Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to people who want to hold my baby

193 replies

pearlsandpetals · 12/05/2022 17:20

Okay so hear me out first !

My baby is 4 months old and we are going through a very clingy phase where she is very attached to me and doesn't like to be held by anyone other than me or my partner and some very close family who she sees regularly. She is also a very calm baby who hates lots of stimulation and has been that way since birth.

Now we have a family event coming up and a few family members who we don't see as often will be there. One of them is my partner's dad and I know he will be wanting to hold the baby and walk around with her and generally make a big fuss of her. I know this comes from a place of good intentions but I know this will distress my baby. Last time this happened he said he would take her outside and walk around with her and this only made things worse. I don't want to put my baby in another situation like this to make her upset and distressed.

Question is am I being unreasonable as I know that these are family who just want to see my baby, and if not how do I handle it in a polite way not to offend anyone

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Asia722 · 28/11/2022 00:34

I actually agree with you OP.
If baby is happy and content to be passed around then no problem!
but if baby is crying and upset like you described, then I think it is very selfish and disrespectful of them to insist to hold her.
I would never dream of NOT handing a crying baby back to its mother. I don’t know what is wrong with some people.

NewandNotImproved · 21/05/2022 18:58

@loulou1966 that wasn’t the hot take you think it is, you just made a complete fool of yourself in that post.

motogirl · 21/05/2022 18:49

Do you want a toddler whose clingy, a preschooler whose clingy??? Babies who are introduced to different situations grow up into easier children. Obviously if she's distressed you can intervene but you are prejudging the situation

Youseethethingis1 · 21/05/2022 18:46

@loulou1966 you don't deserve your grandson with a shitty attitude like that.

loulou1966 · 21/05/2022 18:23

My daughter did this to me when her son (3rd child) was born, she favoured her boyfriends mother to the point where I barely ever held him. Now I have no emotional attachment with him whatsoever. She constantly complains that I favour the older children, who I have very close bonds with.

You are being very selfish. The baby stage is the point where those lifelong bonds are being formed between babies and their relatives. If you prevent grandpa from holding your baby, don't be upset when grandpa is not interested when your child is older and by the way, less cute. Dont forget that you will have to explain to your child why grandpa doesn't love them like he does the other kids.

Somethingneedstochange · 19/05/2022 13:20

Thedogshouses · 17/05/2022 09:44

You are a bit unreasonable but its OK. By the time you have your third you will lobbing them across the room to granny like a rugby ball

True story😂😂😂

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 17/05/2022 13:37

Put her in a sling, with you wearing the sling

say she’s going through a clingy patch and only wants to be with you right now

meet up with grandparents (your ILs) separately on a quieter day so that they can have a cuddle with the baby in a quieter environment

TopSec · 17/05/2022 13:13

pearlsandpetals · 12/05/2022 18:25

Thanks. Yes last time he literally took her outside and walked down the street, she was clearly crying because she wanted me

Without trying to cause any upset, have you thought that it is YOU who is causing the distress of your child - maybe if you were less clingy with her, she would feel a little more comfortable with others. I realise that she is only 4 months old and is the most important thing in your life, but just sometimes a baby feeds of the mother's anxiousness or stress and maybe this is why she isn't comfortable with others? It happens, not just to yourself but to other mums so you are no different, its just how you manage it that may be. The folk that you may very well upset (and insult to some extent) by withdrawing any close contact with your baby are the very same people that you may have to rely on in the months and years to come. Please don't alienate them because of your own anxiety..... I will now go away and put my tin hat on. Take care

Butteryflakycrust83 · 17/05/2022 12:48

You dont KNOW she will be distressed - honestly I would let him try. Babies change all the time

amijustparanoidorjuststoned · 17/05/2022 12:40

Hi OP/PP - can I ask, is this not a good age for your daughter to start getting used to other people? Appreciate she's going through a clingy stage, and hopefully it doesn't last forever! But would it not be worth getting her used to other people even if she does kick off at first? To be honest, as long as she isn't at risk of harm I don't see what the problem is!

Sushi7 · 17/05/2022 12:24

some very close family

@pearlsandpetals The baby’s close family are you, her dad and her grandparents. YABU to stop her granddad from holding her. He isn’t hurting her or stealing her. Please don’t let your anxiety rub off on your Dd. She deserves to bond with multiple people.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 17/05/2022 12:18

AmbushedByCake · 12/05/2022 21:44

Don't really understand these responses. Most people wouldn't force a 4 year old or a 2 year old to hug someone they don't want to be hugged by. So why is it OK to take a tiny infant away from the place they feel secure for 'cuddles', the baby clearly isn't feeling cuddly if they're screaming. They won't bond well with someone who just takes them away from their safe place, they bond with people who interact with then and are patient and responsive to them.

