Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to people who want to hold my baby

193 replies

pearlsandpetals · 12/05/2022 17:20

Okay so hear me out first !

My baby is 4 months old and we are going through a very clingy phase where she is very attached to me and doesn't like to be held by anyone other than me or my partner and some very close family who she sees regularly. She is also a very calm baby who hates lots of stimulation and has been that way since birth.

Now we have a family event coming up and a few family members who we don't see as often will be there. One of them is my partner's dad and I know he will be wanting to hold the baby and walk around with her and generally make a big fuss of her. I know this comes from a place of good intentions but I know this will distress my baby. Last time this happened he said he would take her outside and walk around with her and this only made things worse. I don't want to put my baby in another situation like this to make her upset and distressed.

Question is am I being unreasonable as I know that these are family who just want to see my baby, and if not how do I handle it in a polite way not to offend anyone

OP posts:
CoastalWave · 14/05/2022 18:19

You've probably already created a major issue. I could literally hand my babies to anyone - brilliant as I got a rest and they got to meet people and have fun!

You've created a nervous, anxious baby and sadly this will continue if you don't do something now to change it!

MRex · 14/05/2022 18:15

I had a clingy one. He was always fine if I stood or sat next to the person holding him, or down on the floor playing. Also important, feel and be cheerful in handing her over, she'll pick up on you panicking.

I'd just have a chat with grandad about it in advance, let him know she's super fussy but you want him to be able to hold her so you need to get some time in for her to get used to him. Is there any way that you or they could come to stay for a week before the event? That would be ideal to build up a genuine bond that he can then show off to everyone. Basically, telling grandparents what they can or can't do in front of a gathering isn't kind nor useful, you have lots of other time to chat with them and make arrangements that will work.

BakewellGin1 · 14/05/2022 18:13

DH has always worked away and when DC were younger they would get upset when he came home and picked them up.

So we worked on it, he held them, if they were hysterical I would calm them down and pass back again.

Under your suggestion and some others I would never have handed them over and he would never have built a relationship with his children.

mumsiedarlingrevolta · 14/05/2022 18:06

Based on your continuous responses @pearlsandpetals I have no idea what you want from this thread.
Were you expecting everyone to validate your completely unreasonable behaviour?
You are unwilling to accept anyone else's opinion or that you might need to be open to trying or flexible to allowing the baby's Grandfather hold his grandchild.
What a lucky baby to have people who love her and are proud of her.
If no one holds the baby she will never get used to anyone.
You are being a PFB Mother and you really need to chill

Nanny0gg · 14/05/2022 17:57

pearlsandpetals · 12/05/2022 18:17

To be honest I was expecting these kinds of responses. It appears the vast majority of people on Mumsnet very much like to get a reaction whilst hiding behind their computer screens

Then why bloody ask?

Did you just want a fight?

Hesma · 14/05/2022 17:19

No wonder she’s clingy if you won’t let anyone else hold her. You are being ridiculous OP.

luckylavender · 14/05/2022 16:53

pearlsandpetals · 12/05/2022 18:17

To be honest I was expecting these kinds of responses. It appears the vast majority of people on Mumsnet very much like to get a reaction whilst hiding behind their computer screens

What are you even here asking this question if you don't want responses. It's your baby do what you want. But also it's absolutely true that you need your baby to get used to people so if you carry on being so PFB, you're not doing her any favours.

cottagegardenflower · 14/05/2022 16:39

You really don't like honest opinions do you?

Let grandad hold his granddaughter on the understanding if she gets upset, he gives her back. Easy

Sceptre86 · 14/05/2022 16:18

I just went through this with my current baby, although she is 8 months and largely over it. I'd let them try and if she started to cry they would happily give her back. I actually appreciated those that would at least attempt to soothe her so I could eat or have a cuppa. I wouldn't let thos be rhe hill you die on. Let them have a cuddle, when she cries they will either pass her back or you step in. Of course you could choose not to go.

JudgeJ · 13/05/2022 22:02

Blarting · 12/05/2022 23:04

Surely you're not intimating that it's because the other family are the "in laws" that OP is unhappy for them to hold the baby?

