Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that I’m doing my best with this new colleague?

34 replies

Poodlee · 12/05/2022 18:49

I’ve got a new colleague. She is a little younger than my but by only a few years…
I’ve been training her for a couple of weeks and I’m struggling.

She constantly (and I’m mean like 5-10 times a day) apologies for not knowing stuff and keep saying thank you for explaining stuff to her. It’s driving me nuts!
I’m not expecting her to know stuff and happy to explain but I need her to listen and she doesn’t! She just doesn’t take it in and then gets frustrated… I’ve got quite a lot on at work and she should have been easing the load. I know it’s only been a little time so definitely will give her more to get used to it…
but I need her to use her initiative, listen and make herself useful…

i feel shit, the constant apologies and thank yous and nervousness is making it more difficult to me than it was before.

any tips?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Iamnotamermaid · 13/05/2022 08:14

New job so maybe a deer in spotlight situation. Maybe start the day with a summary of what you are going to show her, and why, and what you expect her to be able to do by the end of the day. End of the day summarise what you have covered and what you expect her to be able to do (again for emphasis).

RhythmStick · 13/05/2022 08:09

People learn differently. If you're 'telling' her things, and despite listening and writing it down, then YOU need to find another way, so that she does understand. How abouting letting her do something and coach her through, step by step.

Also ask yourself, is your frustration evident. If she's apologising and thanking you constantly, she may feel nervous about having to approach you because she's aware you don't have the patience for her. That's not going to get the best performance out of anyone.

Keladrythesaviour · 13/05/2022 07:57

I always try a three stage approach with training.

  1. I talk through the process, from beginning to end and explain why we do it the way we do. I always point out I don't expect them to remember it all at this point, it's just an overview
  2. I show them the process, clarifying at each point "do you remember I explained we do this because of xyz"
  3. Get them to show me the process when it happens, and they have to 'train me'. Talk through what they're doing and why they are doing it.

If 3 doesn't go well, we go back to 1, or 2 depending on what the issue is. Make sure they have correct notes to refer to, or a list of where to go for answers if you need product codes etc.
If 3 goes well enough I would then expect to be on hand for the next 2-3 run throughs, so present but not standing over their shoulder. I would then be 'on call' incase they needed me until they passed their probation but if the same issues were coming up I'd go back to 3, get them to talk through the process so I can see where the failed understanding is.

If she's literally just failing to remember anything I'd suggest she makes herself coherent process notes, assuming work provided ones aren't helping her, and to spend her evenings memorising and working through it. It's boring but has to be done.
If she's really not getting then you need to speak to her line manager so they can start bringing it up in regular reviews so her probation can be extended if necessary, or can be failed. If she's not told early enough and helped to improve she can't be failed and then you're stuck with her.

IWentAwayIStayedAway · 13/05/2022 07:47

does her cv, previous work experience link to current role or is she related to owner? job is maybe not a good fit for her

yousexybugger · 13/05/2022 07:44

Can you consolidate the existing notes into a SOPs or handover pack all.in one place for her role so she can refer to that?

Agreed with coaching her through doing things rather than explaining. Start with the aim of the task and an overview of the process, then the steps.

I worked with a very, very difficult to teach person. It was similar to the apologising but her approach was to agree enthusiastically and say she had got everything, had no questions, saying things like 'thanks! That makes perfect sense now!' And it turned out she had no clue and wasn't doing much at all or making a real mess. It was just a way of deflecting the issue down the road a bit rather than clarifying in the first place what she needed to do.

She wasn't new, I took over as her manager. I had the most success by coaching her through as above, plenty of repetition then finally getting her to show me the process herself.

If it was something online then I'd send instructions with screenshots.

Also, after giving her a task or instruction I would ask her to explain in her own words what I was asking her to do. Sounds patronising AF but it was the only way to work out if it had gone in or not.

Brefugee · 13/05/2022 07:43

how are you actually training her? I have had good trainers and trainees where: I do it first, explaining the steps, then they do it but i pretty much tell them the steps, then they do it while i'm watching. Usually it involves a printed manual and they or i write notes on it.