But this doesn't make sense, no one is saying take a screaming baby away from their parent and hand them over to someone? They're saying allow cuddles and take them back if they start to cry Confused which is the only way they have to communicate they are uncomfortable. 2 and four year olds are (mainly) verbal; babies are not.

hangrylady · 17/05/2022 12:09

OP "AIBU?"
MN "yes"
OP "no I'm not!"
Why bloody ask then 🙄

HelloBarkness · 17/05/2022 11:59

CoastalWave · 14/05/2022 18:19

You've probably already created a major issue. I could literally hand my babies to anyone - brilliant as I got a rest and they got to meet people and have fun!

You've created a nervous, anxious baby and sadly this will continue if you don't do something now to change it!

That's not how babies work 😂

Blossomtoes · 17/05/2022 11:29

Unbelievable, isn’t it? I’m so pleased I won’t be around when kids taught not to share reach adulthood. It bodes very badly for the future of society.

Nanny0gg · 17/05/2022 09:59

LilliannaRose · 17/05/2022 06:43

How? How is this unreasonable? PearlsandPetals NO, you're not being unreasonable. In today's world and in a world wide pandemic... No.
You absolutely have ever right to tell every single person in both sides of the family they can see the baby fine from your care, or your husbands. My children were taught they don't have to share toys with anyone, nor did they have to hug, kiss, or other anyone they didn't want to. Until your baby can say yes or no for themselves you both have every right to make that choice for them. All babies go thru super attachments to a specific person, right at the same time they don't want to go to people they don't know. Forcing the baby to go to someone when the baby will only scream and be afraid makes them insecure and in need of more attention from Mom and Dad for months more than it normally would. Just like you can't pick baby up too much. My kids were raised to be secure and feel safe. That lead to them wanting to be down so they could run and play instead of always being picked up from fussing all the time. Raise your baby so they know they are secure and safe with you so they grow up to be self reliant individuals.

Taught them not to share??

Hope they were given the same treatment!

I understand not accepting unwanted kisses and hugs but not sharing toys is teaching them to be selfish.

Thedogshouses · 17/05/2022 09:44

You are a bit unreasonable but its OK. By the time you have your third you will lobbing them across the room to granny like a rugby ball

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 17/05/2022 08:09

Just let people hold her and take her back if she's too fussy

I'm sure when you have dgc you'll like to have the chance to get to know them and hold them

A 4 month old isn't frightened or traumatised by someone else holding them . Babies cry sometimes 😒

LuckySantangelo35 · 17/05/2022 07:57

GreatStuff67 · 13/05/2022 15:01

Blimey, OP, your post has really brought the worst side of MN out! I hope you're ignoring the ridiculously rude responses. There's a great lack of empathy in many of these replies. Unfortunately, MN tends to be pro pass the baby, and pro grandparent's wants over the baby's needs. My guess is it's a generational thing as the only people I've met who are like this in real life are older, although I do know very understanding older people too, so maybe it's just some people are... odd. 😅

My thoughts on your situation are, no you are not being unreasonable to say no to people who want to hold your baby.

Your baby is perfectly capable of bonding with people without being held by them. (How some PPs think this isn't possible is staggeringly bizarre.)

It's not true that saying no to people now will make her more clingy.

She will not 'grow up terrified of others'.

And most importantly, her clinginess just now is not because of you. You are not the problem.

With all my DC we were happy with all grandparents holding them as babies. DH's parents live abroad, but we made a point of doing lots of video calls with them so the kids got use to them. Maybe something you could do with the Grandad?

However, we only let other people (friends, great-aunties etc) hold DC once DC were old enough to show that they wanted to go to them (so... once they were about 6/7 months, if I remember correctly). All DC had clingy stages (as most babies do) and they all became more confident in their own time.

My suggestion is that Grandad shows he isn't scary by playing with your daughter however she's happy with in the moment. Smiles, songs, being silly etc. but not over the top if your daughter isn't keen on lots of stimulation. Even just sitting a bit away and interacting a little then continuing to talk to everyone else, so it's not too much interaction at first. If things are going well you could try him holding her, but say to him before that if she gets upset he's to hand her back. Some babies do get distracted by going outside or walking around, so I imagine the time before he was only trying to help her calm down. If, however, he wants to hold her and you don't want him to you can say 'We'd rather you didn't hold her just yet, as we don't think she's ready right now,' then suggest something he can do just now like read her a book. If he, or anyone else pushes you on the subject, you can say 'We're doing what we think is right for our daughter,' and, if need be, leave it at that and go talk to other people at the family event.