Imagine, a fathers family being second best.

Isn't that the MN rule, her in laws are evil, his in laws are saintly?

orangeisthenewpuce · 13/05/2022 17:45

GreatStuff67 · 13/05/2022 15:01

Blimey, OP, your post has really brought the worst side of MN out! I hope you're ignoring the ridiculously rude responses. There's a great lack of empathy in many of these replies. Unfortunately, MN tends to be pro pass the baby, and pro grandparent's wants over the baby's needs. My guess is it's a generational thing as the only people I've met who are like this in real life are older, although I do know very understanding older people too, so maybe it's just some people are... odd. 😅

My thoughts on your situation are, no you are not being unreasonable to say no to people who want to hold your baby.

Your baby is perfectly capable of bonding with people without being held by them. (How some PPs think this isn't possible is staggeringly bizarre.)

It's not true that saying no to people now will make her more clingy.

She will not 'grow up terrified of others'.

And most importantly, her clinginess just now is not because of you. You are not the problem.

With all my DC we were happy with all grandparents holding them as babies. DH's parents live abroad, but we made a point of doing lots of video calls with them so the kids got use to them. Maybe something you could do with the Grandad?

However, we only let other people (friends, great-aunties etc) hold DC once DC were old enough to show that they wanted to go to them (so... once they were about 6/7 months, if I remember correctly). All DC had clingy stages (as most babies do) and they all became more confident in their own time.

My suggestion is that Grandad shows he isn't scary by playing with your daughter however she's happy with in the moment. Smiles, songs, being silly etc. but not over the top if your daughter isn't keen on lots of stimulation. Even just sitting a bit away and interacting a little then continuing to talk to everyone else, so it's not too much interaction at first. If things are going well you could try him holding her, but say to him before that if she gets upset he's to hand her back. Some babies do get distracted by going outside or walking around, so I imagine the time before he was only trying to help her calm down. If, however, he wants to hold her and you don't want him to you can say 'We'd rather you didn't hold her just yet, as we don't think she's ready right now,' then suggest something he can do just now like read her a book. If he, or anyone else pushes you on the subject, you can say 'We're doing what we think is right for our daughter,' and, if need be, leave it at that and go talk to other people at the family event.

You sound like a great Mum, who is really thinking about what's best for your daughter. I hope it goes well for you. 💐😊

Wrong. Mumsnet is full of people with common sense. Just because we disagree with the OP doesn't make us wrong.

GreatStuff67 · 13/05/2022 15:01

Blimey, OP, your post has really brought the worst side of MN out! I hope you're ignoring the ridiculously rude responses. There's a great lack of empathy in many of these replies. Unfortunately, MN tends to be pro pass the baby, and pro grandparent's wants over the baby's needs. My guess is it's a generational thing as the only people I've met who are like this in real life are older, although I do know very understanding older people too, so maybe it's just some people are... odd. 😅

My thoughts on your situation are, no you are not being unreasonable to say no to people who want to hold your baby.

Your baby is perfectly capable of bonding with people without being held by them. (How some PPs think this isn't possible is staggeringly bizarre.)

It's not true that saying no to people now will make her more clingy.

She will not 'grow up terrified of others'.

And most importantly, her clinginess just now is not because of you. You are not the problem.

With all my DC we were happy with all grandparents holding them as babies. DH's parents live abroad, but we made a point of doing lots of video calls with them so the kids got use to them. Maybe something you could do with the Grandad?

However, we only let other people (friends, great-aunties etc) hold DC once DC were old enough to show that they wanted to go to them (so... once they were about 6/7 months, if I remember correctly). All DC had clingy stages (as most babies do) and they all became more confident in their own time.