I was in one job where the training was awful, i didn't know how my part fit into the overall picture, why we did things, what the things we were doing were supposed to achieve etc. After a bit of a breakdown i left because the trainer seemed to think that learning works by osmosis and telepathy.

The things i have learned best, btw, are when the person isn't there (sick, left, CBA) and i had to "learn by doing" - is that an option?

Gliblet · 13/05/2022 07:28

Agree with trying the coaching approach, doesn't matter how many times someone talks me through a process, I won't really understand it until I work through it. For some people they need to write things down in their own words, for some they need to talk through the process for it to 'click'.

Coaching approach - what do you think comes next? - may help, as may asking her to show you how it's done so she can be the one that's hands on (obviously be ready to ask questions to prompt her as she goes along).

PurassicJark · 13/05/2022 07:27

Hopefully not the case, but she could just be useless. Worked with some people like that, you hope they'll get the idea eventually and it's just taking time. Months down the line, you're still having to fix mistakes they should know and have given up telling the bosses because they don't care. I actually had someone join a team who didn't even know the very basics of the job that they should have learnt in uni. It became obvious very quickly that they had paid for their degree, knew nothing and weren't interested in learning. They didn't last long.

Rosehugger · 13/05/2022 07:26

Tell her to write down and save up all her questions for one meeting a day, rather than constant pestering. And definitely to make notes. She shouldn't be repeatedly asking you about things which have been already covered.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 13/05/2022 07:22

do you have a guide?
standard operating procedures, for her to refer to

agutrew · 13/05/2022 07:18

Give her more time to learn. It is very stressful starting a new job. It can be completely overwhelming, especially if there are lots of new systems to get to grips with it and new people to meet. This could have been written about me a few years ago. I found there were constant distractions and the person training me was chatting to colleagues in between training me which left me feeling very frustrated. I also had other colleagues telling me to do things different ways. The whole situation made me feel very judged which made me paranoid about asking for help.

Doingmybest12 · 13/05/2022 07:09

In my new job I bought myself a hard backed note book with the alphabet down the side as I felt overwhelmed and couldn't order the information I needed to hand. I also had a small note book as a quick crib which I keep in my bag still . I also need to write out an idiot's guide of how to do some things and tell people to explain step by step to write it long hand if needed. What is easy when you've been around for a long time isn't when you are new and there is so much custom and practice that no one tells you. You need to make it ok for her to ask stupid questions. Hopefully she will soon get her feet under the table, it is early days.

flipflop76 · 13/05/2022 06:58

Does she have any additional needs? My brother comes across as really articulate and had a degree but has aspergers and learning difficulties and has major issues holding down a job. He's so anxious in new situations that he struggles to take in any information and is really slow to process information so everything takes him such a long time to learn. He needs constant repetition of the same task as his processing is so slow and he has poor working memory. I can imagine him doing the constant apologising and asking questions too. Over the years he's been let go from numerous jobs for being too slow.
I'm not sure what the answer is though as it sounds like it's hard for both the employer and employee!

PurplePinecone · 13/05/2022 06:49

Maybe ask her to repeat what you have just told her. If you do this often she will realise she has to concentrate as you are going to ask her to repeat it back. Might be mean and teachery... But will force her to concentrate eventually!

Also if it's something manual, get her to show you how to do it and correct her as she goes, but only as a last resort. Forcing her to work it out.

NumberTheory · 13/05/2022 00:55

You could also ask her how she learns best, how she's picked up similar things in previous jobs and see if you can adapt to that.

If that doesn't work I agree with others that you need to stop showing her and instead get her to show you what she's doing and explain how she thinks it works, what she thinks the solution might be, what she doesn't understand etc.

Is there anything she has got the hang of? If so, it might be good for you and her if you can get her doing a lot of that. So there's something she's having success with, which should boost her confidence, and something you don't have to do anymore, which should make things easier for you. If there's a discreet part of the job that requires a limited understanding of the whole process, concentrate on getting her proficient in that so that you can build off success rather than it all seeming overwhelming.

I would also talk to your manager about the issues now and explain what you're trying but make it clear she isn't making the progress previous hires have. You need these challenges to be clear and you may need more support, both of which require good communication with your manager.

Speakuptomakeyourselfheard · 13/05/2022 00:38

Depending on what exactly it is you're trying to teach her, would it be possible for you to talk her through doing the work as it comes along, rather than showing her? For example, if you are showing her a computer program, I've always found it far more effective to sit the learner down and get them to do what is necessary, as you talk them through it, as expecting someone to watch you do it and make notes, is far less effective in my experience. If it's a case of her not knowing where things go, or in what order they're done, you could perhaps advise her to draw a map/diagram of the process. You say you've 'got quite a lot on at work and she should have been easing the load', are you perhaps hurrying her because you are feeling under pressure knowing that you have a full day's work to do but also being constantly aware that she's holding you back from getting on with things? You say she's a bit younger than you, but you don't say how old either of you are, ie, is she a Mum returning to work, or a youngster just trying to get their feet on the work ladder, either of these situations could make your new colleague far more anxious than if they've just changed jobs. I don't think you've mentioned having trained someone before, so maybe you're just not that great at putting things across to her because they're things that come naturally to you, due to doing them day in, day out? My advice would be put yourself in her shoes, be kind and patient, and then if after another week or two, she's still struggling, have a word with your manager and put them in the picture.

LoveYorkshire · 12/05/2022 23:38

@Poodlee

Your method of teaching her is not matching the way she learns.

That girl sounds very similer to me.

You could explain the same thing 100x to me and I just won't understand - despite being pretty intelligent academically.

I was at a meeting with some two managers today who were explaining what they departments did.

I left the meeting with full understanding of what one department did yet no idea about the other. This was down to they ways of teaching - not that one was better than the other but because it just didn't match the way my brain works!

I agree with previous posters - ask her to keep a notebook to write notes.

I personally learn something new properly once I start doing it myself. Maybe, once she starts doing the job - you'll find she learns much faster.

Please understand and empathise - I bet she feels stupid enough having to ask you over and over again!

Kat1953 · 12/05/2022 23:22

She might be feeling overwhelmed with some information overload combined with new-job anxiety. You say she's getting frustrated and apologising definitely suggests it too, really hard to see the wood for the trees in that state.

I'd get her to focus on one simple thing at a time, some praise/reassurance its been done right and then move onto the next thing.

It's only week 2, I'd give her a bit more time to settle.

nothingtoday · 12/05/2022 23:08

Has she worked in your industry before or is she new to the type of work you do?

I think it's best to talk to her

WhiskerPatrol · 12/05/2022 22:30

YANBU. Nothing worse than having to suffer through a handover to a thicko. Cover your arse by providing written handover notes and leave her to fail.

elephantmarchingin · 12/05/2022 21:46

Go to the 'coaching' approach.

Ask her what she thinks needs to happen. Ask her to share her screen and say you will jump in if you need to. Don't give her the answer

I'm a bit like this, it's anxiety and my previous experiences so not doing it on purpose to annoy just previously had shit managers/training experiences.

Poodlee · 12/05/2022 21:42

@Lurkerlot we don’t have departments, it’s a small business… she can write down things if she wants but there is a lot of material of instructions of using our programs etc.

just to clarify I already spoke to her. I told her that she needs to stop with the sorry s and that I do not expect her to know stuff. We can take it slowly but I need her to listen, use her initiative and the material provided to her…

Getting frustrated when she doesn’t know what to do or how to do etc, it’s not going to help. I need her to listen, take it in and get on. Ask questions, tell me what she understand or what she doesn’t…

OP posts:
Lurkerlot · 12/05/2022 19:49

just curious as to why she is having to write her own notes, does your department have process notes?

LollyLol · 12/05/2022 19:40

Are you her supervisor or manager? Why not just tell them she is hopeless?

What is her CV like? Can you talk to the hiring manager and make sure they followed up her references properly?. Is she on a probation period?

motherofchihuahuas · 12/05/2022 19:22

She's probably feeling bad she's taking you away from your work to train her.

I'd be the same. I know it's annoying. She prob just wants to get on and stop bothering you.

Maybe just talk to her