You sound like a great Mum, who is really thinking about what's best for your daughter. I hope it goes well for you. 💐😊

It’s not the baby’s needs v grandparents needs though is it?
baby wants to held by mum 24/7, baby doesn’t need to be held by mum 24/7. Big difference.

There are loving family members on hand who want to hold her. Baby will not be scared or terrified. Baby might cry the first few times, so? Babies cry 🤷‍♀️ Doesn’t mean they are gong through some terrible trauma. If she keeps crying he will just give her back to you! No one wants to hold a screaming baby, that ain’t fun for anyone.

youll not always want to be glued to your child Op, don’t alienate all your family now otherwise you’ll never get a babysitter for when you fancy a night out later down the line (which you will!)

So yeah in short YABVU and Very PFB

Bunnycat101 · 17/05/2022 07:11

I’m in the middle on this. My second was more of a limpet baby and would have hated being passed around - often hated her dad at that age let alone people she wasn’t familiar with. But, it will do you all good if you can get her to get used to grandparents. We used to do things quite slowly though so spending time sitting next to and interacting before passing her over etc. At 3 she’s much more clingy than my other child ever was. Hard to know whether nature or nurture but it can be very frustrating.

Potterypottering · 17/05/2022 06:58

I get your anxiety as I was the same but it is good for them to get used to being held by others, especially Grandparents but it’s also OK for you to take them back if they’re getting upset and whoever is holding the baby is unable to settle them. I remember our first big family gathering when my baby was 3 months. I found it hard but on reflection I probably shouldn’t have worried so much about my baby. It’s easier said than done though. And at the end of the day it is your baby!

Indicatrice · 17/05/2022 06:52

But if he is never allowed to hold her, how will she get close to him, OP?

LilliannaRose · 17/05/2022 06:43

pearlsandpetals · 12/05/2022 17:20

Okay so hear me out first !

My baby is 4 months old and we are going through a very clingy phase where she is very attached to me and doesn't like to be held by anyone other than me or my partner and some very close family who she sees regularly. She is also a very calm baby who hates lots of stimulation and has been that way since birth.

Now we have a family event coming up and a few family members who we don't see as often will be there. One of them is my partner's dad and I know he will be wanting to hold the baby and walk around with her and generally make a big fuss of her. I know this comes from a place of good intentions but I know this will distress my baby. Last time this happened he said he would take her outside and walk around with her and this only made things worse. I don't want to put my baby in another situation like this to make her upset and distressed.

Question is am I being unreasonable as I know that these are family who just want to see my baby, and if not how do I handle it in a polite way not to offend anyone

How? How is this unreasonable? PearlsandPetals NO, you're not being unreasonable. In today's world and in a world wide pandemic... No.
You absolutely have ever right to tell every single person in both sides of the family they can see the baby fine from your care, or your husbands. My children were taught they don't have to share toys with anyone, nor did they have to hug, kiss, or other anyone they didn't want to. Until your baby can say yes or no for themselves you both have every right to make that choice for them. All babies go thru super attachments to a specific person, right at the same time they don't want to go to people they don't know. Forcing the baby to go to someone when the baby will only scream and be afraid makes them insecure and in need of more attention from Mom and Dad for months more than it normally would. Just like you can't pick baby up too much. My kids were raised to be secure and feel safe. That lead to them wanting to be down so they could run and play instead of always being picked up from fussing all the time. Raise your baby so they know they are secure and safe with you so they grow up to be self reliant individuals.

quiksilver415 · 16/05/2022 17:03

You are absolutely not being unreasonable. As a parent you know your baby better than anyone else. There is no reason anyone has to hold your child other than you and your partner if you don't want them too. Distressing your baby so that a grandparent or anyone else doesn't get their feeling hurt is not ok. They are grown adults, they will get over it. We found that carrying our babies in a sling or carrier is an easy way to show others that we're not "passing" our baby around.

SouperNoodle · 14/05/2022 18:27

YABU.
Every single baby goes through this phase. If you only let the people she's clingy to go near her, she'll stay clingy.
Her grandad should be allowed to cuddle her and it's for your baby's own good that she's exposed to other people.