My suggestion is that Grandad shows he isn't scary by playing with your daughter however she's happy with in the moment. Smiles, songs, being silly etc. but not over the top if your daughter isn't keen on lots of stimulation. Even just sitting a bit away and interacting a little then continuing to talk to everyone else, so it's not too much interaction at first. If things are going well you could try him holding her, but say to him before that if she gets upset he's to hand her back. Some babies do get distracted by going outside or walking around, so I imagine the time before he was only trying to help her calm down. If, however, he wants to hold her and you don't want him to you can say 'We'd rather you didn't hold her just yet, as we don't think she's ready right now,' then suggest something he can do just now like read her a book. If he, or anyone else pushes you on the subject, you can say 'We're doing what we think is right for our daughter,' and, if need be, leave it at that and go talk to other people at the family event.

You sound like a great Mum, who is really thinking about what's best for your daughter. I hope it goes well for you. 💐😊

CaitoftheCantii · 13/05/2022 00:40

Just don’t go to the party - too much when they are so little. Build up her confidence with her wider family in a less overwhelming environment and then in a few months, she’ll be more likely to cope with family gatherings and the attention she’ll inevitably attract.

youboozeyoulose · 12/05/2022 23:07

OP comes across as quite unpleasant in her responses, which makes me think in all probability the problem is with her.

Sunnytwobridges · 12/05/2022 23:06

I'm not the overly protective type but I wouldn't let him walk down the street with her like he did before, but if he stayed within sight and didn't walk around I would be okay with it. I let everyone hold my DD when she was that age but they were all either sitting down or just standing, not strolling around with her.

Blarting · 12/05/2022 23:04

CuriousCatfish · 12/05/2022 17:39

Would the very close family you allow to hold your baby happen to be your parents?

Surely you're not intimating that it's because the other family are the "in laws" that OP is unhappy for them to hold the baby?

Imagine, a fathers family being second best.

Wouldyabeguilty · 12/05/2022 22:44

Absolutely ridiculous. Never heard anything as stupid in my life.

Yumyumcakes · 12/05/2022 22:41

Blossomtoes · 12/05/2022 22:35

This. And I wonder why? 🤔

Because she was neglecting my daughter that’s why, as you were wondering

Apollonia1 · 12/05/2022 22:38

I've 2-year old twins.

One has been very outgoing and sociable since birth, and loves hugging people/sitting on their knee etc.

The other twin only wanted me, and is very shy. She didn't want to sit on my siblings knees for example. So instead of grabbing her for a hug ( and upsetting her), my siblings would sit on the floor beside her, read her a book, interact with a toy, play peek-a-boo etc. So they built it up slowly. Now she's comfortable and happy with them, and goes to them for a hug.

So your partner's dad could built it up slowly too.

Blossomtoes · 12/05/2022 22:35

FabulousKilljoys · 12/05/2022 20:58

It’s entirely possible that children don’t like a specific individual too. both of mine dislike my MIL

You mean their grandma?

This. And I wonder why? 🤔

Haydugee · 12/05/2022 22:30

Just give it a try OP, if she cries ask for her back. It is important that she bonds with her grandparents.

sashagabadon · 12/05/2022 22:20

no one wants to hold a screaming baby. If baby starts screaming people usually can’t wait to hand them back to mum and get on with their day in peace. I wouldn’t sweat it, just see what happens

bg21 · 12/05/2022 22:17

pearlsandpetals · 12/05/2022 18:10

I should probably clarify that yes I would say to everyone that she doesn't like being held, not just her grandfather. She is the same with my own dad and I politely tell him she would rather you interacted with him if she was led down on her playmat instead of picking her up and he takes no offence to this.

she told you that did she lol

pinkunicorns54 · 12/05/2022 22:15

💐. Your baby your decision. I would say though I have been there where I was very triggered by my baby crying - but I wanted them to be comfortable around people, so I did let people hold them. If they got too distressed I would take them back...

I had post natal anxiety...

It does get so much easier and now, I happily wave them off whilst dropping them at grandparents 🤣

cigarettesNalcohol · 12/05/2022 22:08

YABU and making the whole situation into something it's not. Let Grandad hold the baby. Baby might be happy and like it. If so, let things be. If baby hates it and cries, then firmly take baby off Grandad. It's really no big deal. You're over thinking this.

I generally find people don't ask to hold babies, they do get up close though. If baby is getting irritated if people in her face then just casually point out she's tired and needs some quiet cuddles with mummy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread