Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cornwall!!

292 replies

P0larexpress · 12/05/2022 20:47

why do people pay stupid amounts to holiday here?
I nearly spat my coffee out in work today. A co worker has paid £1600 for a week in st Ives, last week of June!

she showed me it! It’s a pretty basic, one bedroomed cottage. Wtf!!

i have booked flights and an Airbnb in greece for just over £1000. I’ll admit I never holiday in the uk, because it just doesn’t feel like a proper holiday to me, but if I do it’s always a deal/ bargain Airbnb type thing.

what’s the attraction of Cornwall?
By all accounts it’s overcrowded cost a fortune to park , and eat out, and a pretty mediocre experience all round!

OP posts:
HesterShaw1 · 21/05/2022 07:36

Small point - all lifeboat crew are volunteers nit just in St Ives. Well, apart from the coxwain and first mechanic.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 21/05/2022 07:35

I’ve never been. Would like to, but put off by the risk of paying a lot of money for a crowded holiday in bad weather. I understand that people like different things, but to me the idea of a long, slow, congested drive to a place that’s heaving with people, some hostility from the locals and the tourism industry itself responsible for the huge inequality in the area… it’s a bit like using “people like different things” to account for when you find out that John next door likes licking his wife’s feet while having a pineapple shoved up his bum.

Bearsan · 21/05/2022 07:27

I do like Cornwall but not in the school holidays, it's far too busy. I do prefer holidays abroad these days because of the cost. You can easily get a beautiful 4/5 star hotel with lots of meals/drinks/facilities included for less than a caravan in the UK. Next year we'll both be retired so we'll probably do a few of both.

CaptainBeakyandhisband · 21/05/2022 07:18

Honestly, everywhere I went on my last visit to St Ives (recently) everyone was super polite and helpful. It’s like a theme park in that regard, not quite real life, with staff who can’t afford to live nearby having to travel into the town to work. This idea that the Cornish are rude to tourists is untrue and unkind.

Locals do use the word emmet though - it’s Cornish for ant, and it’s no coincidence that the tourists tend to arrive in earnest at the same time as the ants. I grew up in west Cornwall and the contrast between winter and summer in terms of people is insane.

Cornwall and the Cornish are a bit stuck though. Most people have been priced out of buying where they grew up because of the tourist trade. Some families have made considerable money cashing in, but most of the holiday lets are owned by the non-Cornish, and the rental fees are not staying in the county (the agents take a small slice but it’s not much). Porthemmet Beach was a spoof website set up about 15 years ago as a joke, but if you read it it’s very obviously not a real place. People don’t actively misdirect tourists to fake places: www.porthemmet.com

I was shocked by how many businesses were struggling to recruit staff (waiting, bar, shop assistants) this time. I guess it’s just the hassle and cost of getting into St Ives for work doesn’t make it worthwhile. There is a bigger knock on effect coming too: the RNLI station is volunteer run and the fire station is reserved, the lack of affordable housing nearby means that the people who used to do those jobs are not available nearby.

So I think on balance, St Ives is a perfect culture clash of people who are spending a fortune to be there being served by people who can no longer afford to be there. The tourist trade is worth something like £85m/year in St Ives (I read in CornwallLive a while back), but hardly any of that wealth is distributed in the local community. Most of the business in the town are owned or backed by a handful of families and most of the accommodation fees go up country.

interferringma · 21/05/2022 06:52

Ooo the Carbis Bay Hotel - aren't they the ones who ripped up habitat prior to the G7 and claim to be 'eco'?

I miss Waitrose too but it's become in an ironic way. And my London friends. But I go on holiday with one of them once a year now - just a short walking break - and visit when I can. And have new friends here in Cornwall.

Movinghouseatlast · 20/05/2022 22:48

I live in Cornwall. On a sunny day where I live could be mistaken for the Mediterranean. I took some photographs of Porthminister Beach in St Ives and people genuinely thought I had gone to Barbados. We went to Carbis Bay Hotel in March and swam.in the amazing infinity pool in glorious sunshine. It felt like a proper holiday!

Things I miss since I moved here are balmy evenings ( we get about 5 a year here) Waitrose (we would have to drive an hour and a half round trip) and my friends.

Chubarubrub · 19/05/2022 12:45

CruCru · 19/05/2022 11:36

When I visited 2 different groups of Cornish friends, both slagged off tourists (or "emmets" as they call them!). They also told me about how some deliberately set out to wind-up tourists by advertising a fake, gorgeous, beach with travel directions sending them on wild goose-chases. And when these confused and lost tourists asked locals for help they'd be sent on further wild goose chases! Apparently set up by a local cousellor (or similar - maybe someone can clarify?) and was a huge source of amusement. Well fuck that, I just can't get passed the biting the hand that feeds them, and as there are other equally beautiful places in Britain I won't be going back.

I am quite shocked by that. I grew up in Brighton (perhaps not somewhere that people do a fortnight's holiday but lots of stag / hen dos and foreign students). It's not cool to live in a place that needs tourist money and be horrible to tourists.

It's not cool to live in a place that needs tourist money and be horrible to tourists.

Agree

interferringma · 19/05/2022 11:43

I hate that word.
I have never used. But occasionally see it on social media. You're right. It's vile. Not funny. Just vile.

CruCru · 19/05/2022 11:36

When I visited 2 different groups of Cornish friends, both slagged off tourists (or "emmets" as they call them!). They also told me about how some deliberately set out to wind-up tourists by advertising a fake, gorgeous, beach with travel directions sending them on wild goose-chases. And when these confused and lost tourists asked locals for help they'd be sent on further wild goose chases! Apparently set up by a local cousellor (or similar - maybe someone can clarify?) and was a huge source of amusement. Well fuck that, I just can't get passed the biting the hand that feeds them, and as there are other equally beautiful places in Britain I won't be going back.

I am quite shocked by that. I grew up in Brighton (perhaps not somewhere that people do a fortnight's holiday but lots of stag / hen dos and foreign students). It's not cool to live in a place that needs tourist money and be horrible to tourists.

CandidaAlbicans2 · 19/05/2022 11:25

Having travelled extensively throughout Britain I found Cornwall amongst the most geologically interesting, with some of the most beautiful coast, but it's let down by the hype and some local's outspoken dislike for tourists IMHO.

When I visited 2 different groups of Cornish friends, both slagged off tourists (or "emmets" as they call them!). They also told me about how some deliberately set out to wind-up tourists by advertising a fake, gorgeous, beach with travel directions sending them on wild goose-chases. And when these confused and lost tourists asked locals for help they'd be sent on further wild goose chases! Apparently set up by a local cousellor (or similar - maybe someone can clarify?) and was a huge source of amusement. Well fuck that, I just can't get passed the biting the hand that feeds them, and as there are other equally beautiful places in Britain I won't be going back.

HesterShaw1 · 19/05/2022 09:39

interferringma · 19/05/2022 07:29

@lancsgirl85 St Ives is silly prices. I really do think that is a special case and owners take the proverbial p@ss there! Look in places like Porthleven, Mousehole, Newlyn, Marazion (I only know the south coast well so can't comment on other N coast places). All have sea views and most have beaches. or Looe or Fowey. Or almost anywhere! St Ives is crazy, and the crowds will drive you crazy too.
Friends in the holiday business say this year will be quieter than last because people are flooding abroad. You may yet get lucky at this late stage. Good luck!

It definitely is far quieter this season. All the tourism businesses are saying it

Back at the start of April I heard of a holiday park near Porthleven who cancelled loads of their longstanding bookings at the start of the season so they could resell them at much higher prices. Only they didn't sell so now they're heavily discounting them 😂

Greedy bastards.

APurpleSquirrel · 19/05/2022 08:36

lancsgirl85 · 18/05/2022 22:02

We were hoping to go in August with our toddler but OMG the price of cottages in St Ives! 2k for 7 nights. I mean, they're beach front and the views look absolutely stunning but still!

If you aren't confined to the school holidays yet, I'd suggest going in June - the weather will probably be better & prices cheaper.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 19/05/2022 08:35

DH and I looked at the cottage we stayed in last year in St Ives, it had been sold and it is now on AirBnB for £700 a week more than last year, fantastic location, amazing see views, but was very much in need of some serious TLC and still is.

@lancsgirl85 with a toddler would you consider somewhere like this

www.rivervalley.co.uk/

It's a great site, not far from Marazion and Penzance. Have stayed there a couple of times and it was lovely.

interferringma · 19/05/2022 07:29

@lancsgirl85 St Ives is silly prices. I really do think that is a special case and owners take the proverbial p@ss there! Look in places like Porthleven, Mousehole, Newlyn, Marazion (I only know the south coast well so can't comment on other N coast places). All have sea views and most have beaches. or Looe or Fowey. Or almost anywhere! St Ives is crazy, and the crowds will drive you crazy too.
Friends in the holiday business say this year will be quieter than last because people are flooding abroad. You may yet get lucky at this late stage. Good luck!

