Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get a cat if visiting family are allergic?

84 replies

chatterbug22 · 12/05/2022 19:18

We are considering adopting our first furry friend, ideally a cat due to our busy working lifestyles.

It is all I can think about! We have done our research, spoken to people with cats that we know and contacted a local rescue, and they have approved our home check for one indoor cat.

My mum had a cat for years and took antihistamines daily but is very allergic to them and saying she would rather we didn’t get one as she couldn’t visit if we did.

Of course it’s a big decision and commitment, I hate the thought of my mum/family never visiting us and feel a bit selfish if they were unable to because of a choice I made.

Thoughts??

OP posts:
Kindastrange · 13/05/2022 08:35

My mil is allergic to cats and dbil has one.

Mil allergy has got worse in severity in time, what was a take an anti histamine before going to the house is now take an anti histamine before having anyone with a cat come to visit her house , and people who have cats have to put on clean clothes and she still feels exhausted and unwell later

It started as would just take an antihistamine, as she aged it then became can't spend the night there, to can't go in at all.

DMil now can't step foot in dbil new house . This means she's never been able to baby sit in the house, go round for dinner, attend any of the functions at the house eg kids birthday parties. She's never set foot in her grandchildrens bedroom etc

There's distance involved for us so popping into see them in the garden isn't too attractive but even with that as she gets older she needs to enter to use the toilet more etc which she can't do. S

It's frustrating for us because it means any care needs for dpil get passed to us as they've not been able to stay there to recoup from operations etc and dbil has to arrange child care, cat care etc to come to pil.

Prior to the cats dpil would often spend a few nights in the summer, and often spend a week or so just playing with the grand kids etc but that's obviously stopped now

When they got the first cat it was excusable as they didn't predict the severity of allergies increasing with age, and the toll antihistamines can take on older people, when they got other cats following that it was hurtful.

I doubt my dpil have ever said anything but it has really impacted their relationship with dbil family and it comes across as purposefully excluding them

Porcupineintherough · 13/05/2022 08:27

@coffeecupsandfairylights not necessarily true. Sometimes living with something you are mildly allergic to dampens down the allergy for a while but when you stop it rebounds - or comes back stronger. And some cats/dogs produce stronger reactions than others.

We used to have a pet rabbit when I was little, which eventually had to go as it was making my asthma worse. Since then my allergy to rabbits is life threatening.

WildCoasts · 13/05/2022 08:27

coffeecupsandfairylights · 13/05/2022 08:18

@HiJenny35 - OP's mum has had cats herself in the past so the allergy can't be that severe!

As other posters have mentioned, these allergies can get more severe as you get older. I've never considered myself allergic to cats but here, in my late 40s, all of sudden I have a terrible cat allergy. Apparently it's not that uncommon at my age either. No fun at all.

Porcupineintherough · 13/05/2022 08:24

Well I wouldn't get anything that meant my mother couldn't visit my house but it's your life and your choice. Expecting her to just chug antihistamines, grin and bear it is not on though.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 13/05/2022 08:18

@HiJenny35 - OP's mum has had cats herself in the past so the allergy can't be that severe!

Selttan · 13/05/2022 01:26

Not quite the same scenario but we discovered my mum is allergic to my cats after I adopted them. Even though we had a cat when I was younger for 19 years and she was fine.

She takes an antihistamine before coming over and while not 100% it's manageable.

I guess it depends on how allergic your mum is and whether you want her to spend significant time at your house.

The only thing we could thing of for my mums allergies is our family cat was long haired and my girls are short haired, so we suspect she's allergic to the oils rather than fur.

WildCoasts · 13/05/2022 00:47

i suppose you'll need to decide what your priority is - visiting family or the cat. It's your home and, if you want a cat, I'd get one but accept that some people might not visit as a result. If you would be upset if people don't visit because of the cat, then maybe the cat isn't the right decision. Would a hypoallergenic breed make a difference? That might be a middle solution.

I myself wouldn't get an animal if someone living in the house full time had to take medication or suffer because of it, but your mother doesn't live with you so you can find other ways to meet up.

ScrollingLeaves · 13/05/2022 00:33

Not many people have a reaction of such severity though, HiJenny35

It doesn’t sound as the OP’s relatives are like this. So one of the less affecting breeds of cat might work out fine.

HiJenny35 · 13/05/2022 00:11

I think the people saying "my x has a allergy and comes over once a week after a tablet and it's fine" are very nieve. After a visit to a house with a cat my child would need to have all clothes washed including shoes and coats, her face, hands etc, she would take an antihistamine before she leaves and still have sore itchy skin and eyes the next day and several after. My best friend got a cat and we now don't go there and yes it's hurt the relationship. Yes I feel cross that she'd get the pet knowing that we would be unable to visit anymore or if we did we would be left uncomfortable, I think it's pretty selfish to expect me to always host or to invite knowing full well we can't accept. I don't think you're that close if you'd get one knowing this. She comes round once a week not once every other month.

Blaze1886 · 13/05/2022 00:02

You're an adult now but your mother is still dictating your life.

Time to show her you're not a little child anymore. It's your house, if you want to get a cat, get a cat.

Your mother can have you round to her's.

Triceratopsrock · 12/05/2022 22:07

I’m very allergic to cats. I used to be able to live with one. But it’s got worse over the years and now I can’t go into a house with a cat without having an asthma attack.

I guess it’s important to think about what kind of relationship you want with your mum long term. Meeting for coffee and going to hers is great if that works for you. Will it always be ok? Are you planning on having kids? Would you be wanting to invite your mum over to baby
sit etc? Are you likely to move further away to somewhere that would require your mum to visit occasionally?

allergies are miserable. Pets are lovely. I hope you find a way to make it work.

Ragwort · 12/05/2022 22:06

Entirely your choice and depends how important it is that your mother visits you at home. My DH is allergic to cats and he just doesn't visit people who have cats - neither side (or the cats !) seem bothered Grin.

SavoyCabbage · 12/05/2022 21:59

I’m sure we’d be able to meet for a coffee or I could go to her!
Potentially forever though, depending on how allergic she is. She might never be able to spend a spontaneous couple of hours at your house.

PinkSyCo · 12/05/2022 21:57

I would chose my mum over a cat all day long. Then again my mum is dead and I’m not a cat lover so……

romdowa · 12/05/2022 21:54

My mother is mildly allergic to cats ... I recently got 2 kittens. My mother doesn't live with me and can take an antihistamine if she wants to come over. Why would your mother have a say about what you do in your own house

easyday · 12/05/2022 21:51

My son is allergic and I have two cats. He comes to stay for a weekend about once a month or more. I have air purifiers in each floor and he takes allergy pills starting a few days before his visit, and the room he sleeps in is off limits to the cats. He sniffles a bit but no real problem.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 12/05/2022 21:40

Hypoallergenic makes no difference for severe allergy sufferers.

WhackingPhoenix · 12/05/2022 21:40

I’ve got three cats, none of whom I am allergic to. My mum has one cat and my dad has two. I am very allergic to all of those.

Your DM might not even be allergic to your cat.

ScrollingLeaves · 12/05/2022 21:38

Have you thought of a cat which is less likely to cause strong allergic reactions:
www.bluecross.org.uk/advice/cat/hypoallergenic-cats

It would need to be a particular breed, but sometimes you can find rescue organisations for a breed.

MangyInseam · 12/05/2022 21:34

It depends. Some people are much more allergic than others. I have a close relative who really can't visit a place with a cat, so we don't have one. Antihistamines don't always really do much.

Summerholidayorcovidagain · 12/05/2022 21:32

Came on to say if it's mil get 3 dcats...
I am allergic and we have 2.
And ahem 4 ddogs...
😬

Ponderingwindow · 12/05/2022 21:31

I kept my cats, despite my mother developing an allergy but that was because she only visited every few years anyway. She still visited with the same frequency, but even with medication, couldn’t spend more than about 10 minutes in my home after extensive prep and cleaning. She also had asthma so an allergy triggering was especially dangerous. She would pop in for a quick tour and we would meet her at her hotel or at other venues the entire rest of the time she was in town.

AMBE123 · 12/05/2022 21:25

It depends on the strength of the allergy really. Some people can take an antihistamine and be fine. I also expect there are people can't take antihistamines for whatever reason, or they don't work.

In my case, I am hyper allergic to cats. If I sit within a couple of metres of a cat owner, eg in office, in a restaurant etc I react within a couple of minutes and have to take an antihistamine - that works for mild exposure like that.
However, if I visit a friend with a cat, even if I take a strong antihistamine beforehand, I can spend max 5 minutes indoors before I start wheezing. The asthma will then carry on for a couple of days afterwards unless I take an antihistamine for the days afterwards as well. When my adult DC had a cat and visited me, they used to bring a change of clothes and put their catty clothes in a bag at the door.

I really like cats btw and would love to have one but it's out of the question. Anyway, if my DC wanted to get a cat I'd be kind of disappointed, I would feel like they chose a cat over time with me. I wouldn't stand in their way but it would severely restrict the ability to hang out with them and babysit etc

purplesequins · 12/05/2022 21:11

yabu

it's your choice to get a pet.
but allergies are awful and you mother has a choice to visit less if it affects her health greatly.
antihistamines are great medicines. but I wouldn't want to take it regularly if I can avoid the allergen.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 12/05/2022 21:10

It’s got much worse as l’ve got older, I’d probably need steroids and a nebuliser now. Inhalers don’t touch it, l just sit there wheezing, sneezing coughing and swelling g up. Eyes close, lips puff up, tonsils hurt.

Sure, I’ll just take an anti histamine🙄