Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get a cat if visiting family are allergic?

84 replies

chatterbug22 · 12/05/2022 19:18

We are considering adopting our first furry friend, ideally a cat due to our busy working lifestyles.

It is all I can think about! We have done our research, spoken to people with cats that we know and contacted a local rescue, and they have approved our home check for one indoor cat.

My mum had a cat for years and took antihistamines daily but is very allergic to them and saying she would rather we didn’t get one as she couldn’t visit if we did.

Of course it’s a big decision and commitment, I hate the thought of my mum/family never visiting us and feel a bit selfish if they were unable to because of a choice I made.

Thoughts??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MsSquiz · 13/05/2022 13:07

I'd get a cat. It's not like she lives with you.
My nephew has many allergies and recently found out they include cats. We have 2 cats and he often comes to visit, as well as us visiting him, probably with cat hairs on our clothes! He takes a daily antihistamine and will happily play with the cats when he visits!

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 13/05/2022 12:46

ScrollingLeaves · 13/05/2022 00:33

Not many people have a reaction of such severity though, HiJenny35

It doesn’t sound as the OP’s relatives are like this. So one of the less affecting breeds of cat might work out fine.

Jenny is not describing a particularly severe reaction TBH. I wish mine were that mild and there are plenty of other stories here of much more severe reactions. When you get a cat the reality is you are always risking a significant percentage of people not being able to visit. People just need to be aware of that and not fall for the myth that an antihistamine will sort it out or that a specific breed is a guarantee of a milder/ no reaction.

MyCatIsInCharge · 13/05/2022 12:27

My DB is allergic. My DM was up in arms when I got a cat, as it meant he would never be able to stay with me again (he lives over 150 miles away). I was pretty quick to point out that he’d only visited me twice in six years so for once every three years, no, I wasn’t prepared to forego the cat. I have to say, I would have done if he came round every week but it’s a very personal decision and depends on the relationship.

BigWoollyJumpers · 13/05/2022 11:49

DH is allergic to cats. As are his family. However, they are all slightly differently affected, and it definitely depends on the cat. DH had cats as a child, so the family coped before, and I have always had cats, so he had to suck it up, get me, get my cats 😁

He actually has become better since getting older. Probably due to exposure. We did have to re-home one cat, who for some reason gave him really bad asthma, but all our others have been fine, and sometimes two at a time, and a couple of long haired cats of DM, who used to come and stay sometimes. Our current cat he can even pet and have on his lap, as long as he washes his hands after. He adores Arthur😍

Sugarplumfairy65 · 13/05/2022 11:34

My granddaughter cannot visit her other grandma because of her allergy to cats. The allergy has got considerably worse as she's getting older and even antihistamines don't work. The grandmother, despite being fit and healthy will not make the effort to visit my granddaughter away from the cats. She just takes in more and more cats. It's her loss. She's missed out on the first 10 years of granddaughters life and will likely miss the rest.

Porcupineintherough · 13/05/2022 11:17

Well it depends on your relationship with your family member, doesn't it? There's no "should" about it, it's a choice but personally I'd prioritize being able to invite a parent, adult child or sibling into my home over a pet. Doesnt mean that OP shouldn't get a cat, just means she should think through the implications carefully first. As my parents/inlaws have aged their ability to host has declined meaning family get togethers now tend to happen in the homes of the next generation. Both my dad and my MiL are disabled and find going out difficult, so being able to have them over at ours is important in a way it wasn't even 5 years ago.

GentlemanJay · 13/05/2022 11:14

I had a friend who visited his girlfriends family for a weekend recently. He had a really uncomfortable time with his allergy.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 13/05/2022 11:11

The thing is, it's not the mums house. Should adult children who want pets really be expected not to get them because someone who doesn't even live in their house has an allergy?

That's bonkers to me 😳

DangerNoodles · 13/05/2022 09:52

I am a cat owner but if I was in your position I would prioritise Mum over cats, you are very lucky to have a mum so close. Unless she is a toxic pain in the arse, in which case get the cats.

Summerwetordry · 13/05/2022 09:35

I wouldn't get a cat in your circumstances. My DD has a severe cat allergy and it's misery. She often doesn't know when visiting people if they have a cat. Even if it's outside she still has a reaction to its fur or dander that's left in the house. We had dogs, poodles, and she was fine with those. If I was the allergic mother, I'd be hurt that my DD put me in danger of a severe reaction.

HummingQuietly · 13/05/2022 09:34

On the practical side, get a HEPA air purifying machine and put it on for several hours in a cat-free room before she visits. Also try not vacuuming directly before she comes as this can suck up allergens from the floor and spit them out into the air. Wooden floors are better than carpet. Damp dust.

Maybe think about adopting an older cat, but even a 7 year old could live another 12 years.

Letsbekindplease · 13/05/2022 09:30

Get the cat.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 13/05/2022 09:27

My face swells up with cat allergy. When l had my allergy testing, cat allergy made my whole arm swell up. The only way of making it bearable for an allergic person is not to have a cat.

Apart from wheezing, sneezing, puffy itchy eyes ( they totally close up) l feel so ill with it too. Anti histamines have never done much for it. Neither has cleaning a house. Just sitting next to someone with cat hairs on them can set me off.

