girls that punching each other in the face is ok, and if you're really good at it you can earn lots of money.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 13/05/2022 10:01

I forgot to add that I'm 49 and am a walking list of risk factors for osteoporosis. I had my first DEXA when I was 35 and another one last summer (48).

I'm not supposed to have the bone density of somebody in their early 30s. But, apparently, I do. I'm told that this is solely due to the types of exercise I have done because there's no way I should have such healthy bones with my medical, social and food related history.

Boxing and kickboxing was the first exercise I ever did. I didn't start until I was 27/28 - but that first step into a gym gave me a physical advantage that I'm still enjoying now. And the knowledge that exercise feels good, that strength feels good and knowing that the pain, heart pounding, sweat, feeling like you can't go on sensation passes when you get back up has been invaluable to me.

Because that's what the intensity of boxing does. It teaches you that when you get knocked on your arse, you just keep on getting back up again.

Fighting isn't an exercise in trying to give somebody else permanent damage. It's an exercise in fighting your own doubts, your own feeling of weakness, your pain, the voices of those who told you you were crap and shouldn't think of yourself as anything special, your temptation to give up and walk away and in, most of all, getting back up again.

You spar or box with an opponent; but the true fight is in your head.

takealettermsjones · 13/05/2022 10:01

There's a huge difference between the kind of boxing you would see in an ordinary club and the kind you see on TV. I'm a martial arts instructor and I've done various arts/styles over the years, including boxing, kickboxing and lots of others.

I often watch boxing because I enjoy it, but I am sometimes horrified at the refereeing. I have coached/refereed many a match and most of the time when watching (esp. heavyweight) boxing, I would have stopped the fight way sooner than they ever do on TV!

In my view they are often sacrificing health/safety for putting on a good show. And that's also incidentally one reason why many martial artists will not touch MMA with a bargepole. But the fighters do know what they're agreeing to, and presumably sign a waiver, so...

But a local club with good, qualified, responsible instructors - a fantastic sport. Give it a go!

KettrickenSmiled · 13/05/2022 09:58

Read the post properly. I said I don't like boxing in general. I do NOT have an issue with women boxing, as stated on original post, I asked why they do it as it is something I do not understand.
Specsavers?

For someone who reckons women shouldn't be uncouth, you've got a lot of aggressive rudeness to dish out ain'tcha OP?

Also not entirely sure why you bothered to consult AIBU, as you''re obviously capable of starting an argument alone in a room & don't need any input from other people:

"I'm not being sexist but ... I cannot understand why women want to do it"

"I don't have an issue with women boxing but ... it's uncouth & ugly"

"I am sure IABU but ... it offers opportunities for disadvantages youngsters, it creates discipline & focus"

"I am not suggesting women only pursue 'dainty' sports ... but am surprised such a violent contact sport is allowed"

Keepitonthedownlow · 13/05/2022 09:53

Women probably box for the same reasons men do: they are good at it, money, a challenge, excitement etc.

Don't like it or fancy it myself right enough.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 13/05/2022 09:50

Toddlerteaplease · 13/05/2022 09:37

I hate boxing full stop and wish it was banned!

Banned because you don't like it? People know the risks and choose to do the sport. If you hate it, don't do it.

childofthecorn · 13/05/2022 09:50

What Olympic sports are people with vaginas allowed to do, OP?

failingtomatoes · 13/05/2022 09:46

10HailMarys · 13/05/2022 09:45

I don't really think it matters whether you personally understand it or not? Nobody's asking you to do it, or to watch it.

I don't understand the appeal of Formula 1, but I don't fret about it. Just accept that different people like different things and move on. Ideally without being so judgemental and throwing words like 'uncouth' around.

But OP is opening up dialogue to discuss why they feel like this? That's a good thing surely?

Staffymumma · 13/05/2022 09:46

For the same reason men box.

10HailMarys · 13/05/2022 09:45

I don't really think it matters whether you personally understand it or not? Nobody's asking you to do it, or to watch it.

I don't understand the appeal of Formula 1, but I don't fret about it. Just accept that different people like different things and move on. Ideally without being so judgemental and throwing words like 'uncouth' around.

CoffeeWithCheese · 13/05/2022 09:41

My daughters both do kickboxing - it's done wonders for my eldest's focus and calms her overactive mind down no end. My youngest... well she manages to insert ballet-esque twirls into the moves but she enjoys it and she's benefiting from it in terms of the exercise and stamina and muscle strength (she has hypotonia). They go to an all ages class where there are adults training with adults, adults training with their kids and kids training with kids - and it's a real family feeling to it all.
I'd rather they were doing that and having a good laugh doing it - than doing something as toxic as dance classes had become.

MrsSkylerWhite · 13/05/2022 09:41

Don’t understand why anyone boxes.
get that it’s great exercise but anything that involves being punched in the head on a regular basis seems a no brainer (pun not intended) to me.

in years to come, when we know much more about degenerative brain diseases, it will finally be banned.

Fizbosshoes · 13/05/2022 09:40

Boxing training looks a great workout and would make you super-fit, but I wouldnt like to actually have a boxing match. (I'm sure I'd be knocked out within a few seconds anyway....which I don't find appealing at all!)

failingtomatoes · 13/05/2022 09:40

PurassicJark · 13/05/2022 07:33

Has someone built a time machine and sent us back to the 1800s? Come on now, be honest, who did it? 😂

Why is that funny? OP is allowed to ask any question she wants. OP wanted a discussion probably to understand why? They have admitted maybe worded awkwardly but a conversation worthy of having surely? Especially if after thought provoking conversation they would possibly acknowledge that their upbringing. Being told what was and wasn't acceptable as a child has affected current thoughts. And instigates change? Your frankly not funny post just makes you look flippant and try hard.

PassThePringles · 13/05/2022 09:39

Forgot to mention, it's great for self defence too :D

PassThePringles · 13/05/2022 09:37

I do TaeKwonDo. That's basically kicking people in the head for best points in competitions... I do it as it's great stress relief. I know boxing is more brutal to the face but some women need to get the stress out some how, better to get it out with a willing partner :D each to their own but that's why I do what I do.