Momicrone · 18/05/2022 22:04

Spending large amounts of money on anything is a such a personal choice. I think spending lots of money on flash cars is pretty stupid but hey if that's what makes people happy, each to their own and all.that.

lancsgirl85 · 18/05/2022 22:02

We were hoping to go in August with our toddler but OMG the price of cottages in St Ives! 2k for 7 nights. I mean, they're beach front and the views look absolutely stunning but still!

HesterShaw1 · 18/05/2022 21:45

420Bruh · 18/05/2022 21:28

Miserable. Overpriced, overfilled and often rains in August. We won't go back. Biggest waste of a holiday ever.

Why on earth did you come? Did you think it was an empty subtropical cheap paradise?

interferringma · 18/05/2022 21:35

420Bruh · 18/05/2022 21:28

Miserable. Overpriced, overfilled and often rains in August. We won't go back. Biggest waste of a holiday ever.

Excellent!
Tbh we only want people holidaying here who want to be here! Anyone else tends to be proper grumpy

420Bruh · 18/05/2022 21:28

Miserable. Overpriced, overfilled and often rains in August. We won't go back. Biggest waste of a holiday ever.

interferringma · 18/05/2022 21:20

Really? @wheredoesitallbegin I have a friend from the east end who is forever telling me 'you can take the girl out of Bow but you can't take Bow out of the girl'. But none of my Cornish friends ever say anything similar!
'You can take the girl out of Camborne but you can't take Camborne out of the girl'.
Imagine!

APurpleSquirrel · 18/05/2022 21:00

wheredoesitallbegin · 18/05/2022 19:21

I don't mind Cornwall or Devon but I do find that the locals shout a lot in my vicinity about how they're from there and all their family are too when I really couldn't give a shiny shit

Really? I live in Somerset & visit Devon frequently & have never heard anyone do this unless you happen to be talking to them about where they're from??

wheredoesitallbegin · 18/05/2022 19:21

I don't mind Cornwall or Devon but I do find that the locals shout a lot in my vicinity about how they're from there and all their family are too when I really couldn't give a shiny shit

HesterShaw1 · 18/05/2022 19:14

sashh · 18/05/2022 05:05

@HesterShaw1

I'm not sure you know how bad the weather is in some parts of the UK.

On my brother's wedding photos you can tell who lives in Devon and Cornwall and those of us who travelled south just by the sun tans.

What an odd thing to say. Yes we do have sun here, and people get suntans Hmm. Of course I know what the weather is like in other parts of the UK. I have been further than the Tamar, you know.

However the weather is generally cooler, rainier and windier than it is further east. These are meteorological facts - we are further west and surrounded on three sides by the sea, so we are notably cooler than say Herfordshire or Suffolk. (the flip side being we are generally milder in the winter). Plymouth and Truro get considerably more rain than Newcastle, London, Oxford or Edinburgh. West Cornwall is one of the windiest places in Europe.

People who say we have a "subtropical climate" because there are palm trees and other exotic plants are just wrong. Palm trees grow in Plockton in Argyll - the west of Scotland doesn't have a subtropical climate either! Like Cornwall, they have the North Atlantic Drift which means frosts at sea level are unusual.

You don't need hot sun to get a suntan.

Anyway....

TabithaTittlemouse · 18/05/2022 11:52

nomistake · 14/05/2022 08:45

Cornwall is only beautiful when the weather is nice. And that's rare. Who wants so spend a holiday mooching round an average town or grey beach in the rain and wind? The locals don't want you there either.

I disagree, it’s beautiful all year. Go and look at Heligan on a rainy day, the colours are amazing!
Obviously if you are scared of getting wet it’s not great.

garlictwist · 18/05/2022 05:26

Seashor · 12/05/2022 21:14

I’ve done two long weekends recently in a treehouse at Center Parcs. Set me back nearly £9000. Many will say I could have gone to XY and Z for that but I didn’t want to! It’s horses for courses. Although I do much prefer Devon to Cornwall but would prefer either to Greece.

😱

Swipe left for the next trending thread