MiddleParking · 13/05/2022 09:20

I honestly wouldn’t consider getting a cat in these circumstances, I think it would be really mean and it sounds like your instinct is telling you the same. Even if your mum was able to take an antihistamine and grin and bear it through puffy eyes with the cat being kept away from her when she visited, I think that would be a really shit basis on which to decide to get one.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 13/05/2022 09:13

Some of the advice on here is from people with very mild allergies and may be of no relevance to your situation. I have severe cat allergy. Anti-histamines don't touch the sides and neither does hoovering, cleaning, or opening windows. On a good day I can manage an hour max in a house which has a cat but I will take 2 days for my breathing to stabilise so I'd only do that when otherwise well (i.e. not with a cold as that is such high risk of chest infection). I don't know how severe your mum's is but you are risking her not being able to come to your house at all for the life-time of the cat and 2 years after. It really depends on whether that bothers you. If she's local and you are prepared to always visit her instead then maybe not too much of an issue. If she lives some distance away and can never visit again I guess it will have more impact? My sister decided not to get cats as never being able to visit her was not a price she was willing to pay. I'd not judge someone who effectively excluded me from their house as I also see the appeal of cats and would get one in a heartbeat if I could. But I would want people to be realistic about what it means for our getting together.

Effram · 13/05/2022 09:12

we have a (non-shedding) dog and my SIL is v v v v v allergic. She is v understanding and in return we do everything we can and accept some inconveniences. We allow time for a deep clean before she visits and keep dog out of living room. Have blankets to cover a chair that he is NEVER allowed on (he does come on sofa with us normally) so she has somewhere untouched to be, and make sure we are stocked on antihistamines! We obviously keep him away from her. We go to my brother and hers more than they come to us because of this, and get dog sitters. When we go on big family holidays we don't take the dog (even if it's a dog friendly walking one we normally would have taken him on). She isn't coming over every week to do childcare or anything though. She is understanding and also likes that my nieces and nephews get to play with the dog as obv they can't have one. I wouldn't not have the dog, but I think it's reasonable for us to be slightly inconvenienced to make her comfortable too as she is a human (and was here first haha!)

axolotlfloof · 13/05/2022 09:04

If your family who live with you want a cat, I think your Mum is quite selfish to suggest you don't get one.
You don't get to decide what other people do at home.
Is there a room (conservatory, dining room) you could keep the cat out of that your Mum visits you in.
Pets are joy, get a cat (and a dog?).

Doofas · 13/05/2022 08:55

It's your house, your families life, you do what you choose. We have friends with cats, and my hubby is very allergic to them. One family has a longer haired cat, DH more allergic to this cat than the other hand witha short haired cat. Also long haired cat family not so familiar with the hoover, might whizz it round the floor before we come round. Family with short haired cat clean regularly (was going to write obsessively, but that felt a bit extreme) DH very little reaction when we go round. But then they vacuum chairs and sofas as well as floor so no where for cat hairs to be hanging around. So yeah I'd say if you want a cat that's your families choice, but there are things you can do to make things more comfortable when they are at yours. And get some anti histamine in in case they forgot to take any before leaving home.

Vikinga · 13/05/2022 08:52

I wouldn't if my mum who saw us once a week was really allergic. Maybe consider a dog that has hair and not fur? But test it first

Kindastrange · 13/05/2022 08:49

I think its naive to think that only meeting in coffee shops, at hers, outside wouldn't impact your relationship.

Especially as if a cat lives 15 years, what age would your mum be? As dmil got older the ability to meet outside in the cold decreased and the ability to spend the afternoon out, accessibility slowly decreased. Realistically now she's hitting the later 70s she doesn't want to sit for hours in a garden

The cat dbil has now will out live my dmil.

We have recently moved house because the layout of my old house meant my elderly parents struggled to visit. It meant that I suddenly realised that theyd never come round for Christmas morning, and that I wasn't able to host family events involving the whole family but also couldn't do basic things like look after them when they were coming out of hospital.

Memyselfandfood · 13/05/2022 08:45

get the cat.
it’s your house. I don’t plan my life around people not in it daily.

alltheteeshirts · 13/05/2022 08:45

Well, it's up to you. Do you want a cat full-time, or do you want your mum to visit you once a week? Because you can't have both.

People telling your mum to just pop an antihistamine have no idea what it's like living with allergies, and also seem to be naive of the fact that your mum will react differently to different cats. They're not all the same. You won't know how badly she reacts until you get one, and if she comes round to see you, you will be actively making her unwell.

If you're happy to always visit your mum (and she's happy to always host!) or to meet your mum away from your home, get the cat.

If you ever want your mum to visit your home, don't get the cat.

No compromises, I'm afraid!

Incidentally, if I spend time with a cat, there are knock on impacts for days and days afterwards. It's bearable as a once off, but I couldn't live like that full-time.

Lollypop701 · 13/05/2022 08:38

get your mum in a room with a cat to see how her allergy is now. If it’s low and antihistamine work ok I’d consider it. If it’s not then I wouldn’t. You see her a lot and that will drop if you have to go to hers. Sorry but there’s no way I’d put a pet I haven’t got ahead of my mum.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 13/05/2022 08:38

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 12/05/2022 21:07

Love all the people saying on here just take an antihistamine and open the windows.

l have severe cat allergy. Anti histamines make fuck all difference. Neither dies opening a window. The allergen molecules stick to the walls for months, so don’t just float out of the window. Hoovering makes no difference either.

Ds is getting a cat. He’s got an outside bit, and when l visit I’ll sit there.

God,that's a bit shit,isn't it? 😢

Midlifemusings · 13/05/2022 08:36

I have major animal allergies. I have family members who chose to get pets which is perfectly their right. They know about my allergies and they know I won't visit with the allergies.

The only thing that annoys me is that they will plan a family event or invite me over or want to host family celebrations / holidays and then be irritated when I decline. Often these celebrations will end up being hosted by other family members without pets so everyone can attend and they take that personally that no one wants them to host. I am always happy to get together at other pet free locations.

I would say get the cat as it is with you everyday and will give you the pet experience year round. But do not pressure or guilt or complain when your mother doesn't visit. Accept that if you want to visit, you need to go to her.